Although the United States has elected an African American president, since that election there have been numerous indicators that racism remains a persistent, and complex, issue in America. Shortly after President Obama took office, for example, renowned Harvard University professor Henry “Skip” Gates was arrested for being uncooperative with the responding officer when police mistook him for a burglar at his own home. This incident served as a small reminder of the resilient nature of racism in the United States. More importantly, there has been an increase in the number of hate groups since 2008, and the proposed plans for an Islamic cultural center near the site of the former World Trade Center have initiated a wave of anti-Islamic sentiment.Footnote 1 Despite the hope that Barack Obama would usher in a new era in race relations, it seems as though his election has brought to the surface tensions that some people assumed had disappeared. Among scholars of black politics, race serves as the central construct. In some cases, race serves as a lens through which other variables such as class and gender are filtered. In other cases, race serves as the key independent variable explaining a number of factors that influence the lives of blacks. Each of the texts reviewed in this essay examines issues of race to varying degrees, and each one reveals the complex nature and long-lasting impact of race on American society.
Perhaps no figure occupies a more central place in African American studies than W. E. B. Du Bois. Du Bois is one of the greatest American intellectuals of the twentieth century, and among those who do African American studies, his role as a thinker and activist is essential to understanding this discursive realm. Examining Du Bois has become a rite of passage among African American intellectuals. The list of distinguished scholars who have dedicated book-length works to Du Bois's various insights include Rayford Logan, Manning Marable, Adolph Reed, and David Levering Lewis;Footnote 2 the list of scholars who have composed shorter essays is too long even to cite. University of Chicago professor Robert Gooding-Williams seeks to enter the Du Boisian discourse by offering his own interpretation of the gigantic figure in his text: In the Shadow of Du Bois. Gooding-Williams locates Du Bois within the tradition of “Afro-modern” political thought. He argues that modern political philosophy is comprised of several genres, each genre composed of paradigmatic figures. Afro-modern philosophy represents a genre of political theory, and Du Bois is a critical figure in its development. Several Africana theorists have argued that the range of issues that confront black thinkers significantly differ from the concerns in other genres.Footnote 3 “Like the classical social contract tradition,” Gooding-Williams posits, “the Afro-modern tradition is bound together by certain genre-defining thematic preoccupations—for example, the political and social organization of white supremacy, the nature and effects of racial ideology, and the possibilities of black emancipation—preoccupations that distinguish it from other traditions and genres of political philosophy” (3). Unlike many treatments of Du Bois, the author seeks to examine the basic assumptions that constitute his views on leadership and the masses.
Gooding-Williams seeks “to reconstruct [The Souls of Black Folk's] response to Jim Crow, or, more exactly, to reconstruct its exploration of how to create and conduct a politics for African Americans that counters white supremacy in the instance of Jim Crow” (4). In particular, the author investigates three Du Boisian positions:
1. That African American politics is a practice of group leadership—and thus a practice of group rule or governance, for Du Bois interprets leadership as a form of rule or governance.
2. That African American politics should take the form of political expressionism, such that it expresses the spiritual identity of the black folk.
3. That African American struggles to counter white supremacy are best understood as struggles against social exclusion.
The author provides a critical exposition of the key assumptions that form the basis of Du Bois's views on “the Negro Problem,” and highlights the shortcomings of those assumptions, particularly the notion that black politics should be an elite-based process. Although Du Bois himself moved away from elite-driven models, the author contends that the preeminent status of Souls and the politics of uplift were frequently embraced by black elites as an ideal model. To challenge this perspective, the author engages in a genealogical investigation of the critical premises in Du Bois's thought with a juxtaposition of Frederick Douglass, who argued for a collective-practice conceptualization of black politics.
The politics of expressionism, according to the author, is a key dynamic in Du Bois's framework. He notes that “Du Bois's politics of expressive self-realization was a form of political expressivism in the romantic tradition—and, moreover, that Du Bois held that it was desirable that anti–white supremacist African American politics take the form of political expressivism” (13–14). Gooding-Williams traces this concept to Du Bois's tripartite classification of leadership (an area the author suggests is frequently overlooked): “leadership that aims at revolt, leadership that aims at adjustment … and leadership that aims at self-realization” (25). Du Bois, according to Gooding-Williams, seeks to defend this third form: self-realization. To accomplish this task, Du Bois constructs a historical narrative that locates leaders like Frederick Douglass and Alexander Crummell, and ultimately himself, within a tradition of political expressivism. It is a political tradition that merges political thought with legitimate action. Beyond the conceptual architecture of Du Bois's constructs, these assumptions regarding African American history lead him to answer political and social questions in a particular manner that neglects collective-action methods.
