In October of 1918, a series of forest fires swept through northeastern Minnesota, destroying 38 communities. The fires, collectively known as the Fire of 1918 or the “Great Holocaust of 1918,” was among one of the worst forest fires in American history.Footnote 1 It killed 453 people, injured 52,371 more, and destroyed $65–$73 million worth of property.Footnote 2 The Fond du Lac Ojibwe Reservation was one of the communities decimated by the fire. Though no one from the reservation was killed, Fond du Lac Ojibwe suffered thousands of dollars worth of destroyed property. Like their white settler neighbors, they brought claims against the United States Railroad Administration (USRA) for compensation. But the Office of Indian Affairs (OIA) paternalistically determined Fond du Lac people's claims based upon whether they were legally citizens or determined to be noncitizen wards of the federal government. The Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), moreover, insisted on suing on behalf of some Ojibwes.
The fire took place during a critical period of transition—the Progressive Era—when some Americans pushed to expand the boundaries of American citizenship and personhood, or what historian Barbara Welke has termed “the borders of belonging.” In so doing, they formed the foundation of what later became the modern welfare state.Footnote 3 These individuals argued that citizens had the rights to belong in a national community and to enjoy security and economic welfare through the state, or social citizenship. Advocates of social citizenship hardly got all that they wanted: citizenship in practice conferred formal political equality but little in the way of the security of such provisions as unemployment and health insurance, workplace safety, or economic security. Nevertheless, social citizenship advocates did manage to secure some economic and social protections for many classes of widows and orphans as well as expand the protections guaranteed by the state to some in organizing the workplace.Footnote 4
A number of historians have explored how inequities based on race and gender shaped the meaning and boundaries of social citizenship for many Americans in the early twentieth century.Footnote 5 Most notably, Alice Kessler Harris has asserted that the United States formulated welfare policy based on the assumption that breadwinners were white and male and that women were subsumed within the family.Footnote 6 Such studies illustrate how the boundaries of the nation-state solidified around gendered, racialized, and able-bodied terms that were embedded in the legal structure of the welfare state by the 1930s.Footnote 7
However, an area that remains underexamined is the unique way that United States' colonialism and paternalism, or its focus on eroding Indigenous people's autonomy based on its assertion of authority over their lands, resources, and nearly all aspects of their lives, shaped social citizenship for American Indians. The distinct political position of Indigenous people as tribal nations existing within the geographic and political boundaries of the United States posed challenges to the idea that incorporation into the nation-state secured rights and freedom. For Indigenous people, incorporation into the United States was really a history of engulfment based on the expansion of the settler state and the extension of colonial control over tribal communities.
Beginning in the nineteenth century, citizenship became a key instrument of colonial control and elimination. As Patrick Wolfe writes, settler colonialism is a process in which the objective of European (and Euro-American) powers is to replace Natives on their own land based on the logic of elimination. In the United States, elimination was not just based on efforts to exterminate American Indians through violence, but also through assimilation into American society (though not with the same rights or privileges as Euro-Americans) and the erasure of their distinct identities, connections to traditional territories, and political rights.Footnote 8
After the Civil War, incorporation became the United States' primary method of eliminating Indigenous identity. It remained such for the rest of the nineteenth and most of the twentieth centuries. Embracing a progressivism based on the idea of Western superiority, the federal government implemented an array of assimilation programs aimed at eradicating American Indian cultures, undercutting their political autonomy and tribal connections, and forcing their incorporation into American society through the authority of the OIA. In 1887, Congress passed the General Allotment Act, which divided tribal lands into individual parcels and gave the surplus lands to settlers. The act provided for legal citizenship to individual American Indians who took allotments in fee simple and adopted a “civilized” lifestyle, while placing others whose land was held in trust under the guardianship of the federal government.Footnote 9 These policies presented contradictions—on the one hand, the federal government promoted American Indian citizenship and individualism as a means to eradicate tribal identity; and on the other hand, it continued to assert paternal protection and control over Indigenous “wards” of the government.
