Barriers Down has a lot going for it: an excellent synthesis of USA Cold War communication practices across a wide array of global media, cogent analyses of many important media practitioners and intellectuals, rigorous and extensive archival research, and a compelling narrative. Seven expository chapters framed by an introduction and epilogue take us through methods, measures, multilingualism, and markets, as well as newsprint, film, broadcasting, and satellites. Barriers Down gives serious consideration and investigation to both media research and media practice, to both media ideologies and media objects. One of the many strengths of this book is how Diana Lemberg clearly and eloquently brings together a range of examples and cases of American free-flow global media across many manifestations of media texts and infrastructures: newspapers, magazines, cinema, radio, television, satellites, Basic English, and educational/instructional media efforts. This synthesis across a range of media texts and infrastructures is valuable and somewhat distinct, and successfully places Barriers Down in a lively and fruitful dialogue with other recent works and studies of Cold War global media. Indeed, the extensive notes and bibliography help readers to appreciate this lively dialogue, and assist readers in their pursuit of new scholarship.
Barriers Down clearly can be seen as a political history, should one like to do so. Opening with a discussion of skeptical attitudes of American media executives viewing overseas news and media competitors in the midst of the Second World War – even in allied nations – Lemberg confirms that her 2019 Barriers Down book opens by considering the concerns voiced in the 1942 Barriers Down book by Kent Cooper, general manager of the Associated Press wire service. Noting that Cooper was not alone among American media executives in viewing overseas news corporations in his call for the USA to take on a “sweeping global mission” (2) of free-flow media in the postwar world, Lemberg demonstrates that American Cold War free-flow global media visions are present even before the creation, if you will. However, in my review I want to take a moment (as I have now done) to recognize the presence of a narrative exploring a political media history in Barriers Down to now highlight the simultaneous presence of a narrative exploring an intellectual media history in Barriers Down.
Intertwined with the American Cold War global pursuit of free-flow media and communication policies was the growth of media and communication research, institutions, foundation funds, and university departments and centers both within and beyond the United States. Indeed, as Lemberg ably shows, the pursuit of free-flow policies was a crucial factor in spurring this intellectual growth, both within and just as much beyond American borders. Many assorted Cold War global-media scholars, shapers, swayers, soothsayers, and other intellectual-media swamis inhabit the pages of Barriers Down. Open this book and meet them: Wilbur Schramm, Ithiel de Sola Pool, Herbert Schiller, Dallas Smythe, Jean D'Arcy, John Grierson, Harold Lasswell, Richard Hoggart, Henry Cassirer, Jacques Kayser, Stuart Hall, Fernand Terrou, Ariel Dorfman, I. A. Richards, Thomas Guback, Raymond Nixon, Daniel Lerner, William Benton, and pretty much everyone else from Armand (Mattelart) to Zechariah (Chaffee). Overwhelmingly white and male (thank goodness for Shirley Hazzard), their organizations and institutions were just as overwhelmingly white and male, ranging from the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), to the International Association for Mass Communication Research (IAMCR), to the various and sundry commissions (Hutchins, McBride, et al.) Like other Cold War intellectual formations, the discursive differences and contestations were not so much found in gender, class, or race as they were in a constrained and closed discursive politics: left versus right, East versus West, market versus regulation, and so forth. In the Cold War's aftermath – beware, spoiler alert – it turned out that the West, the right, and the market had won. Such was the fate of freedom. To his death, de Sola Pool triumphed the technologies of freedom, vindicated the Vietnam War, and echoed Ronald Coase in the call to auction off the radio spectrum, ceaselessly making global media flow, freedom, and markets indivisible, one and inseparable.
So in the end, while it may be that Cold War media intellectuals and their battles over free-flow global media were, in retrospect, yet another Cold War version of The Philosophy of Andy Warhol: From A to B and Back Again, the battles were important and had consequences, as Lemberg reveals. In some instances, the battles produced some early and influential scholarship on media, politics, and human rights. Beyond specific instances and examples of scholarship, Barriers Down holds a double value: Lemberg wonderfully shows us how the pursuit of American Cold War policies toward building free-flow global media shaped both the world of global media and the world of global-media studies. In closing, Barriers Down is highly recommended for all readers.
