‘Epic space presents a world against which reality can crash.’ Thus, this volume begins its ambitious (re)vision of the journey in ancient literature. Originally a conference and colloquium on ‘Home’, it explores the multivalent movements to or from one's Heimat — probing that crucial space in between points of origin and end. While, as the editors admit, recent scholarship has often forayed into such topics, what distinguishes this project is a capacious definition of its terms. Readers browsing the contents page may be surprised to find chapters on Tacitus, Xenophon and Lucian; yet the introduction shows how epic is the launchpad, not the limitation of the enquiry. These journeys all perform, rework or transgress the paradigmatic voyage inscribed in Homer, particularly the Odyssey. The result in many ways mimics its polytrophic model. The four parts, each prefaced with a synopsis, bend through time, resisting obvious chronological or geographical sequencing.
Part I begins with Egbert Bakker's metallurgical reading of Odysseus’ journey as a return from the Gold to the Iron Age. Alexander Loney considers the importance of pompe in the Odyssey, demonstrating how Odysseus’ successful conveyance requires him to trust and resist excessive agency, and his benefactors to offer abundant, even self-destructive generosity. Jessica Blum moves to a poem which is simultaneously a predecessor and heir to Homer. Valerius Flaccus’ Argonautica, she argues, articulates a profound duality — of timeframes, generic models and meanings. As epic players in an imperial world, the heroes’ dependence on a Homeric martial script often leads them astray, and anticipates their tragedy just outside of the poem.
Part II focuses on the intersections between love, relationships and home. Silvia Montiglio, in what for me was one of the finest chapters, examines the parallels and differences between the journeying couples in Apollonius and Heliodorus. Whereas Chariclea and Theagenes succeed in their novelistic prioritisation of love over home, once Medea leaves with — or for — Jason, she is always already homeless. Emily Baragwanath considers the domestic politics of Xenophon's Anabasis, in a more positive reading of the journey's success. Alison Keith provides the first discussion of the Aeneid. Complementing her work on the epic landscape as a contrast between mobile males and grounded women, Keith looks at instances where Vergil almost breaks from this mould. Through Dido, Andromache and the other Trojan women, Vergil ‘repeatedly sounds out the possibility of female participation in the epic voyage’ (144), only to draw back from ultimately letting them in. This chapter was another highlight of the volume, and I found Keith's readings articulate, pithy and moving.
Part III considers movement in the Roman world. Staying with the Aeneid, Timothy O'Sullivan interprets horizontal and vertical motion in the epic: both over-arching (from Troy to Italy) and microcosmic (Aeneas climbing a cliff). O'Sullivan neatly connects these dynamics to Vergil's infamous ideological ambivalence: the triumph of the steady over the chaotic offers an Augustan poetics of festina lente — however problematised that poetics may be. For a generally convincing chapter, there were some surprising omissions. Dido features only in the context of wandering: her own vertical movements (watching the fleet prepare to leave from her tower and ascending the pyre to die) receive no comment; and while O'Sullivan begins with Quint's seminal Epic and Empire, there was no interaction with his recent book, Virgil's Double Cross (2018), which addresses similar ideas from a different perspective. Thomas Biggs shows how Vergil's representation of Aeneas’ pietas is paralleled in other Trojan and Carthaginian figures. Confidently traversing a range of texts, Biggs shines light on how readers could accept enemy figures such as Hanno embodying what came to be the most Roman of virtues. Warfare remains at the forefront of Cynthia Damon and Elizabeth Palazzolo's contribution, which traces the distortions in Tacitus’ account of Germanicus’ eastern travels compared with epigraphic and numismatic evidence. Andrew Johnston tracks the afterlife of Odysseus and his wanderings in the imperial cultural imagination. While this was a potent examination of how imperial authors reconfigure the language of space, exile and knowledge, some of Johnston's most provocative points could have been taken further. For instance, when Scipio, gazing at annihilated Carthage, speaks two lines of Homer (‘a day will come when sacred Troy will meet its end, with Priam and his people’, Polyb. 38.21–2), Johnston suggests that ‘he shows himself to be the fulfilment of Polybius’ Odyssean ideal’ (218). What, then, of the fact that Scipio the ‘new’ Odysseus quotes from the Iliad? The temporal ramifications — amalgamating past and present intertextually too — could be telling.
Part IV moves to an extra-terrestrial plane. Martin Devecka offers a stimulating reading of Rutilius Namatianus’ fifth-century De reditu suo, whose account of the poet's journey to the Moon foresees a Rome that will rise again. The strongest and most important part of this chapter was the religious polemics to which it gestured. Setting the types of ‘classical’ knowledge enshrined in De reditu against contemporary Christian writings like Augustine's City of God, Devecka argues that Rutilius’ poem marks the end of an era: because of Christianity, no one could travel in quite this way again. This engagement with the religious dimensions of the Roman empire was most welcome, and noticeably missing from the previous section. The collection concludes with Karen ní Mheallaigh's account of gaiaskopiai. Lucian's Icaromenippus, whose narrator contemplates Earth from the Moon, is set against other cosmic vantage points, from the mega/meta ecphrasis on Achilles’ Shield to testimonies from modern astronauts. The similarities in responses, for ní Mheallaigh, underline a connectivity of thought: ‘rhetorical failure’, musical reactions and human centrality versus infinitesimal insignificance. Though I remain unconvinced how far Lucian's knowingly erudite expressions of speechlessness can really be compared to modern exclamations like ‘Oh God … it's beyond description’, super-terrestrial visions do provide a powerful space for asking those most Odyssean of questions: ‘who are you?’; but also, ‘who am I?’.
This is a beautifully written and well-crafted volume, combining adventures into unusual texts with fresh treatments of well-trodden territory. Whilst the contributions oscillate in quality and interest, every chapter gave me something new to think about. My only major disappointment was not to see a wider range of coverage. For a collection expressly centred on Homer, there is comparatively little on the Iliad, which offers deep reflection on war and home, journey and stasis, and returns that never come. On the Odyssey itself, it is surprisingly quiet about Book 24, and does not probe this archetypal non-ending: the nostos which is not a telos at all. No chapters are explicitly dedicated to tragedy — the major reconfiguration of epic territory — and the Roman sections contain no imperial Greek epic. This genre offers many examples of (as Blum puts it of Valerius Flaccus) texts ‘stuck in a time warp’, and intense exploitations of topoi of space and time. In particular, a chapter on Colluthus’ Abduction of Helen — which is centred on the love-home dialectic and playfully subverts horizontal and vertical perspectives — and Dionysius Periegetes, the ultimate cosmic travel poet, could offer valuable new perspectives on the topics explored. Such wishful thinking aside, the overarching narrative here is rich and rewarding, and raises elliptical questions about the cost of transition, the nature of belonging and the shifting, plural ways to be home.
