In September 1929, the Detective Branch of An Garda Síochána, the Irish police force, recorded a search of a house on one of Dublin's premier residential streets, Ailesbury Road. The house in question was the family home of Sighle Humphreys “who is well known for anti-State activities.”Footnote 1 Noting that the search revealed a number of incriminating pamphlets hidden under the carpet, the author of the report continued: “Miss Humphries [sic] was mainly responsible for the recent campaign directed against Jurymen and witnesses in cases where Irregulars were charged with various offences. She is a very dangerous type and it is essential that her home should receive particular attention.”Footnote 2 The organized campaign of jury intimidation referred to in this report lasted, in varying degrees of intensity, for approximately 7 years, from 1926 to 1934.Footnote 3 Although the campaign is discussed in passing in a number of general histories of subversive organizations and emergency law,Footnote 4 it has received little detailed analysis.Footnote 5 The practicalities of the scheme and the investigations and trials stemming from it have not been scrutinized. It is noteworthy that books that focus on the women involved in the campaign, and the women's organization of which they were members, give little or no attention to the jury-tampering aspect of their (admittedly wide-ranging) activities.Footnote 6
The central aim of this article is to piece together the personalities and events that converged in a campaign of jury interference and provoked policing, prosecutorial, and legislative responses from the fledgling Irish state. It is the first research to do this in depth. There are a number of sub-themes to the article. One sub-theme is gender. The main players in the attempts at large-scale jury intimidation were women. Their involvement in this activity has been overlooked, in spite of a perceptible increase in historical scholarship on revolutionary Irish women in recent years. A second sub-theme is trial by jury in the Irish Free State. Apart from the de facto exclusion of female jurors,Footnote 7 little has been written about juries in Ireland in the period from 1922 to 1937.Footnote 8 The jury campaign affected the atmosphere in which jurors discharged their duties, led to jury trials in which women were charged with jury interference, and prompted the government to have recourse to extraordinary measures to safeguard the administration of justice. It therefore had a significant impact on the trial of indictable offenses in independent Ireland.
The Irish Free State and Trial by Jury
The Irish Free State was established in the aftermath of the Irish War of Independence pursuant to the Anglo–Irish Treaty of 1921. The Treaty created a twenty-six county free state with dominion status. A civil war ensued between the Free State Government, which regarded the Treaty as a means to achieving longer-term goals such as national reunification and full sovereignty, and the anti-Treaty Irish Republican Army (IRA), which viewed it as an unacceptable compromise with the country's former occupying power. The pro-Treaty side, assisted by British government materiel,Footnote 9 prevailed in that conflict. This left a contingent of Republicans that would not accept the new state and that was prepared to undermine it by violence. The perceived heavy-handedness of the government during the Civil WarFootnote 10 intensified feelings of animosity. For its 10 year period in office, from 1922 to 1932, the ruling Cumann na nGaedheal party regarded the maintenance of law and order as its number one priority. There was frequent recourse to emergency legislation during this period.Footnote 11
The atmosphere of the Irish Free State has been characterized as “a chilly one; flintily austere in finance, dour in public morality, flat in tone.”Footnote 12 Even among those who supported the Treaty, there was disillusionment, in part caused by “the exaggerated rhetoric of expectation”Footnote 13 that had built up over the centuries about life in a free Ireland. Discontent was unavoidable when the political settlement involved uneasy compromises such as the retention of the king as head of state and the partition of the island. The government had to contend with a bleak financial situation and severely damaged infrastructure and create new public institutions, including an unarmed police force.Footnote 14 Continuity with the pre-Independence ways of doing things was highly evident. For many, it made sense to retain British transplants such as cabinet government, an independent civil service, and a common law legal system.Footnote 15 For others, the fledgling state was insufficiently distinct from Britain, ruled by ministers “far too quick to ape the manners and indeed fashion of their former conquerors.”Footnote 16 An alternative vision of what Irish people should expect in self-governance and nationhood, and the denigration of the status quo, were central themes of Republican propaganda in the 1920s. These polarizing motifs were woven into the jury intimidation campaign also.
Although a written constitution represented something of a break with the Westminster model, the legal system continued largely as before. Trial by jury was enshrined in Article 72 of the Constitution of the Irish Free State, which provided: “No person shall be tried on any criminal charge without a jury save in the case of charges in respect of minor offences triable by law before a Court of Summary Jurisdiction and in the case of charges for offences against military law triable by Court Martial or other Military Tribunal.” Jury trial thus remained the mode of trial for serious offenses such as robbery, burglary, murder, and rape. Importantly for present purposes, many so-called “political offences” were also triable by jury. The Treasonable Offences Act 1925 prohibited many acts engaged in by Republicans, including treason,Footnote 17 participation in organizations purporting to be military or police forces,Footnote 18 and involvement in unauthorized military exercises.Footnote 19 It was perhaps naïve to try such offenses by jury in a post-civil war society, when at least some of the jurors were likely to be sympathetic to those on trial. The intimidatory campaign would add another dimension to this already febrile situation.
During the period under consideration, juries were composed of men who satisfied a property rating qualification. There was a deliberate legislative policy of minimizing the likelihood of women serving as jurors, on the basis that jury service was not compatible with the home duties and sensitive dispositions of women.Footnote 20 The curtailment and restriction of women's involvement in jury service also occurred in other common law countries during this period.Footnote 21 Under the Juries (Amendment) Act 1924, Irish women could opt out of jury service,Footnote 22 a public function that had only been extended to them under the Sex Disqualification (Removal) Act 1919.Footnote 23 The opt out arrangement only lasted for 3 years; the Juries Act 1927 provided that women would be excluded from the jury lists unless they chose to opt in.Footnote 24 There is evidence that a small number of women's names appeared on the jury lists prior to the passage of the 1927 Act,Footnote 25 and that they were targeted by those involved in jury intimidation in the same way as potential male jurors.Footnote 26 Very few female names appeared on the jury lists following the passage of the 1927 Act. From then on, the targets of the jury campaign were probably exclusively male. It is ironic that women, who the state had done its best to remove from the jury system, were the prime movers in “a deliberate effort to tamper with jurymen”Footnote 27 that would ultimately be credited with destabilizing that system. In order to understand what inspired these women to act as they did, it is necessary to briefly sketch their dissident activities in the period leading up to, and immediately following, the 1921 settlement with Britain.
