This volume offers an interdisciplinary collection of meditations on the historic election of Barack Obama as President of the United States. At its strongest moments, the volume gestures towards some fruitful avenues of investigation. Maria Lauret's thoughtful reading of Michelle Obama's campaign remarks demonstrates the powerful ways in which the First Lady's self-representations engage with an African American dialogue heretofore unseen in mainstream presidential politics. Emily Bernard's autobiographical account hints provocatively at the pedagogical paradox of deploying an academic discourse that emphasizes the “imagined” quality of race to unsettle students' commitment to “racelessness.” Political scientist Donald W. Beachler highlights the ways in which Barack Obama's election in 2008 reveals the emergence of “two Souths”: a “converging South” identified by rising levels of in-migration and college-educated residents, and a “neo-Confederate South” which has forcefully rejected the national shift toward Obama's Democratic Party.
For the most part, however, the volume is a disappointment. George Lewis's observation that then-Senator Obama self-consciously fashioned his personal history to gain political capital in his 2006 book The Audacity of Hope is indisputable, if rather unremarkable. Harder to accept is Lewis's claim that Obama's 1995 memoir, Dreams from My Father, was also written as a strategic bulwark for Obama's future national political aspirations. In this reading, everything from Obama's descriptions of his father, to his conversations with Puerto Rican neighbours in East Harlem, to his recollections of his youthful years in Indonesia, reflect cagey campaign calculations. Obama's view of Kwame Touré, whom he hears speak at Columbia University, apparently demonstrates not the carefully nuanced view on black power politics that Obama develops throughout the text, but proof that the future President was “clearly alive to the potential political dangers he faced by being linked to Touré too closely.”
Richard King, meanwhile, has a few bones to pick. He seems peeved that James Kloppenberg, in his brilliant intellectual history, Reading Obama (2012), focusses primarily on Obama's time at Harvard (he doesn't), and that Kloppenberg describes Obama's intellectual influences as a “hodgepodge” (he doesn't). He seems troubled with Thomas Sugrue's magisterial synthesis of the civil rights movement in the North, Sweet Land of Liberty (2008), concluding triumphantly that Obama himself would likely challenge Sugrue's “attempt to downplay the importance of the southern movement.” Most of King's venom, however, is reserved for his ad hominem attack on “whiteness studies.” There is not much in the assault, and little consistency. After accusing whiteness studies pioneer David Roediger of treating white supremacy as an “unchanging reality,” King retreats immediately, conceding that Roediger underlines voting and attitudinal changes – but without offering enough of a causal explanation.
If there is a persistent thread in the volume it is the authors' engagement with the much-discussed idea of “post-racialism.” Jonathan Okamura has Obama positioning himself as a “post-racial” candidate. Peter Kuryla argues that he isn't, but that he gestures hopefully to a color-blind future. Brian Ward describes the “vogue of post-racialism” as a reaction to the promise of Obama rather than something particular to the President's own perspective. Damon Freeman argues that Obama's careful meditations on identity in Dreams, far from signaling a commitment to post-racialism, sit comfortably with the insights of critical race theory. It would be a more interesting disagreement if the notion of an American post-racial era did not seem so far-fetched to scholars of American race relations, or so dated by the events subsequent to Obama's election. Or, for that matter, so thoroughly debunked in this volume.
This is not to say that post-election celebrations of a post-racial America should be ignored. Brian Ward, who produces the volume's standout essay, artfully demonstrates the ways in which views of Obama as a transformational candidate – in the positive sense and the negative one – have been refracted through the lens of conceptual and ideological struggles rooted in the 1960s. From this perspective, declarations of a dawning “post-racial” age express not only a trite naivety, or a misreading of Martin Luther King Jr.'s “dream,” but also the weight of liberal exhaustion after decades of conservative ascendancy. For liberals, Obama offers the hope of an end to the battles engendered by the civil rights era, a path forward that evades the racial trapdoor established by the Republican southern strategy and reorients American politics back towards progressivism. Obama has complied with a universalist agenda that both expresses sympathy with persistent racial prejudice and concedes that race-specific strategies have exhausted themselves. If America is to better care for its citizenry, Obama suggests, it will be by delivering class-oriented policies that bridge the gap of racial differences rather than highlight them. What is at issue is not whether race continues to matter – of course it does! – but whether the universalism that Obama proposes offers the making of a new progressive paradigm, and whether it offers a credible path to racial justice. On the former there is reason for optimism; on the latter, with apologies to Dr. King, the arc of history is not promising.