One of the central problems that Souls seeks to address is a problem of leadership, which is fundamentally related with the problem of governance. “Du Bois's normative political philosophical task … was to develop an account of the good governance of African Americans' struggle to cope with white supremacy” (28). Although on the surface this would seem to be a noble endeavor, the author notes that Du Bois is limited by a traditional view of politics that emphasizes governance as a process of ruling. Gooding-Williams contrasts this perspective with the theories of Wolin and Arendt who argue that “politics as governance goes hand in hand with antidemocratic and finally elitist … answers to the question ‘who—or what constitution—should rule?’” (31). This perspective, the author notes, has a profound impact on Du Bois's formulations, in particular the idea of a “talented tenth.” Even after Du Bois distanced himself from the idea in his later years, similar notions of leadership (a top-down view) still permeated his thoughts. Du Bois's view of black politics is seriously limited from Gooding-Williams's perspective. He avers:
Rather the difficulty I mean to stress lies in its [Du Bois's definition of black politics] overly narrow definition of black political agency: that is, in its limited characterization of what is to count as black politics. … Black politics is either a matter of ruling—the agency of black leaders—or obeying, that is, the agency of the black masses. But what of black struggles against white supremacy, which are neither? Du Bois's notion of black politics is too narrow, for it includes no conceptual space for grasping these forms of struggle as political. (36)
From the author's perspective, Du Bois ignores everyday forms of resistance on the part of the subaltern. However, the theories that Gooding-Williams draws from all postdate Du Bois. Even though the author identifies Douglass as a prototype for this form of political activity, the theoretical paradigms that explain this behavior came long after Du Bois. The author goes to great pains to deconstruct the genealogical roots of Du Bois's views in connection with other nineteenth-century thinkers, but those the author cites also adopted elite-driven models of politics. The ethnologically inspired “weapons of the weak” models that some theorists have embraced must be viewed for what they are: a micro-form of political activity. However, there is sometimes a tendency to associate these lower levels of protest with macro–political activity, such as revolts and revolutions.Footnote 4 Furthermore, I believe the author is conflating two dramatically different political contexts. Even though one may classify and identify various forms of resistance as political acts, in any political discussion it is important to distinguish the respective levels of analysis. The hidden-transcripts concept was partially a response to the traditional interpretation of politics, focusing on easily viewable political behavior: elections, parties, wars, revolutions, and so forth. Scholars such as James Scott sought to track the simple forms of resistance that oppressed groups engage in, and while these activities in themselves can form a foundation for more significant political activity, they themselves are still micro-forms.Footnote 5 Douglass acting in concert with other slaves to gain freedom must be distinguished from Douglass the leader.
One of the unique aspects of Gooding-Williams's text is the contrasting of Du Bois's notion of leadership (elite driven) with the collectivist model of Douglass. The author interprets Douglass's views on political activity as more democratic than the ones offered by Du Bois. Focusing mainly on Douglass's work Bondage, the author constructs a narrative of collective political activity. The bulk of this interpretation draws from Douglass's experiences on the slave plantation, which in Gooding-Williams's view constitute an archetype of group politics in action among slaves. The author notes that “Douglass portrays plantation politics as an enterprise of equals driven by a shared and discursively expressed concern to free the world of ‘tyrants and oppressors.’ … The plantation politics that Douglass and his co-conspirators practice is the politics of the few … who pledge themselves to one another, not a politics geared to ruling the many” (187). Additionally, this model exhibits a political bound not found in essential notions of identity or genealogy. This not only represents a more democratic form of politics but also demonstrates that “there can exist multiple and heterogeneous forms of race-conscious African American political solidarity characterized by diverse purposes and diverse understandings of the significance of that condition” (191). While this is a novel interpretation of Douglass's view, one could argue that it is difficult to place a great deal of emphasis on the collective activity of slaves owing to the nonvoluntary context from which they emerged. Regardless of what one may think about humans in general, there are numerous examples of people acting in concert under difficult circumstances. What the author characterizes as collective politics can just as easily be seen in several superordinate and subordinate contexts ranging from colonial to prison environments. Just because prisoners may collaborate during an escape attempt does not mean they have developed an ideal form of demos-based politics. Moreover, Douglass's split with Garrison can easily be viewed as common intra-organizational conflict. One can view a person leaving an organization as an example of rejecting nondemocratic practices or as an example of individual motives (for example, “I” want to run the show).
A final component of the author's work seeks to locate these Douglassian and Du Boisian insights within the contemporary discourse of African American politics. Gooding-Williams says that “postmodern African American political thought must come to grips with the differentiation of African American experience. In Souls, Du Bois advances the expressionist thesis that to be legitimate and effective black politics must embody a collectively shared and racially specific spirit (an ethos) that antecedently unites black Americans.” However, “the persistent and accelerating differentiation of African American experience has undermined the belief that any such spirit, or culture, exists” (218). Within this environment of differentiation, one must remember that something is out there that constitutes a loose bond of sorts. Whether or not this loose bond represents the type of force needed for blacks to engage in collective political activity comparable to the levels of activism prior to desegregation is an issue that many scholars have debated. Gooding-Williams suggests a type of unity without foundation as a possible solution. Following his interpretation of Douglass the author advances a “no-foundation” perspective of black politics, which “persistently but groundlessly renews itself through conflict and contestation among alternative accounts of substantively ambiguous black interest” (238). Despite this multidimensionality, it is still possible that “political participants can forge political unity through collective action, debate, and deliberation ” (238). This draws from the author's reading of Douglass's plantation experiences, which demonstrated collective political activity in the spirit of nonfoundationalism.
