The changes in the nature and context of the Chinese media in the last ten years have been impressive. Over this time, the Internet is believed to have begun to have new implications for media freedom and civic participation. Developments in the Chinese media, however, have presented contradictions, resulting from the clash between the Party's remaining political control over the media and the media's desire for independence, one inspired by the media market and facilitated by communication technologies such as the Internet and its web 2.0 tools. Changing Media, Changing China, edited by Susan Shirk, analyzes the transformations and contradictions that characterize the current Chinese media landscape.
Divided into ten chapters, this book removes the veil covering the changing face of the Chinese media in the new media era. The Internet is seen as a pivotal factor generating changes for the media, the public, and the government. The introduction summarizes the shared themes of the chapters: the explosion of information as a result of popular use of the Internet informs and mobilizes the public to raise demands on government; the media, collaborating with members of the public who actively use the Internet to make their voices heard, have learned how to toe the party line in a better way; and the government thus has been obliged to develop new strategies to cope with control-free information as well as new expectations from its citizens. The chapters examine, from a variety of perspectives, how the Chinese media, the public, and the government have seized chances as well as withstood challenges provided by the wide application of the Internet. Several of these perspectives have been ignored or rarely addressed in the existing literature, including military journalism, the media-court relationship, and the impacts of the media on foreign policy.
In this book, the Internet-facilitated information explosion is weighed against commercialization and political control as the third crucial variable that affects the Chinese media landscape. The authors evaluate its impact in slightly different ways. Some of them tend to stress its positive implications for the function and autonomy of the Chinese media. In chapter 2, with an optimistic view, Qian Gang and David Bandurski argue that the emancipating forces released by the media market and the extensive use of the Internet, plus recent advances in journalistic professionalism, have changed the rules of the game, allowing Chinese journalists to develop certain tactics to deal with the top-down propaganda control and therefore be able to set their own agenda. This view is shared by Hu Shuli and Zhan Jiang. Their respective chapters (3 and 5) emphasize the watchdog function of business and commercial media and the collaboration of the media and public intellectuals, who exert pressure on government with the help of the Internet. In Benjamin Liebman's interesting account of the ambivalent relationship between media and court, the media have benefited from the Internet in terms of pushing courts to increase the transparency of legal cases, though courts also endeavour to develop counter-tactics to deal with this situation. Through analyzing recent cases of protests and social movements, Xiao Qiang argues in chapter 9 that the Internet has been successful in mobilizing the public and facilitating social activism.
By contrast, other authors hold more conservative attitudes toward the influences of the Internet. In chapter 4, Miao Di puts forward a relatively pessimistic argument that Chinese television suffers from serious market competition from its print and online counterparts, as well as yields to requests from the party-state to continue to act as the propaganda apparatus. Similarly, in chapter 6, Tai Ming Cheung believes the existing pattern of military news reporting and the operation of the military media is likely to remain unchanged despite pressure from political and commercial actors. Daniela Stockmann gives a solid analysis of how Chinese citizens filter information absorbed from different sources. She argues that, although they reach a wider audience in China via the Internet, the foreign media cannot replace the domestic media as trustable news sources, while the news that is provided by the state is also rejected as untrustworthy. In chapter 10, Shirk recognizes the continuing power of the government to set foreign policy despite pressures from the media, facilitated by commercialization and the popularity of the Internet. The slightly different views the authors present demonstrate well the paradoxical nature of the Chinese media.
Overall, this book represents a successful attempt to interpret the Chinese media landscape in the new media era with an effective illustration of recent major cases. However, more social dynamics and tensions within the wider context of Chinese society should have been taken into account in interpreting and illustrating the reality. In addition, the authors all accept the premise that the technology of the Internet does indeed matter for the Chinese media and society. Such a premise more or less ignores the impacts of human use of the Internet. That is to say, the extent to which the technology of the Internet can have positive implications for the Chinese media, which is struggling to balance tensions between the market and the party-state, really depends on how this technology is used by particular individuals and institutions and for what purposes. This would require the book to move its emphasis from a macro to a micro level that stresses individuals’ use of the internet and thus reveals a more nuanced and detailed picture of media freedom and autonomy in contemporary China.
