South Korea's impressive performance on international achievement tests has generated widespread interest from foreign observers, yet it is still challenging to find research written in English that carefully examines the nation's education system. Nancy Abelmann, Jung-Ah Choi, and So Jin Park have assembled a collection of essays that provide valuable insights into that system. No Alternative? Experiments in South Korean Education is the product of a conference that was held at the University of Illinois in 2003. As the title suggests, the volume focuses on education offered outside of mainstream institutions; contributors examine such topics as homeschooling, online education, and private tutoring. Although the issue that anchors the book is education at the margins, readers also receive a wealth of information about the goals and effects of the public school system. Each chapter describes perceived deficiencies in mainstream schooling that prompted students and their parents to seek other options. The editors do an excellent job raising key issues and developing threads that create a sense of cohesion across chapters. No Alternative? should satisfy the intellectual appetites of graduate students, scholars whose research interests center on South Korean education, and readers with a more general interest in educational reform.
The first two chapters, “South Korea's Educational Exceptionalism,” by Michael Seth, and “South Korea's ‘School Collapse’ Debates,” by Jae Hoon Lim, include valuable historical context and information about recent debates concerning the schools. Seth and Lim emphasize both the impressive advances facilitated by education planners since 1945 and the costs of the rapid expansion. Readers may surprised to read, for example, that as late as the 1960s, the nation's GNP was lower than that of Ghana and Haiti (p. 19). However, South Korean citizens have paid a price, both figurative and literal, for the educational opportunities delivered to them. Seth notes that urban workers spend an average of 9.8 percent of their income on education, double that of their counterparts in Japan. As has been the case in other settings, the neoliberal policies implemented in South Korea actually limited the options available to many families, especially those with limited financial resources. Ironically, Lim notes, advocates of those reforms held up the American education system “as an example of a successful system that achieves excellence through choice and competition” (p. 42).
The five chapters that follow provide ethnographic accounts of institutions that operate outside of the mainstream education system. Some of those institutions serve students whose needs were not met in the public schools. For example, in chapter 4 Deok-Hee Seo shares the findings of her research on parents who, disillusioned by the dominant school system, opted to homeschool their children. And in chapter 5, Kiyeon Yi reports on her experiences as a member of a study group formed by middle-aged women who returned to school to complete their degrees at Korea National Open University, which Yi refers to as a “pseudo-university.” Chapters 6 and 7 focus on the supplementary education industry—private tutoring institutes that prepare students for entrance examinations. The influence of these institutes is both pervasive and cogent. According to So Jin Park, almost three-quarters of all school-aged students in South Korea attend such schools (p. 118). And while the mothers interviewed by Park and Misook Kim express criticism of the pedagogical approaches relied on by cram school teachers, most continue to send their children to those institutes, hesitant to take any steps that could limit their children's academic prospects.
The book's shortcomings are primarily limited to information that is not included in the volume. For example, it would have been interesting if more attention had been devoted to education in rural areas. Are schools located outside of major metropolitan areas guided by a set of goals that differ from those profiled in the book? Does private tutoring exert such a powerful influence over families who live in the countryside? The collection also would have been enriched by a study or two that examined data collected from larger samples of students or parents. Perhaps that wish list can be met in a follow-up volume.
The essays included in this book underscore troubling aspects of an education system that is often celebrated for its academic accomplishments. In the introduction, the editors “ask who are the winners and losers of these education experiments” (p. 10). The evidence presented in the case studies suggests that the losers outnumber the winners by a wide margin. Rather than provide new opportunities to students who have struggled in mainstream public schools, the alternate options available to the disenfranchised tend to limit their opportunities and reinforce their sense of marginality. Many of those who exit the system with a sense of resistance eventually succumb to the “market logic” (p. 80) that pervades the public schools. The textured descriptions of such disaffected educational consumers make No Alternative? an important contribution to the research literature.