One of the biggest challenges that African Americans face in the postsegregation context is a freedom of choice that did not exist prior to the mid-1960s. If basic survival necessitated some form of coordinated efforts, the gradual elimination of those subordinating conditions in the following decades resulted in a situation where that which was once a necessity becomes a matter of choice. Despite the careful reconstruction of Douglass, it is questionable whether the author's model can withstand contemporary criticism. Douglass's forming a newspaper (representing a counterpublic) is not an example of a more egalitarian form of political activity. Political formations, if they seek longevity, require some type of organizational apparatus, one which coordinates the groups' directives strategically or logistically. Gooding-Williams's contention that Douglass's actions as a slave and as a newspaper editor represent an egalitarian, nonfoundational form of politics is questionable, to say the least. First, the collective action of slaves is a partial byproduct of the forced environment that they inhabited. Although the bond among slaves may not have been ethnically based, the foundation of their association was racially based. There was no need to articulate racial essentials because they were bound by their environment. Secondly, the idea that Douglass's actions as a free man represent a nonfoundational collectivist form of politics may be true, but the significance of these actions is debatable. The author is attempting to superimpose this model as a prescription for contemporary politics where the “differentiation” of African American interests makes the prospects of essential or foundational alliances very difficult. There is a tendency among theorists to conceptualize ideal political forms in a Rawlsian manner, but the problem is that these interpretations often ignore the realities of politics. Raymond Geuss, for example, makes the following observation: “The very idea of total, perfect, and complete egalitarianism can't be a social ideal of any significance because it is literally incoherent. A society is a group of distinct persons, and if it is to survive for any amount of time, it must reproduce itself, so that some of its members will not be equal to other members by virtue of being younger. The only way to attain complete equality would be to eliminate the distinctness between persons, and then there would no longer be a society.”Footnote 6 Political organizations are not built around ideal forms, and the current preoccupation with developing nonfoundational political models is a misguided endeavor that seems to be a byproduct of postmodern critiques of essentialism.
The debates that continue today regarding the current status of blacks, and potential ideologies that could improve their situation, are closely tied to historically institutionalized practice that discriminated against blacks. Despite the legal and constitutional victories of the Civil Rights movement, opponents of these policies continued to resist them long after the 1960s. In the area of education, researchers note that schools are more segregated today than they were during the sixties.Footnote 7 To understand how this process developed, Anders Walker's The Ghost of Jim Crow: How Southern Moderates Used Brown v. Board of Education to Stall Civil Rights provides a fascinating study of the civil rights movement. In some ways, Walker provides a chapter in the ongoing study of racism, as the work unearths the legal language that would be seized upon by many politicians (Republicans and southern Democrats) in their efforts to maintain legally the institutional mechanism of white supremacy. Employing archive materials from three states (Mississippi, Florida, and North Carolina) and legal documents, Walker explores the role of three moderate southern governors who played key roles in resisting the dismantling of Jim Crow. Unlike many authors who focus on extremists, Walker highlights the gradual, and legally pragmatic, manner in which these politicians employed color-blind methods to counter the push of civil rights activists. The respective governors—LeRoy Collins, Luther Hodges, and J. P. Coleman—employed “strategic constitutionalism” to resist the dictates of Brown. According to the author, “the real struggle for civil rights in the 1950s and 1960s” did not take place between “black activists and white extremists, but between black activists and white moderates” (7). Walker notes that these men were able to preserve many elements of segregation through a process of transformation. “By transforming the legal criteria for segregating students from overt racial classifications to facially neutral, standards-based criteria … Collins, Coleman, and Hodges all sought to lay the foundation for a new legal idiom through which racial inequality could be maintained in the post-Brown era” (7). The methods that these men devised had a longer-lasting impact than the dramatic episodes carried out by extremists during the 1950s and 1960s. Moreover, one could argue that they laid the foundation for what some contemporary scholars characterize as color-blind racism.
The author examines the policies of the governors and their efforts to thwart the ruling of Brown through a number of legally based ploys. Common tactics by the governors included centralizing state power, switching the burden of proof from whites to blacks via sociocultural constructs such as illegitimate children and cultural gaps. Interestingly enough, one of the most notorious states in civil rights lore—Mississippi—served as one of the first laboratories of the rhetorical and institutional adaptation on segregation in the South. J. P. Coleman, in Walker's view, “saw the South as guiding constitutional jurisprudence in favor of a new era of segregation” (15). The goal was to bring the South in line with the thinking of the rest of the country by “eliminat[ing] overt racial classifications from its state codes, and rearticulat[ing] its position on segregation in dispassionate terms that most Americans could understand” (15). The strategy entailed controlling the activities of extremist groups and civil rights groups such as the NAACP while also centralizing state power as a surveillance tactic. One of the most notable tactics developed by Coleman was shifting focus on the moral background of African Americans. “It hinged on a legalist measure called pupil placement, a mechanism for assigning students to schools based not on their color but on vague criteria like ‘morals, community welfare, and health’” (39). One example of this is when Coleman, along with the legislature, invalidated the state's common-law marriage statute. Because of the large number of blacks born out of wedlock, state officials were able to classify these children as illegitimate and “having unfavorable background,” therefore making them unfit for integration into white schools (41).
