In recent years there has been growing interest in the medical tradition known in South Asia as Unani Tibb, and in particular in the developments it has undergone in the past two centuries. Amongst those scholars to have studied aspects of it are: Claudia Liebeskind, Seema Alavi, Neshat Qaiser and Barbara Metcalf.Footnote 1 Guy Attewell is the first person to produce a book-length study.Footnote 2 From the beginning he makes it clear that Unani Tibb was not a ‘system’, as many have come to call it, but a pluralist medical tradition, which had at its heart classical texts, the most important of which was Ibn Sina's al-Qanun, but which only in the early twentieth century came to be described as a system by its practitioners as part of their process of establishing its authority and respectability in the colonial environment. Indeed, the use of the term ‘system’, Attewell tells us, “reveals the tensions within a professional elite, whose sphere of authority until this time was rooted in localised, familial and personal contexts, but which gradually through the late nineteenth century and into the twentieth woke up to the need to compete on a more global scale – through print, the mass production of medicines and professional organisation”. Attewell carries his project forward in a series of case studies, in each of which Unani hakims can be seen to be ‘refiguring’ their medical tradition and at the same time re-establishing their authority in new circumstances. A fascinating study of the plague, which broke out in Bombay in 1896 and spread to much of north and west India, reveals how it raised issues of authority for hakims across a great range of areas – ‘Unani traditions, commercialisation, Islam, modernity, folk medicine, the state and the public’. A second study looks at the institutionalisation of the Unani profession, in particular the development of colleges such as the Madrasa Tibbiya in Delhi, the Takmil ut-Tibb in Lucknow and the Nizamia Tibbi in Hyderabad, which taught students for formal qualifications to study medicine as opposed to the informal ones usually derived from family reputation. Nevertheless, Attewell's discovery of a letter from a former student of the Takmil ut-Tibb (a college of high repute), saying that its training had not given him and his colleagues the authority which came from being part of a great family of physicians, enables him to point to the limitations of institutionally-derived authority. A further study examines the work of the All-India Vedic and Unani Tibbi Conference in which vaids and hakims deplored the way in which people had tried to pitch the two medical traditions against each other. Unani practitioners were particularly concerned to promote a vision of Tibb which, rather than looking just to the classical traditions of West Asia, rooted it in India as a national medicine. So they called both for a systematic mobilisation of the land's plant wealth for medical purposes and for the liberation of Indians from the yoke of foreign medicines. Thus the hakims drew authority from the nationalism of their day. Another study examines, and does so for the first time in research on Tibb, the role of women as practitioners and patients. From the early twentieth century Tibb spread its authority amongst women to the extent that now between seventy and eighty per cent of the students in India's largest Unani medical school in Hyderabad are women. A final study focuses on the hakim-patient relationship and the role of the medical journal, its articles and its advertising, in establishing the authority of practitioners.
This is an outstanding book, which demonstrates the great creativity of India's Unani practitioners as they confronted a host of challenges to their medical tradition. It is based on a substantial reading of materials, most of them in Urdu, but some of them in Arabic, ranging from medical journals, reports, monographs, articles to published case notes, all of which are supported by archival research. This book will be a benchmark in the subject for years to come; it should also stimulate further research in the field. This said, it is much more than a book about Unani Tibb. It is a reflection, most notably expressed in its first-class introduction of some forty-nine pages, on the issues for a great civilisation as it confronted ‘modernity’ under colonial rule. Here Attewell's constant focus on the issue of authority, and how it was refashioned in these challenging circumstances, brings to the book a significance which reaches way beyond the matter of Unani Tibb.
