In Stella Adler on America's Master Playwrights Barry Paris recognizes his great challenge right out of the gate, effectively illustrating the enormity of the task he's undertaken in his book's introduction (which he characterizes as an “apologia”). By his own reckoning, Paris delved through the Harry Ransom Center's collection “of hundreds of Adler's audio and videotape lectures, along with thousands of pages of selected transcriptions” (ix) in order to provide us with a condensed view of Adler's thinking concerning some of the twentieth century's most celebrated playwrights: Eugene O'Neill, Thornton Wilder, Clifford Odets, William Saroyan, Tennessee Williams, William Inge, Arthur Miller, and Edward Albee. Paris has structured his book in eight parts, each concerned with one of these writers; in each part, individual chapters focus on Adler's comments to her students regarding specific plays. The result is an exquisite volume that collects and arranges the thought, criticism, charm, and wit of one of America's most legendary theatre artists.
The greatest strength of this book comes from Stella Adler herself. Those familiar with her two previous conversational volumes (The Technique of Acting [Bantam, 1988], and Stella Adler on Ibsen, Strindberg, and Chekhov [ed. Barry Paris, Knopf, 1999]) will recognize the remarkable insight Adler injected into dramatic art, as well as the vitality, passion, and exuberance of her personality. In this latest collection, Adler's voice again shines through with vivid descriptions and penetrating criticism. The reader is all the more informed by Adler's personal reminiscences and the recognition that she communicates not only from her vast knowledge of theatre, but also from her experience of having personally known the playwrights of whom she speaks. Her frequent comparisons of the dramatists throughout the book—artistically as well as personally—are not only enlightening, but often amusing (for example, her perception of Wilder's wit versus Miller's somberness at a party), and sometimes a little scary (for example, her description of Saroyan appearing naked at her hotel door). In this regard, the seamlessness of Paris's editorship serves the book well, as the reader hears only Adler, unencumbered and uncensored. Her thoughts are clear, sharp, and brutally honest. There is never a time when the editing interferes with the flow or structure of the prose.
The choice of plays covered here represents another of the book's strengths, for which Paris should be commended. In his “Apologia and Acknowledgments,” he comments that he “sought a balance between … popular staples and . . . some obscure ones” (x). Thus, the part of the book concerned with Tennessee Williams contains an analysis of The Glass Menagerie as well as a full chapter on The Lady of Larkspur Lotion; the part on Saroyan avoids the obvious choice of The Time of Your Life in favor of the lesser known Hello Out There; and the part on Arthur Miller contains full chapters on both Death of a Salesman and After the Fall. Paris justifies these choices by pointing out that “theater, like music, gets dull when restricted to the Top 40” (x). Indeed, Adler's commentaries on the more obscure works are, in certain ways, some of the most illuminating and edifying sections of the book. By giving attention to lesser-known plays, Paris not only offers to broaden our knowledge of these firmly established dramatists, but also, perhaps, to generate interest in broadening the canon of American theatre.
There are, however, some aspects of the book that could have been edited differently, in order to have improved the collection's overall usefulness and engagement. First, Paris seldom identifies time. It would be interesting to know something of when Adler's comments were made so as to provide some context for them. Occasionally (when Adler comments on politics, for example), Paris provides a footnote indicating a specific reference, but he never offers a specific date. Perhaps the transcripts upon which he drew were not dated, but this is not made explicit in his text. To complicate matters, section breaks within chapters often appear without any accompanying indication that time has passed, or any other explanation of why a particular break exists. Paris explains in the “Apologia” that he and Adler intended the book to “appeal to general readers, not solely (or even mainly) to theater people and scholars” (x). But general readers may well have benefited from, and been interested in, more such (temporal) information. Second, the book lacks an index. Although Paris focuses in the text on Adler's thinking on the eight playwrights mentioned above, Adler's involvement in the theatre was lifelong, and her narratives often stray into stories concerning other well-known figures in American drama, such as Marlon Brando and her own father, Jacob. These passim anecdotes could present valuable nuggets of information for scholars, but finding the relevant material is challenging in the absence of an index.
Despite these minor flaws, Stella Adler on America's Master Playwrights is an invaluable contribution to American theatre practice and scholarship. Paris's efforts have created a somewhat rare hybrid offering that can serve theatre artists in a variety of aspects. Any director, designer, dramaturge, or scholar interested in the playwrights or plays the book covers will find Adler's incisive and penetrating analyses, as condensed by Paris, of tremendous worth. Any actor seeking to understand her craft better will find a treasure trove of wisdom from a master teacher. Moreover, anyone interested in the mind and method of Stella Adler herself will find yet another distillation of her vibrant criticism and sparkling presence.