Women of the Revolution
The role of women in Irish nationalist and revolutionary movements, once overlooked in the literature,Footnote 28 has been a focus of much recent scholarly output.Footnote 29 The campaign to influence jurors was organized by members of Cumann na mBan (The Irishwomen's Council), which has been referred to as “the most influential women's organization in twentieth-century Ireland.”Footnote 30 It was founded in 1914 to assist in the attainment of Irish freedom by force of armsFootnote 31 and its members were active participants in the Easter RisingFootnote 32 and the War of Independence.Footnote 33 It opposed the Anglo–Irish Treaty and supported the IRA against the Free State Government in the Irish Civil War. Following the cessation of hostilities, many determined and energetic women who had been involved in the national struggle against Britain were opposed to the new Irish state. They were demonized by the establishment as “unlovely, destructive-minded, arid begetters of violence”Footnote 34 and found themselves consigned to the fringes of national life.
The campaign targeting jurors was conceived in order to support Republican prisoners facing trial in the Free State courts. A small group of Cumann na mBan members decided that jurors who might sit on the trials of Republicans should be contacted and persuaded to acquit if they got the opportunity to do so. It would appear that Sighle Humphreys was the prime mover behind the campaign. She was certainly the person most associated with the campaign by the authorities.Footnote 35 Humphreys came from a family steeped in the Republican tradition. Her uncle, the O'Rahilly, was killed while fighting in the Easter Rising and her brothers were both imprisoned for seditious activity under the British regime.Footnote 36 In November 1922 Humphreys was imprisoned along with her aunt and mother after Free State soldiers raided their house, in which the IRA Assistant Chief of Staff, Ernie O'Malley, was hiding. A shoot-out ensued in which a soldier was killed, with a press report stating that Sighle Humphreys demonstrated “deadly skill in the handling of a revolver.”Footnote 37 She was not released from jail until November 1923.Footnote 38 Máire Comerford was another important figure in the jury campaign. Having acted as courier for the Republican side during the Civil War, Comerford was arrested for her role in a plot to kidnap the president of the Executive Council of the Irish Free State, W. T. Cosgrave. She joined Humphreys in Mountjoy Prison,Footnote 39 where they went on hunger strike in protest against the conditions of their detention. Both women were leading members of Cumann na mBan. The mid-1920s saw a revival in the activities of that organization, which included painting Republican slogans in public places,Footnote 40 removing British flags from buildings and burning them,Footnote 41 and interrupting Remembrance Sunday events.Footnote 42 The jury campaign therefore represented an escalation in the activities of an organization that was already well known to the police.Footnote 43
The Origins of the Campaign
Cumann na mBan and IRA interest in jurors in the 1920s and 1930s drew on historical patterns of anti-state activism in Ireland. Jury intimidation was a well-known phenomenon in Ireland in the nineteenth century.Footnote 44 Jurors who convicted in agrarian and political trials in that period were sometimes the subjects of denunciatory public notices disseminated by sympathizers of the convicted persons. One such notice warned the farmers of County Kerry to boycott two named men described as “pliant jurors who did the work of the Crown” and who were “worse than Belfast Orangemen.”Footnote 45 Circulars were also sent to jurors in the pre-Independence period, as in the Cork trial of a man charged with shooting at and wounding a policeman in 1919.Footnote 46 In perhaps the most startling precursor of what the Cumann na mBan women would do from 1926 onwards, members of the Ladies’ Land League had targeted jurors in agrarian trials in the 1880s.Footnote 47 Little information appears to survive about this previous campaign, which was but one strand of the varied activities of the League.
The fact that the actions of jurors in political cases were being closely monitored by subversives was publicly evident from the mid-1920s onwards. The pages of the Republican newspaper, An Phoblacht, made this clear. This weekly publication presented the Irish Free State as a British puppet state,Footnote 48 defended violence and murder,Footnote 49 and targeted all manifestations of perceived English influence in Ireland.Footnote 50 Although the circulation and influence of the newspaper is difficult to estimate,Footnote 51 for present purposes it is sufficient to observe that it was publicly sold and distributed and was an organ of the IRA.Footnote 52 While particular issues were seized from time to time,Footnote 53 the newspaper itself was not banned in the Free State.Footnote 54 The preoccupation of An Phoblacht with the actions of jurors may be seen in an article from 1925 reporting that a judge at Mullingar had assented to a prosecution application for a change of trial venue to Dublin. The three men on trial were charged with assisting in the formation of an illegal organization, and the account in the newspaper stated that the change of venue would ensure that a Dublin jury consisting of “Freemasons and Unionists”Footnote 55 could be relied upon to convict them. In the following year the newspaper adopted a new strategy of seeking to influence juror behavior. In August 1926 it discussed the forthcoming trial of four men and two women in connection with raids on the premises of Jewish money-lenders in Dublin. The raids were part of a Republican campaign against usury, and their main object was to intimidate moneylenders and remove the ledgers in which they recorded their loans.Footnote 56 In an article with the headline “What will Dublin Jurors Do?” moneylenders were described as “social pests” and “parasites” engaged in an exploitative trade that amounted to “a sin against God and man.”Footnote 57 It was stated that the jurors’ verdict “would either approve of or condemn a practice which is abhorred by humanity” and implied that it was usury, rather than allegations of violent raids on premises, that was on trial. This direct press appeal to the jurors trying named persons foreshadowed the circulars that would be directly sent to jurors by the women of Cumann na mBan. Indeed, the first stirrings of that campaign can be traced to another item in An Phoblacht.
On August 20, 1926 the newspaper published an “Open Letter” to specific jurors. It began by addressing twelve named jurors and stating that they had recently convicted Denis Allen of Gorey of membership of the Irish Republican Army. It then stated that the 1925 Act under which they had convicted Allen was “a law designed to brand as criminals those who are working for the independence of Ireland” and “a worse Coercion Act than any of the hundreds passed from time to time by the British.”Footnote 58 The effect of the jurors’ decision was to classify a political prisoner as a common criminal, “to associate with criminals, wear convict clothes, work as a convict, to rub shoulders with the dregs of humanity.”Footnote 59 The letter then urged the jurors to publicly call for Allen to be treated as a political prisoner. The letter was signed by Máire Comerford. Comerford has been credited as the initiator of the jury campaign.Footnote 60 Her “Open Letter” was direct evidence that she and other Cumann na mBan members were prepared to reveal the identities of jurors who convicted in political cases.Footnote 61 Contacting jurors directly did not represent a great leap from identifying them and appealing to them in a newspaper.
