Avi Rubin's Ottoman Nizamiye Courts: Law and Modernity is an encouraging addition to the field of Ottoman legal studies. The book makes valuable contributions to discussions of the Nizamiye court system—the judicial apparatus that Ottoman administrators instituted in the mid-19th century to support Tanzimat-era and post-Tanzimat bureaucratic restructuring. By describing this juridical change from the perspective of those “inside the courtroom” (p. 2), including judges, plaintiffs, defendants, public prosecutors, professional attorneys, among others, Rubin contributes a much needed social dimension to existing work on 19th- and early 20th-century Ottoman law. Rubin's aim in providing a “sociolegal” rather than theoretical description of the workings of the Nizamiye courts is to “redirect” conversation about “judicial reform from the self-explanatory narrative of westernization to the path of everyday history” (p. 8).
But Rubin also has more ambitious goals. He seeks to extrapolate from his analysis of the Nizamiye court system a number of more general points about Ottoman modernity writ large. Since the Nizamiye courtroom was a place in which the daily life of ordinary Ottomans overlapped with the formal courtroom procedures and empire-wide legislation developed in Istanbul, it provides an effective case study, he suggests, for “prob[ing] into the experience of modernity in everyday life” (p. 7). The chapters of the book thus include discussions, first, of the “organizational evolution of the Nizamiye courts” (p. 14), the interactions between Şeriat courts and Nizamiye courts, legal formalism as a juridical ideal, and legislation against judicial corruption. Yet Rubin also addresses how Ottoman citizens negotiated what he describes as 19th-century Ottoman “legal pluralism” (p. 60), how these citizens found new opportunities in legal formalism—even while this formalism demanded turning to a new cadre of professional attorneys—and how public prosecutors came to be viewed as “guardians of justice” (p. 133). Rubin's purpose in bringing these social aspects of the Nizamiye court system to bear on formal descriptions of Ottoman law is to show once again, this time at the level of Ottoman modernity in general, that “Westernization” is an ineffective model for describing Ottoman citizens’ everyday experiences in the last centuries of the empire (p. 8).
Rubin grounds his analysis of the Nizamiye court system in an innovative methodological move. He notes that the reason for the “historiographical void” that exists in writing on 19th-century Ottoman law—namely, the absence of any analysis of “the daily interactions” inside local courts—is that there is no equivalent of the Şeriat sicils for the Nizamiye court system (p. 9). Whereas historians of Ottoman law and society prior to the mid-19th century can draw on the vast archive of Şeriat court records for their work, historians interested in the social aspects of the Nizamiye courts have no such similar body of material. Rubin solves this problem by turning to a different source, the Ceride-i Mehakim, or Journal of Courts, which was distributed to the Ottoman legal community as of 1873. Moreover, he reads this source alongside more familiar Ottoman and British archival documents to good effect. Conscious of both the limitations and the value of the Ceride, Rubin is able to “reconstruct daily praxis” (p. 12) in a way that has hitherto been impossible.
This inventive methodology is productive. Rubin's discussion of the work of the public prosecutors, for instance, is both lively and thought provoking. He demonstrates convincingly that their role as overseers of court function was as important as their work in criminal prosecution and that they were essential in both the administrative and social centralization of the Ottoman state. In addition, Rubin's use of the Ceride provides further evidence that the interplay between the jurisdiction of Nizamiye courts and that of Şeriat courts was more complex than an earlier generation of Ottoman historians held it to be.
Indeed, although it is true that a decade has passed since historians of Ottoman law began to dismantle what Rubin refers to as the “duality narrative” (p. 55)—in which the Nizamiye courts and Şeriat courts were portrayed as discrete entities, philosophically and ideologically irrelevant to one another—Rubin's contribution to this scholarly trend is particularly intriguing. Until now, scholars have relied on readings of legislative texts or legal rhetoric, analyses of the movement of judicial personnel, and details of cases that reached Istanbul as evidence that Nizamiye and Şeriat courts complemented rather than competed with one another (or, more broadly, that dichotomies between Nizamiye–secular–modern on the one hand and Şeriat–religious–traditional on the other hand are not analytically helpful). By turning to the Ceride, Rubin is able to show that the “duality narrative” also fails to describe 19th- and early 20th-century Ottoman law at the level of civil trials. This local perspective on the jurisdictional interaction between these two supposedly distinct court systems is invaluable—an indication of what turning to a source like the Ceride can do for ongoing conversations in Ottoman legal studies.
In fact, if the book has a fault, it is that Rubin does not take advantage of the conversational openings that his argument provides. Put differently, Rubin's sometimes radical claims to scholarly uniqueness—that he is the first or the only Ottomanist to make these arguments or to chart this field, for example—shut down the possibility of effectively engaging with those, such as Selim Deringil or İlber Ortaylı, who have written on similar topics. This is a shame because what is exciting about the book is precisely that it is not an obscure study of a marginal topic but rather part of an ongoing trend toward more sophisticated and responsible writing on law in the modern Ottoman Empire. More to the point, this insistence on the book's total originality puts Rubin in an awkward position as far as his analytical foils are concerned. I had a hard time accepting, for instance, that recent scholars of Ottoman law (or Ottoman modernity, for that matter) would refer to Tanzimat-era or post-Tanzimat policies or ideologies as “Westernizing.” Rather than devoting pages of the book to knocking over this straw man (as well as others) in the name of demonstrating the distinctiveness of his argument, therefore, Rubin might have instead developed his fascinating but incomplete discussion of Ottoman legal pluralism or jurisdictional “grey zones” (p. 81) or, better, linked his discussion constructively rather than combatively to other writings in the field.
This frustrating aspect of Rubin's analysis, however, is more than balanced by the detail and effectiveness with which he reconceives the Nizamiye courts as spaces of daily social interaction. His concern for his topic and his desire not to exploit the people who populate the pages of the book—to recognize these people as humans with sometimes difficult and complex lives—are clear throughout. As he writes early on, he is uninterested in “‘grading’ the performances of the Nizamiye court system” because doing so undermines attempts at multidimensional, sensitive interpretations of law (p. 48). This open-mindedness and willingness to eschew easy civilizational comparison are rare among historians, and they will hopefully continue to motivate Rubin as he develops and expands his research on legal modernity in the Ottoman Empire.
