This book adds to the existing literature on material culture in the early modern and late periods of Ottoman history. That literature includes a collection of essays edited by Donald Quataert (2000) and a similar collection edited by Suraiya Faroqhi and Christoph K. Neumann (2003). Grehan's work focuses on one Ottoman province in a still relatively remote period that has gained scholarly attention over the last generation. Further, this book scours a vast array of sources that were previously used primarily for political and economic history; Grehan cuts those sources across the grain and gives readers a rounded picture of everyday life. His central claim is that material culture is critical because “ordinary things can simultaneously hold the most telling revelations and conceal the most elusive secrets” (p. 20).
The book falls into six chapters surrounded by an introduction and conclusion. Three appendices for specialist readers contain lists of everyday objects: furniture, kitchen utensils, and clothing. In the introduction, Grehan analyzes the range of his sources: the well-established literature produced by the cultural elite, namely, adab (belles-lettres), fatwas (judicial responsa), travel literature, urban topographies, biographical dictionaries, and chronicles. Grehan rightly says that this literature is characterized by an “absence of a personal voice”; even poetry exhibits “the same emotional distance” (p. 19). Making use of this material involves a laborious effort to find and then to sort leading examples of attitudes toward consumption and wealth and individuals' habits as they acquired and spent. More recently exploited sources, namely, the judicial records of the local courts, include probate inventories. Grehan claims that these inventories represent a skewed sample (because inventories were drawn up largely for those who died intestate or who had not made arrangements for distribution of their wealth before their deaths) and were characterized by formulaic phrases and evidence of hasty and sloppy preparation. Despite these limitations, it must be said that this category of source is all we have. Yes, many questions remain regarding the mechanics of probate inventories, but we must use these sources anyway. Grehan certainly does so with great skill, giving the reader a vivid sense of the things people owned or aspired to own.
Grehan then proceeds to describe the city of Damascus—its topographical, climatic, and ecological setting, which has historically set limits to both agriculture and human settlement. As other scholars have shown, and as Grehan emphasizes, the Ottoman period of Damascus history witnessed significant urban growth beyond the old city walls and the rise of new suburbs and neighborhoods that today are indistinguishable from the older quarters. For agriculture, Grehan stresses the relative paucity of rainfall and frequent threats to adequate harvests. Finally, means of transport (horses, mules, donkeys, camels) also set limits to the quantity of foodstuffs that could be shipped over great distances. Transport thus remained quite expensive: those who owned beasts of burden possessed prized assets. All these factors helped create a kind of local provincialism among the population: “Though not oblivious to the wider world, Damascenes were thoroughly preoccupied with their own corner of the empire” (p. 54).
Chapters 2 and 3 deal with basic foodstuffs, namely, bread and other varieties of food. He aptly quotes the late 17th- and early 18th-century polymath, ʿAbd al-Ghani al-Nabulsi: bread was “the pillar of religion, the support of the spirit, and the life-blood of the soul” (p. 59). Grehan tries to give hard figures for the gap between rich and poor. Based on what he could find in the probate inventories, he estimates how much people had to spend on food. He notes a sharp difference between Damascenes who belonged to what he calls the Ottoman class and ordinary folk. As a result, the “urban imagination populated the marketplace with sinister forces bent on manipulating stocks of grain at public expense and suffering” (p. 70). These popular ideas clashed with the middling and upper classes' ambition to pursue wealth. In the eyes of the latter, “material gain was an entirely legitimate pursuit, as long as it was not sought with excessive ardor or in violation of Islamic precepts” (p. 77).
Grehan then looks at the cause of Damascus's frequent food shortages in the 18th century. Previous scholarship blamed weak Ottoman rule, but Grehan argues that Ottoman rule was changing, becoming more decentralized. He also shows that at times of great stress, Damascus was able to supply grain to the island of Rhodes and Egypt; on another occasion, the governor of Tunis was able to supply grain to Damascus! Grehan speculates that the problem really lay with social unrest involving conflicts among local militias; the public would respond with frequent protests and demands to the authorities that they control the price of bread and discipline greedy merchants. He calls this pattern “a kind of economic paternalism” (p. 88). The rest of Chapter 3 is devoted to the varieties and prices of other foods: meat, vegetables, and fruit. Grehan concludes that Damascenes generally “enjoyed a diet which was probably a little more substantial than their obsession with bread would at first indicate” (p. 121).
The next chapter builds on its predecessors by extending the discussion to water, its use and regulation, and the introduction during the Ottoman period of two new consumption items: coffee and tobacco. In Arabic idiom, one “drank” a tobacco product, so its placement in this chapter is apt. Other beverages consumed mainly by the well-to-do included sugar water, citrus drinks, and sherbet. Alcoholic beverages were consumed mainly by the non-Muslim population and the Ottoman class, especially the local Janissaries. Coffee and tobacco, most of all, came to be in great demand; there were frequent debates concerning their morality, the social occasions of their consumption, and the guilty pleasures they produced.
Chapter 5 (“Domestic Space”) closely analyzes housing and home amenities (water supply, latrines, household furnishings, etc.). Grehan argues, as he does elsewhere, that for most Damascenes “the balance of resources and expenditures was heavily tilted in favor of food and drink, blunting most other consumerist impulses and, in particular, leaving townspeople with relatively little to lavish on their living spaces” (p. 157). In contrast, Chapter 6 (“Fashion and Deportment”) argues that “clothing was not merely a matter of personal taste and style; it placed a person within an all-encompassing social hierarchy that fashion helped to make visible and explicit” (p. 192).
Three general observations concerning this book may now be made. The first, relatively minor, is that when citing a number of multivolume works the author does not give volume numbers. The second, a bit more substantive, is that the illustrations provided in this book all date from the 19th century; readers may ask whether the illustrations might also suggest what conditions were like in the 18th century (probably the same, given what is known). The third observation is that the book's conclusion is far too short and does not develop some of the author's more arresting points, in particular his argument that Damascenes felt a certain anxiety about change in their material objects and habits (such as the triumph of coffee and tobacco as consumer items). This reader also wishes that the author had developed the idea that “the Ottoman period [was] the final stage in a long and irregular series of premodern innovations that followed the formation and growth of new commercial networks” worldwide (p. 228). Likewise needing elaboration are the author's penultimate words concerning “the ineradicable poverty and insecurity of the premodern economy”: “Though some authors might insist on religion as the defining feature of Middle Eastern culture, this is a highly idealized (and ideological) understanding of the past, which lays the emphasis on all the wrong places. It strips everyday experience of its gritty urgency and immersion in the demands and pressures of the moment” (p. 234). This last statement makes a very important point about the contingency of everyday life, a welcome corrective to the emphasis “on all the wrong places.” Grehan's book is always interesting, even fascinating in places, and should serve as a gateway to further inquiry.
