In the wake of the late-November 2008 attacks in Mumbai, India, attributed to the Pakistan-based outfit Lashkar-e Taiba, one could hardly read a more timely and important book than Ayesha Jalal's Partisans of Allah: Jihad in South Asia. Though not an easy read for those unschooled in South Asian history, Jalal's effort to historicize jihad and give nuanced specificity to a concept too often misconstrued is well worth the challenge. In six chapters, largely chronologically arranged, Partisans of Allah breaks down the facile characterizations of jihad that have obscured rather than clarified its meaning and, most crucially, its practice. By elucidating specific campaigns labeled as jihads and engaging the interlocutors who promoted or critiqued the application of the term, Jalal effectively dispels the idea that jihad in practice is always a fulfillment of the ethical obligation as set forth in the Qurʾan. In addition, rather than marginalize jihad, as some have sought to do, or define it as solely a spiritual practice, Jalal places jihad at the center of Islam even as she rejects its use as a justification for violence: “Equating jihad with violence and terror makes a sheer travesty of a concept that, for all the distortions and misinterpretations, remains the core principle of Islamic ethics” (p. 304). Academics, journalists, apologists, and terrorists have all been guilty of erasing jihad's ethical core, and Jalal's effort here goes a long way to restoring the complexity and the integrity of the concept.
All too often jihad is explained as either a solely spiritual struggle against one's lower nature or as an unremitting, merciless war against nonbelievers. Thankfully, Jalal is a historian who abhors such imprecision. She argues, “Muslim exegetes, legists, theologians, and historians in different times and places have distorted the meaning of jihad in the Quran.” In response to such distortions, Jalal contends that “jihad is best understood with reference to the historical evolution of the idea in response to the shifting requirements of the Muslim community, especially in the South Asian context” (p. 14).
Thus it is all the more surprising that Jalal does not always make the primary sources from which she draws sufficiently available to her readers. Beginning with a thumbnail sketch of early Islamic history and the concept of jihad, in this section Jalal misses an opportunity to establish the Qurʾanic usage of the term. Instead, she makes a generalized assertion that jihad in the Qurʾan has “expansive, spiritual meanings” (p. 17) without ever establishing what those meanings are, how they were construed by the early community, or how Muslim legists in the Umayyad and Abbasid periods managed to redefine jihad as an “ideology to legitimate the wars of conquest” (p. 9). By not providing minimal grounding in the Qurʾanic language concerning jihad, Jalal's readers are deprived of a rich and helpful resource that would actually bolster her argument. Many books specifically addressing jihad in this period certainly exist (Firestone, 1997; Bonney, 2002; Cook, 2005), but if the core argument is that jihad is a fundamentally ethical concept as articulated in the Qurʾan and that the Qurʾanic usage is also the most authentic, then the reader would be helped by exemplary passages, such as 9:20 and 9:24, which enjoin striving hard in God's way by not placing any material possession or worldly attachment above the struggle to live in accordance with belief in the unity of God and the inevitability of God's judgment. By contrast, Jalal's frequent quotations from influential poets and philosophers such as Mirza Ghalib and Muhammad Iqbal are extremely useful ways to establish the rich and contested nature of jihad in Muslim thought, making it all the more curious why she neglects the source of the ethical meaning to which she refers.
