As our knowledge of the functional and pharmacological architecture of the nervous system increases, we are getting better at treating cognitive and affective disorders. Along with the ability to modify cognitive and affective systems in disease, we are also learning how to modify these systems in health. “Cosmetic neurology,” the practice of intervening to improve cognition and affect in healthy individuals, raises several ethical concerns.1
Farah MJ, Illes J, Cook-Deegan R, Gardner H, Kandel E, King P, et al. Neurocognitive enhancement: What can we do and what should we do? Nature Review Neurosciences 2004;5:421–5; Chatterjee A. Cosmetic neurology: The controversy over enhancing movement, mentation and mood. Neurology 2004;63:968–74.
Chatterjee A. The promise and predicament of cosmetic neurology. The Journal of Medical Ethics 2006;32:110–3.
Clinical and Technical Imperatives
Cosmetic surgery was propelled by a combination of a pivotal need for reconstructive surgery and technical developments. Although reconstructive surgical techniques date back to Indian treatises from 600 BC and were known in Europe during the Renaissance, the introduction of anesthesia and antibiotics made these surgical procedures far more feasible. The First World War served as a major impetus for the development of cosmetic surgery.3
Haiken E. Venus Envy. A History of Cosmetic Surgery. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press; 1997.
Ryan L. Plastic surgery. Illinois Medical Journal 1918;34:69.
During the 20th century, technological innovations continued, and the scope of cosmetic surgery expanded to cover almost every part of the body.5
Hait P. History of the American Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons, Inc., 1931–1994. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 1994;94:1A–99A.
As an example of technical developments in this enterprise, as of 2003, fillers include bovine and porcine collagen, hyaluronic acid, autologous collagen, cultured autologous fibroblasts, silicone, cadaver fascia lata, cadaver dermis, polymethylmethacrylate, polylactic acid, polyoxyethylene, polyoxypropylene and dextran; Rohrich R, Rios J, Fagien S. Role of new fillers in facial rejuvenation: A cautious outlook. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 2003;112:1899–902.
Thus, clinical needs prompted by war injuries and technical developments were preconditions for the development of cosmetic surgery. Analogous clinical needs for cosmetic neurology are now present. By the age of 85 between a quarter and a half of the population may have a dementing illness.7
Evans D, Funkenstein H, Albert M, Scherr P, Cook N, Chown M, et al. Prevalence of Alzheimer's disease in a community population of older persons. Higher than previously reported. Journal of the American Medical Association 1989;262:2551–6.
Kessler R, Chui W, Demler O, Walters E. Prevalence, severity, and comorbidity of 12-month DSM IV disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives of General Psychiatry 2005;62:617–27.
The clinical need for treatments for cognitive and affective disorders is accompanied by scientific developments that make neuroenhancement possible. The targets for neuroenhancement include motor, cognitive, and affective systems. Motor abilities can be enhanced by modulating cardiovascular, peripheral motor, and central nervous systems. Human erythropoietin and sildenefil increases oxygen-carrying capacities for better endurance.9
Varlet-Marie E, Gaudard A, Audran M, Bressolle F. Pharmacokinetics/pharmacodynamics of recombinant human erythropoietins in doping control. Sports Medicine 2003;33:301–15; Gaudard A, Varlet-Marie E, Bressolle F, Audran M. Drugs for increasing oxygen transport and their potential use in doping. Sports Medicine 2003;33:187–212.
Barton-Davis E, Shoturma D, Musaro A, Rosenthal N, Sweeney H. Viral mediated expression of insulin-like growth factor I blocks the aging-related loss of skeletal muscle function. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 1998;95:15603–7.
Walker-Batson D, Smith P, Curtis S, Unwin H, Greenlee R. Amphetamine paired with physical therapy accelerates motor recovery after stroke: Further evidence. Stroke 1995;26:2254–9.
Attention, memory, and learning can also be modulated in healthy people. Cholinesterase inhibitors improve normal performance in laboratory vigilance tests.12
Yesavage J, Mumenthaler M, Taylor J, Friedman L, O'Hara R, Sheikh J, et al. Donezepil and flight simulator performance: Effects on retention of complex skills. Neurology 2001;59:123–5.
Turner D, Robbins T, Clark L, Aron A, Dowson J, Sahakian B. Cognitive enhancing effects of modafinil in healthy volunteers. Psychopharmacology 2003;165:260–9.
Lynch G. Memory enhancement: The search for mechanism-based drugs. Nature Neuroscience Supplement 2003;5:1035–8.
Finally, we continue to refine ways to modify affective systems. Beta-blockers appear to help with posttraumatic symptoms in individuals who come to emergency departments after car crashes.15
Pitman R, Sanders K, Zusman R, Healy A, Cheema F, Lasko N, et al. Pilot study of secondary prevention of posttraumatic stress disorder with propanolol. Biological Psychiatry 2002;51:189–92.
Knutson B, Wolkowitz O, Cole S, Chan T, Moore E, Johnson R, et al. Selective alteration of personality and social behavior by serotonergic intervention. American Journal of Psychiatry 1998;155:373–9.
