In 2008, Satoshi Nakamoto, a pseudonym for a person or group of persons yet to be identified, published a white paper unveiling Bitcoin, a virtual currency based on blockchain technology that enables secure, anonymous, peer-to-peer transactions outside the control of traditional, third-party intermediaries (i.e., banks and States). Bitcoin's blockchain is an example of a “public and permissionless” technology that operates through a distributed network wherein anyone with an internet connection has equal opportunity to participate and equal status to track and verify ongoing activity recorded in an immutable ledger. The egalitarian and transparent environment provided by Bitcoin's blockchain system offers a glimpse of a future, libertarian utopia where people interact in democratic, trust-based communities without need of government regulation. As the authors of Blockchain and Public Law: Global Challenges in the Era of Decentralisation explain, however, this utopia is far from becoming reality.
Blockchain and Public Law: Global Challenges in the Era of Decentralisation is an edited volume of thirteen chapters written by European scholars from a variety of academic institutions. The thirteen chapters are divided into two parts: part I examines the impact of blockchain technology on topics solely within the domain of public law (e.g., sovereignty, citizenship, public administration, data protection, etc.) and part II analyzes the use of blockchain technology on topics within the domain of private law at the intersection of public law (e.g., contracts, fintech, antitrust). Most chapters range between 15–18 pages packed with substantive analysis that assumes an audience of sophisticated readers with basic knowledge of blockchain technology and of existing legal frameworks in continental Europe.
Several themes emerge from the chapters taken as a whole. At the outset, many chapters quickly distinguish the types of blockchain technology. While all types of blockchain technology collect and disburse data for exchange, they differ depending on which participants have the authority to join the network and verify information. Private blockchains, such as those adopted by some corporations and administrative agencies, welcome participants from within designated groups, institutions, or consortia. Within these private and permissioned networks, the status of participants may vary with only select participants able to view certain data or verify information.
On the other hand, public blockchains, like Bitcoin, welcome anyone to the network and all participants have equal authority to verify information using a novel “proof of work” consensus protocol that records activity on a permanent ledger everyone can see. This public and permissionless type of blockchain technology, which was purposefully designed to challenge State control, earns the most attention from the book's authors because it disrupts existing notions of legal jurisdiction and enforcement. Which State's laws apply to anonymous transactions occurring simultaneously between participants (“nodes”) around the world? How does a State protect its citizens from theft and fraud or identify and punish a nefarious actor—human and/or robot, individual and/or group—that acts as “an amorphous swarm that runs on every node in its globe-spanning network without subsisting in any one place at any one time”? (p.93)
Another common theme is the juxtaposition between the promise of blockchain technology and the reality of blockchain technology as currently executed. Scholars rave about the potential of blockchain technology to create efficient, permanent, trust-based systems of data collection and exchange. Some States have already launched pilot programs applying blockchain technology to monitor elections, issue passports, and register public documents. The UN World Food Programme uses an application based on blockchain technology called EyePay, which scans the irises of refugees and confirms their identities so they can pay for groceries at the store. Bitcoin is thriving despite its volatility compared to fiat currencies. Yet, scholars also warn that blockchain technology is nascent, immature, and vulnerable to hackers. A few chapters discuss an event that occurred in June 2016, when a group of anonymous hackers manipulated weaknesses in the blockchain technology of a “digital autonomous organization” that was acting as a crowdfunding platform. The thieves were able to siphon-off millions of dollars from unsuspecting peers and the developers of the platform had to convince the remaining participants to collectively agree to modify the blockchain (i.e., “perform a hard fork”) to correct the ledger and return the funds. This revision was only possible because the thieves hadn't managed to gain 51% control of the public blockchain; it is easy to imagine future scenarios involving a more comprehensive takeover.
Additionally, many of the book's authors fear that even if blockchain's technology is perfected, its adoption may result in a dystopia that further reinforces existing inequities. The division between “the haves” (people with digital identities) and “the have-nots” (people without digital identities or without good ones) is likely to grow wider with increasing reliance on immutable ledgers that do not accommodate human discretion. Some examples (other than the degrading iris scans of refugees in Jordanian camps trying to buy food, noted above) are: the use of blockchain technology to remotely lock the doors of an apartment when the rent payment is late or to disable a car when the car payment is late; the use of blockchain technology to anonymously upload unlawful or embarrassing content on the permanent record that no court has the power to remove.
How should existing legal frameworks respond to the current reality and the future potential of blockchain technology? Ultimately, that academic question is the crux of the book and the answer is elusive. Some authors argue that existing EU regulations and directives can apply to blockchain technology; others insist that public and permissionless blockchain technology is too distinct to fall under current definitions and that the EU needs to write new laws to address its many facets. As one author says “one cannot regulate, nor supervise, what one does not understand and qualify.” (p. 211). All of the authors, though, seem confident that blockchain technology is capable of eventually becoming defined and regulated as it matures and, just as the law has adapted to the disruption caused by the internet, the law will adapt to blockchain.
Blockchain and Public Law: Global Challenges in the Era of Decentralisation belongs in every academic law library among the burgeoning collection (print and electronic) of titles analyzing blockchain technology and the law. It is not perfect, though. For example, only four of the eighteen contributors are women and, of those, only one woman is the sole author of her own chapter. This reader would have appreciated more gender diversity in the list of contributors, particularly a scholar who studies the gender bias in technology law and development. Additionally, Chapter 10, which describes and analyzes an empirical study on the use of blockchain technology in healthcare, is twice as long as the other chapters and doesn't fit easily among the others in substance or tone. These criticisms, though, do not take away from the value of the book contributing to the ongoing discussion in domestic, regional, and international spaces about the impact of blockchain technology on aspects of public law. As Professor Tom W. Bell states in Chapter 6: “Humans increasingly entrust their wealth, their secrets, and indeed their lives to clouds of bits swirling through inscrutably complex networks.”[p101]. Global challenges to legal frameworks in this era of decentralization will continue.