Drawing on the insights of Coleman, Luther Hodges in North Carolina followed a similar path in attempting to thwart Brown. The author notes that “Hodges worked hard to reframe segregation as a legal arrangement that helped African Americans by protecting them from white interference and preserving racial peace” (50). Moreover, he sought to placate white fears of integration by developing “safety valves that allowed white voters to close school systems if they did not trust the manner in which he proposed to handle them” (50). One of the tools Hodges employed to combat Brown was the Pearsall Committee, which was charged with drafting the state's legal response. Hodges also targeted black cultural practices by focusing on illegitimacy rates. Walker contends that “the rhetoric of controlling illegitimacy coincided closely with the rhetoric of preserving segregation and maintaining white culture. At a very basic level, such rhetoric drew attention away from black demands for increased resources … and the enforcement of constitutional rights and refocused it on black moral shortcomings” (79). Some state officials, for example, even discussed the possibility of mass sterilization to combat black illegitimacy.
LeRoy Collins would draw from the same playbook as his gubernatorial colleagues, resisting segregation by “centralizing the state's police power, coordinating law enforcement agencies, and tracking potential agitators, both black and white” (88). In Florida, it was the Fabinski Committee that developed the state strategy for combating desegregation. The committee recommended pupil placement based on sociological and psychological factors, and an expansion of the governor's law enforcement powers; specifically, through the increase in the number of state troopers and the creation of a Sheriffs Bureau which served as a monitoring agency to oversee local sheriffs. Collins also targeted housing as negatively affecting blacks' moral status, making them unfit for segregation. The author quotes Collins as saying, “the Negro's most pressing needs are better health, education, moral and housing standards” (109). This tactic allowed the governor to both shift the onus on moral standards as well as slum clearance and gentrification techniques.
In addition to the strategies used by Collins, Coleman, and Hodges during their time as governor, Walker also examines how these men remained influential on the national stage as counselors to presidents and as federal judges. Collins was later appointed director of a federal agency by President Johnson and charged with negotiating between “civil rights leaders and whites, effectively limiting the power of direct action to create the type of dramatic confrontations that ultimately won national support for the movement” (120). When heated conflicts arose between groups, such as the march in Selma, Collins was the chief negotiator seeking to defuse the situation. In the legal arena J. P. Coleman was appointed to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in 1965, which allowed him to take a “restrictive reading of school cases, employment discrimination claims, and voting rights cases, repeatedly using the principle that the Constitution is color-blind to deny black civil rights claims” (121). This “color-blind” interpretation ignored the historical context of Jim Crow, and ultimately became a highly influential doctrine used by conservatives for decades to come.Footnote 8
With the decline of the civil rights movement in the 1970s, southern moderates would wield more sway as the country seemed less inclined to aggressively support civil rights without the presence of extremists. “No matter how much federal officials like Presidents Kennedy and Johnson may have personally supported the black struggle, larger structural forces—many related to electoral politics—pushed them to reject direct-action protest, embrace southern moderates, and ultimately employ strategic constitutionalism themselves to limit black claims” (122). The author suggests the foundation of modern segregation may be found in the activities of these men. “Federal courts began developing perfectly constitutional color-blind arguments to counter black voting rights claims, black employment discrimination claims, and even black protest against the resegregation of public schools through white migration to racially homogeneous school districts” (157). The steps that were developed by these men laid the foundation for what many scholars label color-blind racism. According to Bonilla-Silva, there are four central frames of color-blind racism: abstract liberalism, naturalization, cultural racism, and minimization of racism. The prescriptions of the governors examined by Walker mirror Bonilla-Silva's naturalization and cultural frames. Naturalization explains racist activity as a byproduct of natural occurrences. For example “whites claim ‘segregation’ is natural because all backgrounds gravitate toward likeness.”Footnote 9 Cultural racism, moreover, argues that certain groups have cultural traits that have an adverse effect on their performance. For example, one may suggest that blacks have too many babies out of wedlock, which affects the family household and therefore leads to deviant behavior. Walker demonstrates that both Luther Hodges and LeRoy Collins developed naturalized and cultural premises to challenge desegregation.