Meanwhile, the IRA was stepping up its own activities in relation to jurors. In May 1926, Moss Twomey, the Acting Chief of Staff of the IRA, sent a coded message to the organization's director of intelligence telling him to investigate where the jury panel was prepared and to arrange for its seizure.Footnote 62 In early June, armed men raided the sub-sheriff's office in Dublin and removed copies of the jury lists.Footnote 63 A jury list bearing the date of the raid is contained in the papers of Cumann na mBan member Annie O'Farrelly, who worked in an administrative capacity for the IRA.Footnote 64 The list provides the names and addresses of 200 potential jurors, and is annotated with x's and o's beside the prospective jurors’ names. Three names have “fair” written beside them. O'Farrelly thus had access to jury lists as part of her IRA work, presumably so that those on the list could be approached and influenced by IRA men. When the Cumann na mBan executive met on September 1, 1926 and decided to contact potential jurors in advance of Republican trials, it was agreed that Annie O'Farrelly would procure a copy of the jury panel and that the Director of Publicity, Sighle Humphreys, would draft a circular to send to jurors.Footnote 65 O'Farrelly's access to jury lists as part of her IRA work obviously informed the executive's decision that she was in an advantageous position to acquire the lists for its own campaign.
The Campaign in Action
Circulars addressed to jurors were read and approved by the executive of Cumann na mBan at meetings held in September and October 1926.Footnote 66 With the imprimatur of the executive, the campaign could commence. In a letter from October 1926 that was subsequently seized by the police, Humphreys told a comrade about the modus operandi of the women involved:
[W]e are sending out three different letters to the Jurors in connection with the forthcoming trials. And the trouble is we are sending them separately as we feel they will have more affect [sic] that way…When you hear that there are 300 jurors all living in different sides of the town you will have some idea of the work. We are not of course sending them through the post as that would be giving the enemy money, so we are delivering them all by hand. I hope it will have some result, as it would be great if we could get the jury to refuse to convict.Footnote 67
The people to whom these circulars were sent had been called for jury service during a period when a number of Republicans were facing trial for the violent raids on money-lenders mentioned above and for charges of treason. One of the circulars was typed on Cumann na mBan headed paper and provided an address of 27 Dawson Street, Dublin. Reminding the jurors that they were “charged with the destinies of a number of your fellow men and women”Footnote 68 it continued: “We ask you to consider whether you count it a crime to put a stop to the exploitation of the poor through the practice of usury, and we urge you to render your verdict accordingly.” The second circular bore the heading “Usury” and cited several Catholic thinkers and decrees condemning moneylending. It added that contrary to the teaching of the Catholic Church “the Free State following the British precedent protects usury…and imprisons those who interfere to prevent the exploitation of the poor.”Footnote 69 It named the woman and three men facing charges in connection with the raids, and was signed “M G McB for Political Prisoners’ Committee.” Maud Gonne MacBride had been active in nationalist and Republican circles for more than 30 years, and although it does not appear that she participated in the jury campaign, the inclusion of her name would have added gravitas and helped to disguise the fact that the three letters emanated from a single source.Footnote 70 The third letter most closely prefigured the content and layout of the Cumann na mBan circulars that would be sent to jurors over the following 7 years. It bore the name of the Political Prisoners’ Committee and began “To each Member of the Jury Panel” with the Irish salutation “A Chara” (Dear Friend) immediately underneath. It then stated that the recipient might be called upon “to try the cases of certain political prisoners.”Footnote 71 Three male and two female prisoners were then listed by name in an indented paragraph, a format that became typical of the circulars. In a strategy that would be deployed repeatedly in subsequent communications to jurors, the legitimacy of the criminal charges facing the prisoners was queried: “As regards the charge of ‘treason’; knowing what constitutes treason you must know in your conscience these citizens are not guilty of this charge. Treason includes the charge of attempting to SUBVERT the independence of one's country. These prisoners’ “crime” is for being connected (sic) with a movement having for its object the RESTORATION AND ASSERTION of their country's sovereign independence.” In a highly charged passage, the circular advised: “If you are English in ideas, outlook and sentiment, you will probably consider these prisoners traitors and criminals, but if you are Irish you will emphatically declare they are not.” Moving on to those accused of violent raids on moneylenders, the circular pointed to the potential moral authority of a jury's verdict: “You may be given an opportunity of declaring against usury.” Noting that usury had a detrimental effect “on the poorest and most miserable section of the citizens,” it stated that a failure to acquit the accused would make the jurors “equally guilty with the usurers.” The outcomes in the trials concerned did not suggest an immediate victory for the jury campaign. Although an acquittal was returned in respect of Mark Killalea on treason charges, four other Republicans were convicted in respect of the attacks on moneylenders.Footnote 72
Few, if any, explicit threats were made to jurors in the circulars sent in advance of trials, and this was probably deliberate. The writers may have hoped to activate sympathies that they believed existed in a sizeable proportion of their fellow citizens, and to persuade others to their point of view. Decades later, Eithne Coyle recollected: “Our practice was to write to each of [the potential jurors] making the best case we could for finding the person not guilty. Of course the government…said this was intimidation.”Footnote 73 This statement ignored the fact that attempting to persuade jurors other than in open court constituted a well-established common law offense called embracery, which will be discussed presently. It also overlooked the reality that the line between persuasion and intimidation may be a fine one. The final circular in the 1926 trio enjoined its recipients: “You will incur a grave responsibility if you condone injustice and are a party to the attempted suppression of the Independence Movement.”Footnote 74 Sentences of this nature were presumably designed to be ambiguous regarding the possible consequences of non-cooperation by the juror.
The circulars were of varying print quality and mostly consisted of plain, typed pages. They may have been typed by Florence McCarthy, one of the women who would be prosecuted for contacting jurors and who worked in the Cumann na mBan office. On at least one occasion in the early days of the campaign, a printing firm was engaged to produce the circulars.Footnote 75 As official interest in them intensified, their appearance became more rudimentary. A police report of 1928 concluded that an intercepted letter to jurors had been produced on a copying press in “some private house.”Footnote 76
Although the raid on the sub-sheriff's office of June 1926, discussed above, was a significant event in gaining access to the official jury panel, it would only have provided a list that was current for one legal term at most. It does not appear that jurors on that panel received communications from Cumann na mBan.Footnote 77 The campaign required access to the names and addresses of jurors whenever a political case went to trial, as the panels were prepared afresh for each sitting period of the criminal courts.Footnote 78 Section 50 of the Juries Act 1927 provided that “any person” was entitled to a copy of the jury panel on payment of a fee,Footnote 79 replacing a similar provision in the Juries (Ireland) Act 1871.Footnote 80 Acquiring the jury panel in this way would have made those involved quite traceable, particularly once the campaign came to the notice of the authorities. A second limitation on its usefulness to would-be jury influencers was that s 50(3) permitted access to the list no more than 3 days before particular sittings were due to commence, which would have created a very tight time period within which to contact the hundreds of names on the jury panel. Bowyer Bell suggests that the women were passed information relating to the jury panels by a sympathetic contact who worked in Green Street Courthouse, where criminal jury trials were held in Dublin.Footnote 81 The existence of a contact of this nature most easily explains the ability of the women to organize and sustain the campaign over several years.
