The quarter century following the Second World War saw the transformation of Scottish politics. In the decade after 1945, election results in Scotland largely mirrored wider British trends, with Labour initially dominant, before the Unionists, as the Conservatives were labelled in Scotland until 1965, recovered in the early 1950s.Footnote 1 From the 1959 general election onwards, however, Labour enjoyed an electoral supremacy that would survive for more than five decades; in contrast, the Unionists, and their Conservative successors, entered an era of sustained decline. Scottish Conservatism's travails were accentuated by the resuscitation of Liberalism and the arrival of the Scottish National party (SNP) as a credible political force. By the 1970s, a distinctive four-party Scottish electoral contest was established.Footnote 2
Assessments of this period of political realignment have emphasised the importance of several factors. Secularisation eroded the popular Protestantism that underpinned working-class Unionism, exposing the party to accusations that it represented only a remote and Anglicised landed elite, and encouraging younger voters to view the SNP with greater sympathy. Further, the growing reliance of Scots on the public sector for employment and housing, coupled with the relative weakness of the Scottish economy from the late 1950s, entrenched support for the Labour party in urban and industrial areas, while simultaneously lending weight to nationalist criticisms of the performance of successive Westminster regimes. The improved fortunes of the SNP have, perhaps more speculatively, been attributed too to a loss of faith in British identity triggered by economic stagnation and imperial retreat.Footnote 3 Equally, political scientists have suggested that the fall in Unionist support after 1959 represented the assertion of ‘natural’ political allegiances, as Scotland's social and economic structure began to be reflected at the polls.Footnote 4 It is, in such a reading, the anomaly of earlier Unionist success that needs explanation, with the distinctive Scottish aspects of the party's appeal being highlighted.Footnote 5
Such developments were undoubtedly significant. The intention in this study is, nonetheless, to offer a different perspective, one that both complements and complicates existing accounts by foregrounding the role of ideology in post-war Scottish politics, as disclosed chiefly through political rhetoric. Since the 1920s, Unionists had exploited concerns over the alleged threat posed by socialism to attract the support of erstwhile Liberals, often building upon the purportedly non-partisan anti-Labour pacts established at a municipal level.Footnote 6 During the 1940s, this anti-socialist appeal was amplified by wartime experiences and the election of the first majority Labour government, imbuing Unionism with an individualist idiom centred upon the defence of individual liberty, and opposed to the expansion of the authority of central government. The principal divide within Scottish political debate after 1945 was provided not by class, or by attitudes towards the constitution, but by this contest between individualism and socialism. Efforts to understand post-war Scottish politics require an examination of why the electoral alliance assembled beneath the Unionist banner, and held together by an appeal to individual freedom, began to disintegrate. We should, then, reconsider the language used by Unionist politicians and their allies, as well as the worldview they promoted. In doing so, we may relate an assessment of Scottish politics to wider British debates, and especially those that concern the fluctuating fortunes of what W. H. Greenleaf described as the ‘libertarian strand’ within British political thought.Footnote 7 Libertarian in this context should, of course, not be interpreted in a literal or absolute manner, but rather as denoting an inclination to view the growing power of the central state with foreboding, alongside a scepticism regarding the viability of economic planning.Footnote 8
The primary concern here is, then, with the attempts of politicians to secure public support, to convince voters to view matters in a certain way; the focus is, by necessity, on what politicians said. As scholars of political rhetoric have recognised, ideologies are more than sets of substantive policy positions: they are, as Alan Finlayson and James Martin have stressed, also a matter of ‘a “mood”, an emotional register and a style of presentation’.Footnote 9 The analysis that follows is designed to trace the temper of post-war Scottish politics, particularly among that half of the electorate unconvinced by the claims of the Labour party. First, the nature of the Unionist appeal after 1945 is outlined; second, the rise of discontent among Unionist supporters in the late 1950s is explored alongside the upturn in the fortunes of the Liberal party; third, the Unionist response to the 1959 general election is examined; lastly, the implications of the decrease in Unionist support during the 1960s are assessed.
I
The Unionists, in common with their Conservative colleagues in England, contested the 1945 general election on a platform of defending individual freedom and lifting the economic controls imposed during wartime. The campaign culminated with Winston Churchill's infamous radio broadcast, where, echoing Friedrich Hayek's Road to Serfdom, published the previous year, he warned that a Labour victory, and the ensuing introduction of socialism, would presage a slide into tyranny.Footnote 10 The result was, nevertheless, a Labour landslide, with the Conservatives enduring their worst defeat since 1906. Yet the party soon regrouped: at the 1950 general election, Labour's parliamentary majority was reduced to five; the following year the Conservatives returned to power, and remained in office for over a decade.