For many American Indians, including Ojibwes, the federal government's contradictory policies as well as the emerging, fledgling, and contested ideal of the welfare state presented many challenges and restrictions as well as some openings during the Progressive Era. American Indian children were taken far from their homes to boarding schools where they were forced to shed any trace of tribal culture and identity in exchange for a Euro-American education that prepared them for American citizenship. The allotment of tribal lands as well as the federal government's efforts to implement agriculture and Euro-American ways of life in tribal communities led to land loss, poverty, environmental devastation, and an undermining of Indigenous traditions. Yet a number of Native people, the most well-known being the Society of American Indians, also worked within the American political system in an effort to obtain greater economic and political rights based on American Indian citizenship. Moreover, as Philip Deloria points out in Indians in Unexpected Places, American Indians engaged with the same forces of modernity that gripped other Americans and participated in many aspects of popular culture ranging from athletics to opera.Footnote 10
American Indians did not act solely in response to federal policy or shifts in American culture more broadly. Ojibwe responses to the fire and their attempts to seek compensation for damages were based on their efforts to exercise self-determination, or to make choices and exercise agency in ways that best served their tribal communities, families, and individual interests. Their choices were diverse and based on a flexible political culture that had informed their approach to relations with the United States and other European powers for hundreds of years. Ojibwes shifted alliances and their approaches to state policies in order to retain agency, economic benefits, and political power.Footnote 11 While on the surface Ojibwe efforts to seek claims for fire damages may not have appeared to have challenged colonial views of belonging, they emerged from a desire to exercise self-determination rather than a desire for incorporation or assimilation into the emerging welfare state. They used social citizenship when it was beneficial or enabled them to retain greater freedom from the control of the OAI, but they also retained their distinct legal relationship and continued to exercise their treaty rights to hunt, fish, and gather—all of which were the lifeblood of their communities and culture.
The Fire of 1918 provides rich ground for investigating the challenges and openings presented by social citizenship and the formation of the modern welfare state for American Indians. A number of federal departments, including the National Guard, the Red Cross, the OIA, and the USRA played a critical role in shaping the scope of disaster relief and compensation following the fire. The fire, like all natural disasters, sheds light on the relationships between the nation-state and the populations living within its boundaries. In his book on hurricanes and colonial British society in the Caribbean, Matthew Mulcahy has suggested that natural disasters provide “new insights on institutions, attitudes, and relationships that are not always fully visible or articulated during periods of ‘normality.’”Footnote 12 This argument was especially true for the early twentieth century, when federal power expanded in the arena of public affairs.Footnote 13 Legal scholar Michele Landis Dauber points out that the unpredictability of natural disasters and the urgent need for relief gave the federal government unparalleled power to intervene in these circumstances and offered a more powerful rationale for federal relief and intervention than did other challenges. She argues that the federal governments used disaster relief to expand its reach during the nineteenth century and to launch the American welfare state in the early twentieth century.Footnote 14
Few scholars have explored the relationship between federal disaster policy and American colonialism.Footnote 15 While Landis Dauber does a fine job of showing us that politicians advocated for federal funding and intervention in response to a range of political and social issues and institutions, including the Freedman's Bureau, she assumes that in all cases this intervention was “governed by a strong concern with equity and precedent.”Footnote 16 This was certainly not the case with American Indian communities, or for that matter, African American or immigrant communities, where federal intervention compounded the devastating impact of several “natural” disasters and led to the erosion of political rights.Footnote 17
In northeastern Minnesota, the framework of social citizenship developed in the context of the processes of settler expansion and industrial capitalism. Though the region's labor and political traditions were diverse and changed over time, the United States made its growth possible through the dispossession and of Indigenous lands, resources, and the erosion of tribal sovereignty through treaties. In 1854, the federal government negotiated a land cession treaty with Lake Superior Ojibwes. The treaty established permanent reservations, including one at Fond du Lac, and it confirmed Ojibwe rights to hunt, fish, and gather on lands ceded in previous treaties.Footnote 18 It led to the cession of thousands of acres of Indian lands on the western shore of Lake Superior and established the right of the way for roads, highways, and railroads to run through reservations. The treaty also stipulated that the federal government could divide reservation lands into eighty-acre tracts assigned to heads of households or individuals.Footnote 19 Under this provision, many Ojibwes lived on lands allotted and held in trust by the federal government prior to the Dawes Act, and this complicated the division of lands and property ownership on the reservation in years to come.
