This book builds upon Ann Olga Koloski-Ostrow's extensive practical work on toilets, sewers and baths to provide a full-length theoretical and methodological exploration of the social and cultural attitudes surrounding sanitation and human waste management in the Roman world. As the author rightly points out, until relatively recently scholars have tended to ignore or neglect the function and importance of latrines and sewers in removing human, animal and other such waste; perceived as topics either too quotidian or ‘dirty’ to warrant proper investigation. Consequently, the monograph achieves its aim of putting latrines and sewers ‘more directly into the spotlight of Roman history and the history of technology’ (1). The monograph brings together an extensive range of archaeological, literary and epigraphic material on hygiene, latrines, baths and water management, topics often discussed in separate publications. Since one of the author's primary goals is to explain the introduction and growing popularity of public and private latrines in Roman cities, K.-O. focuses on Italian material, mostly from Rome, Ostia, Pompeii and Herculaneum, dating between the first century b.c. and the first century a.d. Following a long preface that functions as a literature review, the book is divided into five chapters.
The first chapter introduces some of the overarching questions of the monograph. Did latrines improve sanitary conditions and were urban toilets designed with the goal of improving urban health (4)? The remainder of the chapter is a descriptive catalogue of archaeologically attested latrines in Italy, followed by a suggested typology of toilet types. While the list is extensive, a summary table at the end of the chapter would have been useful. The second chapter provides overviews of sanitary practices in other cultures, both past and present, including ancient Jews, European practices in the Middle Ages, and modern Muslims and Hindus. One of the major strengths of the volume is that K.-O. frequently forces the reader to question ancient notions of hygiene and to dispel many modern Western assumptions. Although brief, these overviews serve that purpose.
The third chapter starts with K.-O.’s argument that the increased popularity of public multi-seater latrines in Italy was the result of Greek influence and that the Roman military helped spread the practice to the provinces. The following section describes how the Cloaca Maxima and most other sewers, in the Roman mind, acted primarily as drains for run-off aqueduct and rain water, and only secondarily as receptacles for waste. The chapter concludes with an explanation for the seemingly strange tendency for Romans not to connect their private domestic latrines to the main sewer lines. K.-O. convincingly argues that sewers could back up during storms or flooding and that exposure to the large sewer tunnels would allow vermin and (even more) insects to climb up a private toilet.
The fourth chapter looks at Roman attitudes and behaviours regarding urination and defecation. While the section on the uses of human waste, especially as fertiliser, makes good use of the ancient sources, the other theories presented in the chapter are not as well argued. The idea that the sponge on a stick was used as toilet paper is no longer considered valid. Although there was undoubtedly a political element to their construction, the notion that the elite built public latrines to force the non-elite to hide their toilet activities seems a stretch. We are unsure how often the elite used these spaces, yet we are certain that the vast majority of the non-elite did not simply defecate in the middle of an urban centre on a regular basis, but must have attempted to use some sort of private or semi-private facilities whenever possible. The fifth and final chapter focuses on the literary sources and the way that sewers and toilets were used as metaphors, especially in satire. After a discussion of graffiti related to or found within latrines, the chapter ends with a brief concluding section that again warns the reader against modern biases when applying our notions of hygiene to the Roman world.
Although the monograph addresses and challenges numerous pertinent issues, important ideas are spread throughout the text, at times making the overarching argument difficult to follow. The reader is not left with a clear impression of Roman attitudes towards hygiene nor approaches to sanitation. Similarly, while an enormous range of topics is discussed, from Greek latrines to Parisian sewers to modern chemical treatment methods, most are not described in detail; at only 122 pages there were times when more attention could have been paid to particular topics. The reader is similarly not aided by the layout of the monograph. All the images are at the end, followed by an extensive series of notes that do not contain full bibliographic references. Consequently the reader has to continuously flip back and forth between the text, images, notes and bibliography.
The monograph was published in 2015, and in hindsight it is now possible to see that it was not alone in putting the topics of sanitation, hygiene and water management into the spotlight. It is difficult to say if the book inspired or spawned the increased attention paid to these topics, but nonetheless it is one of the early and important contributors to the field. As a more theoretical and methodological exploration, it is unfortunate that K.-O. completed the manuscript just prior to the full publication of the Cardo V sewer at Herculaneum (which is presented incorrectly in the monograph: 66, 76), Hobson and Trusler's more extensive work on the toilets at Pompeii, Piers Mitchell's work on Roman parasites and the rise of sensory archaeology, especially as it relates to smell (e.g. M. Bradley (ed.), Smell and the Ancient Senses (2015)). However, it is a testament to the author that almost none of her conclusions have been proven incorrect, and many of the theories presented in the monograph are now supported by additional archaeological evidence. Perhaps a second edition of the book would help shed even more light on this seemingly dark and dank aspect of Roman life.
