Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T00:48:31.067Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Self-sustainment of coherent structures in counter-rotating Taylor–Couette flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 November 2022

B. Wang
Affiliation:
Departament de Física, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, 08034 Barcelona, Spain
R. Ayats
Affiliation:
Institute of Science and Technology Austria (ISTA), 3400 Klosterneuburg, Austria
K. Deguchi
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics, Monash University, VIC 3800, Australia
F. Mellibovsky*
Affiliation:
Departament de Física, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, 08034 Barcelona, Spain
A. Meseguer
Affiliation:
Departament de Física, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, 08034 Barcelona, Spain
*
†Email address for correspondence: fernando.mellibovsky@upc.edu

Abstract

We investigate the local self-sustained process underlying spiral turbulence in counter-rotating Taylor–Couette flow using a periodic annular domain, shaped as a parallelogram, two of whose sides are aligned with the cylindrical helix described by the spiral pattern. The primary focus of the study is placed on the emergence of drifting–rotating waves (DRW) that capture, in a relatively small domain, the main features of coherent structures typically observed in developed turbulence. The transitional dynamics of the subcritical region, far below the first instability of the laminar circular Couette flow, is determined by the upper and lower branches of DRW solutions originated at saddle-node bifurcations. The mechanism whereby these solutions self-sustain, and the chaotic dynamics they induce, are conspicuously reminiscent of other subcritical shear flows. Remarkably, the flow properties of DRW persist even as the Reynolds number is increased beyond the linear stability threshold of the base flow. Simulations in a narrow parallelogram domain stretched in the azimuthal direction to revolve around the apparatus a full turn confirm that self-sustained vortices eventually concentrate into a localised pattern. The resulting statistical steady state satisfactorily reproduces qualitatively, and to a certain degree also quantitatively, the topology and properties of spiral turbulence as calculated in a large periodic domain of sufficient aspect ratio that is representative of the real system.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch of the parallelogram domain introducing the new variables $(\xi,\zeta )$ that replace the usual azimuthal and axial coordinates $(\theta,z)$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Instantaneous fields of statistically steady states obtained with DNS for $(\eta,{{R}_{o}},{{R}_{i}})=(0.883,-1200,600)$. All panels show radial vorticity $\omega _r\in [-4000,4000]$ colourmaps at the intermediate radius $r_{m} = (r_{i}+r_{o})/2 \approx 8.05$. (a) The SPT in the full orthogonal domain of periodic aspect ratio $\varLambda =31.4$, with spectral resolution $(L,N,M) = (322,322,42)$ (see Supplementary Movie 1 available at https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2022.828). The white dashed line indicates the tilt of the stripe and of the minimal narrow domain that can capture SPT (solid red enclosure). (b) The SPT in a narrow long parallelogram domain $(n_1,k_1,n_2,k_2)=(1,0.2,0,4.5)$ with resolution $(L,N,M) = (18,322,42)$ (see Supplementary Movie 2). The solid cyan parallelogram delimits the minimal domain required for self-sustained turbulent dynamics and used throughout the paper. (c) Turbulent (i) and laminar (ii) snapshots at different time instants along the same simulation within a narrow and short parallelogram domain $(n_1,k_1,n_2,k_2)=(10,2,0,4.5)$, using $(L,N,M) = (18,32,42)$ spectral modes (see Supplementary Movie 3).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Bifurcation diagram of ECS in the small box of figure 2(c). Shown are solution branches of stationary Taylor vortex flow (TVF, blue) and drifting Taylor vortex flow (DTVF, red), as well as of DRW (black). White bullets denote saddle-node (SN), pitchfork (P), Hopf (H), azimuthal invariance breaking (IB$_{\theta }$) and axial-modulational subharmonic (SH$_{z}$) bifurcation points. The number of unstable real eigenvalues (${\rm R}^+$) and complex conjugate pairs (${\rm C}^+$) of some solutions along the branches are given in parentheses.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Distinct types of ECS at specific points labelled in figure 3. Shown are positive (yellow) and negative (blue) isosurfaces of azimuthal vorticity at $\omega _\theta =\pm 100$ for (a) TVF at SH$_z$, (b) TVF at P and (c) DTVF at IB$_\theta$, and at $\omega _\theta =\pm 600$ for (d) DRW at SN$_1$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Bifurcation diagram of ECS for (a) $k_2=5$, (b) $k_2=5.1$ and (c) $k_2=4$. Colour coding and labels as for figure 3.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Three-dimensional flow structure of DRW solutions at subcritical ${{R}_{i}}=450$, corresponding to points (a) A, (b) B and (c) C of figure 3. Shown are positive (yellow) and negative (blue) isosurfaces of (i) perturbation azimuthal velocity $v$, and (ii) azimuthal vorticity $\omega _\theta$. The corresponding isosurface levels are $v=\{-100,250\}$ and $\omega _\theta =\pm 1000$ (solution A), $v=\{-100,250\}$ and $\omega _\theta =\pm 600$ (B), and $v=\{-40,90\}$ and $\omega _\theta =\pm 300$ (C).

