In April 2002, the Immigration and Ethnic History Society (IEHS) made its first lifetime achievement award. It was my honor to be president of the IEHS at that time, and I can recall the pleasure and unanimity of board members in designating John Higham the first recipient of that honor. It was a special pleasure for me to notify John and to present the award to him because over the years John had become both a personal friend and a powerful intellectual influence. When I called him at his home in Baltimore, he accepted with delight but as always with the soft-spoken graciousness that was his way. We chatted about the fact that initially he had not defined himself as an immigration scholar, yet in 1967, more than a decade after the publication of Strangers in the Land had found himself one of the founding members of what was then called the Immigration History Society and later one of its presidents. As we often did, we also talked about our hometown, New York. John had grown up in Queens, while I had grown up in the South Bronx. On many occasions we discussed how our New York roots had lured us into thinking and writing about immigration and ethnicity.
John Higham and his work shaped my thinking in many ways. My work on the stigmatization of certain immigrant groups as the carriers of particular diseases, on the medicalization of prejudice—or as I thought of it, the double helix of health and fear—and on the role of various groups in shaping the public health system in American cities, was in no small measure the result of reading Strangers in the Land and numerous conversations with its author.
Published in 1955, Strangers in the Land was John's first book. In what kind of atmosphere was it published? He remembered, “Joseph McCarthy's infamous career of anti-Communist fear-mongering was still vivid. Southern defiance of a Supreme Court order to integrate the public schools was producing an ideological clash as dangerous as any the country had faced since the Civil War. It was a good time to be uncovering and examining critically the nationalist hysterias of the past.”Footnote 1 Covering the period 1860 to 1925, John Higham boldly and critically proclaimed nativism to be more than an episodic, panicky response to the latest wave of newcomers, but a thread running through the very fabric of American culture, “a defensive type of nationalism.”Footnote 2 Higham defined anti-Catholicism, anti-radicalism, and racial nativism as distinct varieties of this American perennial of prejudice. For John, racism and nativism were different impulses. Nativism differentiated between groups on the basis of who belonged to the nation and who did not. Race could certainly be one of the indelible excluding criteria, but as John put it, “Nativism could espouse assimilation. Racism could not.”Footnote 3
Over the years, and especially since the 1970s, scholars criticized Higham's volume for its shortcomings. In the 1970s when historians turned to detailed local studies and also quantitative analysis of aggregate populations in order to track immigration's influence on communities and Americans' reactions to aliens, Higham's broad brush intellectual and cultural history seemed anachronistic. Others argued that Higham was too Euro-centric, neglecting or giving too little attention to anti-Asian and anti-Latino nativism. More recently, the emphasis on race, class, and gender in immigration and ethnic studies, as well as the appearance of transnational and comparative perspectives on newcomers and natives fueled fresh criticism of Higham's approach. He was admonished for ignoring the voices of the immigrants themselves and for favoring published sources over un-mined manuscript collections.Footnote 4
However, of all the critics of Strangers in the Land, none was as vociferous over the years as the author himself. Essential to John Higham's greatness as a scholar was his willingness over more than forty years to review his own work, to question his own assumptions, and to revisit his arguments in essays and lectures. So it is illustrative to consider examples of how John continued to revisit Strangers in the Land and rethink it conceptually, thereby helping set in place an agenda for others.
In response to criticism that he had not dealt adequately with anti-Asian and anti-Latino attitudes, Higham initially explained that he did not think these groups were perceived as threats to the nation in the same way that Catholics and Eastern European Jews were. However, in an afterward to the 1988 edition of Strangers of the Land, Higham wrote that he should have probed anti-Asian and anti-Latino thought more deeply because it would have offered the opportunity to “test critically the preeminent importance that Strangers in the Land ascribed to nationalism.”Footnote 5
Higham continued to reconsider the Latino experience. In his last essay, “The Amplitude of Ethnic History: An American Story,” Higham spoke of a segment of American society, “deeply underprivileged,” that “sprang up through forcible incorporation rather than choice.” He observed, “If the experience of seizure includes a traditional homeland, the myths that cling to the landed heritage of the group brought with it can entail some esteem and even advantage.” He might well have used the Mexican experience in the southwest as an example, conquered and annexed, but he chose to use Puerto Ricans who he described as “part captive and part immigrant.”Footnote 6
A second self-criticism concerned what John called “an alternative form of nationalism.” If nativism was a kind of pessimistic nationalism, a much more positive form was what he called “America's cosmopolitan faith,” a concept that emphasized “the diversity of the nation's origins, the egalitarian dimension of its self-image, and the universality of its founding principles.”Footnote 7 In a 2000 essay, he lamented not having devoted more space to this optimism because “it was a message of hope which I failed to emphasize enough.” He referred to this liberal strain in the national consciousness as “American universalism.” He realized that some called this universalism “American exceptionalism” and that they dismissed the notion of exceptionalism as intellectual jingoism. However, John never confused the two notions. To him, universalism had a positive meaning because it was a way of reducing the disparities between “cosmopolitan ideals,” for example, freedom, individual liberty, equality of opportunity, and “parochial realities.” He wrote, “Regrettably, I failed to make explicit the further point that American universalism could revive and become once more a precious resource for liberal politics. It tells us that the dream of a widening interracial community is not just an airy abstraction. The aspiration for such a community has endured because it is rooted in a national pride.”Footnote 8
