While I was reading Performing Antagonism: Theatre, Performance & Radical Democracy, coedited by Tony Fisher and Eve Katsouraki, Hurricane Maria ravaged Puerto Rico. The majority of the island was left without power, drinkable water, or access to medical help for its 3.4 million American citizens. President Donald Trump did not acknowledge the devastating effects caused to the unincorporated US territory for several days after the storm hit. His response was a nonperformance whose silence spoke volumes.
It is rare and exhilarating to come across a book that penetrates to the very heart of concerns for performance and politics in the immediate present. As Eve Katsouraki writes in her erudite epilogue, each of the chapters in Performing Antagonism “discusses a radicalism in the aesthetics and politics of the ‘theatrical’ invested in the practice of antagonism as an articulatory practice” (291). The (US) political climate within which I read this book underscored the urgency of its themes, making its primary line of inquiry viscerally felt: if antagonism operates at the heart of contemporary global politics, how does this critically impact notions of performance and performativity?
Tony Fisher's excellent introduction traces the centrality of antagonism to both democratic politics and tragic theatre in ancient Greece. He writes, “Greek society, during the age of the tragic drama, produced a political imaginary that defined itself in every sense as agonistic” (11). A return to ancient Greece in Fisher's introduction, as well as in Simon Critchley's chapter, “Tragedy's Philosophy,” nicely frames the lineage of thinking about the connection between performance and antagonism, to which Katsouraki returns in her epilogue.
There is an impressive caliber of scholarship throughout the book, and a significant unification around the centrality of antagonism as a critical device. Across its fifteen chapters, Performing Antagonism ultimately proposes, drawing heavily on the work of Chantal Mouffe, that we need to acknowledge the antagonism that lies at the heart of politics, and that through this acknowledgment, we can begin to embrace a tragic conception of politics: what Fisher describes as “plac[ing] ‘the agōn’—or ‘struggle’—at the very centre of the experience of the political” (4). What the book shows is that performance broadly conceived—from protests (Theron Schmidt, Pollyanna Ruiz, Eve Katsouraki, Gigi Argyropoulou) to museum presentations (Rachel Cockburn) to wrestling matches (Broderick D. V. Chow)—has the potential to illuminate and question the antagonistic heart of politics, and to draw the spectator/participant's attention critically toward these aspects of the world.
Many chapters use evocative examples of performances as the foundations of their arguments; others focus heavily on theoretical and political aspects. In the latter, the performances themselves become a kind of afterthought to the analysis, whereas those that use firsthand encounters with performance as their starting point do so in extraordinarily sophisticated ways from which complex and challenging insights emerge. For example, Theron Schmidt examines a protest in which he participated in 2001 at a US Army base in Georgia near the border of Alabama, an experience that inspired him to ask, “Can a radical, dissensual democracy only be expressed in the negative, or might it find a positive, durable form?” (103). Rachel Cockburn carries this question across her own account of the institutionalization of critique as she examines performances in museums that seek to challenge hegemonic modes of art and knowledge production. Sruti Bala's discussion of Augusto Boal's Theatre of the Oppressed techniques used in workshops in rural South India is another standout, and ultimately reveals the ways in which unexpected failures in performance can have pedagogical and ethical significance.
The collection's extensive reliance on Mouffe highlights the importance of her work. Given the many references to her scholarship, I would recommend that readers unfamiliar with her books treat them as supplementary reading for this collection, in order best to engage critically with much of the volume's content, and because many of the chapters are secondary readings of her work. Indeed, one might think of Performing Antagonism as an illuminating entry point into Mouffe's work from a theatre and performance studies perspective.
Performing Antagonism is an indispensable contribution to theatre and performance studies scholarship that marks a significant turning point toward a more radical and nuanced engagement with how performance is political, and politics is performative. As Fisher points out, the collection avoids collapsing performance into politics and vice versa. Rather, it endeavors—and succeeds—in showing “how theatre and performance can be ‘political’ without reiterating the hoary idea that theatre and politics are somehow ‘the same’ and without resorting to the cliché that because theatre possesses a public it must, therefore, be inherently political (or the converse that politics is a kind of ‘theatre’)” (4). This is a welcome contribution to the scholarship, making much-needed room for subtlety and affective nuance in such discussions.
Fisher and Katsouraki have brought together an impressive and impassioned range of scholarship that responds to urgent questions and that makes for urgent reading for our time. The book appeals to a readership both within and beyond theatre and performance studies. What is gleaned from the collection are some radically new propositions for how performance can and does respond to challenges we face as a dēmos, whose struggle—symptomatic of neoliberalism—is to wrestle with and realize the inherently antagonistic dimensions of politics in order to challenge them.