The missing part of Walker's narrative is the Black Power movement, which took the energy of the civil rights movement to the rest of the country and engaged in more provocative forms of protest. Agency on the part of black organizations shifted the focus in a number of areas. A number of conventional, or less controversial, organizations turned their attention to attempting to influence the development of ameliorative socioeconomic policies by the government, while other leaders sought to run for political office. A large number of younger blacks began affiliating themselves with the Black Power movement, which minimized public policy in the early years of its activism in favor of provocative, and sometimes grandiose, prescriptions for blacks. These factors do not diminish Walker's claims, but they do represent an important part of the post–civil rights narrative.
The way in which race affects the public discourse and informs historical narratives is a central subject of inquiry in the works of Amy Bass and Susan Reverby. In Those About Him Remained Silent: The Battle over W. E. B. Du Bois, Amy Bass highlights the struggle to establish a memorial site in Du Bois's birthplace of Great Barrington, Massachusetts. Beyond the biographical nature of the project, the author's text surveys the process of symbol formation, particularly how we memorialize people and the political and social forces that go into the process. Bass investigates how the Cold War context interacted with race in the battle over how Du Bois would be memorialized in his home town. Bass asserts that “the controversy over Du Bois's legacy demonstrates an underlying rage regarding race relations and ideas of communism held within a community” (xix). In the case of Du Bois, his legacy was deeply tarnished by his affiliations with the Communist Party later in his career. By becoming an official member of the Communist Party in 1961 while maintaining a commitment to anticapitalism and anticolonialism in his writings, Du Bois was not remembered for his contributions to civil rights in his home town (43). Bass suggests that this characteristically liberal New England town used anticommunist Cold War rhetoric to mask deeper racial tensions.
As noted earlier, Du Bois is widely regarded as one of the greatest American intellectuals and activists of the twentieth century, and the idea that his home town would fight against a memorial to him seems unreasonable today. However, when organizers for a Du Bois memorial site began publicizing their intentions in the late sixties the “Great Barrington chapter of the Veterans of Foreign Wars … strongly opposed a memorial” to him (62). Several other local organizations opposed the plan, and the local newspaper called it “traitorous.” This battle would continue for the next few years, and even though Du Bois's birthplace became a national landmark in 1979, the area still struggles with the legacy of one of its most famous native sons. In 2004, a proposal was made that one of the local schools be named after Du Bois. This was followed by heated debate that mirrored “the movement to honor Du Bois some thirty-five years earlier. Yet again, Du Bois exemplified how history is generated and recreated at the most local and personal levels, by people passionately determined for their voices—and thus their ways of remembering—to be heard” (144). This type of episode has occurred with other historic African American figures, as well as with antebellum and Confederacy figures. The manner in which Martin Luther King Jr. has been memorialized and remembered is one example of this process. There was a battle between public-interest groups and politicians in establishing a national holiday for Dr. King in the mid-1980s. Today Martin Luther King Jr. is an iconic American in the public discourse, but the image of King as presented in popular society is a one-dimensional and noncritical King, devoid of criticisms of the United States in Vietnam and of capitalism. The author demonstrates how the characterization of Du Bois as a Communist would affect the views of much of the town's populace for decades after his death. Although examining Du Bois's views was not the author's goal, I think her work could have been greatly enriched if she had gone into more detail about possible connections between Great Barrington and Du Bois's intellectual formation. Bass mentions concepts in passing, but largely leaves theorizing about the matter to secondary sources. Whereas Bass focuses on how one person is remembered in a local context, Reverby highlights how normative judgments are temporally dependent. Both authors interrogate the effect of context on public discourse, particularly how the politics of the time affects public judgment.
In Examining Tuskegee: The Infamous Syphilis Study and Its Legacy, Susan Reverby provides an exhaustive examination of that notorious study, in which government health officials were accused (according to contemporary accounts) of infecting hundreds of black men with syphilis. Reverby seeks to provide a “rereading and reanalysis” of “what happened and why” the Tuskegee study has such power. It is about why the study happened, how it might have been stopped, and why the stories go on and on (5). Methodologically, drawing on personal interviews and government documents the author attempts to analyze the testimony of key actors in the process. More than a method of oral history, Reverby looks to capture “what testimony tells us about what happened and how testifying captures what might be different communal explanations for the truths” (7). The work examines how the various actors in the process perceived their role and whether they were culpable in the process. Although the popular narrative of the project suggests that physicians gave the men syphilis, Reverby contends that there are no public records of medical personnel exposing the men to syphilis. Instead, the critical part of the narrative has to do with consent and with medical ethics.