Court Appearances and Punishment
The offense used to prosecute the women involved in the campaign was the ancient, but little-known, common law crime of embracery. Writing in 1789, William Hawkins had defined embracery as “any attempt whatsoever to corrupt, or influence, or instruct a jury, or any way to incline them to be more favourable to the one side than to the other, by money, promises, letters, threats or perswasions [sic], except only by the strength of the evidence and the arguments of the counsel in open court.”Footnote 82 Blackstone referred to Hawkins's treatise for his own definition, adding “entertainments” as one of the means an embracer might employ to corruptly influence a juryman.Footnote 83 He noted that if the juror was receptive to the approaches of the embracer, both parties could be convicted of the offense.Footnote 84 Crosby notes that embracery prosecutions appear to have been resorted to very rarely in England, even where there was clear evidence of conduct that would have justified them.Footnote 85
Because of its rarity, and its archaic, peculiar name, embracery inevitably attracted the attention of journalists when it appeared before the courts.Footnote 86 Those sympathetic to the women conducting the jury campaign belittled the offense with which they were charged. At a protest meeting against the imprisonment of Republicans, Mary MacSwiney of Cumann na mBan referred to it as “a very curious crime, so named by the English.”Footnote 87 When a member of Cork County Council said that Humphreys was facing trial for embracery, and added that he did not know what that was, another member quipped: “Putting her arms around some man.”Footnote 88
Given that the campaign involved the creation, publication, and distribution of printed materials, the generation of a paper trail was somewhat unavoidable. Nonetheless, the apparent failure of the protagonists to conceal their activities could be surprising. For example, evidence for the prosecution in the first embracery trial included a diary containing the following entry for October 13, 1926: “Saw M. re circulars to Jurors. Ordered 350 at 15/-.”Footnote 89 A receipt from the Foley Typewriter Trading Company for “350 copies of letter to members of Jury Panel,” specifying that they were printed on Irish-manufactured paper and provided at a special price was also relied upon.Footnote 90 Official knowledge that letters to jurors were in circulation at specific times seemed to depend on the people who received them reporting their arrival to the police.Footnote 91
Court appearances afforded Republicans opportunities to generate publicity for their campaign of subversion by ignoring or disrespecting the proceedings. As they did not regard the courts as competent tribunals of a legitimate State, they generally did not participate when brought before them.Footnote 92 The women who were charged with embracery adhered to this policy of non-recognition. One consequence of their non-cooperation was that a separate jury had to be sworn in to determine if they were “mute of malice or by the visitation of God.”Footnote 93 These juries generally accepted police evidence that the women were capable of speaking, and a not guilty plea was entered on their behalf.
The first prosecution arising from the jury intimidation campaign was notable because three women were tried together. On December 3, 1926, Sighle Humphreys, Máire Comerford, and Helena Molony (using the name of Eileen or Ellen O'Daly) were brought before Dublin District Court charged with embracery. Molony was an established actress and prominent trade union organizer with a long history of anti-state activity. Under British rule she had handed out leaflets to women promenading with soldiers, discouraging them from consorting with the occupying forces,Footnote 94 and had also participated in the Easter Rising. Evidence was given by a juror who received a circular at this home, and by policemen who testified that they discovered the three women with envelopes containing the same circular when they raided the offices of Cumann na mBan. The defendants ignored the court, as the unionist and pro-Treaty Irish Times reported: “The accused conversed audibly while the case was being heard, and made one or two interjections in Gaelic.”Footnote 95 The women appeared for trial at the Central Criminal Court on December 9, once again talking among themselves and ignoring the trial.Footnote 96 A jury convicted the women and Mr. Justice O'Byrne sentenced them to 3 months’ imprisonment in the second division and to an additional 2 months in default of finding bail to keep the peace for a period of 2 years. He said that they had been convicted of a serious offense and that he had taken into account that they were women.Footnote 97 Following their conviction, Helena Molony pointed to the lion and the unicorn over the Judge's bench and said that it demonstrated that “the same old English law” was being administered by people who were supposedly Irish.Footnote 98 One account of the trial quoted Máire Comerford stating that she was on hunger strike and too weak to speak.Footnote 99 Several reports referred to disturbances within the court that annoyed the judge, including applause for the women's speeches and shouts of “Up the Republic.”Footnote 100 Humphreys’ cousin Niall O'Rahilly wrote to her from Fribourg, stating: “It is a great pity that you will be ‘in’ again for Christmas but the spite and hatred of tyrants when in power has to be satisfied.”Footnote 101 The prisoners were released in April 1927 and Humphreys went to Paris with her mother, from where she continued on to New York with her brother Emmet.Footnote 102
When Cumann na mBan member Florence McCarthy was arraigned before the District Court in April 1928 on a charge of being involved in a military organization not established by law, proceedings were interrupted by “a smartly dressed young woman,”Footnote 103 namely Sighle Humphreys, who called for three cheers for McCarthy and for the Irish Republic. The newspapers quoted the judge as addressing Humphreys, who was placed in the dock, rather plaintively: “It is not fair. It is not what you say that I object to, but you are setting a bad example to the other people who come down to this Court.”Footnote 104 Humphreys did not reply and was instructed to leave the dock. A charge of embracery was later added to the indictment in McCarthy's case. The police gave evidence that they had found all manner of incriminating documents in a wardrobe in her house, including an official copy of a jury list. One document began: “All our energies should be directed towards securing the collapse of Free State Courts.”Footnote 105 It continued: “When juries acquit our prisoners it proves that the people if they will not assist at least approve of others who fight the old fight. Therefore, juries ought to be bombarded with literature of all sorts.”Footnote 106 Speaking in Irish, McCarthy said that she did not recognize the court and would do everything she could “to overthrow the rule of the Sassenach in Ireland.”Footnote 107 On May 4, she was convicted at Dublin Circuit Court of attempting to influence or intimidate jurors and of being involved in the formation of an illegal military force. Rather surprisingly, the jury in McCarthy's case added a rider to its verdict of guilty, asking the judge to treat the prisoner leniently.Footnote 108 McCarthy protested against this recommendation, stating that she did not want leniency and did not believe she had done anything wrong.Footnote 109 Judge Davitt sentenced her to 6 months’ imprisonment in the second division, apparently without comment. He had already told another Cumann na mBan member at the same sitting: “Anything I say to you will, I know, have little or no effect, and I will simply confine myself to performing the task of passing the sentence of the Court.”Footnote 110
