We are living in the golden age of Jane Addams's scholarship, and Marilyn Fischer's Jane Addams's Evolutionary Theorizing: Constructing “Democracy and Social Ethics” moves to the top of the list of contemporary books on Addams's thinking and philosophy, particularly in terms of understanding her scholarship in the intellectual context of her life (1860–1935).
Public and scholarly regard for Jane Addams has certainly waxed and waned. During her lifetime, her work at the Chicago social settlement, Hull House, as well as her many national progressive endeavors propelled Addams to being considered one of the most beloved women in the country. Her criticism of World War I caused a public backlash, and she found herself reviled in many circles. In the last years of her life, buoyed by the Nobel Peace Prize in 1931, she was once again considered a national treasure. Despite Eleanor Roosevelt's call to have Addams's birthday celebrated to remember her many contributions to the nation, Addams was largely forgotten in the latter part of the twentieth century.Footnote 1 If remembered at all, Addams was viewed as a sanguine moral crusader and activist for the poor. An early exceptional voice was sociologist Christopher Lasch, who edited a collection of excerpts from Addams's social thought. He described his effort as trying “to rescue the less familiar, but to my mind more important, side of Jane Addams’ life … as theorist and intellectual—a thinker of originality and daring.”Footnote 2 A few scholars in the 1980s resuscitated a recognition for Addams's work, but their projects were peppered with the prevailing view that Addams was an activist or proto-social worker who, although literarily prolific, gleaned most of her intellectual outlook from her well-known male colleagues including John Dewey, William James, and George Herbert Mead. It was not until the 1990s with the rise of feminist scholarship that Addams garnered independent scholarly respect. Mary Jo Deegan pioneered reestablishing Addams as an innovative founding mother of sociology.Footnote 3 Charlene Haddock Seigfried spearheaded the notion of Addams's philosophical significance, particularly in regard to American pragmatism.Footnote 4 Following in Seigfried's footsteps, a number of contemporary feminist pragmatists recovered Addams's intellectual legacy. Fischer acknowledges that Jane Addams's Evolutionary Theorizing “furthers Seigfried's line of inquiry by demonstrating how Addams developed a pragmatist method of ethics well before Dewey articulated virtually the same method” (20). The 2000s witnessed several outstanding biographies of Addams that dispelled some of the biases of past efforts.Footnote 5 Against this backdrop and through meticulous research and analysis into Addams's references, themes, and nuances of thought, Marilyn Fischer brings us the closest glimpse yet into the mind of Addams.
Jane Addams's Evolutionary Theorizing is an extraordinary intellectual project that only someone with the philosophical training and scrupulous scholarship of Fischer could accomplish. Fischer has spearheaded many works on Addams including an introductory text, edited collections, and numerous book chapters and articles.Footnote 6 She has also been an important voice for bringing feminist pragmatism to the fore at the Society for the Advancement of American Philosophy. However, Evolutionary Thinking is her magnum opus. In this book, Fischer epitomizes the best of humanities research by following up on all available resources to reconstruct the nuances of Addams's thought process in writing her first and most philosophical book, Democracy and Social Ethics. Published in 1902, less than a decade after the founding of Hull House, the chapters in Democracy and Social Ethics represent refined versions of previous Addams's articles and speeches. What Fischer adeptly pulls off is to identify and explain to the reader what was behind Addams's words in their context. Fisher describes her process:
I have drawn from philosophy, history literature, rhetoric, and more to create a hybrid methodology suited for bringing this evidence to light. My method is in part archeological, as I excavate Addams's texts to identify her intellectual resources and place them on the conceptual map of social evolutionary theorizing. My method is also architectural, as I use this material to reconstruct Addams's argument in the text (1).
Evolutionary Theorizing weaves intellectual history, particularly social evolutionary thought, into a narrative of Addams's thought process vis-à-vis Democracy and Social Ethics. The first two chapters engage important published essays by Addams about the nature of social settlements, “The Subjective Necessity of Social Settlements” and “The Settlement as a Factor in the Labor Movement.” These essays were not included in Democracy and Social Ethics but demonstrate the trajectory of her method of ethical deliberation that she develops further in the years to come. Chapters Three through Five engage a variety of published essays by Addams that would evolve into chapters in Democracy and Social Ethics. As Fischer describes, she “decodes” Addams's century-old references to trace intellectual themes so that the reader can better understand her significant ideas. Fischer's archaeological work is particularly important given that Addams wrote in an era when citations were not as carefully offered as they are today. On numerous occasions, Fischer notes how she traced an uncredited quote or reference by using clues to find original sources. As a reader, I often found myself in awe of the time and attention necessary for Fischer to make the discoveries necessary to write this book. Chapter Six analyzes “A Function of the Social Settlement,” an essay that did not make it into Democracy and Social Ethics. Fischer claims that it reveals the ongoing development of Addams's approach to social settlements as endeavors of scientific inquiry. In the final chapter, Fischer addresses the overarching theme of Democracy and Social Ethics: the historical movement from individual to social ethics. Addams used essays that had different analytical frameworks and altered them to fit the individual-to-social ethics conceptual theme resulting in a book for which Fischer describes as, “conceptual coherence is not achieved” (183).
In putting all the pieces together, Fischer is not afraid to critique what Addams has accomplished. Make no mistake, however, about Addams as a scholarly figure. One comes away from reading this book with renewed respect for Addams's intellectual and methodological skill. Addams's writing and social achievements at a time when so many strict barriers were placed on women is nothing short of astounding. Jane Addams is not the first name one thinks of in regard to American pragmatist philosophy, but perhaps it should be. As Fischer describes, “Addams's voice is one of the most significant in the quest for social justice in American history” (18). Given the evidence in Jane Addams's Evolutionary Theorizing, this claim does not appear to be hyperbole.
Fisher is an “Addams Nerd” in the most endearing sense of the word. This comprehensive study could only be improved by bringing Jane Addams back to life. From this point forward, Jane Addams's Evolutionary Theorizing is essential reading for anyone studying Jane Addams.
