Quantitative analysis in numismatic research and the Roman Empire in the third century a.d. have both received growing attention during recent years. The publication to be reviewed here applies quantitative analysis to the Roman Imperial coinage of the third century as a whole, involving 8,227 coin types. The book is divided into eight chapters followed by a conclusion and enriched by six useful appendices and a bibliography. Part One of the book (chs 1–5) deals with general patterns on third-century coinage, offering an introduction to the methods and the historical background, followed by chapters containing an analysis of the main themes representing power on imperial coinage, while Part Two (chs 6–8) consists of case studies dealing with the emperors Caracalla, Decius and Gallienus.
As it is, of course, not possible to review every detail of such a broad study, I will limit myself to general remarks concerning methodology. The main point of criticism is the author's strict division of the material, mainly following the legends of the coins. Her framework of ‘Representational categories’ as presented in table 2 (41–8) generates some major problems. The category ‘Divine association’, for example, contains all coins showing the emperor capite velato sacrificing, because they are regarded as representations of the emperor as a priest. That most of those images are simply general depictions of the emperor's pietas and should be included in the category ‘Virtues’ together with coins actually depicting a personification of pietas has been the standard view for many years; furthermore, one would expect some differentiation of priesthoods by attributes. The same is true for the category ‘Military representation’. Every type showing the emperor in military dress is integrated here rather than being included in the category of ‘Virtues’ as general images of the emperor’s virtus. It is also not quite clear why coins bearing the legend VICTORIA AETERNA/PERPETVA or VICTORIOSO SEMPER are less military or less connected with the emperor's virtus than those showing him in military dress or those depicting the personified virtus. Problems like this, as they concern the fundamental structuring of the material, of course re-emerge in the respective chapters dealing with the categories. This becomes most obvious in ch. 4 ‘Imperial Exempla’. As stated above, virtues of the emperor are only interpreted as such if they are named in the legend. Manders acknowledges that references to victories, the army and especially images of the emperor in military dress are ‘indirect references to virtus’ (170) even if the legend VIRTVS is missing, but nonetheless ignores the fact that there was more than one way to display the emperor's virtus, including the use of images without an explicit legend. The calculations might have shifted significantly if she had included those types commonly interpreted as virtus-imagery by archaeologists. The section dealing with pietas also poses problems (178–82). As all images of the emperor sacrificing capite velato are left out of the evaluation, programmatic sentences like ‘In the third century, however, references to pietas on imperial coins were less common than in earlier periods. Obviously, more importance was attached to propagating other virtues, such for example virtus and providentia’ (178) are insecure. M. is equally definite when she states that ‘Liberalitas was only officially considered an imperial virtue from the second century a.d. onwards; liberalitas types were struck for the first time under Hadrian’ (165). This ignores congiaria types minted earlier which present the liberalitas of the emperor as well as the specific congiarium. Otherwise it would not have been possible that from Hadrian onwards ‘the broader concept LIBERALITAS AVG began to replace the more specific CONGIARIVM’ (167).
Similar problems arise from the title of ch. 2, ‘Appeasing the Army’, since most of the types representing the emperor in military dress, his adventus/profectio or Victoria can hardly be interpreted as appeasing the army but rather represent the concept of everlasting victorious military leadership, one of the foundations of Roman emperorship. Even specific triumphs cannot automatically be interpreted as appeasing the army involved rather than as celebration of that specific victory (and above all as manifestation of the everlasting victory of the Roman Empire) unless the victorious army can be proven to be the direct target group of those coins. On the other hand, coins displaying legends like VIRTVS EXERCITVS or VIRTVS MILITVM are only interpreted as reflections of the emperor's virtus (158 and 177) and do not appear in the chapter ‘Appeasing the Army’ at all. Likewise, it is unconvincing that the legionary series and fides/concordia militum types minted under Gallienus are interpreted as propagating ‘the emperor's legitimacy by referring to the troops’ (280). Together with the correct assumption that they ‘reflect the growing power of the armed forces in imperial matters’ (280), they are more plausibly seen not as propagating legitimacy but evoking fides and concordia of and within the troops as a whole and of specific legions. It would be worthwhile exploring whether the hoard evidence suggests that the coins were handed over directly to the troops mentioned on the legionary issues as payment or donativum.
The third point of criticism concerns iconographical analysis. Sometimes it is missing (e.g. 115–21, where no difference is made between different Mars types, although M. states that ‘Mars was not solely invoked as the god of warfare’); and sometimes image and legend are not interpreted together (e.g. images of Victoria accompanied by the legends FIDES EXERCITVS or CONCORDIA MILITVM, which represent a significant narrowing of the image of Victoria: through fides exercitus or concordia militum, the emperor — and the Roman Empire — could be victorious). There are also some apparent confusions between iconographical type and iconographical type modified by legend (e.g. 131f. on Apollo Salutaris).
These comments should not give the impression that M.'s book is not worth reading. It is full of data fruitful for further research and its systematic approach is very valuable. The case studies, especially that for the emperor Decius, clearly demonstrate the value of M.'s emphasis on the importance of statistical analysis for the study of Roman history and archaeology. Her book will become, despite the shortcomings, part of the standard literature for those dealing with statistics, may they be historians, archaeologists or numismatists, and is definitely a comprehensive basis for debate.