A few days later on May 10, Humphreys was charged in the District Court with membership of an illegal organization and was remanded in custody for a week.Footnote 111 A number of counts of embracery were added to the indictment 8 days later. Police evidence stated that documents addressed to jurors were found during a search of her bedroom in her mother's house and in an attaché case she was carrying. When Humphreys was asked if she wished to say anything in reply to the allegations, she began reading at great speed in Irish from a book. Reports of this second court appearance described the accused as “smiling sarcastically”Footnote 112 throughout the hearing and “laughing excitedly”Footnote 113 as she left the dock. Humphreys wrote to her family in high spirits stating that prison conditions were good and that she and her fellow inmates looked wonderful.Footnote 114 A few days later she reported that the prison library was very good and that she could eat everything.Footnote 115 However, on June 5, she went on hunger strike with four other women, including Florence McCarthy, in order to protest at the refusal of the authorities to allow them to associate together and to recognize them as political prisoners. On June 7, their case was raised in parliament by the Leader of the Opposition, Eamon de Valera. He said that he had received information that the women were “pulled and dragged about”Footnote 116 when they tried to associate together. The Minister for Justice, Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney, replied that prison regulations stipulated that prisoners on remand and convicted prisoners must be separated, and that as two of the women had been convicted of offenses (Florence McCarthy and Sighle MacInerney) they had to be kept apart from the other three. The issue of political status was raised by Humphreys’ brother Richard in a letter to the Minister written on June 8.Footnote 117 Replying at length 4 days later, the Minister noted that the women had called off their hunger strike. He stated that when imprisonment without hard labor was imposed on a prisoner by a court, the court could nominate what division the sentence would be served in, with first division being the most lenient and third being the least lenient. Fitzgerald-Kenney added that first division imprisonment was “usually reserved for prisoners serving sentences for seditious libel or for contempt of court…I am unable to see that the arguments which justify first division treatment for seditious libel could be said to apply to such serious offences as under-mining the jury system, intimidating jurors to be false to their oath, carrying lethal weapons for purposes of violence or inciting persons to assassination.”Footnote 118 He concluded by disputing Humphreys’ contention that the offenses involved were “solely of a political nature,”Footnote 119 stating that no such classification existed in law.
Humphreys was tried before a jury at the Central Criminal Court on June 22, 1928. Ironically, given that one of the charges she faced was jury interference, Cumann na mBan issued a circular to jurors in relation to her trial.Footnote 120 While in the dock, she passed the time by knitting, speaking only to say that she was proud to be a member of the Irish Republic.Footnote 121 This statement engendered some applause in the court, and a young man who clapped and cheered was arrested. Mr Justice Hanna told the jury that there was no dispute as to the facts. Evidently conscious of the effects of political sympathy and fear of the prisoner's associates on the jury, and anxious to secure a conviction, he added that they were required to “maintain the laws of the country under which they lived.”Footnote 122 While the jury was deliberating, the man who had interrupted proceedings received a stern lecture from the judge. In spite of the firm summing up, the jury disagreed on the verdict, necessitating a fresh trial at a future date. Writing to her mother from Mountjoy Prison the next day, Humphreys described herself as “very pleased”Footnote 123 with the outcome, noting: “I'd rather the jury would disagree than anything except of course acquit which would be too much to expect from their names.”Footnote 124 This implies that the jurors’ names suggested unionist or pro-government sympathies. Humphreys revealed with great satisfaction that the young interrupter of proceedings was her cousin, Mac O'Rahilly: “I was simply charmed afterwards, this at the moment I felt I was doomed to get everyone into trouble.”Footnote 125
Humphreys’ detention in Mountjoy Prison between the jury disagreement in June and her second trial in November 1928 was mitigated by the supportive letters she received. One correspondent enjoined her: “You and your comrades deserve the highest gratitude from the ungrateful Irish.”Footnote 126 In a chivalrous flourish, he added: “I would do your imprisonment for you if it's possible.”Footnote 127 There were public airings of her plight also, including in parliament.Footnote 128 Her ongoing fixation with jurors is evident from some poetry she wrote while on remand. Addressing her mind to jurors who would try men charged with removing British flags from a Dublin building, the final verse reads:
The inclusion of the word “embracery” in a poem must rank as a world first. In October a circular was distributed in connection with her forthcoming trial,Footnote 130 as had happened with respect to the earlier trial in June. Seeking to arouse jury sympathy for “this young Irish girl,” the letter stated that her only crime was “love of Ireland, and striving, as Tone strove in a past generation, to ‘break the connection with England.’” Humphreys’ case was eventually heard in November. When asked if she wished to respond to the police evidence, she did so, stating that no documents were found in her attaché case. This departure from her usual non-engagement (and the fact that, as usual, she had to be found mute of malice before the trial proper commenced) was reflected in one sub-headline, “Silent Prisoner Speaks.”Footnote 131 Another unusual aspect of this trial was that several newspapers identified the juror who gave evidence of receiving the circular, naming him as Mr. Reuben Mellon of Rathmines.Footnote 132 In a somewhat puzzling outcome, the jury convicted Humphreys of involvement in an illegal military organization but acquitted her on the embracery charge. Judge Davitt sentenced her to 6 months in prison, but as she had been on remand for that length of time after the first jury disagreed, she was released.
Gendered Subversion
Much has been written about the conservative society that emerged in the aftermath of Irish independence, and of the concerted efforts of successive governments to confine women to the domestic sphere.Footnote 133 The women involved in the jury campaign were therefore not only subverting the administration of justice in a democratic state, but they were also defying its gender norms and expectations. Nor was the Irish Free State unique in its desire that women would remain at home as wives and mothers. Ryan notes that nationalist revolutionary movements that include and rely on women often marginalize them when their objectives are achieved.Footnote 134 Beaumont observes that many European countries, including Britain and Germany, promoted “an ideology of motherhood and domesticity”Footnote 135 between the World Wars. The fact that the women involved in jury interference were transgressing broader gender norms, not only in their intimidatory activities but also in their disrespectful behavior in court, may be seen in the extensive press coverage given to their trials, domestically and in Britain. Newspaper headlines often referred to their sex as an item of interest.Footnote 136 The Daily Mail Atlantic Edition, printed on board the liners travelling between Southampton and New York, regaled its readers about one of Sighle Humphreys’ court appearances.Footnote 137 The independence and disdain for authority of these activists stood in total contrast to the passivity and acceptance of male power that were expected qualities of women at that time.
