What course is not required of undergraduate economics majors at Harvard, Chicago, and Stanford? It is the history of economic thought. Why? Because the dust has settled on most major economic concepts. There is consensus. These concepts now have the status of “laws.” Economics programs have shifted from a battle over ideas to a more technical focus on econometrics and quantitative methods.
Marginal productivity theory tells us, for example, that in competitive factor and product markets workers receive compensation exactly equivalent to their contribution to output. Labor, in other words, is receiving a “just” wage.
What if, however, there is a surplus of labor that drives down the marginal product? If product prices don’t fall correspondingly with the drop in labor costs, then workers do not receive a “living wage.” What if, in reality, competitive markets never exist? What if a worker, when young, did not have access to quality public education and is thus permanently disadvantaged in the human capital-driven service economy? (See the data on expenditures per public school pupil by race in the South during the 1950s [Stapleford Reference Stapleford2008].)
These are substantive issues with real consequences for “folks,” and they absolutely merit consideration, discussion, argument. There are, in fact, few economic concepts that are able to dodge ethics. The log-log regression equation, for example, tells us that the price elasticity of oranges is 0.7. This ranges, however, from 0.3 in West Chester county to 2.5 in the Bronx. Why? Because of the current distribution of income. Is the current distribution of income fair? If not, what should be done about it? And whatever is done about it will change the overall price elasticity of demand for oranges.
Donald Frey, in a gem of a book, lays out the arguments made over more than three centuries in America regarding the appropriate balance between pursuit of self-interest and obligation to community. Does voluntary exchange among self-interested individuals sufficiently advance social welfare, or is some amount of coercive intervention necessary to maintain relational justice? If you believe this issue has been settled, then watch the commentary on Fox News and MSNBC regarding health care.
The areas of contention are provoking. Is scarcity a natural state and poverty inevitable, or have we, through technological advances, moved into an era of abundance where poverty results from greed and imperfect human institutions? Am I my brother’s keeper or, if my brother doesn’t work, shouldn’t he not eat? Does poverty result from poor moral choices or from discrimination, racism, and elitism? Should individuals leave each other alone or are we all in the boat together? Is life about learning to love our neighborhood or is it simply survival of the fittest? Is self-interest the reality of fallen man or is it a learned behavior reinforced and encouraged by the market system?
Who doesn’t get fired up by such questions? And if you do, Frey summarizes the points and counterpoints made by major influential thinkers from the founding of the country onward, including those seeking to mediate between the extremes. Among the persons whose writings are summarized are such familiar luminaries as John Locke, Cotton Mather, Benjamin Franklin, Adam Smith, Robert Malthus, William Paley, Francis Wayland, Thorstein Veblen, Richard Ely, John Maynard Keynes, Paul Samuelson, Friedrich Hayek, Milton Friedman, Frank Knight, George Stigler, Amatai Etzioni, Michael Novak, John Kenneth Galbraith, John Rawls, and Amartya Sen. Whew!
Frey’s summary of Adam Smith’s position on the tension between self-interest and community is alone worth the price of the book. According to Frey, Smith believed that the natural sympathy between individuals decreases as social distance increases. In a more complex society characterized by the division of labor and impersonal transactions, there is more social distance and human interactions will occur increasingly on the basis of self-interest rather than sympathy.
Frey also involves lesser known individuals and schools of thought. He recaps the views of the Calvinist Puritans (with reflections on Weber), the Quakers, the Moravians (the General Economy communities), the social gospel movement, and postmodern theology. Individuals discussed include Harriet Beecher Stowe, Herbert Spencer, William Sumner, Andrew Carnegie, Walter Rauschenbusch, Pope Leo XIII, John Ryan, Rexford Tugwell, Abraham Heschel, Philip Wogaman, and Father Divine (!). (Father Divine is a personal favorite since I grew up in Philadelphia and used to walk by his mansion on the way to school.)
If a reader is looking for resolution, none is provided. You will have to come to your own conclusions. Does “other interest” restore human dignity and relational morality to capitalist systems (Blank and McGurn Reference Blank and McGurn2004)? Or, does paternalism undermine self-worth and destroy voluntary commitments among individuals (Murray Reference Murray1984)? If one believes that this tension, this division, this dichotomy merits attention as it is basic to the pursuit of happiness within the context of economy, then Frey’s book is a rich buffet.
Finally, are there things one could take issue with in the book? Of course. Is it true that the writings of major thinkers at any point in time are an accurate reflection of the opinions that hold sway within a populace? Or are these writers simply arguing with each other in a battle of egos? Is the Pope an American? Were Americans really swayed by what Pope Leo XIII had to say about labor? Do Amartya Sen’s thoughts on poverty and freedom have merit because he won a Nobel Prize for research on droughts? (Do I really believe that Krugman and Stilitz are more than polemic?) But these are minor strokes in what is a major contribution to the history of economic thought.
