A carefully attentive visitor to Tate Modern's 2007–8 exhibition The World as a Stage would have noticed a small black-and-white photographic print depicting an old woman in a wide-sleeved gown, actively posed in front of an immense tree trunk. The image, from Trisha Donnelly's The Redwood and the Raven, would have appeared to be a single documentation of a performer in the woods. However, as Georgina Guy details in Chapter 2 of Theatre, Exhibition, and Curation: Displayed & Performed, the image of the woman and the tree was replaced with a subsequent image in a sequence each day, so that the woman (and the tree) completed a dance over the course of every thirty-one days (79). Thus, in The Redwood and the Raven, what might have appeared as a document of a performance if encountered in an archive, actually performed in the exhibition, and did so without the original artist or subject present. Moreover, The Redwood and the Raven exploded the frame of a photographic document, the performance of which has only relatively recently been explored in scholarship (for example, in Rebecca Schneider's Performing Remains: Art and War in Times of Theatrical Reenactment, 2011). It could perform in this particular manner only in the space of exhibition (81), a space “premised on the symbiosis of performance and display” (95).
Guy, like Schneider, Susan Bennett, Shannon Jackson, and Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett before her, is interested in the interplay between static museum display and live theatrical performance. Where Guy attempts a new trajectory of discourse is in establishing an “optic” (71) for exhibitions and performances that shrug off, as in the example above, the discrete categories of displayed and performed, plumbing instead—as the ampersand in the subtitle represents—the blurry and dynamic space of “productive frictions” (174) in between. Rather than looking to reenactments or conventional performances in museum spaces for examples, as have, for instance, Catherine Hughes (Museum Theatre), Anthony Jackson and Jenny Kidd (Performing Heritage), and Tessa Bridal (Exploring Museum Theatre), or to exhibitions of theatre artifacts and ephemera (Bennett's Theatre & Museums), Guy primarily focuses on exhibitions produced by artists in high-profile “white cube” (1) art museums, principally in London.
Using what she calls, “after Peggy Phelan, a ‘performance-minded’ approach” (23), Guy purports to use this optic to identify a new moment in “the artistic, intellectual, and social life of performance” (1)—a moment in which the binary between conventional modes of exhibition (stasis) and performance (transience), “often presented as a site of antagonism and exclusion” (4), gives way, revealing new or previously hidden manners of seeing or attending to each mode in relation to the other. Further, Guy argues that, taken together, the case studies between 2007 and 2012 that she examines constitute “what might now be considered a seminal event in the history of live art” (3). Responding in particular to Schneider's work, Guy writes, “[i]t is my hope that this book will contribute to the disciplinary debates currently rewriting the performance field by taking exhibition, rather than performance or object, as its primary optic” (10).
The book begins with a lengthy introduction. Each chapter thereafter brings together a variety of exhibitions and other events that complement one another both in theme and in the manner through which they “exceed the form of the static object in perpetual display and the disappearing performance” in order to “operate beyond both performed modes and object-centric display practices by occupying their interstice” (24). Chapter 1, the strongest in the book, draws out a number of helpful propositions by pairing two works: Drama Queens, a 2008 performance at the Old Vic Theatre, London, by Elmgreen & Dragset with text by Tim Etchells, which staged a dialogue between famous museum sculptures (voiced by famous actors); and Marina Abramović Presents … at the Whitworth Art Gallery in Manchester in 2009, which put a series of performances in a gallery that had been cleared of art objects usually displayed therein. Whereas Michael Fried's foundational argument in 1967 was that minimalism subverts both art as object and art as representation, Drama Queens exposed the material “thingness” of the sculptures and exposed them as representational (these are not the real sculptures; they're standing in for them); and in so doing, it evidences how objects may communicate through these material and representational modes (48–9, 55). By the same token, Abramović and others have played with duration, time, linearity, and progression in their performances in gallery spaces, which “makes visible th[e] usually fleeting and accidental” (59) and thus ascribes a concreteness to performance usually reserved for static objects.
Chapter 2 couples Barnaby Wright's 2008 Courtauld Gallery exhibition Renoir at the Theatre: Looking at “La Loge” and Tate Modern's 2007 The World as a Stage, in order to present instances in which the elements of “static display and fleeting performance” are “redefined as latent in the other” (27). Chapter 3 and Chapter 4 take up performative and digital modes in exhibitions that make explicit the presence of the visitor, her patterns of movement and stillness in a gallery space, or even (as in the case of the Eye Tracking System at University College London's Interaction Centre) the scanning movement of her eyes as she attends to different parts of a single work over time. While the book ultimately may not go far enough to convince readers that these exhibitions signal “a seminal event in the history of live art” (3), the approaches the author carefully describes in these last two chapters especially illuminate Guy's fundamental contribution to the discussion of visual arts and performance. The paths we cut with our bodies and eyes, and the relationships we create among art objects (in relation to each other and in relation to concepts in time), structure the meaning we derive from the performance as much as do the creators’ intentions and the structures of the works themselves (132, 141).
