No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
In recent years works by Andre Gunder Frank, R. Bin Wong, and Kenneth Pomeranz, among others, have placed Asian societies in a new historical light. This research contradicted the accepted views of an European exceptionalism. These historians pointed out how the invention of the steam engine enabled European nations to achieve standards of living comparable to those of China or Japan and to gain supremacy in the world economy.
Recent debates about the European role in the world have centered on the comparison of economic developments in Europe and Asia. In contrast, Geoffrey Gunn studies cultural relations in the Eurasian landmass. Instead of comparing economies, he considers the cultural exchanges between Asians and Europeans.
According to Gunn, the European imperialism of the nineteenth century was contingent upon the previous three centuries of cultural exchanges with Asia, “unlocking the knowledge and empowerments necessary for establishing commercial bridgeheads and future colonial empires” (p. 247). Before the nineteenth century, Dutch, British, French, Spanish, and Portuguese influences were confined to outposts of the Asian continent. Japanese, Indians, Chinese, Ottomans, and Persians dictated the terms of trade and the cultural impact of the Europeans was relatively minimal.
The cultural interactions of this 300-year period were made possible by the “Print Capitalism” ushered in by the Gutenberg Press, which made accessible new worlds to European publics. Post-Ptolemaic atlases, cartographic reproductions, and travel accounts were printed and had great impact on European voyages of exploration. For instance, in 1461, Aeneas Sylviis Piccolomini, Pope Pius II, in a geography book rejected the notion of a closed Indian ocean and supported the idea of rounding Africa to reach India. Ludovico Varthema in his Itinerario, printed in several European cities between 1508 and 1550, indicated the places where nutmeg and cloves were grown. Five years later the Portuguese Antonio de Abreu went to the Moluccas.
During the sixteenth century the Jesuits were the main providers of knowledge about Asian lands. In addition to missionary activities, the Jesuits participated in a two-way cultural exchange introducing European science and culture in general to Asian countries and sending back to Europe news about unknown regions. This was not an open exchange, as the missionaries censored secular ideas contrary to Catholic teachings. “Even so, the Jesuits played a key bridging role in interpreting the Orient for European audiences and seeking to change it through demonstrations of ‘superior’ cosmology” (p. 110). It is during the prominence of Iberian powers in Asia that in addition to the coveted species, tea, porcelain, lacquerware, and other merchandise reached markets in Europe and America. In spite of the prominence achieved by the Dutch in Asian waters in the seventeenth century and the arrival of other European powers, “the church canon in Asia remained canonical until breached by the scientific discoveries and knowledge gathered by the great Enlightenment-era discoverers” (p. 110). During the eighteenth century China was admired due to “industry, inventiveness, philosophical strengths, and cultural richness” (p. 146). Voltaire celebrated the Chinese system of government as an “enlightened despotism” that was criticized by European intellectual after the French Revolution as an odious Oriental despotism. Marx considered “Asian regions as not only despotic but also fossilized, incapable of progress and offering obstacles to capitalist development” (p. 167). European imperialism and negative views of Asian societies went hand in hand.
Geoffrey Gunn is right when he observes that without “schools, churches, presses, and missionary activities, the circuits of commerce and trade reaching from Europe to Asia could not have flourished” (p. 284). Nonetheless, the book's central argument is highly problematic: “Our thesis of Eurasian cultural metamorphoses restores Asia to its rightful civilizational equivalence or even preeminence in an era before the rise of industrialism” (p. 284), in light of his observations about the state of science and technology in Asia. In China, according to Gunn, “intellectual involution appeared to be entrenched across the Confucian world.” The Ottomans lacked technological know-how and “only Tokugawa Japan came to emulate the spirit of Enlightenment inquiry” (p. 279). However, the Japanese, in scientific terms, were far behind Americans and Europeans when Commodore Perry arrived. The author does not address the reasons why the Japanese, the Chinese, and the Ottomans did not have the technological edge that he attributes to “Enlightenment advances in sciences and technology” (p. 279). It appears that in the Eurasian exchange, which is, according to Gunn, the crucial intellectual arena in world history, the Europeans were able to profit the most.
Many of the themes and ideas present in Gunn's book have been addressed before in detail by historians such as Donald F. Lach, Joseph Needham, Charles Boxer, and Jonathan Spence. Lacking in the present volume, despite the diverse topics, regions, and time periods covered, is a coherent intellectual synthesis of the material. Nonetheless, as an introduction to the cultural exchanges in Eurasia, Gunn's book is highly useful.