The study began in 1930 as an outgrowth of a partnership between Tuskegee Institute and the US Public Health Service (PHS). It began in Macon County, Alabama, as one of the “Rosenwald Fund Demonstration Projects,” and the goal was to study the effects of the disease. The Fund and PHS doctors sought to prove “to health departments and state and federal legislatures that syphilis was prevalent but that it was possible to control its spread” (33). After the initial testing of men, the decision was made to continue the project and monitor the subjects' progress. The questionable issue that emerges is that of consent: specifically, the men who were seen by the PHS officials were never told they had syphilis, only bad blood. Furthermore, the men were under the assumption that they were getting treatment, not that they were subjects in a research project. Deception, according to the author, was clearly part of the process. Reverby notes:
The deception devised next was stunning and reflected the PHS's belief that it could not explain what it was doing to the men. In order to get the men to come in, Dr. Murray Smith … devised a letter. Reminding the men that they had already had a “thorough examination” with the “hope you have gotten a great deal of treatment for your bad blood,” they promised, “You now will be given your last chance to get a second examination. This examination is a very special one and after it is finished you will be given a special treatment if it is believed you are in condition to stand it.” (45)
The special treatment the PHS was referring to was spinal taps, which were notoriously painful and dangerous during this period. Historical records show that the PHS was actively deceiving the men by giving them aspirin tablets, while very few subjects received arsphenamine—one of the actual treatments at the time. From the perspective of the PHS, the study was never intended to be a treatment project, but rather a scientific study to collect data on the effects of syphilis. When penicillin emerged in the 1940s there were indications that it could successfully be used to treat the disease, but within the PHS doctors debated the “usefulness of penicillin in patients who had developed both cardiovascular and neurological complications” until the 1950s (65). The undertone that begins to emerge in these discussions is a distinction between subject and human, as many doctors affiliated with the project emphasized the need for more research rather than the needs of the men.
By the 1950s problems with the study continued to surface, as more physicians questioned its ethical basis. The author notes that “the PHS was not hiding the study, and medical journals published the articles and reports. Unless a physician picking up the articles thought deeply, it would have been easy to see the men as volunteers” (70). Even though doctors who found out the details of the study raised ethical questions, “powerful men in a government bureaucracy, medical uncertainties, and racial beliefs kept the Study going” (72). The sixties brought a new context to the study, and more officials wrestled with how to proceed with the project. One whistle-blower during this period was Peter Buxtun, an investigator working for PHS. Recalling a discussion between Buxton and William Brown, chief of the Venereal Disease Division in the CDC, Reverby notes:
Concerned about how it [the study] would play out politically, he reminded Brown: “The group is 100% negro. This in itself is political dynamite and subject to wild journalistic misinterpretation.” … Buxtun, no wild eyed radical in the years of wild-eyed radicalism, was pointing out what should have been obvious by then: if there was more public knowledge, the Study's purpose and procedures would be read as racist and deceptive, and possibly illegal and … murderous. (79)
In 1972 the Associated Press gained details of the study, and released a story on the wire with the heading: “Syphilis Victims in US Study Went Untreated for 40 Years” (85). When the general press began following the story, the author notes, its narrative highlighted all of the negative aspects of the project. In the post–civil rights, Black Power, antiwar period, the “idea that an arm of the state could have infected black men with a deadly disease was more than plausible. The idea that the PHS had intentionally infected the men became linked to the story” (90). From there it became a question of how this revelation would play out in the public discourse. Bowing to pressure from such groups as the NAACP and the Congressional Black Caucus, the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare called for an ad hoc panel to investigate the matter; this panel was shortly followed by congressional hearings called for by Senator Ted Kennedy. As an example of the different narratives on medicine, race, and power, the author contrasts the testimonies of two physicians who were part of the project. Joshua Williams, a black intern at the time, “allied himself with the subjects, and his testimony suggested the pained sense of a professional who felt he should have known more and spoken up. Emphasizing the racial segregation at the time, Williams made it clear that he had felt powerless” (95). This view is contrasted with the testimony of Dr. Arnold Schroeter, who oversaw the study in 1969. Schroeter's responses focused on scientific motives; he noted that “their goal was not to withhold treatment, but to observe what would happen; and at no time was treatment denied any of those patients if they sought it” (95). Neither doctor's response is factually inaccurate, but they provide an example of two different narratives and how the story is told. Ultimately, the final report of the ad hoc panel “declared the Study ethically unjustified” (99).
A final part of the author's work is to examine the role of key black participants in the study: Nurse Rivers and Dr. Eugene Dibble. Dr. Dibble is painted as a complex man by the author, a gifted and hard-working “race man” deeply committed to his patients and Tuskegee Institute. The question thus emerges: Why would he participate in such a project? According to the author he was subject to two shortcomings that influenced his decision. One, he was actively seeking funding for Tuskegee's hospital and the PHS offered a great opportunity for improving the facilities. “In circumstances in which every penny counted, the need for medical care was overwhelming, and the economic crisis and racism was limiting everything, Dibble agreed to research in order to gain resources for his underserved population” (158). Later in the study's existence Dibble still supported the program, but seemed ambivalent about its ethical undertone (there are reports that he may have given some men penicillin). The second explanation of Dibble's actions invokes the greater good of science. Although these subjects may have suffered, the importance of gaining medical data and more resources for these rural medical facilities overrode the ethical concerns at that time (164–66).