Traditionally, the Conservative revival was attributed to the party's acceptance of the new political landscape created by the war and confirmed by Labour's victory in 1945, one in which the primary role of government was to ensure full employment, manage a mixed economy and oversee the running of the nascent welfare state.Footnote 11 It was, in this model, not until the 1970s that this governing consensus collapsed, amid economic crisis and the Conservative party's turn to the right under the leadership of Margaret Thatcher.Footnote 12 Since the 1990s, however, this interpretation has been questioned, and the extent to which Conservative opinion remained unreconciled to the post-war settlement emphasised. Ina Zweiniger-Bargielowska highlighted the crucial role that opposition to rationing, particularly among female voters, played in the Conservative victory in 1951; likewise, Harriet Jones argued that post-war Conservatism was hostile towards redistributive taxation and universal welfare provision.Footnote 13 For Ewen Green, notions of a post-war consensus were weakened by the continued influence within Conservative ranks of ‘liberal-market’ opposition to state intervention.Footnote 14 As Green noted drily, the party's slogan in this era was ‘“Set the People Free”, not the welfare state and the mixed economy are safe in our hands.’Footnote 15
Still, these debates have had relatively little impact on studies of Scottish politics, where the conviction that Unionist success hinged upon a combination of an appeal to Scottish identity and an embrace of corporatism remains dominant.Footnote 16 Yet this assessment is at odds with the rhetoric often deployed by the party, infused as it could be with Hayekian warnings that the increasing powers accrued by the central state, while perhaps necessary during wartime, had become a threat to personal freedom, and claims that Labour's programme of nationalisation would, if allowed to continue, lead inexorably to totalitarianism. As the party's Western Divisional Council declared in 1948, the Labour government had overseen the erection of ‘a crazy economy’ characterised by ‘crushing taxation, restrictive controls, subsidies and a depreciated currency’: the public must choose ‘between the Unionist policy of a free economy and the democratic way of life on the one hand, and Socialist State monopoly and eventual servitude on the other’.Footnote 17
Individual Unionist politicians could speak in similarly apocalyptic terms. At a constituency association meeting in late 1946, William McNair Snadden, MP for Kinross and West Perthshire, advised that the ‘Socialist [i.e. Labour] policy of concentrating power into the hands of a few political bosses would result in the…final destruction of the freedom of the individual’: he urged all ‘anti-socialists’ to unite, since, if they remained divided, ‘they made certain of bringing about the very thing they had fought for six years to destroy – the Totalitarian State’. A year later, following the introduction of direction of labour, Snadden warned that the ‘fundamental right of the citizen to choose his own work was being taken away [and] if they did not bring down the Government then the Government would bring down the nation’.Footnote 18 Such doom-laden predictions were, no matter how hyperbolic, a common refrain, as Unionists depicted every political issue as evidence of the need to remove the Labour government from office. At a mass rally at Callender House in Falkirk, James Reid, the Unionist MP for Glasgow Hillhead who had served as lord advocate in the wartime coalition, stated that the next general election ‘would be vital for the future of this country’, since if Labour were re-elected, ‘they would drift to the left and freedom and prosperity would be so far gone that perhaps we should never recover’.Footnote 19 A few months later, Reid's Unionist counterpart in Glasgow Central, James Hutchison, declared that nationalisation had created ‘a race of sycophants – people who were always wondering if the man above was satisfied’. The public, he lamented, ‘simply did not realise just how dangerous a situation was being created for them’.Footnote 20 Alan Gomme Duncan, the Unionist member for Perth, was even blunter: if Labour secured another term, he warned, it would mark the ‘last general election in this country’.Footnote 21
Of course, none of these hysterical predictions were borne out by events; nor is it clear that the politicians who made them believed what they said. These limitations are, nevertheless, comparatively unimportant: such statements were, to use Maurice Cowling's formulation, ‘a form of exemplary utterance’, an ‘attempt to provide new landmarks for the electorate’.Footnote 22 What matters is that it was through an explicit rejection of consensus, and the promotion of a binary political contest structured around opposition to socialism, that Unionist politicians believed they could win public backing. Clearly, this approach was not total, or necessarily coherent: the party did not reject government action in every field; notably, Unionists, like their Conservative counterparts in England and Wales, considered local government to be an important source of civic identity and an essential counterweight to the expansion of the central state.Footnote 23 The dangers of socialism stemmed from centralisation, as embodied by the ‘vast State monopolies’ created to administer the nationalised industries.Footnote 24