The United States defined its economic growth and political power in northeastern Minnesota based on the mineral and timber wealth it obtained through the 1854 treaty. Shortly after the treaty, settlers built the town of Cloquet on the St. Louis River just southeast of the reservation. More settlers moved in to build and work in the town's numerous lumber camps and sawmills. The availability of work drew hundreds of migrant and immigrant workers to the town who sought to build a new life in the region. Moreover, the growth of the area lumber industry fostered the construction of the railroad and later roads, on which trains and wagons carried timber from the town to the port city of Duluth where it was shipped to cities farther to the east and south to meet growing demands for lumber and settler expansion. In the early twentieth century, Walter O'Meara, a local writer, observed that the people of Cloquet “thought timber, talked timber, labored with it deep in the woods and steam-driven mills, and sometimes gave their lives to it in the somber forest or the white-water streams. They spent their lives from youth to old age in the cutting, driving, and sawing of timber.”Footnote 20 The timber gained through the treaties became the lifeblood of northern Minnesota towns such as Cloquet.
The 1854 treaty also defined Fond du Lac people's integration into the local economy and into the nation-state as colonial subjects. Under the treaties, Ojibwes lived under the jurisdiction of the United States not as citizens, but as wards of the federal government. The cession of lands in the treaty and their subsequent relocation to reservations left Fond du Lac people with a limited land base of 100,000 acres on which to survive. This was minuscule in comparison to traditional Ojibwe territory, which covered much of the Western Great Lakes and entailed a reduction of roughly 98 percent of their lands.Footnote 21 Such a dramatic reduction of territory made it difficult to rely solely on traditional subsistence activities for a livelihood.
The OIA urged Fond du Lac people to clear timber from the reservation with the intent of encouraging them to engage in capitalist ventures and agriculture. These initiatives led to further dispossession of hundreds of additional acres of reservation timber. Under the control of corrupt Indian agents who had conflicting interests in the local lumber industry, allotment enabled lumber companies to seize or purchase much of the land remaining in Ojibwe hands.Footnote 22 Under the Dawes Act, Ojibwes who took allotments were granted citizenship, but because of poverty, most of them could not afford to pay state or federal taxes on their lands. They lost or sold land to settlers or lumber companies. Furthermore, logging rendered useless for farming any lands community members managed to retain because the cutover land was too rocky to nourish crops during the region's short growing season.
