This collection of essays, ‘With the Feather and the Sword: The Military and Scholarship–Scholars and War’ derives from a 2009 conference held in Berlin as part of the German Research Foundation's Scholarship, Politics, and Society. Germany in International Context in the Late Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries: People, Institutions, Discourses. As the editors emphasize at the very beginning of their book, although the theme of ‘science and war’ in the German context immediately conjures up images of Nazi doctors in concentration camps and engineers working on rockets in Peenemünde, there is much more to this story. Indeed, the important and striking examples from the Third Reich can only be understood if they are placed in both a longer chronological and a comparative international context.
Rüdiger Hachtmann examines the ‘militarization of the sciences and the scientification of war’ (p. 25). The cooperation between the sciences, on the one hand, and both the military and institutions of the Nazi regime, on the other, was mutually beneficial. One cannot dismiss the participation of so many scientists in activities that, in retrospect, would be classified as criminal, as simply a question of individual morals or decency. Instead this is also a structural problem. A politically and morally ‘neutral’ science can serve fascist or other authoritarian systems as well as democratic ones. Martin Winter investigates military-related educational institutions in German-speaking Europe in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, and in particular the effect of the Enlightenment on the training of officers. Sven Haase's chapter studies professors at Berlin during the early nineteenth-century ‘wars of liberation’, when these scholars provided ideological support for the war. ‘Honour and nation’ is the title of Klaus Ries's analysis of the communication network created among politicized professors and students by the wars against Napoleon and its subsequent effect as a force of modernization.
The next essays in this collection deal with the two world wars. Sören Flachowsky compares and contrasts scientists of three different types as ‘crisis managers’, and demonstrates clearly the strong connections between the ‘self-mobilization’ of science in both wars. German scholars working in occupied Belgium during the First World War are the topic of Christoph Roolf's chapter. ‘A fortunate opportunity’ documents how these scholars took advantage of the German occupation to advance their own research agendas and careers. Arne Schirrmacher compares and contrasts the mobilization of military and basic research for each other in France, Britain and Germany during and after the First World War. Moving from ballistics to atomic orbits, Schirrmacher concludes that, precisely in defeated and internationally isolated Germany, atomic physics made its greatest advances and experienced comparatively few visible transfers from war innovations to basic research. ‘Military science’ is the subject of Frank Reichherzer's chapter. After Germany's defeat, there were several attempts to establish ‘war’ as an overarching integrating concept in the universities, which had significant effects on German science.
Sabine Schleiermacher makes the connection between spatial planning and efforts to fight against disease epidemics during the Second World War. This took the form of an ‘Atlas of epidemics’, which was conceived and researched in the context of the German war effort, but continued on after the defeat of Germany as a contribution to public health. Jens Thiel studies the university scholar who goes off to war. His essay demonstrates that even individuals whose scholarly career had been hindered for ideological reasons during the Third Reich internalized some of the National Socialist justification for the war. Moreover, the years fighting on the front reinforced the military habitus of many scholars. Matthias Berg's chapter examines ‘Jewish research’ in the Third Reich. The historian Wilhelm Grau argued, ‘The Jewish Question is a task for the new historical research’ (p. 242). Most of such ‘Jewish researchers’ had traditional academic training and, in contrast to anti-Semitic propaganda, wanted ‘Jewish research’ to satisfy academic standards. Of course, Jewish historians were not allowed to participate in this discussion, but Jewish archives and papers were seized and exploited.
Several chapters examine case studies in other countries. Till Knaudt and Hans Martin Krämer investigate the mobilization of science and scientists in Japan during the Second World War. The Japanese government and military recognized early on that science needed to be supported in order that it in turn would contribute to the war effort. Japanese scientists embraced both the war and scientific research in its service, in part out of their own interests. Levke Harders's chapter is also set in the Second World War, here studying the role played by American studies. In particular, the founding scholars of this discipline used the crisis brought on by the war to anchor their subject in the American university system. American studies was going to help define the American way of life, while others were defending it, and educate Americans in democracy. Not surprisingly this rhetoric was successfully extended after the war. The American ‘Enemy research’ during the Cold War is the subject of Tim Müller's chapter. Scholars and scientists participated in intelligence gathering and assessment as part of the wartime Office of Strategic Services, and continued on during the Cold War, which included participation in psychological warfare, or a war of ideas. Alexia Arnold studies scholars from the American civil service working for the American military occupation government in Germany after the Second World War, including four case studies. In the last chapter in this collection, Ute Gerhardt examines the end of German militarism as a subject for social-science research by the American military government from 1945 to 1949, which was a transitional period from the charismatic–traditional to the national–legal political system. This can perhaps be summed up by the question asked at the time: was National Socialism a bad idea, or a good idea that just was carried out badly? At the end of the war, the consensus in the war and state departments was that the German mentality was the key to the aggressiveness of the Nazis and that the military government had to put an end to the militaristic mentality of the Germans. Gerhardt notes that the American social-science research in Germany embodied the political perspectives of the time.
Rüdiger vom Bruch's commentary, which comes at the very end of the book, surveys the various chapters. He notes the gap in the contributions between the Napoleonic Wars and the First World War. The German Empire was born out of war, and there probably is a ‘feather-and-sword’ story to tell here as well. Despite this omission, however, this collection sheds much light on the important subject of the relationship between science and war.