Holmes A, Heilig M, Rupniak N, Steckler T, Griebel G. Neuropeptide systems as novel therapeutic targets for depression and anxiety disorders. Trends in Pharmacological Sciences 2003;24:580–8.
Salzano J. Taming stress. Scientific American 2003;289:87–95.
We are in the midst of a period of unprecedented and ongoing development in neuropharmacology. Reconstructive surgery toppled into cosmetic surgery as if pushed by a technological imperative. Will a similar technological imperative tip the clinical neurosciences into cosmetic neurology?
Ethics and Inevitability
The ethical concerns raised by cosmetic neurology have been reviewed in detail elsewhere.19
See note 1, Chatterjee 2004.
Similar ethical concerns applied to cosmetic surgery, and yet cosmetic surgery is now practiced widely. Concerns about safety for cosmetic surgical procedures have always been present and became especially salient when silicone breast implants were implicated in autoimmune disorders.20
Sullivan D. Cosmetic Surgery: The Cutting Edge of Commercial Medicine in America. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press; 2001.
Selz M. Lenders find niche in cosmetic surgery that isn't insured. Wall Street Journal 1997 Jan 15.
Banner L. American Beauty. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1986; Davis K. Reshaping the female body. The dilemma of cosmetic surgery. New York: Routledge; 1995.
Morgan K. Women and the knife: Cosmetic surgery and the colonization of women's bodies. Hypatia 1991;6:25–53.
Ring A. Using “anti-aging” to market cosmetic surgery: Just good business, or another wrinkle on the face of medical practice? Medical Journal of Australia 2002;176:597–9; Miller F, Brody H, Chung K. Cosmetic surgery and the internal morality of medicine. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 2000;9:353–64.
Despite these concerns about cosmetic surgery, in 2004 board-certified surgeons performed 9.2 million cosmetic surgical procedures (compared to 5.6 million reconstructive procedures), a 700% increase since 1992. For women, the top five cosmetic surgical procedures were liposuction, breast augmentation, eyelid surgery, nose reshaping, and face-lifts. For men, the top five cosmetic surgical procedures were nose reshaping, hair transplantation, eyelid surgery, liposuction, and breast reduction. These procedures are not confined to white America. Between 2000 and 2004, 49% more procedures were performed on Hispanics and 24% each on African-Americans and Asian-Americans. These statistics (http://www.plasticsurgery.org/public_education/2004Statistics.cfm) apply to board-certified physicians and undoubtedly underestimate the actual number of procedures performed.
How did cosmetic surgery become so common? Although technical and scientific developments were a necessary prerequisite for this development, cultural, sociological, and economic forces paved the way. Analogous forces seem poised to pave the way for cosmetic neurology.
Cultural Conditions
The most important impediment to the legitimacy of cosmetic surgery was the view that it was frivolous. Over the years, choosing to undergo cosmetic surgery was reframed as a rational economic and psychological decision. This reframing occurred as the American ideal of self-improvement was changing. Seventeenth and 18th century religious notions of self-improvement gave way in the 19th century to moral but secular constructions, in which developing character became the goal. In the early 20th century, the emphasis on character shifted to a cult of personality. Personality emphasized the presentation of one's self in order to stand out in a crowd and was rooted in a social rather than an individual judgment. It could be augmented by proper speech, dress, and manners.25
Sussman W. ‘Personality’ and the making of twentieth century culture. In: Culture as History: The transformation of American Society in the Twentieth Century. New York: Pantheon; 1985:273–4.
Finally, and most importantly, psychology provided a conceptual framework for the practice of cosmetic surgery.26
See note 3, Haiken 1997.
Maltz M. New Faces, New Futures: Rebuilding Character with Plastic Surgery. New York: Richard R Smith; 1936.
Thus, the major criticism of cosmetic surgery as frivolous was countered by the view that it fell within the obligation to improve one's self, and that it was a serious rational decision with clear economic and psychological consequences. Cosmetic neurology, by contrast, does not face the frivolity concern, at least not directly. The obligation to improve one's self extends to a responsibility to be productive and congenial. The economic rationale to maximize abilities is also evident. The workplace has only become more competitive over the years. Many sectors of society have winner-take-all conditions in which small advantages produce disproportionate rewards.28
Frank R, Cook P. The Winner-Take-All Strategy. New York: The Free Press; 1995.
The Media's Role
The changing cultural values that legitimized the use of cosmetic surgery were promoted most clearly by the media. Womens' magazines advised women on gender roles, methods of self-improvement, and how to deal with new technologies, including surgical innovations. They introduced a vocabulary that made cosmetic surgery familiar. In the 1950s, the postwar emphasis on domesticity extended to comparing cosmetic procedures to sewing, and face-lifts as a way to “neaten” or “tidy up” one's face. Articles on appearance related themes served as instructional guides and updates on new trends or autobiographical accounts. According to Sullivan,29
See note 20, Sullivan 2001.
