In 1716, Johann Jakob Scheuchzer, the Swiss polymath and physician, published Helvetia historia naturalis. In seeking to highlight the natural wonders of his beloved Switzerland, he created a text that became a popular reference work for European naturalists. While such nationalist motivations were on the rise at the time, longitudinal studies on the forms of print that gave birth to such large projects are hard to find. In Inventing the Indigenous, Alix Cooper addresses this gap in scholarship and gives an original account of how local knowledge moved through texts that addressed local, regional and national natural history. To accomplish this task she focuses on the literary technologies that naturalists used to gather and record information in central Europe during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. She touches on a wide number of subjects, but she concentrates on how varieties of local knowledge affected the ways in which natural objects were described, catalogued and organized. In following this path, she provides a nuanced picture of how the intellectual context of various naturalists affected how they conceived of the natural history of Europe, Asia, Africa and the Americas. Chapter 1 pursues this point in detail and offers several well-crafted case studies that illustrate the heterogeneous state of European natural knowledge. Cooper shows that ‘indigenous’ and ‘exotic’ views of nature were strongly shaped by the local epistemologies present in a naturalist's home village, town or city.
The next two chapters concentrate on the practices of textual compilation employed by botanists and mineralogists. Chapter 2 focuses on the emergence of plant catalogues as a distinct genre. Cooper details how naturalists adapted the inventorial format of the catalogue into a type of classificatory tool. Although her points on this topic are undoubtedly applicable to a wide number of local settings, she astutely uses the University of Altdorf to examine the ways in which plant catalogues evince local knowledge in the making. She suggests that the list format of local floras served as a codified model that followed a consistent organizational pattern. In her words:
After providing the most authoritative names available for a given plant, and citing references from which these names had been drawn, an entry proceeded immediately to the description of where it was that the plant could be found; this formed the remainder, and thus the bulk, of the entry (p. 81).
The implication of her summary here is clear: a key element of order shared by most indigenous floras was their conceptual format, not necessarily the principles that were used to classify the specifics of their content. Turning the focus to minerals, Chapter 3 widens the scope of the indigenous to include regional territories known through first- and third-person testimonies. Cooper avers that the principal form of literary representation was a revised humanist style of ‘extensive description’ that was effectively absent from the list format used in local floras. It included summaries of an object's attributes and qualities as well as relevant aspects of folklore, civil history, medicinal usage and industrial relevance. In this style of description, indigenous knowledge played a central, but different, role. Its unique and specific nature forced compilers of regional mineralogies to accept the written accounts and specimens submitted by indigenes and engendered the formation of correspondence networks specifically focused on natural history.
Chapter 4 focuses on the role of indigenous knowledge in natural histories written about entire countries in central Europe. Following on from the style advocated by Francis Bacon, Robert Boyle and Henry Oldenburg, European naturalists combined the list and narrative with information obtained via correspondence networks to create a wide-ranging genre of natural history dependent on local knowledge. To tell the story of this transformation, she concentrates on how Scheuchzer constructed his Helvetia historia naturalis from a list of published questions and from a catalogue of books relevant to the natural history of Switzerland. In 1706 he combined the information from his books and the responses from correspondents to form a weekly magazine. He then took all of the magazine's issues and made the four volumes of Helvetia. One point underlying Cooper's adept exercise in publication history is that the form and content of Scheuchzer's book, which became a model for naturalists, constitutes an excellent example of a national natural history that was utterly dependent on indigenous experts. She explores this point further in Chapter 5 by using Scheuchzer's Bibliotheca scriptorium and Carolus Linnaeus's Bibliotheca botanica, both bibliographies of natural history, to evaluate the ways in which each author appreciated local informants. The nub of her argument is that Scheuchzer did and Linnaeus did not. However, Cooper seems to be pushing her point a bit too hard here because she does not clearly explain that, outside the pages of his Bibliotheca, Linnaeus did indeed value the testimony of indigenous actors, and that the aims and objectives of his Systema Naturae were different from those of Scheuchzer's Helvetia.
Cooper's indigenous argument is strongest in sections that treat the form and importance of local plant catalogues. Her sections on mineralogy could be firmer. For example, the absence of a sustained discussion on the form and content of local ‘fossil’ catalogues seems to suggest that such sources do not exist. On the whole, however, Inventing the Indigenous is easily one of the most innovative and informative books on the history of natural history that I have recently read. Instead of elaborate hand-waving towards trendy, but transient, buzzwords, Cooper tells a story well grounded in a canon of neo-Latinate texts that speak to unique themes which could have emerged only through years of painstaking reading and rereading. This uniqueness comes through again and again in strategically chosen examples that convincingly show that there was an influential and diverse world of indigenous natural-history practices in early modern central Europe.