The factor of Nurse Rivers, the black woman who largely facilitated the hands-on part of the study, is another interesting part of Reverby's study. Rivers is often viewed as “either a middle-class race traitor or a powerless nurse” (168). In the author's view the narrative is more complex, as an underlying theme is the interaction between self-interest and powerless actor. She notes:
If we accept that she cared deeply about the men in the community, we are then reminded that caring can be blinding to complexity and context. Her sense that her beneficence mattered may have allowed her to ignore everything else. … Her testifying voice, the one that speaks of the difficulties in the community and of hard choices, becomes the one that seems to be her most honest one. The moral triage she performed is central to her nursing.
If she did help some of the men get to treatment, her innocence and powerlessness are undermined. We would have to accept her complexities and even her sources of power. We have to allow for the possibilities that her views changed over time and that she picked some men to save but not others. (182–83)
The author contends that Rivers represents a much more complex figure than the characterization of a simple good/bad person. However, these types of conceptualizations are not new within the history of the pan-African Diaspora. There have always been intermediaries who interacted with whites and served the dual role of manager (for whites) and provider (for blacks). In these instances, normative judgments vary on the status of these people. For example, Clarence Thomas is widely viewed as a negative figure within the black community, classified as an “Uncle Tom” by some. However, other contemporary black Republicans such as Condoleezza Rice and Colin Powell are viewed more favorably, even though they were involved in imperial foreign policy decisions during the second Bush presidency.Footnote 10 Although Dr. Dibble and Nurse Rivers witnessed their communal standing shift when the project became public knowledge, the historical narrative of Tuskegee remains focused on the atrocities initiated by the US government, specifically the PHS.
On the whole, the author provides an exhaustive examination of the syphilis study, but some of her arguments rely too heavily on the racial context of the period without considering the aggregate legacy of racism in the United States. For example, the initial argument by PHS doctors that science dictated that the men be deceived and denied treatment inherently involved a racial dynamic that Reverby overlooks. One of the main attributes of historical antiblack racism in the United States is the notion of inferiority. Dating from constitutional arguments and late nineteenth-century scientific studies is the position that people of African descent are biologically inferior to whites. Whether one talks about the psychological behavior of people engaged in genocide or the socialization process that soldiers are exposed to, a central element among people who engage in atrocities or mass killings is the dehumanizing of the “other.” Humans have demonstrated a capacity to engage in a plethora of morally reprehensible acts when constructing people as the other. In relation to the syphilis study, although the doctors appealed to the greater good of science, the willingness to engage in such behavior was aided by a racist sentiment that viewed blacks as inferior to whites. Moreover, Reverby suggests that the inaccurate part (the belief that government officials exposed the men to syphilis) of the Tuskegee narrative is an outgrowth of the heightened racial context of the sixties and early seventies. Historical African American distrust of the government may be traced to the earliest encounters between slaves and whites. Gamble notes that “black American fears about the medical profession date back to the antebellum period and the use of slaves and free Black people as subjects for dissection and medical experiments.”Footnote 11 There were even reports of grave robbers who would dig up black bodies for medical schools. In this context, Tuskegee should be viewed not as an anomaly or a byproduct of the period but as a confirmation of longstanding concerns. The author asks the question why the Tuskegee study continues to grow and be part of popular culture, but part of this has to do with a preexistent history of blacks experiencing various forms of discrimination. The study cannot be abstracted or atomized away from the legacy of racism in the United States. Although the Constitution has been expunged of any explicit racial discrimination, and overt acts of racism have significantly declined, the collective memories and wounds of the past continue to influence African American perceptions.
The legacy and unresolved nature of racism in the United States can be viewed in the periodic episodes where race is thrust into the public/media dialogue as a byproduct of an event or policy. This is an area that Michael Awkward seeks to examine in his text Burying Don Imus: Anatomy of a Scapegoat. In 2007, radio talk-show host Don Imus performed a skit that referred to the Rutgers University women's basketball team as “nappy-headed hos.” The comment sparked widespread outrage from pundits, activists, and intellectuals, and Awkward seeks to investigate this event. The author “explores why so many blacks … felt that Imus's symbolic burial was utterly necessary” (xv). Awkward contends that the episode, and many events like it, reflect the deep animus that blacks suppress, which is a result of “the still-unresolved trauma from which black Americans continue to suffer because … our nation still has barely addressed, yet alone begun to atone for, its racially motivated sins” (xv).
His text examines the racial tensions that lie beneath the surface in the United States only to be exposed in public incidents; when these public episodes occur they allow for brief releases of tension. Because the country has failed to engage in a dialogue of atonement, or a reparations process, African Americans never reach a psychological state of closure. Awkward asserts that “we [blacks] hope for a long-deferred hour of atonement when the legitimacy of our collective pain will finally be acknowledged and attended to. But, prior to that unforeseeable event, we seek … the satisfaction that comes from being able to identify ‘who hate me’ and ‘what evil look like’” (6). Controversies such as the Imus incident partially fulfill this function. The goal is to place the Imus incident in a broader context where the rationale of such incidents can be seen for what it is. He notes:
I evaluate the skit in terms of both informed discussions of the art of comedy, which consider the capacity of jokes and other forms of humor to offer potentially valuable contributions to the nation's cultural dialogue about contentious issues such as race and gender, and controversies that garnered national attention at whose core is the assumption that whites fundamentally “don't like” blacks. (18)
Awkward asserts that when one considers what comedy represents as an art form combined with the context in which Imus and his contributors operate, his comments cannot be viewed as racist behavior. In essence, these episodes represent a sideshow of sorts, a short moment to vent, but they fail to address the deeper factors that caused African Americans such pain.
