Between 1955 and 2000, a legal loophole allowed American soldiers literally to get away with murder. Active-duty soldiers could be tried via military tribunal, but those who left military service before their crime was discovered became civilians immune from military justice. Because domestic federal courts lacked jurisdiction over many crimes committed overseas, the former soldier would face no punishment at all. This was not merely a theoretical problem: more than a dozen men who took part in the 1968 massacre of Vietnamese civilians at My Lai went unpunished for lack of jurisdiction. Patrick Hagopian's American Immunity investigates the history of this “jurisdictional gap” in detail. Though the direct consequences of the gap were relatively small, Hagopian successfully uses it to explore America's hypocritical relationship with international justice.
In seven well-organized chapters, Hagopian provides a focussed history of the jurisdictional gap's opening, persistence, and eventual closure. The gap emerged in 1955, he shows in chapter 1, when the Supreme Court ruled in Toth v. Quarles that former soldiers could not be tried in military courts under the Universal Code of Military Justice. Concern for Constitutional rights motivated the ruling: military courts martial would deprive civilians of their right to trial by jury. The Court recognized that it had created a loophole, and urged Congress to pass legislation enabling federal courts to try veterans for overseas crimes. In chapter 3, Hagopian follows Senator Sam Ervin, who repeatedly introduced such legislation to no avail. Chapters 4 through 6 explain how soldiers and commanders guilty of murder at My Lai escaped justice, and note the surprising persistence of the jurisdictional gap even after it had become the subject of national attention. Chapter 7 brings the story to the present day and explains how the Military Extraterritorial Justice Act (MEJA) finally closed the gap in 2000.
American Immunity is the first book to provide a full accounting of the jurisdictional gap for former soldiers. It makes excellent use of extensive legislative and judicial published and archival sources and provides a thorough overview of the relevant case law that created and eventually closed the gap. Scholars seeking a detailed account of this particular legal loophole will find it especially useful. In chapters 2 and 7, Hagopian also incorporates an account of another legal loophole: civilians accompanying US armed forces overseas were free from both military and domestic jurisdiction. His account of this gap is less original – legal scholars like Kal Raustiala have examined it at length – but it does provide important context, for actions to address the civilian gap intersected with attempts to close the loophole affecting veterans.
For Hagopian, the jurisdictional loophole provides evidence of a broader gap: the one between America's words and its deeds. The persistence of the jurisdictional gap for decades reveals broad “apathy and moral blindness” (57). As Hagopian argues, even attempts to close the gap were not motivated by moral outrage but by the fear that Americans might otherwise be tried by foreign courts. Indeed, Hagopian challenges the standard account of the passage of MEJA, which emphasizes Congress's revulsion when a sex offender used a loophole to evade punishment. Instead he shows that Congress acted in 2000 because it feared the looming creation of the International Criminal Court and growing enthusiasm for universal jurisdiction. Hagopian criticizes US leaders for claiming an “American exemption” (163) from the international rule of law, even as the nation justifies its global power in the name of spreading legal order. The most engaging parts of the book are its introduction and conclusion, which constitute an impassioned call to reject this exemption and thereby create a world “where justice is possible” (163).
Supposing Hagopian's analysis is correct, we are still left with the question: just how significant was the particular “jurisdictional gap” that Hagopian explores? Outside the My Lai example, the book is vague on precisely how many people were affected. And as Hagopian himself shows, all but one of the men actually charged with crimes at My Lai – those who were still on active duty and thus not affected by the gap – escaped punishment anyway. It was not the lack of jurisdiction that mattered but the unwillingness to use the jurisdiction that did exist. Moreover, focussing on violations of the laws of war obscures how international law enables as well as constrains the use of violence: millions of Vietnamese died from actions that were considered “legal” at the time. Nevertheless, since law remains the primary means for punishing malevolent acts, understanding the unruly spaces that emerge at the interstices of multiple jurisdictions is a worthwhile project. American Immunity provides a valuable contribution to this effort.