This conception of post-war politics informed the Unionist appeal to Scottish national identity, usually treated as a cynical, if nonetheless successful, effort to provoke opposition to nationalisation from the safety of opposition.Footnote 25 There was, no doubt, a degree of electoral calculation present: it was not mere chance that the Unionist promotion of Scottish autonomy coincided with the launch of the Scottish Covenant, a mass petition in support of home rule organised by John MacCormick, the former national secretary of the SNP.Footnote 26 And, as Matthew Cragoe has shown, sympathy towards Scottish and Welsh sensibilities was integral to Conservatism's broader ‘discourse of decentralisation’.Footnote 27 But it would be wrong to dismiss this simply as tactics: as with the defence of local government, the promotion of Scottish distinctiveness was effective because it could be accommodated within, and even strengthen, a preexisting critique of centralised bureaucracy. It was not just that the growing dominance of Whitehall and Westminster threatened Scottish autonomy: socialism was a form of ‘despotism’, a political philosophy hostile to ‘individuality either in men or in nations’.Footnote 28 Equally, Churchill's deployment of quasi-nationalist language when appearing in Scotland during the 1950 and 1951 general election campaigns was tempered by his assertion that it was the prospect of the ‘serfdom of socialism’ that threatened the union between Scotland and England.Footnote 29 Even in the case of John MacCormick's candidacy at the 1948 Paisley by-election, when MacCormick felt he had united Labour's opponents on a home rule platform, local Unionists backed him only on the basis that he was the ‘anti-socialist candidate’.Footnote 30
For all that Unionism was defined by hostility to socialism, it was not narrowly partisan in outlook. If anything, the urgency of the threat alleged to be posed by Labour required the construction of a broad-based anti-socialist coalition. This strategy was evident in the 1947 pact concluded with the National Liberals, which saw the parties merge their constituency apparatus in some sixty seats.Footnote 31 As the parties declared in a joint statement, there was ‘one fundamental political issue’, namely ‘whether the principles of liberty of the individual’ and ‘freedom of enterprise’ would survive, ‘or whether the Socialist doctrine of regimentation, state-ownership and centralised control is to prevail’.Footnote 32 National Liberalism, which originated with those Liberals who remained loyal to the National Government after the abandonment of free trade in 1932, has been largely forgotten, with the 1947 agreement viewed as marking the effective end of the party's independent existence.Footnote 33 This may have been true in England, where the relative strength of Conservatism was far greater. In Scotland, though, National Liberalism enjoyed a long afterlife, exerting influence throughout the 1950s. Of the sixty joint constituency associations established by 1950, fifteen were in Scotland; in the decade that followed, the National Liberals routinely secured the support of just under one in ten Scottish voters, while the number of candidates adopting some form of the label increased.Footnote 34 National Liberalism's appeal was especially potent in the north-east, south-west and Highlands, areas of historic Conservative weakness: here, Unionism bent towards an entrenched Liberalism. Conspicuous too was the prominence of National Liberals sitting for Scottish seats both in the leadership of their party at Westminster, and, after 1951, in ministerial roles at the Scottish Office. Between 1947 and 1964, the position of National Liberal chairman was held exclusively by Scottish MPs, while John Maclay, National Liberal MP for West Renfrewshire, served as secretary of state for Scotland between 1957 and 1962; Niall MacPherson and James Henderson-Stewart, who sat as National Liberals for Galloway and East Fife respectively, were both junior Scottish Office ministers in this period.Footnote 35 The National Liberals were not, as has been suggested, simply ‘absorbed’ by the Unionists.Footnote 36
More even than support at the polls or personnel in cabinet, National Liberalism offered Unionism's instinctive anti-socialism, inherited from the 1920s and defined by allegations that socialism was a close relative of Bolshevism, and posed a similar threat to organised religion and family life, a more coherent intellectual framework.Footnote 37 If, in England, former Liberals were enlisted as ‘subaltern anti-socialists’, across rural and provincial Scotland the Unionists, through their association with National Liberalism, operated as ersatz Liberals.Footnote 38 Post-war Unionism is, then, understood best as composite in nature, as a coalition of Conservatives, Liberals and even nationalists united by a shared opposition to socialism. Such a view was given voice by Henderson-Stewart when he addressed a meeting of Unionist and National Liberal activists in South Angus in November 1949. Warning that if Labour were returned to power for a second term then liberal values would disappear ‘for a generation’, Henderson-Stewart urged Liberals and nationalists to support what he termed the ‘coalition led by Mr Churchill’, since if there were ‘a straight fight in every constituency’, Labour ‘would be thrashed’.Footnote 39 A year later, Maclay called similarly for a ‘united front’ to defeat socialism, and asked Liberals to overlook their historic opposition to Toryism and prioritise instead their shared commitment to individual freedom.Footnote 40