A third revision that John made in his thinking concerned the three categories of nativism. In 1975, twenty years after Strangers in the Land, John published a collection of essays, Send These to Me: Jews and Other Immigrants in Urban America. Higham, in Strangers, cast Jews as one of the foreign groups, defined by Americans as a race and marginalized because of the foreignness. However, in Send These to Me, Higham recast his view of anti-Semitism as a pattern of hatred leading to acts of oppression that could be understood as two genres: social anti-Semitism and ideological anti-Semitism.Footnote 9 The former meant patterns of discrimination—the Jew excluded from neighborhoods, targeted by quotas, shunned professionally and socially; the latter a political or power-hungry agitation addressed to the entire body politic, which “blames the major ills of society on the Jews”—the Jewish Bolshevik, the Wall Street Jew.Footnote 10 Anti-Semitism was both a genre of nativism and more than that. Interestingly the one category that Higham did not explore was anti-Semitism grounded in religious feelings and thought. Although Higham recognized that American Protestants identified Americanism with Protestantism, he never followed that equation to its logical conclusion that much American anti-Semitism was grounded in religious prejudices and that the alleviation of overt anti-Semitism was as much the result of Jewish efforts in the realms of education and community relations as it was the lessening of the “cultural anxieties” after World War II identified by Higham.Footnote 11
Perhaps the most significant example of Higham's self-critique revolved around the primacy of nativism as a subject of study. That process began as early as the winter of 1957 when he spoke to a joint session of the American Catholic Historical Association, which met with the American Historical Association. Acknowledging the perils of revisionism, especially of one's own work, Higham, confessed that he was “nerved to do so by the reflection that historical inquiry does not advance so much by reversal and disavowal as it does by a widening of focus. At its best, it achieves a fruitful tension between perspectives that do not cancel, but rather complement one another.”Footnote 12 Having published a well-reviewed volume on nativism two years earlier, Higham announced that “nativism now looks less adequate as a vehicle for studying the struggles of nationalities in America, than my earlier report of it and other reports might indicate.” He proclaimed the nativist theme “imaginatively exhausted.” Higham explained that the problem with nativism was that it was an “ism,” a “set of attitudes, a state of mind.”Footnote 13 Instead, he called on historians to better understand the ethnic structure of American society and attendant behavior patterns. “We must assume I think, that in a competitive society everything which differentiates one group from another involves a potential conflict of interest, and we must proceed to analyze the historical composition of American society in ethnic terms.”Footnote 14 He called on historians to study ethnic rivalries and religious rivalries. Boldly recalibrating the objective for future scholarship, he concluded:
What I miss, in the most general way, is a serious effort to study historically the structure of American society—to work out, in other words, the interrelations between classes and ethnic groups, taking account of regional and local differences. This task transcends the dimensions of nativism. It transcends a preoccupation with conflict and discord, and urges us to confront our involvements with one another in comparative terms. As this is done, the history of nativism itself should fall into a truer perspective.Footnote 15
Using Strangers as a launching pad, then, John Higham spent much of the rest of his career studying the structure of American society, what in 2000 he would call a “‘cultural subsoil’ of habits, preferences, appearances and capacities that no historian had studied.” He regretted the social contexts in which nativism functioned and described his neglect of frictions between ethnic minorities as “a major shortcoming of Strangers in the Land.”Footnote 16
In the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries, the United States experienced a new wave of immigration and of nativism. On the ground, there were shrill, epithet-riddled screams of the fearful or the hateful, crowded into parking lots in Hazleton, PA and Prince William County, VA. Over the air, one heard Lou Dobbs and Pat Buchanan, and in print one encountered the cultural pessimism of the late Samuel Huntington. One can only wonder what John Higham would have made of it all.
Chances are that John would warn against arriving at pat answers. The next to last paragraph of Strangers is a caution to scholars who might be too quick to use the book—or the past—as a precise blueprint for understanding contemporary patterns: “History may move partly in cycles but never in circles. With every revolution some new direction opens, and some permanent accretion is carried into the next phase. Each upthrust of nativism left a mark on American thought and society.”Footnote 17 Thanks to John Higham's insight both when he first penned Strangers in the Land and then as he revisited its arguments time and again, historians were well positioned to place more recent tides of immigration and nativist reaction to them in the context of the American past.