Nonetheless, Partisans of Allah gains momentum as it proceeds. By carefully pulling apart the strands of thought that emerged from luminaries of the precolonial period, such as Shaikh Ahmad Sirhindi and Shah Waliullah, Jalal avoids typecasting them as (proto) Wahhabis or puritanical, if mystical, guides from whose thought emerged fully blown the modern Muslim extremists of South Asia. Instead, we see how certain ideas from these formative figures are drawn out by their spiritual and intellectual heirs, many of whom come to disagree with one another. Although Chapter 3, “The Martyrs of Balakot,” concerning the 19th-century campaign of Sayyid Ahmad of Rai Bareilly is somewhat convoluted at times (shifting between several central characters and back and forth in time), this is a particularly rich chapter and will reward the careful reader, as Sayyid Ahmad is put into conversation with the Indian ʿulamaʾ and tribal leaders of the period. It is also a fascinating window into the political and social turmoil as the realities of the weakening Mughal Empire and the double threat of British colonialism and the Sikh kingdom of Maharaja Ranjit Singh became increasingly apparent to Indian Muslims. Jalal manages to demonstrate the idealism and ethical underpinnings of Sayyid Ahmad and his associates, even as they were often dismayed by the pragmatic alliances and concessions they were forced to make. Jalal situates Sayyid Ahmad and his jihad, now idealized by some contemporary Muslims, into context.
In subsequent chapters on jihad in colonial times and as resistance to colonialism, Jalal continues to illuminate the variations in the practice of jihad and its interpretations in specific historic instances. For example, she documents the variety of opinions taken by South Asian ʿulamaʾ on the 1857 rebellion against the expanding British East India Company. In addition to the well-known opposition to the rebellion by figures like Sayyid Ahmad Khan, Jalal carefully parses the attitude of other key figures such as Nana Sahib, Fazl-i-Haq Khairabadi, and Maulana Nautawi of Dar-ul-ulum Deoband. These latter three all opposed the British in the conflict but with varying motives, rationales, and actual actions undertaken. In another example, the poet Ghalib was critical of the British, but suspicious of labeling the resistance “jihad.” Such particular cases of Muslims grappling with an ethical teaching in a trying situation provide object lessons in the contested nature of jihad and the ethical, political, and spiritual contexts in which its definition takes shape.
In the chapter “Jihad as Anti-colonial Nationalism,” Jalal sheds important light on a little-discussed period in the life of one of the most influential thinkers in the revival of modern Islam, Jamal al-Din al-Afghani. By juxtaposing al-Afghani and Sayyid Ahmad Khan, who took opposing attitudes toward British sovereignty but similar attitudes toward the importance of reconciling modernity and Islam, al-Afghani's pragmatism and tendency toward dissimulation are cast into sharp relief.
Maulana Maududi (d. 1979), one of the most influential thinkers of the contemporary period, also appears in a new light in Partisans of Allah. In a fascinating journey into his thought and influence, Jalal reminds us not only of Maududi's famous opposition to the establishment of a separate state of Pakistan but also of his less well-known opposition to labeling the Kashmiri conflict with India as a jihad. Probably a surprise to many of his present-day admirers, Maududi did not sanction Pakistan's support of a jihad in Kashmir as long as the state maintained diplomatic ties with India, arguing that to do so would violate shariʿa. In this final chapter, “Jihad as Terrorism,” Jalal focuses on the phases of Pakistan's development as a state and the shifting relations between religious actors, the state, and the military. It is here that the history of jihad and the histories of colonialism, militarism, and nationalism converge. Lashkar-e-Taiba is but one of the many groups that emerge from this vortex putting forward an ideology of resistance and of purification through the language of jihad. By placing such organizations into this broader framework, Jalal simultaneously demystifies them and undermines their misuse of jihad. Neither the Pakistani nor the U.S. government is let off the hook regarding these groups, and Jalal skillfully points out the conundrum of the vast majority of Pakistanis whose ability to restore the ethical core of jihad “runs the risk of being labeled both antinational and un-Islamic!” (p. 301).
Partisans of Allah is a welcome addition to the growing body of subtle and nuanced work on jihad—a concept both overexposed and little understood. Appropriate for any reader with a strong grounding in South Asian history and Islamic studies, this book demonstrates that methodological rigor in scholarly praxis may also double as sound ethical praxis in combating the misappropriation of jihad. Ayesha Jalal's close and critical analysis of jihad past and present is an excellent resource in the struggle to “restore [jihad's] essential meaning as an ethical struggle to be human and thereby more effectively combat the forces of disequilibrium that plague the contemporary world” (p. 19).
