On being asked to write a review for Arguments for a Better World, the book review editor was kind enough to warn me in advance that this was ‘a mighty tome’. It is indeed that. This 600 page Festschrift features 29 essays by prominent academics and activists who have worked with Sen throughout his illustrious career. Indeed, the strength of the volume lies in the fact that so many prestigious academics have contributed to it: A.B. Atkinson, Joseph Stiglitz, James Foster, Martin Ravallion, Kwame Anthony Appiah and Sabina Alkire, amongst others. The book is divided into four parts that reflect ‘the truly remarkable range’ of Sen's writings’ (p. 1): (i) ethics and normative economics, (ii) agency and social choice, (iii) poverty and capabilities and (iv) identity and collective action.
Perhaps the main interest for readers of this journal will be the eight chapters devoted to poverty and capabilities, the emphasis of which is on empirical applications of poverty and capability-based analysis rather than on conceptual work. Indeed, many chapters are rather technical, employing detailed econometric techniques with some containing pages of complex algebraic equations.
Within this part, Paul Anand, Santos and Smith provide empirical analysis of three topics: health and poverty, violence, vulnerability and life satisfaction, and the relationship between capability deprivation and life satisfaction. Sudhir Anand, Harris and Linton follow, exploring the concept of the ‘ultra-poor’, defined as a situation where food intake falls below 70% of typical calorific requirements and where food expenditure makes up in excess of 80% of income, and examine evidence for this concept using data from the Sri Lanka Consumer Finance Survey. Bourguignon and Chakravarty contribute a chapter presenting important work on developing multidimensional poverty orderings; an increasingly important area of study given the growing popularity of multidimensional poverty measures. Foster and Handy outline the concept of ‘external capabilities’, which relate to capabilities that are expanded through interaction with others in social networks; for example, through informal sharing of technology and information. This is followed by a chapter by Ravallion who explores Runciman's concept of relative deprivation using data from Malawi, and presents results contrary to what would be predicted by that theory. Robeyns presents an insightful discussion about the capability approach and its relationship to Rawls’ A Theory of Justice (Reference Rawls1971), which serves as a stimulating prelude to Sen's subsequent The Idea of Justice (Reference Sen2009). Shorrocks and Wan contribute a paper on generating information on individual income when micro-data are unavailable and one must rely on grouped income data, while Subramanian attempts to present a method for simplifying the measurement of income poverty by using Occam's razor to sidestep the necessity of identifying the poor – which remains so contentious in the literature – drawing on Indian data to show how this might occur.
However, while the breadth of Sen's writings are rightly celebrated and are indicative of the considerable academic contribution he has made throughout his career, such breadth makes for extremely heterogenous content in such a Festschrift. Furthermore, the focus of a number of the chapters in the part on poverty and capabilities is somewhat surprising. For example, Shorrocks and Wan, and Subramanian present interesting papers about the measurement of income poverty. Sen himself has made a major contribution to this literature in his call for an axiomatic approach for developing income poverty measures (Sen, Reference Sen1976). Nonetheless, he has now spent the best part of three decades criticising the reliance on income in terms of poverty analysis. Similarly, the chapters by Paul Anand et al. and Ravallion both focus to a greater or lesser extent on subjective deprivation, which Sen has argued should not be of paramount importance. The emphasis on these topics is rather prominent given Sen's well-known reservations about both.
In addition, there is rather little attention given to the conceptual challenges that emerge in applying the capability approach for the purpose of poverty analysis. As is well known, the approach is ‘deliberately incomplete’ and thus in need of supplementation. Foster and Handy's concept of ‘external capabilities’ is merely a subset of the capabilities that a person may possess and is unlikely to be a concept many find useful. And while Robeyns does an excellent job of locating the approach vis-à-vis Rawls’ justice as fairness approach, and in particular in providing a critique of his focus on primary goods, the context is one of justice and not poverty. While conceptual analysis occurs in other parts of the book, there is, aside from a very brief discussion by Paul Anand et al., little dedicated consideration of the challenges of applying Sen's approach specifically to analysing poverty. Considering the problems, and choices, that remain in any application of the approach, this is something of a lacuna.
Nonetheless, this Festschrift successfully demonstrates the breadth of Sen's work and includes several stimulating papers by prominent authors on issues related to same. Those interested in the full range of fields to which Sen has contributed or, indeed, those who are interested in the contribution of Sen himself will undoubtedly find the volume stimulating. However, those with a more limited focus are likely to find whole sections somewhat superfluous. In terms of its focus on poverty and capabilities, the volume will be of particular interest to those within social policy who operate at the border of economics and those interested in empirical applications of Sen's approach.
