It is not often that books on Japanese politics effectively combine eclectic social science methodologies with culturally sensitive empirical analysis. This is one such book. In its analysis of how international norms are interpreted and transformed at the national level to serve often unrelated political objectives, this extremely well-written study offers fascinating insights into the mechanisms of norm dissemination, Japan's responses to international political trends, and the state of Japanese domestic politics over the past two decades.
David Leheny's immediate objective is to unravel the processes through which international norms are combined with local fears to produce new political justifications for the expansion of state powers in Japan. To that end, he examines national reactions to international normative trends relating to the sexual exploitation of children and the expansion of global terrorism. In the case of the sexual exploitation of children, the Japanese government responded to growing international criticisms that it was soft on the issue by passing a law in 1999 that banned child pornography and prostitution and by promising to crack down on those who engaged in such practices. But the state's enhanced powers were used less for its intended purposes than to tackle another scourge of contemporary Japan: a practice known as “compensated dating” (enjo kōsai) in which teenage girls would liaison—sometimes sexually—with older men, receiving fees in return for their favors. Compensated dating unnerved many conservative Japanese during the 1990s, raising fears that Japan's youth were rapidly slipping into moral degeneracy and jeopardizing the health and future standing of Japanese society. Thus, pressures on Japan to conform to new international norms on child prostitution and pornography proved a godsend to concerned Japanese, giving the state the normative, legal, and institutional wherewithal to confront a social problem that for years it had been all but powerless to address.
Similar dynamics were at play in Japan's response to American pressures to contribute substantively to the global war on terror. Once again, the world's misfortune produced positive side effects for the Japanese. For years, the state had been grappling with constitutional constraints on the use of its armed forces as it confronted a growing threat from North Korea. Then after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on New York City, Japan passed a series of laws—including one authorizing the dispatch of the Maritime Self-Defense Forces to Iraq—that enhanced its ability to more effectively confront North Korean incursions into Japanese waters by increasing the powers of both the military and the heretofore powerless Coast Guard.
In both cases, Leheny effectively illustrates how actors combine international norms with local fears to produce new interpretations of social and political problems that, in turn, lead to broader political constituencies behind the expansion of state powers. In the case of compensated dating, conservative politicians and their allies orchestrated national redefinitions of prostitution, the age of sexual consent, and the apportionment of personal responsibility in illegal sexual transactions. In the case of terrorism, the shock of 9/11enabled Japanese political hard-liners to include North Korea within the orbit of international “terrorism” by stretching the concept's definition to include Pyongyang's secretive abduction of Japanese nationals and infiltration of Japanese waters. In the process, Kim Jong Il became Japan's Osama bin Laden, posing a threat that could only be met—not coincidentally—by beefed up military power.
Leheny's findings in these two cases make important contributions to the growing constructivist literature by showing us how international norms can be manipulated for political gain to produce unintended local consequences. Academics in search of generalizable hypotheses may be disappointed by the absence in this study of clear causal relationships between norms and national political outcomes, but so be it. Norms are messy things that are subject to historical contingency, political agency, and cultural considerations; national context, in other words, matters. And the author should be commended for applying a broad range of methodologies to effectively establish this important point. For each case, he relies on painstaking analyses of Diet records and newspapers, while providing fascinating insights from academe and even popular culture (novels, magazines, television programs), to uncover the complexities of the moral and ideological debates that, in turn, helped shape policy outcomes. Along the way, he injects his own personal observations and snippets of conversations with acquaintances and official contacts to give added spice to the story.
The overall effect is highly illuminating and, at times, very funny. To cite just one example, Leheny's description of the profound discomfort he felt while witnessing two teenage girls change their clothes in a subway car in preparation for what might have been a sexual rendezvous made me laugh out loud. More to the point, the account gave me an in-depth appreciation of the moral controversies and dilemmas surrounding the behavior of Japanese youth and, consequently, of the political complexities surrounding their solution.
The book delivers more than it promises. In Chapter 2, Leheny provides an excellent overview of the many events of the 1990s—from the political upheavals and economic recession of the early part of the decade to the Hanshin earthquake and Aum Shinrikyo's sarin gas attacks on the Tokyo subway system in 1995—that produced a profound sense of anxiety and malaise among ordinary Japanese. The chapter's immediate goal is to explain the general environment that produced the public's susceptibility to political fear mongering later in the decade and beyond, but it also functions as an excellent stand-alone snapshot of the state of Japanese politics and society. In a similar vein, the chapters on child pornography and prostitution give us rare glimpses into the paternalistic ethos of, and legal constraints confronting, the National Police Agency, as well the police's handling of various forms of juvenile delinquency. Finally, the analysis of Japanese approaches to counterterrorism is couched in an excellent analysis of the trajectory of late–twentieth-century security policy, including a rare look at the Coast Guard's recent growth.
Think Global, Fear Local is a beautifully researched and argued—not to mention entertaining—study that will appeal to both students (graduate and senior undergraduate) and scholars alike in the fields of international relations, political science, and, more broadly, Japan studies. I enthusiastically recommend it.