At the same time, Minnesota conservation officials targeted Indians in the implementation and enforcement of fish and game laws. They disregarded Ojibwe hunting, fishing, and gathering rights set aside in treaties by defining them as outdated and special privileges that would enable Indians to “exterminate” all wildlife in the state.Footnote 23 They arrested and harassed Ojibwes for exercising their treaty rights on and off-reservation until 1999, when the United States Supreme Court upheld the validity of Ojibwe treaty rights.Footnote 24
Forced by these conditions to make a living through other means, Fond du Lac people sought wage work in the lumber camps and lumber mills, in an industry built on lands that they once held. Fond du Lac men worked as lumberjacks, timber cruisers, surveyors, and mill workers. Some men even attained local fame for their ability to win logrolling or burling contests. Fond du Lac women also took on work as domestic servants, laundresses, and midwives in the lumber towns bordering the reservation.Footnote 25
By the early twentieth century, the Fond du Lac Reservation resembled many of the settlements surrounding it, though treaties, access to resources (or the lack of), race, and the OIA's extension of authority over Ojibwe people, clearly delineated Indian and settler relationships to the nation-state in dramatically different ways. Little more than a thousand people lived on the reservation.Footnote 26 Many of them lived in the Indian village, the main settlement of the reservation, in small farms and houses that overlooked the St. Louis River. Nearby stood the government-run Indian farm, Indian hospital, and Father Simon's Catholic church. On and off of the reservation, the lumber industry transformed the dense pine forest into a barren cutover landscape with branches and stumps that stretched as far as the eye could see. This was the perfect backdrop for a forest fire.Footnote 27
On October 10, 1918, a spark flew from a passing train and ignited scraps of wood scattered around the tracks at Milepost 62 of the Great Northern Railway. The railway crew could not put the fire out, and it spread southeast to the Fond du Lac Reservation. It reached the Indian village between 7:00 and 7:30 p.m. the next evening and overtook anything that was in its route. Fond du Lac people survived the fire, by taking refuge in lakes, rivers, or on islands knowing that they would fare better in these areas.Footnote 28 Testifying for a later fire claims case, Fond du Lac band member Joseph Petite stated that he and his wife fled the fire, which quickly engulfed their farm. They departed toward the Indian village but they saw sparks in the sky and so continued to Cloquet. “You could hear it crackling and sparks coming over us…” he said. The firebrands were “as big as fire balls” and that he could see “the fire flying all over us.”Footnote 29 The Petite family eventually spent the night in a small lake with a number of other Fond du Lac community members. Similarly, Mike Beargrease, another tribal member, rescued his settler neighbor Grace Sheehy and her two children, and they fled to the Twin Lakes where they found a boat at the western edge of the lake. Beargrease paddled the boat out onto the water where they watched as the fire roared past the opposite side of the lake.
Elizabeth (Betty) Gurno was a young girl at the time of the fire. Her grandfather, who worked as a timber cruiser, rushed home to the reservation and told her family to evacuate. Taking a few blankets and food, they ran to the banks of the river near the Indian village. They drenched the blankets with water and huddled under them. Gurno remembered watching the railroad tracks buckle like snakes from the heat; the community priest, Father Simon, donning a cloak and a red kerchief over his heat-blistered scalp, as he hurriedly attempted to reassure people that if they said their prayers they would not die; and younger men from the reservation running with buckets of water. Gurno recalled that they heard someone crying for help in the cemetery next to the church and a man took three trips with wet blankets yelling, “Come this way,” in Ojibwe and English. When he reached the spot, he found only the charred ruins of the church. However, the community continued to hear many voices screaming from the cemetery throughout the night. “My grandmother always said that the dead were hollering. They were burning too…” Gurno remembered.Footnote 30
Although tribal members did not have access to the relief trains sent to rescue people living in the fire's path, everyone was able to escape and no one from the Fond du Lac community died in the fire. The reservation superintendent George W Cross and State Forester William Cox both remarked that Ojibwe people were much better at managing fire than whites, and the local Pine Knot newspaper reported that Ojibwe people's “keen wits saved them from perishing.”Footnote 31 Gurno suggested that it was Indigenous knowledge and resilience that saved Fond du Lac Ojibwes from the fire. “[We] had the common sense that God gave [us] to go to the river like an animal. All the animals were there. There were bears swimming out there…” she remembered.Footnote 32 “No Indian people got killed. Four hundred white people died right in this area. Right here,” she said.Footnote 33
When the fire finally ended on the morning of October 13, there was little left of Cloquet and the surrounding farms. Thousands of people had nowhere to go. On the Fond du Lac Reservation, the fire destroyed the Catholic church and Indian village. It destroyed fifty-seven homes, as well as outbuildings and property including livestock, farming implements, wagons, food, furniture, and clothing.