The earliest jury circulars indicated that they emanated from Cumann na mBan. Leaving aside the possibility that the senders did not know that embracery was an offense and thought that they could openly communicate with jurors, it is also possible that gender was a consideration in branding the letters in this way. A circular from a women's organization would have been seen as less menacing than one coming directly from the IRA, and a persuasive approach may have been considered more likely to meet with success in influencing juror behavior. On the other hand, the receipt of a targeted message from a militant women's organization about IRA trials could itself be regarded as threatening. The arrival of the circular meant that a person or persons supportive of Republicans knew the name and address, and impending jury service, of the householder. A British newspaper noted in October 1928: “The words are carefully chosen, but the implication is clear. If the prisoners are convicted, the jurors are marked men.”Footnote 138
From 1928, the use of headed notepaper appears to have been discontinued. Instead, the circulars ended with “Sinne, Ghosts” (literally “We are, Ghosts”) or “Issued by Ghosts.” The “Ghosts” are referred to in the extract from Humphreys’ prison poetry reproduced above. Appending such a signature to a communication had echoes of the threatening letters ending with names including “Captain Rock” and “Captain Moonlight” sent during the agrarian disturbances of nineteenth-century Ireland.Footnote 139 Ní Bheacháin convincingly argues that the spectral imagery of the publications was particularly apt in the Irish Free State and conjured up “the remonstrating presence of a phantom Republic.”Footnote 140 In the context of Republican activism, the reference to ghosts might also have been calculated to invoke the patriot dead of previous generations; the martyrs who had tried and failed to bring an end to British rule.
The adoption of the “Ghosts” moniker may have been an attempt to create the impression of distance between Cumann na mBan, whose members were by this time being prosecuted for writing to jurors, and the jury campaign. However, if this was the reason for the changed presentation, it was not very successful, as the material issued by “Ghosts” was very similar in content and appearance to the previous circulars bearing the Cumann na mBan name and was clearly produced by the same individuals. Another potential reason for the change may lie in the perception that a circular signed “Ghosts” is inherently more unsettling than one identified with a group of Republican women. The transition to the “Ghosts” signature perhaps represented a hardening of the attitudes of those involved in the jury campaign, with a greater desire to frighten jurors into submission. “Ghosts’” enabled the senders to conceal their sex from the recipients, which had it been known may have reduced the efficacy of the letters.Footnote 141 There was official recognition that “Ghosts” was a potent device that was liable to induce greater apprehension than a letter that obviously came from women. A Garda report of 1929 observed of Humphreys: “It may be well to demonstrate to the public and to potential jury-men that this woman is the author of this vicious campaign, because the very fact that the offence has never been brought home to [her] has left people in terror of this secret organisation.”Footnote 142 In other words, unmasking Humphreys could neutralize the fear caused by her anonymous actions. Circulars issued toward the end of the campaign in 1933 and 1934 did not use the “Ghosts” appellation and were branded with the Cumann na mBan name once more.Footnote 143 The reason for this reversion to the original branding is difficult to discern. It may have been decided to abandon the pretence that the source of the circulars was an organization other than Cumann na mBan. Alternatively, the women involved might have felt that they could be more open in their activities following the election of the Republican Fianna Fáil party to government in 1932. If this was their hope, it was quickly dashed by the arrest and imprisonment of 513 Republicans between September 1933 and February 1935.Footnote 144
Gendered language was invoked by supporters of the women in their public statements about their imprisonment and trials. They often referred to them as “girls,” implying that ingénues scarcely out of the schoolroom were victims of heavy-handed treatment by the state. Referring in parliament to the imprisonment of Humphreys after her first conviction for embracery, the Leader of the Opposition, Eamon de Valera stated: “[N]othing that this young girl is doing now is different from anything which was preached…by members of the Republican Cabinet, some of whom are now persecuting her.”Footnote 145 In similar vein in a letter to the Irish Independent, Maud Gonne MacBride bemoaned the fact that “this young girl” (almost 30 years of age) was imprisoned pending her trial, “her whole summer lost in…hideous conditions.”Footnote 146 An Phoblacht also evoked images of harsh and unchivalrous conduct in headlines such as “Sentences on Girls.”Footnote 147 In an article about a police raid on the Cumann na mBan offices, under the headline “War on Women,” the newspaper thundered: “When the Black-and-Tans dared arrest a lady, all Ireland voiced a protest. Where now is our vaunted respect for women-folk?”Footnote 148
It is interesting that no denigration of Cumann na mBan members on the basis of their sex is evident in the police files that survive. On the contrary, it appears that their activities were treated very seriously. The police memorandum quoted at the beginning of this article describes Humphreys as “a very dangerous type”Footnote 149 and several secret reports emphasized the importance of keeping her under constant surveillance.Footnote 150 One Garda assessment stated the following: “[T]he title ‘Ghosts’ and the activities and attacks of the band of gun-men associated with this woman have terrorised many citizens.”Footnote 151 The statement that armed men were associated with Humphreys rather than the converse is significant, as it implies that she was thought to exercise influence and authority over them.
A patronizing dimension is visible in some of the prosecutions arising from the campaign. As was seen in the analysis of their trials, the women were recipients of “faux-chivalric”Footnote 152 comments by at least one judge and one jury, suggesting that they should receive a lighter sentence because of their sex. Such infantilizing statements in relation to women were common in Irish and English courtrooms in the first half of the twentieth century.Footnote 153 An attempt to appeal to the sentiment that women defendants should be treated differently in criminal trials may have informed the way that Republican women were referred to in the Cumann na mBan circulars. They were accorded the prefix “Miss,” whereas men listed as defendants in the same publications were given no title.
The opposition that Cumann na mBan encountered to its jury campaign from within the broader, male Republican movement provides another gender dimension. As demonstrated above, initially there was cooperation in relation to the campaign, at least between the IRA-controlled An Phoblacht and the women. One of the earliest circulars sent to jurors was reproduced verbatim in the newspaper in November 1926.Footnote 154 However, a letter sent by the IRA adjutant general to the honorary secretaries of Cumann na mBan 1 year later informed the women that the IRA leadership resented “very strongly the independent action”Footnote 155 that they had taken in sending anonymous materials to jurors. It may be that that the IRA was happy to publish Cumann na mBan appeals to jurors in a newspaper under its control but was less pleased with a campaign of contacting jurors directly with written circulars, which left a trail of evidence that visits by IRA members did not.Footnote 156 The letter from the adjutant general provoked a testy reply from Sighle Humphreys.Footnote 157 Sympathetic reports of the jury campaign in An Phoblacht in the years that followed suggest that the IRA ultimately accepted and supported the Cumann na mBan jury campaign. Accounts of the trials of the women involved were given great prominence on the front page of the newspaper,Footnote 158 and were evidently considered to have significant propaganda value.