The arrangement with the National Liberals was intended to act as a prelude to a wider pact with the Liberal party. Although a formal alliance would prove elusive, winning over those who traditionally voted Liberal was central to Conservative electoral strategy.Footnote 41 As the party's 1950 campaign guide argued, there was ‘little fundamental difference between the Conservatives and Liberals such as exists between these parties and the bureaucratic and, at times, totalitarian control of the present Socialist Party’.Footnote 42 Indeed, the dramatic fall in the number of Liberal candidates at the 1951 general election was a critical factor in the Conservative victory. But Liberal retrenchment was partly a recognition of electoral reality, as opposition to Labour overrode older party loyalties, and limited the demand for more than one anti-socialist candidate in each constituency. Winston Churchill, upon his return to office in 1951, even offered the Liberal leader Clement Davies the role of minister of education in his new cabinet.Footnote 43
Claims that there was a return to partisan politics after 1945, or that elections in the 1950s were monochrome, two-party affairs, should thus be treated with caution.Footnote 44 Such a conclusion does a disservice to the patchwork, provisional nature of Unionism; it also overlooks the motivations of activists and voters. The ‘culture of coalitionism’ identified by Michael Dyer as prevailing on the centre and right of Scottish politics during the 1930s, but which he suggests was fading by the late 1940s, was in truth revitalised by antagonism towards the post-war Labour government and by the context of the cold war, which encouraged anti-communist sentiment, and granted warnings of a drift towards totalitarianism a certain plausibility, however ridiculous they appear in retrospect. To select one voice as an example: in late 1949, George Ramsay, a member of the executive committee of the Central Ayrshire Unionist association, wrote to Lord Woolton, the Conservative party chairman, to encourage the pursuit of unity with the Liberals. Despite his participation in Unionist politics, Ramsay described himself openly as a lifelong Liberal; crucially, though, while known locally as a Liberal, he was, he claimed, ‘better known…as an anti-socialist’, active in Unionist politics as it was the only party in the area that was ‘fighting Socialism’.Footnote 45
In constituencies with more robust Liberal traditions than Central Ayrshire, informal local agreements, designed to maximise the anti-Labour vote, were reached. The clearest example was Dundee, where cooperation between Liberals and Unionists had existed since the 1920s, a result of the city being one of the few double-member constituencies to survive into the twentieth century. When this changed ahead of the 1950 general election, and Dundee was split into eastern and western divisions, the old agreement, whereby the parties each nominated one candidate, was rendered obsolete; matters were complicated further by the Unionist pact with the National Liberals. Throughout 1948 and 1949, the Dundee Unionist association, now incorporating the National Liberals, encouraged local Liberals to agree to an alliance.Footnote 46 In practice, this meant supporting a National Liberal candidate in both seats. Initially, the Liberals refused, insisting that they would contest Dundee West, nominating the journalist John Junor and blaming the Unionists for creating a ‘situation where two anti-Socialist candidates are going forward in the Western division’. Yet there was little local appetite for separate candidacies, and an Anti-Socialist association was formed just three weeks before polling to press for a pact. Similar demands were made by the Dundee Housewives’ association, an organisation that campaigned for an end to rationing.Footnote 47 Within days, Junor agreed to stand down, on the condition that if the Unionist candidate were defeated then the Liberals would be given the opportunity to contest the seat at the next election. Important here is the fact that none of this was sanctioned by the Liberal leadership; indeed, the national party promoted a last-minute Liberal candidacy in Dundee West. But this was shunned by local members, who viewed anti-socialist unity as the primary aim. Such compromises could work in the opposite direction, as in Greenock, where in 1950 the Unionists stood aside in favour of the Liberals. Likewise, in Ross and Cromarty, the Unionist association offered support to Jack Macleod, first elected in 1945 as an independent Liberal, stating that as long as candidates opposed socialism, they had little interest in party labels.Footnote 48 At the 1951 election, Unionists had reached ‘anti-socialist’ understandings, whether with Liberals or National Liberals, in twenty of Scotland's seventy-one constituencies.Footnote 49
These tactics were not always successful: in Dundee and Greenock, the anti-socialist candidates, whether Unionist, Liberal or some combination of both, failed to defeat the Labour incumbents. All the same, they illustrate the extent to which Unionist electoral success in the 1950s was conditional. It rested upon two claims: first, that Labour presented a threat to individual liberty and economic freedom; second, that the Unionists were best placed to check, and then reverse, the socialist advance. The question was always how long such a defensive electoral coalition could last, and whether it could survive the transition from opposition to government.
