How does a city take shape? How do its inhabitants make it a physical space infused with self-awareness? These are some of the questions that Jens Hanssen seeks to answer in regard to Beirut during its formative years in the second half of the 19th century. Along the way he proposes two main ideas that frame his historical exploration. The first is that Beiruti intellectual activities were not simply reflections of urbanization and the socioeconomic changes it engendered but also were indeed formative of that historical process. Or, as he puts it in his introduction, “the challenge of this study lies in relating the literary networks to municipal politics and to the production of space in fin de siècle Beirut” (p. 5). The second part of his thesis is that the modernity that came to define Beirut's emergence as a provincial Ottoman capital was not a European-driven process. Rather, he contends that locals (elites and commoners) were as critical as Ottoman officials and European capitalists to transforming Beirut.
Culling information from an impressively wide range of sources—including not only the expected Ottoman and European archives but also literary works, newspapers accounts, photographs, and even a sketch by Gibran Khalil Gibran—Hanssen painstakingly and almost lovingly traces the rise of Beirut from a small town into a cosmopolitan city. Across his nine chapters, the urban history of the city is populated by humanized characters whose voices render the narrative symphonic. The tenor of the story is set from the first pages with Butrus al-Bustani's description of “Bayrut” as a city ranking among the world's major urban centers and formed by the “Eastern, Ottoman, Arab and Syrian” cultural circles (p. 7). From this beginning we are led on a chronological and thematic tour of Beirut's rise to prominence.
In the first part of the book, titled “Capitalizations,” the focus is on the attempts of Beiruti elites to promote the city's status within the Ottoman Empire. Notable families (such as the Bayhums, Sabbaghs, and al-As'ads) rose to prominence between 1880 and 1920 as members of Beirut's provincial council. Within that governing body they actively participated with various Ottoman governors of the province in governing the city, shaping its relationship to Istanbul, and improving its rank vis-à-vis Acre, Damascus, and Lattakia. Hanssen shows that their fruitful struggles to elevate Beirut into a provincial capital played out not only through petitions and appeals to the Sublime Porte but also through the process of physically constructing a modern city. Construction projects such as enlarging and modernizing the port, building a railroad between Beirut and Damascus, lighting the street with gas lamps, and laying down city tramlines were conscious efforts to create a “modern” city that bypassed all other provincial ones. Yet, the process was deeply contested. Not only were other cities competing for the same type of facilities and thus status but also local workers and foreign capitalists battled each other. The mood of workers vis-à-vis French capitalists is captured in the words of one group of demonstrators against the French-owned customs office: “You are not in France here, you are in Turkey. You are not the masters.” Through a series of labor strikes and boycotts, local workers and merchants were able to maintain control over the modernization and capitalization of Beirut and to keep it from becoming a city dominated by colonial forces and elites.
In the second part of his book, Hanssen turns to the concept of “Mediations.” Through the section's three chapters, he explores the city through measures of public health, the rise of a local bourgeoisie, and the thickening of cultural and intellectual production with the rise of “modern” local and foreign educational institutions. In contrast to the Orientalist narrative of the Ottoman Empire as a metaphorically and literally “diseased” body, Hanssen presents a history of public health in Beirut as a struggle against disease through a network of Ottoman, local, European, and Egyptian hygienists working in tandem. Focusing on cholera, he shows that Beirut's rapidly growing population and the resultant crowding prompted local calls for improved public health services and rules that were rooted in the Tanzimat language of modernization and progress. The cholera epidemic and other crises necessitated a new style of governance that integrated the urban bourgeoisie into an elected municipal and provincial council. The relevance and importance of these councils is affirmed through the list of notables who consistently vied for posts. This participatory type of institution was modeled after the Istanbul municipal reforms and prompted by the “urgency of health concerns in the wake of the civil war in Mount Lebanon” (p. 161). Moreover, these councils were populated not only by members of the city bourgeoisie but also by intellectuals who themselves were products of new urban educational institutions. Whether it was the Syrian Protestant College, al-Bustani's al-madrasa al-waṭaniyya, or the government sultaniye and ʿuthmaniye schools, these institutions—as Hanssen argues convincingly—produced a generation of intellectuals who sought to shape Beirut through their vision of modernity. Through debates in the council and the myriad newspapers and journals that were published in the city, these Beiruti intellectuals were constructing a new type of public space that discursively and in practice imagined Beirut into existence.
The final part of Hanssen's book examines the “physical and mental spaces of the city” as imagined by these intellectuals, constructed by the city's bourgeoisie, and contested by its subaltern populations. Hanssen examines the everyday life of the inhabitants of the city. He takes us through its coffee shops, theaters, parks, and squares as well as into the private abodes of working-class families and the grand villas around the hilltops. The increasingly cosmopolitan urban life brought middle-class theater-goers into conflict with an “underworld” that had hitherto claimed the nights. The qabaḍayāt (henchmen) and prostitutes of Beirut were faced with the moralists (such as al-Bustani and Jirji Zaydan) who objected to their vice-ridden existence that undermined the progressive march to modernity. Yet, as Hanssen notes, the subalterns were never “eradicated” from the map or the landscape of Beirut, and the boundaries between them and their bourgeois opponents were fluid lines that ebbed and flowed around policing efforts. If morality was one axis defining the changing geography of Beirut, Hanssen contends that literary imaginations and new architecture equally shaped its space. Across newspaper pages and in the new genre of the novel, writers and intellectuals imagined Beirut and in the case of Gibran, sketched an emblem of the city in the form of an architecturally mixed opera house. If the opera house was never built, banks, department stores, grand and petit serails, vocational educational complexes, and clock towers came to dot the urban landscape and visually define Beirut as a modern city. All of these complexes were built, Hanssen shows, through the collaboration of local imagination, Ottoman imperial support, and—to a far lesser extent—European capital.
In concluding his book in this manner, Hanssen firmly establishes that at least one Ottoman city was not a product of European capital and imposition but rather an outcome of a complex set of historical interactions that defined a local modernity on the terms of its inhabitants. My only critique of this work is that the narrative at times appears more like a series of vignettes than a coherent and fluid tale of the city. While the multiple strands of the story were necessary to effectively illustrate the complexity of the physical and intellectual construction of Beirut as a modern space, it seems to me that their interweaving could have been more seamless. Nonetheless, this a most welcome addition to a series of books that have taken the Ottoman city (Aleppo, Salonica, Cairo) as their site of historical inquiry and that have produced a more nuanced story of the interaction between Europe and the Middle East and of the resultant creation of modernity.