A key part of the author's text is the collective trauma that blacks have historically experienced in the United States, in contrast with the refusal of governing bodies to earnestly confront the injustices committed against African Americans. His aim is not to advance an argument for national atonement or reconciliation, but rather to show that the absence of such endeavors has consequences. One of the main consequences, in his view, is this idea of collective trauma. Like anyone with a psychological condition, the lack of appropriate treatment can lead to instability in judgment. Awkward writes:
I hope to demonstrate that the deep, festering fissures in the souls of black American folk have led us to react compulsively when we feel our humanity challenged by events and language we perceive … as indistinguishable from our experience of racism. … In such instances, our behavior indicates that our souls' wounds have metastasized and that our collective identities may be so thoroughly the product of our traumatized national status that we are unable to distinguish the real threats we face—such as the fact that … black boys and men kill each other indiscriminately and at an alarming rate—from cynically orchestrated events like the Imus controversy. (46)
From the author's vantage point, when one considers the nature of a comedic talk show combined with Imus's general history as a commentator, it is wrong both to label Imus a racist and to engage in an unnecessary sideshow that evades the core issues. An avowed fan of the show prior to and following the incident, the author seeks to place the show in the context of other public racial events of this type.
Awkward uses contemporary hip-hop music/culture as an example of the negative lyrics and destructive attitudes that are widely supported by blacks and whites. He contends that “contemporary hip-hop culture, marked, as it is, by misogynistic notions of gender and a resultant glorification of pimps, is inconceivable without such formulations as nappy-headed hos” (104). Blacks have been willing participants and promoters of cultural productions that adversely affect African Americans, and because these studio projections by entertainers are absorbed by popular culture, the listening public cannot be blamed for adopting these stereotypes. Once publicized, the author notes, “people outside that depressed—and oppressed—sphere can and will use that information to assess, make predictions about, praise and ridicule, and tell jokes pertaining to, that group's behavior” (115, author's emphasis). I believe the author's point is valid, but it is one-dimensional in its failure to recognize the influence of the music industry in the promotion of certain images and stereotypes.
The hip-hop-as-villain argument has been quite common over the years.Footnote 12 Both the imagery and language employed by some artists, it is argued, are morally reprehensible, adding to the cycle of violence and self-destructive behavior on the part of blacks. Many of these artists that Awkward refers to are heavily financed by Fortune 500 media corporations, and numerous artists over the years have noted the heavy hand of the record labels in directing content and imagery. This is a process that is not only limited to black artists; several musicians have noted the need to switch or form their own labels to escape the constraining influences of record executives. I am not suggesting that record executives made certain artists engage in negative behavior, but the commoditization process would not be possible without these media elites.Footnote 13 Critique aside, Awkward's central contention is that integration of hip-hop (which sometimes employs negative images of blacks) into mainstream culture gives license to personalities like Imus to use these controversial terms. A position such as this ignores the unspoken intersubjective agreement between whites and blacks that there are certain parameters to the popular discourse. While one may find teenagers in a diverse area listening to rap and calling each other the N-word, communal understandings among friends cannot eclipse the anxiety and tension that appears in most environments when a white person refers to a black person using the N-word. Being a comedian or an East Coast liberal does not negate this very basic rule. This is not to suggest that the response to Imus's commentary was justified, but rather that his comments were clearly inappropriate despite his personal comedic/shock-jock style or political ideology. Awkward is correct that the crime may not fit the punishment, but there was a crime.
Another shortcoming of the author's argument is his conceptualization of the political process. Specifically, politics frequently involves theatrics in an effort to publicize whatever issue the actor's interest group is trying to advertise. Both Gooding-Williams's and Anders Walker's books touch on the theatrical side of politics to a certain degree. The model of black political leadership that Du Bois advocated, according to Gooding-Williams, was an expressionist model. Du Bois sought to integrate sociocultural dynamics into his model that drew from the spiritual practices of African Americans. Moreover, Walker's text indicates the importance of spectacular events in shaping public opinion during the height of the civil rights movement. Black leaders sought out dynamic conflicts that would grab public attention, while white moderates attempted to thwart dynamic events as a part of their resistance to desegregation. This is not to assert that the Duke Lacrosse case or the Imus incident mirror the battles of the civil rights movement; rather the politics of theater is something that all political leaders, if they are to be successful, must master. What the author views as overreactions may be, in fact, evidence of a lack of political organization.