II
The Conservatives, having defeated Labour at the 1951 general election, were returned to office with an increased majority in 1955; in Scotland, the Unionists and National Liberals together secured a majority of both votes and seats. Soon, though, the anti-socialism that underlay Conservative success began to fray, and the party's vote slumped at a series of by-elections, climaxing with the Liberal victory at Torrington in March 1958. The humiliation of the Suez crisis, which ended the career of Churchill's successor Anthony Eden, was partly responsible; there were, however, other determinants. The stringency of the individualist appeal employed by the Conservatives in opposition was always likely to prove difficult to sustain in office. Nevertheless, the return of iron and steel to private ownership, and the abandonment of Labour's plans to nationalise road haulage, could, when set alongside reductions in income tax and the abolition of rationing in 1954, be presented as evidence that the government had delivered on its pledges ‘to restore freedom, to reduce the burden of taxation and to give individual men and women a better chance to live a decent life’.Footnote 50 In Scotland, Unionists could point too to the appointment of an additional minister of state to the Scottish Office, and the convening of a Royal Commission on Scottish Affairs, as evidence of their commitment to the defence of Scottish autonomy from the incursions of London.Footnote 51 For the leadership, this represented the limits of the possible: further attempts at reform of the nationalised industries, or scaling back of the welfare state, risked controversy. But for party activists and voters, this caution was a source of frustration, as rising inflation eroded the position of those on fixed incomes and fostered antipathy towards the seemingly privileged position enjoyed by organised labour, especially in the public sector.Footnote 52
In Scotland, complaints that the government was failing to live up to its pre-election rhetoric were heard soon after the Conservatives had regained power: in 1953, there were demands from Unionist supporters for ‘more evidence of the intention to reduce the government's expenditure of the taxpayer's money’. After the 1955 general election, these grievances were voiced with increasing frequency. In October 1955, Patrick Blair, secretary of the Scottish Unionist association, reported a widespread ‘feeling’ amongst the party's supporters that there had not been a sufficient commitment to reducing public expenditure; there was, he reported, a feeling that the government was ‘too much afraid of voters who will not support it anyhow at any time’, and was doing ‘too little’ to assist ‘the really stabilising element of the population’. Unionist voters, he warned, were beginning ‘to say that it does not matter which party is in office – they are equally bad’. Here was an early iteration of the criticism of consensus that would come to prevail on the political right in the 1970s. The following year, Blair related a desire among Unionist voters for reductions in both the level of taxation and government spending, amid ‘complaints’ of what was referred to as the ‘slow torture of the middle classes’, some of whom were threatening either to abstain at the next election, or, worse, to vote Liberal.Footnote 53 As the annual report of the party's Western Divisional Council noted, the challenges facing the ‘Middle Classes’ were being ‘frequently and vigorously stressed’.Footnote 54 By July 1956, the party's president, William Sinclair, was protesting that he ‘found himself continually defending the Government not against recognised opponents but against declared Unionist Electors, some of whom were threatening to withdraw their support from the Party’. This anger, Sinclair made clear, was driven by concerns over ‘the cost of living, inflation and the lack of resistance to Trade Union demands for more and more wages not covered by corresponding increases in production’.Footnote 55
The most notable short-term political consequence of these expressions of discontent was the emergence of the Middle-Class Alliance (MCA) and the People's League for the Defence of Freedom (PLDF), pressure groups that demanded reductions in government expenditure, further tax cuts and, in the case of the PLDF, the removal of the legal privileges granted to the trades unions. This so-called ‘middle-class revolt’ has been discussed from the standpoint of national politics, as part of the background to the electoral revival of the Liberal party.Footnote 56 The activities of the MCA and PLDF, and the January 1958 treasury resignations, when the chancellor, Peter Thorneycroft, and two junior treasury ministers, Enoch Powell and Nigel Birch, stepped down in protest at the refusal of the cabinet to endorse spending cuts intended to curb inflation, have been treated too as a precursor to the politicisation of inflation in the 1970s.Footnote 57 Yet the MCA and PLDF enjoyed a presence in Scotland that should encourage a reassessment of the basis of Scottish politics during the 1950s; the Unionist leadership certainly feared that the energies of party members were being diverted by membership of these organisations.Footnote 58 Patrick Blair cautioned Unionists against being swayed by the aggressive stance adopted by the PLDF in particular: the demand that trades unions should again be made liable for losses incurred as a result of industrial action would, he warned, create a ‘tremendous surge of ill-feeling’ likely to be electorally damaging. Blair pleaded that the government was trying its utmost ‘to arrest inflation and maintain the value of money’.Footnote 59