The federal government provided immediate relief to local towns: it mobilized the Minnesota Infantry National Guard, which searched for victims, buried the dead, and kept civil order. The Red Cross treated the injured and provided shelter for “refugees” of the fire. The Minnesota Commission of Public safety spent $2,150,000 in relief in the winter of 1919 to help settlers rebuild their businesses and farms and many more private donations poured in through local organizations.Footnote 34 Fond du Lac Ojibwes received $5000.00 in immediate relief from the federal government and tribal members could get assistance from the Red Cross and the Indian hospital. However, the OIA and Congress determined the scope of relief for Ojibwe people was a lengthier bureaucratic process. Superintendent Cross estimated that it would take $100,000.00 to restore the homes lost. Yet, Congress authorized only $60,000 in funds to be paid to those who lost homes. The cost of each home was not to exceed $1000.00 and the federal government refused requests for funds to build barns and outbuildings.Footnote 35 The federal government did not provide compensation for the loss of other kinds of property of damage to lands. Moreover, it did not make these funds available until late 1919 and 1920.
Following disaster relief efforts, the fire survivors demanded an inquiry into the railroad's role in causing the fire. The state appointed a Forest Fire Investigation Commission, which included a railroad lawyer, a state forest ranger, several forestry professors, and a number of local citizens. In the first few years following the fire, survivors brought 15,003 claims against the USRA in Minnesota state courts and the courts ruled in favor of the victims. In 1921, the USRA appealed the cases in the Minnesota Supreme Court in hopes of reversing the decisions of the state courts. Although the Minnesota Supreme Court held that the USRA was responsible for the fire, the USRA determined that it would only compensate the 278 fire victims who had already won their cases for 50 percent of their total claims and those whose cases were still untried in the courts for 40 percent of their claims. USRA officials never explained how they determined these numbers, but the head representative stated that this was the best he could do and that the survivors could “take it or leave it.”Footnote 36
Like their settler neighbors, Fond du Lac people sued for damages, but the federal government's approach to their claims was different based on federal paternalism and the notion that Indians were wards of the federal government. Much of the territory investigated by lawyers and timber cruisers in the course of determining the cause of the fire in the immediate aftermath fell within the boundaries of the reservation. Therefore, they attained detailed information about the losses that Fond du Lac people suffered. With this evidence in place, Fond du Lac Ojibwes stood to win a number of settlements based on individual claims. They filed more than 250 claims alongside white fire survivors from Cloquet.Footnote 37 However, a substantial number of tribal members still held lands under the treaty of 1854 in trust patents. The OIA counted 130 of the Ojibwe who sued for damages as wards of the federal government and not owners of their own lands.Footnote 38 This distinction diminished the amount of damages they could claim and clearly illustrated the contradictory nature of policy deployed by the federal government based on wardship and citizenship.
In October of 1920, lawyer J. A. Fesenbeck wrote to Superintendent Cross inquiring whether Indians whose lands were held in trust could sue for damages on their own behalf. He commented that it seemed to him that they “should follow the same claim of a white person.”Footnote 39 After consulting with the OIA, Cross concluded that only the federal government could represent these claimants. The OIA disregarded the earlier evidence and started new cases on their behalf. The claimants represented by the federal government could only receive a fraction of the damages they sued for because the OIA launched its own costly investigation three years after the fire using evidence weakened by natural environmental changes.Footnote 40 Despite the fact that the government asserted title over trust lands, many Ojibwes built homes on this land through their own income and labor, making it impossible to separate trust claims from personal claims.Footnote 41 Nevertheless, the OIA pressed on and sued on behalf of Ojibwes whose lands were held in trust rather than allowing them to sue independently. The OAI continued to that their interests would be better served by the federal government and sued for significantly fewer damages.Footnote 42