Escalation, Violence, and State Responses
The year 1929 was a significant one in the jury campaign, as the IRA intervened in it with physical force. This in turn had considerable effects on the government's attitude to the internal security situation and, ultimately, on the legal system. By 1928, the government believed that conditions were stabilizing in the new state.Footnote 159 In November, the Republican Con Healy was convicted of the attempted murder of detectives. A “Ghosts” handbill was subsequently published listing the names and addresses of the jurors that convicted him. Describing the jurors as “degenerate and slavish citizens,” the flyer concluded with the chilling sentence: “Death would be their fate in any free country of the world.”Footnote 160 On January 23, John White, one of the jurors in Healy's case, was shot when he answered the door at his home in Terenure. Following the attack on White, the earlier flyer was amended, and the ominous words “Now in Stephens Hospital” were printed under Mr. White's name and address. The handbill also informed readers that the jurors from the Healy case were “spending their lives guarded day and night by England's paid gun-men.”Footnote 161 Although Mr. White survived, Albert Armstrong of Kilmainham (a witness in the trial of Republicans who had stolen the Union Jack from a building and burned it) was not so fortunate. On February 20, he was shot in his car outside his house in Kilmainham and died later in hospital. These attacks represented a hardened IRA approach to people who participated in the trial of Republicans. Previously, the organization had been interested in discovering the “name, address, occupation and general particulars”Footnote 162 of a man who had testified for the prosecution at Florence McCarthy's trial for embracery. The Gardaí were aware that the witness's life was in danger and took “the necessary precautions”Footnote 163 to prevent his murder.
The degree to which there was cooperation between the IRA and Cumann na mBan in relation to the attack on John White is difficult to assess. It is possible that there was no formal contact between the two groups on the matter, but that the IRA used the name and address provided in the initial “Ghosts” handbill to confront White at his home, and that Humphreys independently included the attack on White in the second version of the flyer. Official reports from 1929 show that Humphreys managed to create the impression that she had ceased seditious activity. In the middle of that year, her brother Richard told Superintendent Peter Ennis that “Sheila had given up politics.”Footnote 164 In August, a search of 36 Ailesbury Road by detectives uncovered “Ghosts” leaflets urging police and army personnel to defect from the Free State to the Republican side.Footnote 165 The Attorney General, John A Costello, was of the view that a prosecution should not be pursued in this instance, because the leaflets were old and police reports documented Humphreys’ “assumed cessation of political activities.”Footnote 166 It is highly unlikely that this was ever the case, however, and in December, Ennis was writing that she was “again active and will continue to receive close attention.”Footnote 167
On May 1, James Fitzgerald-Kenney, the Minister for Justice, introduced the Juries (Protection) Bill 1929 in parliament. The purpose of the Bill was to frustrate, as far as possible, attempts to interfere with jurors. It proposed to do this by reducing the transparency that had previously attached to the empaneling of juries, and by criminalizing a broad range of acts in which persons intent on influencing jurors might engage. Fitzgerald-Kenney justified the measures with reference to the attacks on White and Armstrong, the circulars being sent to jurors, and the actions of “certain women [who] go round [sic] the courts and make out lists of jurors and witnesses.”Footnote 168 In response to Opposition claims that the bill was unnecessary and was being pursued by the government for political reasons, Fitzgerald-Kenney replied: “[T]he ordinary decent citizen must be able to live his life in safety. That is much more important than that Miss Sheila Humphries [sic], or somebody else like that, should not run the risk of spending a certain period of time in jail.”Footnote 169 Informed by the speakerFootnote 170 that he had contravened a convention of not referring to people by name in the House, the Minister apologized, adding that he had only done so to rebut the Opposition insinuation “that one has nothing behind what one may say.”Footnote 171 After months of intense parliamentary debate, the Juries (Protection) Act 1929 was signed into law by the Governor General on August 1, 1929.Footnote 172 The Act's most radical departure from established practice was that it permitted majority verdicts.Footnote 173 It also criminalized the publication of jurors’ names,Footnote 174 stipulated that jurors were to be referred to by number rather than by name in all circumstances,Footnote 175 removed the right of accused persons to a copy of the jury panel,Footnote 176 and created a statutory jury intimidation offence.Footnote 177 Initially envisaged to last for 2 years only,Footnote 178 the operation of the statute was extended for a further 2 years by the Juries (Protection) Act 1931.Footnote 179 The Act did not stop Humphreys’ attempts to contact jurors, however. A diary for 1930 in her papers contains multiple references, such as the entry “Jurors, letters to” on March 16.Footnote 180 The police were of the view that with the passage of the Juries (Protection) Act she now obtained names and addresses from the Voters’ List.Footnote 181 This was a crude method of identifying potential jurors and on at least one occasion she sent a circular to someone who was ineligible for jury service.Footnote 182
Meanwhile, the government attempted to get the influential Catholic bishops to denounce subversive activity, including interference with the administration of justice. In June 1929, Fitzgerald-Kenney contacted Archbishop Byrne of Dublin, pleading with him to persuade his fellow prelates to publicly condemn seditious activities. He opined that “a denunciation of this class of crime by the entire Bench of Bishops”Footnote 183 would have a powerful effect. In order to convince the Hierarchy to intervene, the Executive Council sent it information designed to persuade it that a conspiracy was afoot that had as its objects “the abolition of government as we understand it, the confiscation of property, the destruction of the existing order, and the creation of a state of anarchy.”Footnote 184 In seeking to convince the Bishops of the social menace posed by various anti-state groupings, the government characterized Cumann na mBan as follows: “An organisation of women who give moral, financial and active assistance to the Irish Republican Army, whose activities include propaganda in favour of violence of all kinds against established authority…the terrorisation of jurors…and interference with the administration of justice through the medium of threatening communications and publications…”Footnote 185 The memorandum stated that, prior to 1929, a campaign to intimidate jurors “met with indifferent success”Footnote 186 but that the wounding of White and the murder of Armstrong that year “signalised the break-down of the jury system”Footnote 187 in political cases. Summarizing the effect of these developments on trial by jury, the memorandum concluded: “[N]o ordinary jury will now convict in any prosecution for a treasonable offence or in any case where the impression is created that the accused is a member of or is associated with this armed conspiracy. And so the criminal may go his way secure.”Footnote 188 The government also included copies of circulars sent to jurors in its correspondence with the bishops.