An exception to this trend is discussions of breast implants, but only after 1990 Congressional hearings were conducted in response to pressure from medical researchers and patient advocates.
It is too early to predict the media's role in the evolution of cosmetic neurology. What is clear is that they will be active participants.31
In eight months following a single article on cosmetic neurology published in the journal Neurology, I was interviewed by six newspaper journalists (whose articles have been reprinted in many newspapers), 11 print, and two web magazine journalists, three radio journalists, and one book author. The interest was not confined to the United States. The interviewers have included journalists from Canada, Europe, and Asia. The press messages have varied from being informative, to expectant, to optimistic, to cautious, to caustic. Two television programs also contacted me. Neither produced a story. One was explicit about the need to avoid nuanced discussions in order to make stories “palatable” to viewers.
Medicine's Response
Cosmetic surgery introduced a medical practice without precedent. Despite considerable initial resistance and deep ambivalences among physicians, in 2004 almost twice as many cosmetic as reconstructive procedures were conducted in the United States. How did physicians reconsider their role to make this practice possible, and what can we expect of physicians in the development of cosmetic neurology?
The initial resistance to cosmetic surgery in the early 20th century arose when physicians were establishing their legitimacy as healthcare practitioners.32
Starr P. The Social Transformation of American Medicine. New York: Basic Books; 1982.
Blair V. Plastic surgery of the head, face and neck: The psychic reaction. Journal of the American Dental Association 1936;23:236–40.
Sullivan34
See note 20, Sullivan 2001.
In the 1970s, the Federal Trade Commission, attempting to decrease medical costs, decided that bans on advertising violated antitrust laws. Vigorous medical marketing followed this ruling.35
See note 5, Hait 1994.
How do the dynamics within medicine over the last 85 years in response to cosmetic surgery compare to what might be expected for cosmetic neurology? The struggles of the AMA in the first half of the 20th century to legitimize medicine by upholding standards and decrying commercialism seem a distant memory. Physicians as a group seem less motivated to establish or maintain their role as cultural authorities. Consequently, the idea of distinguishing between legitimate and quack practitioners, although still germane, is not likely to gather much force. The competitive pressures in the practice of medicine continue unabated. Physician salaries have decreased in recent years, and the bureaucratic burdens of practicing corporate medicine are substantial. The option to engage in a fee for service practice remains enticing. Many psychiatrists now only see patients in fee for service practices, an example cosmetic neurology is likely to follow. Pharmacological enhancements do not face the technical barriers present with cosmetic surgery. Pharmaceutical companies promote the myriad ways in which medications can be used. The Internet as a source of unregulated information and as a marketplace serves to increase demand and creates availability not conceivable for cosmetic surgery.
Ironically, success in clinical neurosciences may bolster cosmetic neurology practices, analogous to the way that decreased demand for reconstructive surgery strengthened cosmetic surgery. Consider Alzheimer's disease, the most common degenerative dementia. Specialized clinical and research Alzheimer's Disease Centers now dot the landscape, and intensive efforts at understanding the pathophysiology and developing treatments are underway. To date most treatments are symptomatic. Although these interventions can improve patients' quality of life, they do not halt or reverse the disease. However, within our lifetime AD might be diagnosed and treated in its preclinical stages. Then, will this massive infrastructure of cognitive experts and specialized centers be redirected to the practice of cosmetic neurology?
It is hard to know if medicine as a profession will engage in promoting cosmetic neurology in an organized way. As part of the ongoing specialization of medicine, this past year, the United Council for Neurologic Subspecialties approved accreditation and licensing procedures for fellowships in behavioral neurology and neuropsychiatry. Thus, an organizational body that might eventually have an economic interest in the development and promotion of cosmetic neurology is in place. More broadly, fiduciary and commercial interests in medicine are increasingly conflated. Academicians develop patents and start their own companies. Hospitals engage in aggressive marketing campaigns. Relationships with rich donor–patients and families are carefully nurtured. Paradoxically, medicine is returning to a marketplace mentality and morality that the AMA decried a century ago. If there is money to be made, barriers to cosmetic neurology appear flimsy at best.
Challenges
If the history of cosmetic surgery is a guide, then the growth of cosmetic neurology seems inevitable. Factors that impeded the development of cosmetic surgery have dissipated, whereas the relevant factors that promoted cosmetic surgery remain in force. The advent of cosmetic neurology presents challenges to physicians and bioethicists.
Physicians are less engaged in questions of legitimacy. Legal and economic concerns insert themselves into decisions made by physicians at the bedside as their autonomy has declined markedly.36
Rothman D. Strangers at the Bedside. New York: Aldine; 2003.
Bioethics evolved in an organized form in the late 1960s and early 1970s and has focused on medical and technological advances.37
Fox R, Swazey J. Examining American bioethics: Its problems and prospects. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 2005;14:361–73.
Nuffield Council on Bioethics. Genetics and Human Behavior: The Ethical Context. London: The Council; 2002.