Despite Blair's efforts, it was difficult to reconcile the pragmatism of the party leadership with the distrust of state intervention and organised labour prevalent among Unionist supporters; moreover, the affinity between Liberals and Unionists, rooted in a hostility towards socialism and concern for individual freedom, was weakening by the second half of the 1950s. The Unionist vote collapsed by upwards of twenty percentage points at a series of by-elections between 1957 and 1959, each time as a result of Liberal intervention in seats not contested by the party since 1950. At Edinburgh South in May 1957, the Liberal candidate polled nearly a quarter of the vote: the Unionist post-mortem attributed the increase in Liberal support to ‘disgruntlement’ among ‘middle-class voters’ and a ‘feeling that [the] government was not sufficiently Tory’, a reference, it seemed, to the failure of the government to pursue further economic reforms.Footnote 60 Similar conclusions were reached by Lord John Hope, a junior minister at the Scottish Office and the MP for Edinburgh Pentlands. Hope accepted that the ‘cost of living’ was an issue; he suggested, nonetheless, that ‘something else’ had caused ‘discontent’ to ‘develop into anger’. There was, he felt, ‘a widespread feeling that the only people who had been insulated against rises in the cost of living were the people who had caused it – the Trades Unionists with their endless wage demands’.Footnote 61 Such sentiments were certainly visible: in early 1958, in a letter to the Conservative chairman Lord Hailsham, Gordon Murray, secretary of Dundee Unionist and National Liberal association, recorded local support for the recently departed treasury ministers, expressing his hope that the ‘prosperity of the country [would] not be jeopardised in pandering to unjust and unrealistic demands, from whatever section they may come’.Footnote 62
The stance adopted by the Liberal party during this period is instructive. Jo Grimond, the MP for Orkney and Shetland who assumed the leadership of the party in 1956, repositioned the Liberals as a progressive alternative to Labour's state socialism.Footnote 63 Yet Grimond's defence of individual freedom, criticisms of nationalisation and the welfare state, and support for further reductions in personal taxation, represented a renewal of post-war anti-socialism and individualism rather than a departure. Notably, the Conservative government was now being reproached for being too timid in its reforms, too willing to acquiesce in the settlement inherited from Labour. Grimond accused the Conservatives of ‘conserving Socialism’, and of failing to address the high taxes and excessive government expenditure he believed to be the ‘most damaging legacy of Socialism’. To those worried that a vote for the Liberals would allow Labour to regain power, Grimond replied that ‘surely there is no point in keeping a Conservative Government in power unless it is going to be something different in kind from a Socialist Government’.Footnote 64
This message was clearly intended to appeal to disillusioned Unionist supporters. In May 1958, there were reports from Unionist agents across Scotland of a Liberal revival driven by a suspicion that the government was ‘pandering too much to Socialism’ with the result that ‘too much is being spent on the Welfare State’.Footnote 65 At the June 1958 Argyllshire by-election, the Liberal candidate William McKean, who secured almost 30 per cent of the vote, told the public that, although new to the Liberal party, ‘he felt he must take a stand now against the two major parties. If we did not the individual would be crushed.’ He offered a programme of tax cuts and restrictions on public and private monopolies. Speaking in his support, John Bannerman, chairman of the Scottish Liberals, echoed McKean's individualism, declaring that his party would return the state to its proper role as ‘servant of the people’, and would always ‘look to the individual's interest’.Footnote 66
By the close of the 1950s, the division that had sustained electoral politics in Scotland since 1945 had become confused. The Conservative record in office had, unsurprisingly, failed to match the heights of the party's rhetoric in opposition. Equally, the Liberal revival after 1955, however limited and lacking in lasting parliamentary success, suggested that the longer the Conservative party remained in office, the more exposed it would be to criticisms that drew on the very language of liberal individualism that had been so central to its earlier victories. It was, however, the party's response to the 1959 general election that would prove critical in the ensuing realignment of Scottish politics.
III
The loss by the Unionists of their preeminent position in Scotland in 1959, a result that contrasted with continued Conservative success in England, was believed by contemporaries to be a consequence of Scotland's relatively weak economic performance. Unionists in the west of Scotland were convinced that the national decision to campaign on the theme of rising prosperity had been mistaken, with the ‘fear of unemployment’ and hostility towards the 1957 Rent Act, which lifted controls on private lettings, strengthening support for Labour in working-class communities.Footnote 67 This supposition has been echoed by subsequent assessments, which have stressed the electoral impact of economic concerns, and the extent to which this assisted the Labour party by increasing public support for state intervention.Footnote 68
To be sure, the Unionists lost four seats in 1959, all to Labour: Central Ayrshire, Lanark and the Craigton and Scotstoun divisions of Glasgow. There is, all the same, a sense that the party misread these results: as Richard Finlay has rightly observed, Labour's gains in Scotland stemmed from the vagaries of the electoral system.Footnote 69 The Unionists had held the four seats lost by a cumulative majority of fewer than 2,000 votes: these were constituencies secured narrowly in the early 1950s, and the party's support had only to fall slightly for them to be lost. In truth, the Unionist vote was reasonably resilient in 1959: in tandem with the National Liberals, the party still outpolled the Labour party across Scotland. Indeed, in Glasgow, Unionist support amongst the electorate as a whole even increased marginally, despite the loss of two seats, and the party regained the city's Kelvingrove division, lost at a by-election in 1958.Footnote 70 Claims that Scottish politics had moved leftwards were thus overstated, and obscured the extent to which Labour's vote had largely remained static. Where Unionist support did fall, this was more often due to the intervention of Liberal candidates.