At the same time that the bishops were being lobbied by politicians, legislation was being prepared to provide for non-jury trial in certain circumstances. Although non-jury trial had been provided for under the Public Safety Act 1927, the provision had never been used,Footnote 189 and the Act was repealed in 1928.Footnote 190 The government now moved to remove juries from trials for subversive offenses and did so in a “radical and draconian”Footnote 191 fashion in the Constitution (Amendment No 17) Act 1931. This Act abrogated the constitutional guarantee of jury trial for non-minor offenses.Footnote 192 Persons charged with offenses under the Treasonable Offences Act, the Juries (Protection) Act, the Firearms Act, and the 1931 Act itself would now be tried by the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal, staffed by military officers.Footnote 193 The Tribunal could impose the death penalty for any offenseFootnote 194 and there was no appeal from its decisions.Footnote 195 Other offenses could be tried by the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal if a government minister certified that the offenses were committed for the purpose of interfering with the institutions of government or the administration of justice.Footnote 196 The legislation was defended by the government on the basis that the Juries (Protection) Act had not been sufficient to prevent the intimidation of jurors, who “even in face of the most definite proof, refuse to convict.”Footnote 197 President Cosgrave noted that Cumann na mBan had been heavily involved “in the campaign of terrorisation, and in the breakdown of the judicial system.”Footnote 198 When juries in political cases acquitted, their actions were celebrated in Cumann na mBan propaganda leaflets, a factor that must have increased official resolve to remove jury trial in such instances.Footnote 199 The Constitution (Amendment No 17) Act was signed into law on October 17, 1931.Footnote 200 On October 20, an order was signed declaring twelve organizations, including the IRA and Cumann na mBan, to be unlawful organizations for the purposes of the Act.Footnote 201
The Catholic bishops ultimately issued a joint pastoral letter that was read at all Masses on Sunday October 18. The letter denounced the twin evils of undermining a democratically elected government and propagating Godless communism. Most of the letter concentrated on communism, the popularity of which had been exaggerated by the Government in order to get the Hierarchy to condemn sedition.Footnote 202 In relation to the IRA, the bishops’ statement told its flock: “You have no need to be told that there is in active operation amongst us a society of a militarist character whose avowed object is to overthrow the State by force of arms. In pursuit of this aim they abrogate to themselves the right to terrorise public officials and conscientious jurymen, to intimidate decent citizens into silence…and even to take human life itself.”Footnote 203 The bishops’ letter condemned such activities as “contrary to Divine Law and subversive of social order.”Footnote 204 Republicans were well used to clerical condemnation of their activities. The bishops had issued a stern pastoral letter in 1922 that decried the actions of the anti-Treaty side in the Civil War, stating that they had “wrecked Ireland from end to end,” rendering “our Motherland, as far as they could, a heap of ruins.”Footnote 205
By December 1931, Humphreys was in prison again pending trial on charges of membership of illegal organizations.Footnote 206 In January, she was convicted by the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal of membership of Cumann na mBan and another Republican organization called Saor Éire, which the bishops had condemned as “frankly Communistic”Footnote 207 in their pastoral letter.Footnote 208 Never one to miss an opportunity of garnering press attention, Humphreys informed the officers of the tribunal that they were “members of the British Army of Occupation,”Footnote 209 who were trying cases because they could not find twelve jurors in Dublin to convict Republicans. The prosecutor was Cecil Lavery, who would later be Chief Justice of Ireland. He told the Tribunal that the only extenuating circumstance was the childish nature of the materials found in the prisoner's house.Footnote 210 The behavior of Humphreys and her female co-accused Maeve Whelan was so outlandish that it was once again picked up by the British press.Footnote 211 Humphreys was sentenced to 29 days’ imprisonment but was released, as she had been imprisoned prior to the trial. Although the charges before the tribunal did not relate to jury interference, the mode of trial owed much to Humphreys’ campaign of intimidation in the preceding 5 and a half years.
Circulars addressed to jurors continued to appear intermittently in the 2 years that followed. They were sent to jurors in Dublin in 1933Footnote 212 and in Drogheda in 1934.Footnote 213 The campaign was petering out, however, and there were a number of reasons for this. Cumann na mBan was becoming increasingly fractured as an organization, losing members and momentum in internal disagreements.Footnote 214 Eamon de Valera's Fianna Fáil party had won the 1932 general election, replacing the pro-Treaty government that Republicans had so despised. The new government moved quickly to release political prisoners and dismantle aspects of the Treaty that annoyed Republicans, such as the appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy CouncilFootnote 215 and the parliamentary oath of allegiance to the British monarch.Footnote 216 The office of Governor General was abolished in 1936.Footnote 217 The government also set up a scheme of military pensions for those who had been active in the national struggle between 1916 and 1921.Footnote 218 Many of the grievances that had inspired subversive activities under the previous regime were thus removed. The IRA did not go away entirely, and de Valera increasingly clamped down on the organization as the 1930s progressed, particularly as the Second World War approached.Footnote 219 His new Constitution of 1937 provided for non-jury special courts to try subversive crime,Footnote 220 minimizing the prospect of future anti-juror campaigns.
Conclusion
The impact of the Cumann na mBan campaign is difficult to measure. Prior to the distribution of the first circulars in 1926, state officials were complaining that jurors were too sympathetic to Republican prisoners and acquitted them despite strong prosecution evidence.Footnote 221 There were notable acquittals in political cases, including those of Mark Killalea in 1926,Footnote 222 Frank RyanFootnote 223 and William KinsellaFootnote 224 in 1929, and Sean Russell and Michael Price in 1931.Footnote 225 A number of juries also failed to agree when empaneled to determine if Republicans were mute of malice.Footnote 226 Such verdicts were loudly cheered by the anti-Free State press.Footnote 227 However, it is impossible to definitively link these jury decisions with the intimidatory tactics of Humphreys and her associates. Juror unhappiness with prosecution evidence or support for the political views of the prisoners were other factors that could have affected trial outcomes. The shooting of John White just a few weeks before may have weighed on the minds of jurors trying the Ryan and Kinsella cases. Although the campaign has receded from public memory, its longer-term effects may be seen in its shaping of Irish political attitudes to trial by jury. This may be seen in particular in the constitutional provision for special, non-jury courts and the decisions of successive governments that such courts should be maintained for the trial of paramilitary offenses.
Whatever its precise impact, the jury campaign was significant. Women planned and implemented it, despite at least some disapproval from the men in an allied subversive organization. When brought to court to answer for their actions, they were articulate, difficult, and unrepentant. Their behavior defied social expectations of their sex in an authoritarian and patriarchal society. The provisions of the Juries (Protection) Act 1929 were clearly tailored to counter the activities of the women, with Sighle Humphreys referred to by name during the parliamentary debates on the legislation. The campaign was covered extensively in newspapers, not only in Ireland but also across Britain. In 1929, The Times of London observed that the threatening circulars were thought to be “the work of some irresponsible women.”Footnote 228 When one considers its boldness and the prosecutions arising from it, it is strange that both the campaign and its female protagonists, who were among the most determined enemies of the Irish Free State, are largely forgotten today.