Fond du Lac people did not accept the inequities created by federal intervention and power. Instead, they fought for individual rights and relief available to all other fire survivors. They used the rights associated with citizenship to challenge federal paternalism. In 1923, Joseph La Veirge challenged the OIA's paternalism in state courts, arguing that his claim was equal to that of any other fire survivor. La Veirge hired the Duluth law firm Arnold and Arnold to file a suit claiming $4000.00 worth of damages against the USRA. When the case came up for hearing, the United States district attorney “appeared specially” and successfully filed a motion that the case be dismissed because La Veirge was being represented by the federal government.Footnote 43 Instead of $4000.00, the OIA claimed $400.00 in damages for La Veirge based on its own estimates. Because the USRA agreed only to pay 40 percent to 50 percent of the claim, La Veirge stood to receive between $140.00 to $150.00—a small fraction of the amount he originally sued for.Footnote 44 La Veirge appealed the case in the Minnesota Supreme Court. He argued that state courts “were open for the redress of any wrong an Indian suffered in person or property precisely as they were to any other person.”Footnote 45 Still, the court determined that the property destroyed was held by the federal government and that Indians had to accept its representation. The court did not rule on the case until 1926, two years after American Indians were granted full citizenship under the Indian Citizenship Act.Footnote 46 The delay in the court's decision held up government payments until years after white fire claimants were compensated.Footnote 47 La Vierge's case revealed the interplay between the contradictions in federal policy, the flexibility of Ojibwe political approaches to fire relief, and social citizenship more broadly. It also exposed the limitations of citizenship for American Indians based on federal paternalism. La Vierge argued that the court rule in his favor based on his rights as an individual before the law with claims equal to those of white fire victims. Not only did he stand to receive greater compensation for his losses but also greater autonomy from the OIA. However, the Minnesota Supreme Court adhered to the idea that as a ward of the government La Vierge did not have access to those rights.
With the decision made in the La Veirge case, the matter of representation by the OIA was closed and those who lived on trust lands received less compensation than any of the survivors. The damage caused by the fire coupled with the meager compensation, pushed Fond du Lac people to seek additional opportunities off-reservation. In 1925, the superintendent of the reservation reported that they made a living through a variety of labor and trades and that many lived off-reservation. The reservation was slow to recover; twenty years after the fire the landscape was still largely barren, cut over land.Footnote 48 However, Indian and settler fire survivors angered by the claims process collectively pressed Congress for the full and final resolution of their claims. In 1935, after seventeen years of lobbying, the survivors received full compensation; President Roosevelt signed a bill that restored the remaining half of the settlements.Footnote 49
Though local in its scope, the history of the Fire of 1918 speaks to broader patterns related to natural disasters, the boundaries of citizenship, American colonialism, and the contested ideals of the welfare state in the early twentieth century. People's responses to natural disasters are based on ideologies deeply entrenched in society. In the case of the fire, the federal government's approach to disaster relief and compensation demonstrated the extent to which colonialism limited citizenship for Native people in the early twentieth century. In the aftermath of the fire, the OIA's paternalism and its desire for control interfered with Ojibwe efforts to sue independently. As a result, Ojibwes who had suffered the same losses as their neighbors stood to receive less in compensation. It was only through the collective efforts of settlers and Indians that both communities finally received just compensation, challenging the boundaries set forth by the nation-state in the process of demarcating social citizenship for Indigenous and non-Indigenous people.
This history suggests that there are valuable connections between American Indian history and the Progressive Era that merit further exploration. The emergence of social citizenship and the contested ideal of the welfare state, critical themes in Progressive Era history, transcended the borders of Indian and non-Indian communities and linked nearly all Americans in diverse ways. Like many other marginalized people, Fond du Lac Ojibwes faced possibilities and limitations in the transformation of American political culture, and they challenged the federal paternalism based on the contradictions between wardship and citizenship. However, they also did so, based on their distinct relationship with the federal government and their struggle to exercise self-determination. Their story and those of other Native people not only add to a rich body of scholarship examining how marginalized people pushed back against Progressive norms, but it also suggests the possibility of exploring how many Americans attempted to do so by working within and outside of the boundaries of the nation-state, based on their own interests as Indigenous people.
