Marc Lynch, also known as the blogger “Abu Aardvark,” has written an empirically rich and challenging statement about the political effects of the “new media” in the Arab world with a particular (but not exclusive) focus on the Al Jazeera satellite television news network. Lynch's argument successfully links a theoretical argument to both a detailed empirical analysis and an important foreign-policy critique.
Lynch's book is based in the analytical paradigm of Jurgen Habermas's theory of communicative action in the public sphere. Although not rigidly chained to Habermas, Lynch borrows the important message that ideas and discourse have real political power. For Lynch, this means that “what people say in public matters more for shaping political identities and strategies than their private beliefs or internal deliberations” (p. 27). Thus, the technological changes in the public sphere have led to greater opportunities for the Arabic-speaking public to debate and reach a consensus about political issues that are relevant to all Arabs. Lynch cautions, however, against seeing Al Jazeera and new Arab media as the cure (or the cause) for all the Middle East's political problems. Rather, he offers the conclusion that the Arab public sphere is a real public sphere but lacks institutional mechanisms for turning a consensus in public opinion into policy outcomes. Nevertheless, the public sphere has magnified and spread public mobilization as public protests have garnered transnational publicity.
For Lynch, the Arab public sphere had the potential for becoming a site based on classical liberal values of debate and tolerance. However, political developments of the past decade—namely, foreign intervention—coupled with the transnational public sphere's lack of domestic institutionalization have led to a more populist public sphere based in debates about the authenticity of Arab identity.
Lynch grounds this theoretical argument through an empirical analysis of Arab debates about Iraq from the aftermath of Operation Desert Storm through the period following the fall of Baghdad in 2003. His analysis draws mainly on a data set of 976 episodes of the five most watched general-interest talk shows on Al Jazeera from January 1999 to June 2004 (p. 76). Judging from scores of press editorials, Lynch points out that before the popularity of Al Jazeera, the issues of sanctions on Iraq were dealt with in the elite transnational Arabic press or in domestic print publics. Nevertheless, by 1996 a consensus had been reached in the Arab public sphere that “virtually no discussion of Iraq could omit reference to sympathy with the suffering of the Iraqi people” (p. 123).
With the rise of Al Jazeera in the late 1990s, however, the public sphere engaged in a series of debates about international events, the reaction of various Arab regimes, and even the new media's role in creating a public sphere. On the eve of the U.S. invasion of Iraq, a consensus had emerged around a shared identity in opposition to Israeli policies in the occupied territories and U.S. sanctions against Iraq. Lynch also notes the absence of voices of the Iraqi public in these debates. With the U.S. invasion and the fall of Baghdad, “the Arab public sphere did play a major role in shaping the political and normative environment, but in a more complex and ambiguous way than its critics recognize” (p. 172) because of rising competition from other media outlets to Al Jazeera.
Lynch presents detailed analysis of the open phone-in forums on Al Jazeera talk shows from the spring of 2003, which expressed an enormous range of Arab public opinion. However, the Arab media incorporated the newly vocal Iraqi public uneasily due to the failure of the new Iraq to develop reliable media outlets outside of American control and censorship. This period also was remarkable for the self-criticism to which the Arab public sphere subjected itself. Lynch also briefly discusses the impact of the Arab public sphere on issues beyond Iraq such as the debate about Arab political reform and the Egyptian Kifaya movement. Lynch brings non-Arabic-speaking audiences the richness of the debates in the Arab public sphere with a rare attention to nuance and detail.
Finally, Lynch also makes an important contribution to foreign-policy debates in Washington. He argues against the simplistic characterization of Al Jazeera as “Terrorist TV.” Lynch points out that the Arab public sphere is more than just the Al Jazeera network; it includes its satellite competitors as well as the transnational Arab newspapers and related websites. Lynch also briefly addresses the more interactive Internet media, but at the time of the book's writing the medium had not yet deeply penetrated the Arab world.
Despite common perceptions to the contrary, Al Jazeera and its competitors have provided a much more nuanced and balanced presentation of Iraq before and after the U.S. invasion as a result of both journalistic ethics and competition for market share. Lynch makes the point that although the Arab public sphere reached a consensus about the undesirability of human suffering under the sanctions against Iraq in the 1990s, that consensus did not embrace Saddam Hussein's leadership. Moreover, Iraqi opposition groups were given quite ample opportunity to make their case to the Arab public, but their message failed to persuade. Finally, U.S. scapegoating of Al Jazeera reflected an ignorance of the debates it had presented and took the Arab public as a force to be ignored or manipulated rather than engaged with in the spirit of persuasive debate.
The book is appropriate for advanced undergraduates studying Arab politics and perhaps graduate students reading about how political cultural research has moved well beyond Orientalist essentialism. General readers also have a lot to gain from Lynch's accessible text. Voices of the New Arab Public balances its multiple objectives in a complex but quite readable manner. Each of these objectives would have been sufficient in its own right; sometimes a reader longs for more of each in the book. Nevertheless, Lynch has provided an important contribution to our theoretical understating of the Arab public sphere, a rich empirical account of the debates about Iraq in the Arab media, and an essential critique of U.S. foreign-policy understandings about Al Jazeera and its counterparts in the Arab public sphere.
