Man (and woman) is a sociable animal. Unsurprisingly, therefore, human association finds expression in multiple forms. In the Graeco-Roman world, such association occurred in fora that are commonly referred to as private and public, from the household to the bouleuterion, as well as in the many grey zones that existed between these seemingly clear-cut extremes. The organisation of individuals in collectives that are called by modern scholars ‘associations’ is a prime example of this: the existence of such groups, documented above all by inscriptions, is thus no surprise and needs little explication. What requires critical attention, however, is the formation and evolution of such associations, their functional diversity and hybridity (including the thorny question of their private or public nature), the mechanisms behind (and repercussions from) the assembly of diverse (legal) status groups and, finally, how such groups related to one another, whether cooperatively or competitively. In particular, did the development of what are widely appreciated as cultic associations facilitate the growth of larger associative networks on a regional level — koinona, notably in the Hellenistic and Roman imperial periods, thereby potentially gaining in force and influence on broader historical developments? This bundle of questions is at the core of the book under review, as laid out in the volume's Introduction (9–15), by Julien Demaille, organiser of two workshops devoted to their analysis through evidence from Greece and Asia Minor, and joint editor with Guy Labarre of the published product.
Privileging, then, regional contextualisations, eight chapters explore different aspects of what Demaille calls the ‘niveau supra-civique’ (12), i.e. the wider embeddedness of diverse associations. Taking the lead from the Athenian Iobacchoi known from IG II2 1368 (164/5 c.e.), Anne-Françoise Jaccottet opens by contextualising several Bacchic associations’ claims to be ‘best’ or ‘first’ among their ilk (17–39); despite the comparative implication, Jaccottet concludes that any supra-regional association is generic at best, articulated ‘de manière très abstraite’, especially on the cultic level (34). Concentrating on women's associations, Athanase Rizakis explores Macedonian attestations of Dionysian cult and maenadism generally (41–64), foremost at (Roman) Philippi (but also at Lete and Pella), arguing for a widespread and shared revival of early Greek and Macedonian models, aided by Euripidean tragedy, i.e. a broader ‘résurrection du passé gréco-macédonien’ (59). Turning to peripheral, colonial territory, at Pydna, 250 c.e., and devotion to Zeus Hypsistos (and the related reverence of Jupiter Optimus Maximus), Demaille belabours the details of SEG XLVI 800 vis-à-vis cognate attestations (65–88): foregrounding the cult's widely recognised and practised openness to different legal and social statuses (and genders), Demaille finally underlines the worshippers’ specifically cultic motivations as the defining supra-civic link — ‘leurs aspirations spirituelles et religieuses’ (84). Diverse social and legal statuses are also in focus in Stéphanie Maillot's chapter concerned with enslaved and freed devotees in (mainly) classical and Hellenistic Greece (89–116). Reviewing the pros and cons of onomastic diagnostics of status (concentrated on Phrygian names), Maillot argues for widespread servile and freed participation, exemplified by the Hellenistic koinon of the Phrygians from Rhodian Astypalaia (IdI 88), and interpreted (with some reservations) as evidence for social integration — ‘un signe de l'integration statutaire et sociale’ (109). Arriving at something like a class-based interpretation, Maillot contends that the (formerly) enslaved availed themselves of a Phrygian identity, expressing in this way a solidarity that arose from their (shared) condition and common interests. Fifteen texts documenting Asklepiastai in Western Asia Minor and the nearby islands, notably Rhodes, c. 200 b.c.e. to 300 c.e., are surveyed by Émilie Piguet to outline these groups’ compositions and settings (117–42): while acknowledging the involvement of local aristocracies, Piguet identifies the foreign participants as the driver behind the associations’ (seeming) proliferation; conversely, the prominence of these foreigners is interpreted as evidence for the groups’ role in their social integration and mobility — ‘des mécanismes d'intégration et d’élévation sociale’ (136). Approaching the xenoi tekmoreioi of Antioch in Pisidia, Guy Labarre reviews older and newer contributions to the epigraphy and its interpretation, such as the association's composition and title, returning in the process to his earlier argument for the identification of the tekmoreioi as devotees of Men (143–58, with, e.g., Le dieu Mèn, 2010, 126–8). Emphasising the sanctuary's renown also outside Antioch (‘il est vraisemblable que les pèlerins étaient attirés par le culte du dieu lunaire’: 156), Labarre concludes that supra-civic relations, i.e. the fellowship of (Antiochian) hosts and (foreign) pilgrims, explain the association of specifically xenoi tekmoreioi, parallel to the devotion by the (local) tekmoreioi. Religious concern is also the explanatory force behind William Pillot's return to the question of the nature of the Hellenistic koinon of Athena Ilias (159–71, with, e.g. Erga-Logoi 5.2 (2017), 155–67). Rejecting the koinon's identification as a purely political confederation, Pillot emphasises the geographical dispersal and ethnic diversity of its members (Aeolian, Ionian, Dorian) who availed themselves of free association with the sanctuary to everyone's benefit (‘de se partager de façon efficace et pacifique les bénéfices du prestige d'un sanctuaire célèbre et réputé’: 169). In the final chapter, Gabrielle Frija conversely underlines the political, that is diplomatic, role of the koinon of the Ionians among its member cities in the Roman imperial period, at the civic level (173–95). Reviewing the documented individual honours, besides different cities’ claims to supremacy, Frija identifies the koinon as an agonistic arena for the region: ‘une arène, locale et modeste certes, pour l'expression du patriotisme civique et la course à la primauté’ (187).
The disjointed nature of this chapter-by-chapter review does justice to the volume, which is the sum of its parts. The aim to reach a higher level, literally, in reassessing evidence for supra-civic association is pursued in analytical isolation despite multiple points of contact — notably claims to civic and/or regional superiority (Jaccottet, Maillot, Frija), evidence for status diversity and social integration (Demaille, Maillot, Piguet), the facilitation of identity formation (Rizakis, Frija) and the (unifying) role of renowned sanctuaries (Labarre, Pillot). Consequently, the question of the relationship between political, social and religious functions of diverse types of associations is peripheral, as is actually the issue of what makes an association an association (as opposed to, say, a confederation). To gain a fuller appreciation of how associations functioned, structurally speaking, and how associations gained sufficient weight to influence developments at a regional level (again, structurally speaking), the different analytical ‘laboratories’ need to overcome their own boundaries in pursuit of productive association, a bit like the xenoi tekmoreioi. Moreover, separating the study of Graeco-Roman cultic associations from the contemporary association of the devotees of Christ (precisely in Greece and Asia Minor) is counterproductive to advancing our understanding of the role of associations on the big historical plane.
Epigraphic problems are not always fully broached (e.g. 111, unproblematically reconstructing IG II2 2940 to document the cult of Men; cf. S. Lauffer, Die Bergwerkssklaven von Laureion, 1979, 185, passively cited at 107), nor are the challenges of status identification (esp. onomastically — passim) and interpretation (e.g. 81, taking devotion to Jupiter Optimus Maximus by a tabularius publicus — ‘un personnage public’ — to document the cult's importance while simultaneously understanding servile participation as a sign of social integration). That women were attracted to Bacchic associations by the chance to behave like men is, in the context under review, obviously an idea propagated by a man (i.e. Euripides, with 59).
