Santiago Levy is well placed to write about Mexico's flagship anti-poverty programme, PROGRESA/Oportunidades. As its principal architect, and as minister with responsibility for its implementation, he was among the pioneers of a new approach to poverty relief known today by the acronym CCT, or Conditional Cash Transfers. Levy provides an insider's account of the origins and evolution of his programme, now in its eleventh year. He summarises its results, and reflects, critically, on the lessons that can be drawn from the Mexican experience so far.
CCTs were and are designed to overcome the multiple shortcomings of previous approaches to poverty relief, many of which were based on transfers in kind, as in the long-favoured food programmes. Levy writes of his frustration at the wastage and inefficiency of Mexico's previous schemes, which were blighted by costly and inefficient administration, and were prone to party political manipulation, local corruption and clientelism. Food programmes in particular were widely regarded as failing the populations they were intended to serve. In 1995 more than 75 per cent of the Mexican food programme's total budget was channelled to urban areas where fewer than 40 per cent of the poor lived, while 60 per cent of poor rural households received no food support at all. The lack of any remotely rigorous targeting mechanism meant that much of the transfer was captured by non-poor households.
Levy's anti poverty programme, PROGRESA, was introduced in Mexico under the Zedillo government in 1997. It was expanded and renamed as Oportunidades under the Fox administration, and is set to continue under Calderón. Today it covers a quarter of the population with some 25 million beneficiaries, making it the second largest programme of its kind after Brazil's Bolsa Familia. PROGRESA'S design was based on three assumptions: first, that if beneficiaries had more choice over their expenditures and became ‘active consumers’ they would no longer be stigmatised as ‘passive recipients of handouts’; second, there would be positive spillover effects such as increased savings and greater nutritional quality and diversity; third, there would be clear administrative and cost benefits: cash is more easily delivered than food, and can reach distant or scattered communities previously left out of the delivery system. Monetary transfers are centrally administered, allowing for more efficient targeting and monitoring. Once set up, the system is relatively cheap, as well as being easy to administer (most CCTs cost around 1 per cent of GNP). Finally, computerised systems simultaneously help to curb administrative and political malpractice and prevent multiple claiming by beneficiaries.
Beyond these evident improvements over previous systems, supporters of CCTs have been impressed by their other innovative features. In addition to providing measurable relief from hardship, they aim to accomplish a number of social and human development objectives. These are usually pursued as part of a co-ordinated programme focused on children that includes three related components comprising education, health and nutrition. Levy's innovation was to provide beneficiary households with a cash sum conditional on meeting targets for children's attendance at school and health checks. The transfers, often in the form of ‘scholarships’ for education, are paid to mothers, who are responsible for meeting programme demands. Here conditionality (‘co-responsibility’) is designed both to achieve behavioural changes and an element of cost sharing, with the time and money costs of the programme and the responsibilities for its success born in part by the stipendiary mother.
These combined features reflect two broad views in the development policy community: that targeted approaches are the necessary complement to prevailing economic policies; and that poverty and deprivation must be tackled through human development initiatives, and at source, in the family, so as to prevent the inter-generational transmission of vulnerability. The results of CCTs, in Mexico and elsewhere, have been positive with regard to children's rising school attendance and improved health, although other claimed spillover effects (increased savings, improved nutrition, women's ‘empowerment’) are less well, if at all, substantiated.
Improvements in children's well being are clearly to be welcomed, but there remain a number of critical questions about how effectively these programmes tackle poverty, either for the beneficiary children or for the households in which they reside. They suffer from three main limitations: first, that in targeting only the extremely poor they reach only a small percentage of those in poverty; second, that even though they invest in children's education, they offer no clear exit strategies for households in poverty as there is inadequate attention to labour market linkages or stimulating local and regional development; third, they do little to tackle inequality, which has reached unprecedented levels in Latin America. Indeed, by adopting a highly selective approach to social need, they risk exacerbating existing inequalities at household and community level.
Levy's book is a welcome contribution to the debate over the effectiveness of current approaches to poverty. He argues that CCTs should not be seen as the solution to poverty or treated as stand-alone strategies. Instead, he insists that they must be part of a broader onslaught against social deprivation and economic hardship that provides an integrated programme of good quality social services. In other words the current focus on CCTs as yet another magic bullet misses the point. Cash transfers may be more efficient instruments of poverty relief than their predecessors, but they do not obviate the necessity for radical social policy reform. Levy is surely right to state that if CCT programmes have a role to play in Latin America they should be treated as short term measures, supplementing more serious efforts to reform systems of social redistribution and economic development in ways that might finally deal with the region's persistent poverty, deep inequality, and social exclusion.
