As the title suggests, The Reckoning of Pluralism examines and evaluates the political dynamics and consequences of pluralism as an institutional and ideological-cultural arrangement for recognizing and accommodating subnational difference. The focus is on Turkey, which on the face of it appears to be an odd choice for a study of pluralism: Turkey is, after all, a country where instead of the pluralist recognition of subnational diversity, the writ of a unitary and homogenizing republican nationalism has run large for almost a century. As Kabir Tambar himself notes in the opening sentence, pluralism is an “oxymoron” in the Turkish context (p. 1). But as the book soon reveals, this counterintuitive case selection is analytically productive, and makes for an original and innovative inquiry into a topic on which much scholarly ink has been spilled.
There are three major analytical dividends that a study of pluralism in Turkey yields, which are also the three main emphases of Tambar's argument. First, it dismantles the widely held presumption that pluralism and unitary nationalism share an antinomial and mutually exclusive relationship. In Turkey as in other contexts, the pluralist demand for the granting of rights and recognition to minority groups has generally been understood as an effort to counter the homogenizing impulse of official nationalism. However, as is shown by Tambar's discussion of the official political and cultural recognition granted to the minority Alevi community and the enhanced visibility of Alevi cultural practices in public cultural arenas in recent decades, there are also significant alignments and mutually reinforcing relations between the two. Pluralism, he insists, can also be a tool and resource of national sovereignty.
Second, the focus on Alevi negotiations of pluralism in Turkey draws attention to the centrality of history as a resource in pluralist politics. The demand for the historical visibility of communities that have been marginalized and effectively silenced in dominant narratives of national history has assumed renewed importance in Turkey in recent times. Moreover, as the politically fraught nature of the “Armenian question” and the “Kurdish question” or the respective struggles to introduce into the Turkish public sphere accounts of the Armenian genocide and of the historical richness of Kurdish language and culture show, the establishment of historical depth and presence is central to minority struggles for recognition and autonomy. But this turn to history has an ambivalent political effect, and Tambar's engagement with the pluralist politics of history reveals the limits of historical recuperation as an emancipatory strategy. When Alevi groups express their distinctive cultural identities in public arenas, the author argues in a strongly Foucaultian vein, they do so “upon the institutional scaffolding of the modernist project” (p. 4), in the terms of a state-sanctioned political modernity that conceptualizes Alevis anachronistically, as quaint heritage communities that embody the national past. The historicizing logic of the Turkish state, and the overarching vision of national unity that this recourse to history serves, is thus shored up by Alevi efforts to realize a more pluralist political-cultural order.
The discussion of the “limits of history” as a resource and strategy of Alevi emancipation (and that of minority politics more broadly speaking) draws attention to a wider political-philosophical concern. This is the third main innovation of the book: the interrogation of normative presumptions about political presence and voice, or the assumption that voice, visibility, and public presence in a more general sense is a necessary guarantor of political emancipation and agency. Through a discussion of various “incitements to visibility” (p. 77) that Alevi communities have experienced in recent years, such as the increasing public presence and popularity of certain kinds of political rituals and the production of new Alevi histories, Tambar suggests that “vocality” has ambivalent effects. For instance, the chapters on Alevi ritual practices (Chapters 2, 4, and 6) document how the enhanced public visibility of Alevi ritual presence has consolidated normative understandings of Alevi identity that deny and erase many of its significant aspects, most notably the transnational character of Alevi histories and the dense historical and symbolic links that have linked Turkey's Alevis with places and communities beyond Turkey. The chapters on history writing and historical pedagogy make a related point (Chapters 3 and 5), showing how efforts to break the historical silence about Alevis yields community-authored “Anatolized” histories, where, much like republican nationalist narratives, Alevis are placed within the Anatolian heartland of Turkey, and their ineffable Turkishness and lack of ties to transnational Shi'ism is emphasized. In both cases, the effort to secure ritual and historical voice and visibility does not so much force as it strengthens the hand of official nationalism and republican unity.
While a nuanced ethnographic documentation of the ways in which Alevi communal practices reflect Turkey's “ambivalent pluralism” (p. 4) is the main task of the book, Tambar does not simply stop here. He goes on to provide an equally convincing account of its origins, contextualizing the contemporary ambivalences of pluralism in Turkey and the particular historicizing thrust of Alevi identity politics within a broader political history of state sovereignty, nationalist ideology, and, most interestingly, historical and sociological knowledge formations. If, as the book’s subtitle asserts, pluralist politics in Turkey is burdened by history, this is an historically contingent and path-dependent outcome, shaped by the particular intersections and articulations of institutions and ideology, power, and knowledge at several key conjunctures between the late Ottoman period and the present, twenty-first century moment. Developed most effectively and comprehensively in Chapter 3, the book's attention to historical depth and detail enhances its ethnographic description with a valuable explanatory lens. We learn not just about the how but the why of Alevi identity politics and Turkish pluralism.
The explanatory power of the book is diminished by a few puzzling omissions. First, the account of the politics of pluralism is surprisingly devoid of politics in the sense of either organized political actors and institutions, or conflict, violence, and agonism as such. Although there are stray mentions of political parties, civil society groups, and associational activity in the text, the actions and views of individual informants mostly drive the narrative forward, and the wider sociopolitical field in which the politics of Alevi assertion and pluralist negotiations are embedded receives sparse attention. Yet these are consequential to the case at hand. As Tambar notes in passing, left politics, diaspora groups, and the policy frameworks of the European Union have all variously shaped Alevi politics in important and lasting ways. The role of partisan political change, specifically the rise of the political Islamist AKP (Justice and Development Party), is also a key factor in explaining state policy change toward Alevis, but this too receives sparse attention.
A more sustained consideration of intra- and intergroup political contests and struggles over identity and difference is also in order. Do Alevi political parties engage Turkish pluralism differently than do the religious and cultural groups discussed in the book? What are the spatial dynamics of Alevi assertion: To what extent is Tambar's account distinctive to his ethnographic location of Çorum, a provincial town where the Alevi community is numerous, historically significant, and spatially segregated? Who are the others against which assertions of Alevi selfhood unfold—what are the relational dynamics of pluralism, for example, the relations between Alevis and Kurds? Addressing these questions would further enhance the many compelling insights of this book.
Third, the analytical potential of Tambar's pluralist “reckoning” could be more fully realized through an engagement with a wider, comparative canvas. This is not just a political scientist's plea for generalization. Instead, by aligning and contrasting the contingent ambivalences of Turkish pluralism with projects of multiculturalism and diversity in the United States, Canada, Australia, and India, among others, the explanatory importance of historical contingency and ethnographic context would more firmly be established.
In conclusion, further attention to the institutional-political and comparative context of Turkish pluralism would improve what is already a strong book. With its several compelling interventions in topical social science debates on pluralism and minority rights and on the politics of history writing, it is likely to appeal to a broad range of scholarly audiences beyond its “home turf” of Turkish studies and anthropology.
