The anthropological study of religious change has gained importance, even urgency, as mission activity has expanded globally, and as traditional communities increasingly participate in global culture. Understanding how and why religious change takes place is a classic problem of social theory, and the editors of the current volume have made significant contributions to this issue in Amazonia. Robin Wright is noted for two earlier edited volumes on religious conversion, and Aparecida Vilaça for some of the most interesting and insightful work to be carried out on religion and religious change in Amazonia, based on her work with the Wari' Indians of Brazil. In this new collection, the contributors take up the issue of the indigenous experience of Christianity, asking not whether indigenous communities will embrace Christianity but how they have done so, and seeking the ‘natives’ point of view' of this new religion.
Two of the chapters in the current volume consider North American indigenous communities (Allan Greer's on seventeenth-century Canada, and a chapter on an Inuit region by Frederic Laugrand and Jarich Oosten), but the primary focus of the collection is South America, and for the most part lowland South America, where the experience of Christianity has been more volatile.
Most of the contributions explore the variable uses of Christianity in changing expressions of identity. Peter Gow's essay, for example, starts with the intriguing claim by the Peruvian Piro that they are and always have been cristianos, a claim that he situates within Piro notions of social classification: of ‘humans and other people’. Similarly, Giovanna Bacchiddu considers the presence of evangelical Protestant missionaries among the people of Apiao, a small island off the coast of Chile; in an interesting echo of the Piro, the Apiao say, ‘before, we were all Catholics’. The majority of the population is Catholic, but a small minority has converted to the evangelical religion. Bacchiddu's chapter illustrates one of the enduring difficulties of thinking anthropologically about ‘conversion’. She appears unable to offer any explanation or account of how or why those who convert have done so; she comes close when one of her informants points to the better clothes he wears as an evangelical, but she does not explain why the majority of the population does not take advantage of these benefits, and instead simply quotes one of her Catholic informants who labels the well-dressed convert ‘just a bit nuts’. It is common for community members to psychologise conversion, but an anthropological account needs more. Bacchiddu gets closer to the goals of the editors when she proposes that for the Apiao religious affiliation ‘is strongly tied up with notions of descent, tradition, identity and community’, but she seems unaware that religious affiliation for North Americans, as David Schneider argued 40 years ago, is equally tied up with notions of descent and so on, and one suspects that religious affiliation is usually thus around the world. Rather than clarifying how and why religious affiliation changes, such observations merely highlight that a mid-range theory of religious identity would have been useful in understanding how some members of this community relinquish the importance of those notions in favour of others. In this regard Bacigalupo's chapter on Mapuche shamans is a more successful and satisfying exploration of the use of Catholic notions of the priesthood to legitimate shamanic identity within a modern Chilean state.
A number of anthropologists have explored identity in Amazonia through the medium of the body – Amazonian peoples often use somatic tropes and practices to express personhood – and these bodily notions are explored creatively here in essays by Vanessa Elisa Grotti among the Trio and Akuriyo of Guiana, Oiara Bonilla among the Brazilian Paumari, and Aparecida Vilaça (who expands this idea through the notions of perspectivalism and predation as well) among the Wari'. None of these authors takes up the ironic possibility that a religion so focused (theologically) on the salvation of souls is experienced so thoroughly by their informants as a somatic state, but whether this is an artefact of indigenous belief and practice or of anthropological fashions in the understanding of native Amazonians remains to be seen.
A fundamental puzzle that remains is the question of why indigenous communities would adopt Christianity in the apparent absence of any enduring benefits for doing so. The short-term rewards of participation in missionary life, usually material or political, were often transient enough to lead indigenous peoples to abandon that participation and its associated systems of belief and religious practice once the overt benefits were no longer available. This is not ‘conversion’ so much as accommodation, and Allan Greer notes perceptively that this is more of a conversion to colonialism than to Christianity (p. 30). As Karen Anderson has noted in her study of missionisation in seventeenth-century New France, it is astonishing that within a brief few years the Huron accepted the fairly rigid subjugation of the Jesuits, and the benefits of Christian belief alone cannot account for this. There are numerous hints in the contributions in this volume that the selective appropriation of Christian beliefs and practices may be either accommodation, or conversion to colonialism or globalisation, and this possibility may be worth exploring further.
Joel Robbins, a Melanesia specialist and one of the pre-eminent anthropologists of Christianity, offers an excellent Afterword in which he highlights major themes of the contributions to this volume but also points to some interesting gaps, including any effort by most of the authors to engage the broader field of the anthropology of Christianity, and the (perhaps related) absence of attention to forces of globalisation in the experience of the communities considered here. With a few notable exceptions, Amazonia specialists tend to be an insular group, and the invitation to Robbins to contribute his Afterword is a welcome effort to expand the ethnographic horizon of much of the work done in South America; it may also be an expression of that limited view, however, since Robbins' area of research, Papua New Guinea, is the region to which scholars most commonly turn for comparisons with Amazonia. Happily, Robbins' own perspective is global and encyclopaedic, and it is an important contribution to this collection in its own right.