Yet the signs that the ties that bound the post-war anti-socialist coalition were beginning to loosen went unheeded. Unionist commentators chose to focus instead on the contest with Labour, and to continue to treat support for the Liberals uncomplicatedly as a proxy vote for Unionism. For the Glasgow Herald, Unionist in loyalty, the Liberals were a party ‘dedicated to individual liberty’; their improved performance in 1959 could therefore be treated as signalling ‘a firm “No” to policies of restriction and control’, and an indication that ‘for the majority, the mixed economy now in being, and its efficient management by Conservatism, marks the acceptable limit of government interference with the individual’.Footnote 71 Perhaps, but we should note that the Liberals fought the election on a manifesto that called for an end to the closed shop, reductions in inheritance tax and for council tenants to be granted the right to buy their homes.Footnote 72 Grimond, for his part, declared that nationalisation was a ‘fiasco’ that would in time prove ‘incompatible with freedom’; he was equally critical of ‘the promise of endless welfare benefits’ administered by ‘the grandmother state’.Footnote 73 There were, then, those for whom the Conservative conception of the relationship between the state and the individual required refinement; after almost a decade in office, for a significant section of the electorate it was no longer enough for the Unionists to claim merely to be better than Labour.
The Unionists failed to acknowledge the threat posed by this new appeal to individualism, discarding their earlier rhetoric of liberty, and emphasising instead their willingness to intervene in the economy, a response that reflected the direction taken by the Conservative party under the leadership of Harold Macmillan.Footnote 74 The government accepted the recommendations of the 1961 Toothill enquiry into the Scottish economy, directing investment towards ‘growth points’; in 1962, an economic development department was added to a steadily expanding Scottish Office.Footnote 75 A year later, a development plan for central Scotland was published, which promised a ‘massive programme of national reconstruction and modernisation’, and conceded that ‘full employment’ could ‘only be maintained by conscious and far-ranging acts of policy’.Footnote 76 By the 1964 general election, Sir Alec Douglas-Home, who had replaced Macmillan as premier a year earlier, could tell electors that he recognised ‘that in modern conditions there must be a good deal of both central and regional planning’.Footnote 77 That year's Unionist manifesto praised the benefits of planning, pledging the creation of a ‘vast new economic complex’ in central Scotland.Footnote 78 As Priscilla Buchan, Unionist member for Aberdeen South since 1946, acknowledged during the campaign, her party now accepted ‘far more the need for gov[ernment] to take greater responsibility to promote social and economic change’.Footnote 79 Yet these attempts to rebrand Unionism as a modernising creed, one able to deliver a more efficient form of planning than Labour, failed. The party lost a further six seats, reducing the number of Unionists MPs to twenty-four, down from the thirty-six returned in 1955; the party's share of the vote fell by almost a fifth.
The abandonment by the Unionists of the individualist rhetoric of the late 1940s and early 1950s created a space within Scottish politics for the Liberal party. The three Highland constituencies lost by the Unionists in 1964 fell to the Liberals; the presence of Liberal candidates also triggered sharp falls in the Unionist vote in the north-east of Scotland as well as in Renfrewshire and Ayrshire, and led to the loss of West Renfrewshire and Glasgow Pollok to Labour.Footnote 80 As the 1960s progressed, however, it would become clear that in parts of provincial Scotland the chief beneficiary of the growing inability of the Unionists to pose credibly as a party committed to the defence of the individual was the SNP. Scottish nationalism's espousal of an intensely individualist stance during the post-war decades remains underappreciated. Yet the nationalist vision was informed by the same fear of an overmighty central state as Unionism's anti-socialism and was often expressed in similar language. The post-war SNP was equally enamoured of the virtues of local government; in 1946, the party newspaper, the Scots Independent, could be found employing lengthy quotations from Hayek's Road to Serfdom in its editorial column.Footnote 81 These inclinations were heightened by an identification with the small nations of Eastern Europe occupied by the Soviet Union after 1945, which encouraged anti-communist sentiment within nationalist circles. Self-government was, as a result, often envisaged in instrumental terms, as a bulwark against a Labour government believed to harbour authoritarian tendencies. As the SNP's 1947 policy statement suggested, the conflict between capitalism and socialism had been rendered meaningless by the victory of the state, in whatever guise it assumed; the task now was to defend individual liberty and the rule of law, and to resist the rise of a ‘despotism ruling over an irresponsible proletariat’: Scots must choose ‘either the road to tyranny or the way to freedom’.Footnote 82
