The Japanese term ‘Tsundoku’ refers to the practice of acquiring books but never getting around to reading them. One of the authors of this review (HOC) has an extensive Tsundoku problem and when the other author of this review (GB) gave him a gift of the book ‘Outlive’ by Dr Peter Attia, that book joined a Tsundoku book pile for almost a year. However, we have both got around to reading and reviewing the book in recent times.
Dr Peter Attia is a former surgical oncologist who left clinical medicine for some years and then returned to focus his considerable energies on longevity research, writing and broadcasting over the past decade.
In ‘Outlive’, Attia begins by describing how medicine has evolved from Medicine 1.0 (going back to Ancient Greece, with its emphasis on humours, etc.) to Medicine 2.0, from the 19thcentury to now, whereby scientific methods are employed in defining causes of disease and shaping a process of assessment, diagnosis and treatment, but with the obvious flaw of arriving too late and focusing on treating already established (and often incurable) conditions. Furthermore, although the vast majority of clinical conditions and healthcare demands are related in large part to ageing and senescence, Medicine 2.0 is strangely blind to this, at individual and population levels.
‘Outlive’ is Attia’s well-argued case for Medicine 3.0, an approach to individual and population healthcare that should involve much broader perspectives and strategic thinking in the medical profession and in society generally on prevention, early intervention and, ultimately, an emphasis on enhancing not just lifespan but healthspan, i.e. our quality of life as we age.
Attia begins by identifying the four ‘Deadly Horsemen’: metabolic disease, cardiovascular disease, cancer and neurodegenerative disorders and how risk factors, illness progression, treatments and prevention strategies for these conditions can often be seen to overlap (e.g. APOE4 status and risk for cardiovascular disease and dementia).
Attia outlines how a lifelong strategic approach to individual and population healthcare is essential, not merely in identifying and treating illness but ultimately in preparing us to be fit (and happy) enough to engage in anotional ‘Centenarian Decathlon’, the individual events being of our own choosing. Age related declines in strength, stability and cardiovascular fitness should be acknowledged and a lifelong strategy of building physiological reserve to prepare for the inevitable decline of ageing is a core argument of this book.
Attia’s passion for his subject is clear and his writing style is accessible, likely to engage both healthcare professionals and the general public. Fascinating updates on topics such as diabetes and pre-diabetes, lipid metabolism and cardiovascular disease are provided in the early chapters.
The lifelong strategies outlined by Attia relate primarily to focused exercise with an emphasis both on aerobic and strength training while also incorporating stability. Attia shines a strong and highly critical light on the many problems associated with the Standard American Diet (SAD), which has spread throughout much of the world, whereby the wonder of cheap food production for millions has led to almost unimaginable levels of pathology due to consumption of bland, processed food laden with carbohydrates, fructose and saturated fats. In response to this huge challenge, he has included two chapters focused on nutritional biochemistry. Finally, the book ends with chapters on the importance of sleep and managing mental health, the latter chapter offering insights into the author’s own struggles with childhood trauma.
As psychiatrists, we were disappointed at the lack of emphasis on mental health and mental illness in such a broad ranging book. While Attia is to be commended on his openness in the last chapter in discussing his own mental health struggles, it felt like this chapter had been bolted on as an afterthought. More importantly, no mention is made of the vast disparities in physical health morbidities, mortality rates and lifespan (not to mention healthspan) between those with severe and enduring mental illnesses such as schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder and the general population. Increasing attention on such populations is essential, because of their obvious clinical needs and because we are likely to learn so much about chronic illnesses (and how they overlap) from treating and studying those who suffer the most from them.
As psychiatrists with strong interests in the evolutionary perspective, we were also somewhat disappointed at the lack of an evolutionary framework in this book. Such a framework could effectively pull together many of the different strands and make Attia’s arguments more cohesive and compelling. That said, Attia does acknowledge some important evolutionary perspectives, such as the fact that evolution is not really interested in ageing, a process that generally occurs after our reproductive years. Therefore, many of the (largely) age-related health conditions we develop in middle age and later life are not weeded out in the evolutionary process. He also touches on the key evolutionary concept of environmental mismatch, in relation to the vast differences between our ancestral environments and our modern environments, with increasingly SAD diets, sedentary habits and (not emphasised enough in this book) our greatly diminished levels of social and family connectedness.
The scope of this book is broad and aspirational, and so it is understandably difficult for Attia to give specific ‘prescriptions’. However, we would like to have seen some outlines in relation to optimal screening strategies at different life stages (e.g. relating to haematological screening, gastrointestinal scoping and cardiac investigations) along with some more specifics on potential longevity enhancing drugs such as metformin, statins and vitamin supplements.
Overall, however, this is an accessible and thought-provoking book that is likely to be of interest to anyone working in healthcare or anyone who is interested in improving their chances of living a longer and healthier life.
