Perhaps the most famous shack in the history of science may be the one in southern Wisconsin purchased by American ecologist Aldo Leopold in 1935 as a sort of second home, hunting lodge and land-management experiment. His family's work on the degraded farmland, forests, wetlands and meadows surrounding that shack inspired Leopold's classic work of nature writing and popular conservationism, A Sand County Almanac (1949). This work subsequently became a pillar of American environmentalism due to its promulgation of the ‘land ethic’ – a scientifically rationalizable, albeit Romantically described, mutualistic relationship between a human landowner and her or his non-human living environment. In Stories from the Leopold Shack, his daughter, palaeobotanist Estella Leopold, offers a first-hand history of her family's various shack projects – not just the first one, but similarly ambitious restoration projects across the American West and, in the case of her brother Carl, in Costa Rica.
Stories comprises both memoiristic accounts of Estella Leopold's childhood visits to the original Shack (which she capitalizes), and more essayistic accounts of ecological restoration projects carried out by members of her family or inspired by them. Both sets of materials are presented in long chapters divided into many short, often unrelated, passages, all buttressed by numerous photographs. Mostly taken by Carl, these bring to life a mix of Depression-era shards of Americana (making homemade furniture, thieves stealing the enamel coffeepot ‘with a graceful handle’ (p. 24)) and conservation (the family planting endless rows of pine trees together, setting planned fires to control the prairie).
The initial, Wisconsin-focused, chapters trace the development of the Leopolds’ Shack project over the course of four seasons and, in doing so, offer brief biographies of the precocious family's constituents: ‘Dad’ (Aldo Leopold, 1887–1948), ‘Mother’ (Estella Bergere Leopold, 1890–1975), and the junior Estella's siblings – Aldo Starker (1913–1983, forester and zoologist), Luna Bergere (1915–2006, geomorphologist and hydrologist), Nina (Nina Leopold Bradley, 1917–2011, conservationist), and Aldo Carl (1919–2009, plant physiologist and soya expert). In addition, family friend and Nina's eventual husband Charles C. Bradley (1911–2002, geologist), two dogs (Flicky and Gus), and a pet crow (Pedro) provide cameos. One highlight of the early chapters is Estella Leopold's blow-by-blow account of her father's detailed plans for long-term forest restoration, in which, as with all of the original Shack projects, she and her mother vigorously participated.
Middle chapters offer more scientifically specific, less family-focused, accounts of the Shack property, including vivid descriptions of the local flora and poetic reflections of interacting with the deep past. Concerning the annual flooding of the Wisconsin river near the Shack, for example, Estella Leopold writes, ‘The beach was once huge, and these patterns cut by nature were beautiful and regular. One hated to walk on it for fear of disturbing something sacred’ (p. 120). The final chapters broaden in narrative range to tell the stories of the siblings’ and Charles Bradley's later scientific research and conservation work, which may particularly interest historians of post-Second World War American ecology and environmentalism.
The overall impression of the book is serene but scattered. Estella Leopold writes clearly and with an infectious passion for seemingly all animals and plants, but also with a colloquial touch – e.g. regarding a time she successfully imitated a screech owl, fooling her father's friends: ‘I thought that was LOTS of fun!’ (p. 98). This effect can be charming when she writes of her large, close-knit family's collective love of nature and enjoyment of the Shack's humble pleasures. When she writes of the various projects that transformed the Shack and the lands around it, however, her style can sometimes pull the reader out of the historical moment.
And although Stories enriches our understanding of the Shack idea's relation to Depression- and Second World War-era American ecology, forestry and wildlife biology, it offers little new analytic insights or surprises to the history of biology in general. Moreover, potentially valuable critical engagements are conspicuously absent: Estella Leopold clearly describes but does not analyse her family's doubly grand-immigrant character: Aldo was the grandson of German immigrants to Iowa, his first language was German and he travelled to Germany in 1935 to study forestry (Estella mentions the Second World War only in passing); the senior Estella was the granddaughter of wealthy New Mexican sheep ranchers, spoke fluent Spanish and taught her children Mexican songs and stories. One wonders how the Leopolds’ family history might have influenced their ideas about landownership and ecological management, and in general how these ideas might have conflicted with other prevailing understandings of the land.
That is, the southern Wisconsin presented in Stories feels somewhat devoid of a larger social context. A sharper example of this void is the book's (again, too brief) treatment of Native Americans. For the most part, Native Americans don't play a role in Stories, despite their historical importance to the character of the land that it concerns. Thus, even as it exists primarily as a domestic history of a figure important both to the history of ecology and to American environmentalism, perhaps Stories can also generate reappraisal of the cultural influences that did or did not factor into these scientific and political developments.
This aside, Estella Leopold's history offers an inspiring portrait of a family dedicated to an abstraction – that humans should learn to live more harmoniously with whatever land happens to surround them. In Stories, Aldo Leopold asserts multiple times that the raison d’être for the Shack was primarily economic; it enabled richly experiential, if not luxurious, family vacations during the Depression. But in Estella Leopold's own words, the point of the Shack and its successors seems to be defiantly extra-economic: shack-lands are hard work, they cost money to create and maintain, and they are not worth much in the end. The reason that such long-term ecological restoration projects inspire us is that they highlight the biological and geological contexts for human social life, and in doing so cloud the boundaries between context and content.