This individualist version of nationalist politics survived the 1950s largely intact, finding an outlet in criticisms of the welfare state, which, from a nationalist perspective, represented little more than a bribe designed to induce loyalty to the British state.Footnote 83 The SNP's 1957 conference programme duly dismissed the post-war settlement as ‘a mass of taxes designed to make the individual look to the state for his needs’; what masqueraded as compassion was just ‘a vote-catching fraud’. The SNP promoted ‘independence for the individual Scottish citizen as well as for the Scottish nation’.Footnote 84 Following the 1959 general election, James Halliday, the party chairman who had unsuccessfully contested the Stirling and Falkirk Burghs constituency, lamented that Scottish voters appeared content to accept ‘concessions and handouts’ from central government in ‘a spirit of meek and docile gratitude’.Footnote 85 By the early 1960s, as the SNP's electoral fortunes began to improve following positive performances at the Glasgow Bridgeton and West Lothian by-elections, what Gordon Wilson, SNP national secretary during the 1960s and later MP for Dundee East, described as the party's tradition of ‘libertarianism and desire for decentralisation’ appeared newly relevant to a political contest in which both major parties advocated economic planning of one form or another.Footnote 86 In those areas where the Liberals lacked a presence, particularly in central and eastern Scotland, the SNP offered an increasingly potent, and overtly constitutional, critique of the central state that tapped a historic provincial liberal tradition.
IV
Support for nationalisation and the welfare state was, no doubt, widespread amongst Scots in the post-war era; the consistent ability of the Labour party to attract the support of near half the Scottish electorate is testament enough to that. Still, to concentrate on such positive responses neglects the existence of another constituency of roughly equal size, one far more sceptical of economic planning and resentful of the taxes required to pay for the welfare state. For those of the latter inclination, Scotland's sluggish economic performance in the late 1950s and early 1960s was evidence that government intervention had failed, not that there was any need for more of it. This liberal, individualist strand did not disappear from Scottish politics during the upheaval of the 1960s; rather, the ability of Unionism to pose as its dominant political expression declined, and the Liberals and the SNP were able to construct new versions of this appeal.
This would become apparent in the wake of Winnie Ewing's famous victory for the SNP at the November 1967 Hamilton by-election. An opinion survey commissioned by the Conservatives to discover why they had failed to benefit from discontent with the Labour government revealed deep-rooted opposition to what was perceived as excessive government intervention in the economy, an opinion especially visceral in relation to the level of personal taxation.Footnote 87 The policy group launched to consider proposals for devolution in the wake of Edward Heath's May 1968 ‘declaration of Perth’, which, in reaction to Hamilton, had committed the Conservatives to supporting a Scottish assembly, uncovered a similar liberal ethos and resentment of bureaucracy.Footnote 88 The group's report stressed that the popular disenchantment central to the nationalist victory at Hamilton was not unique to Scotland, but was driven by anger towards central government, by ‘a feeling that decisions are taken by people far away from the objects of these decisions’ and ‘a sense of impotence in the face of governmental acts and policies’.Footnote 89 It was, however, no longer axiomatic that the natural political home for such sentiments was the Conservative party.
The weakening of a once-dominant Unionist tradition, the recovery of Scottish Liberalism and the rise of the SNP had, to be sure, multiple causes. But the relinquishment by the Unionists of an appeal to liberal individualism was a crucial element within this process, undercutting as it did the coherence of the party's identity, and reducing the distinction with Labour to one of degree, not kind. There was some awareness of the dangers posed by this shift within Unionist ranks: prior to the 1964 election, Lord Dalkeith, the MP for Edinburgh North, warned that party literature was placing ‘insufficient emphasis’ on what he felt was the ‘essential difference’ between the two major parties: that the Unionists, unlike Labour, did not regard ‘the individual as a cog in the great state machine planned and controlled by the all-knowing man in Whitehall’.Footnote 90 Similarly, the inroads made by the Liberals into Unionist support in Angus, Aberdeenshire and the Borders was credited to a wish for ‘idealism’, especially among younger voters.Footnote 91 The Unionism of the 1940s and early 1950s had, alongside its traditional role as the representative of important interests within Scottish society, fulfilled this desire for ideological principle, presenting a powerful critique of socialism, and defence of individual liberty and the free economy. But by the 1960s, softened by the experience of office, the party had mislaid this intellectual confidence; there were, moreover, now other parties able to provide the electorate with liberal political ideals. Significantly, however, individual liberty was coming to be viewed through a constitutional rather than economic lens.