Figure 6

Figure 7.Comparison of (i) the streak field as signified by azimuthally averaged distribution of total angular azimuthal velocity $\langle V \rangle _{\theta }/r\in [-1200,450]$, (ii) the roll field, exposed through the azimuthally averaged azimuthal vorticity field $\langle \omega _{\theta } \rangle _{\theta }\in [-1000,1000]$ and (iii,iv) the wave field, represented by azimuthal vorticity $\omega _{\theta }^{w}=\langle \omega _{\theta } \rangle _{\theta }-\omega _{\theta }\in [-1000,1000]$, at $\theta =0$ (iii) and $\theta ={\rm \pi} /n_1=0.314$ (iv), for DRW solutions labelled (a) A, (b) B and (c) C in figure 3. Lines indicate the location of the critical layer (solid) and the nodal radius $r_{n}$ (dashed).

Figure 7

Figure 8.The role of the wave component in sustaining DRW at B of figures 3, 6(b) and 7(b). (a) Time evolution of kinetic energy $\kappa$ starting from either the DRW (solid blue line) or only its roll–streak components (dashed black). (b) Azimuthal vorticity colourmaps at $\theta =0$ (bi) and ${\rm \pi} /n_1=0.314$ (bii) of the only unstable eigenmode of the roll–streak system.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Onset of P-DRW solutions. (a) The bifurcation diagram near the saddle-node SN${_1}$ shown in figure 3. Line styles denote DRW branches with different stability properties: stable (solid), one unstable real eigenvalue (dashed) and one unstable complex pair (dash–dotted). The small black circles indicate the maximum and minimum $\tau _{i}$ attained by the relative periodic orbit P-DRW, whose oscillation amplitude is delimited by the shaded blue region. The P-DRW emerges supercritically at the Hopf bifurcation point H, such that the amplitudes obey locally a square root fit (grey dashed curve). (b) The $(\tau _{o},\tau _{i})$-phase map projections of upper and lower branches of DRW (bullets and crosses, respectively) and the P-DRW limit cycles (solid curves) for different values of ${{R}_{i}}$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Phase-map projections of trajectories issued from the unstable lower-torque DRW$_{LT}$ solution on the $(\tau _{o},\tau _{i})$-plane at inner Reynolds number (a) ${{R}_{i}}=392$ and (b) ${{R}_{i}}=394$. The represented solutions are CCF (square), lower-torque (DRW$_{LT}$, cross) and higher-torque (DRW$_{HT}$, circle) DRW solutions, and P-DRW (blue line). The red/black lines depict DNS trajectories starting from initial conditions taken by scaling DRW$_{LT}$ by $(1+\gamma )$, with $\gamma =\pm 10^{-4}$, respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Two stages of the period-doubling cascade of P-DRW as illustrated by phase-map projections on the $(\tau _{o},\tau _{i})$ plane at (a) ${{R}_{i}}=395.5$ and (b) ${{R}_{i}}=395.7816$. Shown are the stable attractor (black line) along with the unstable P-DRW solution (red dashed line).

Figure 11

Figure 12.Chaotic dynamics at ${{R}_{i}}=600$ in the short parallelogram domain of figure 2(c) $(n_1,k_1,n_2,k_2)=(10,2,0,4.5)$. (a) Phase-map projections on the $(\tau _{o},\tau _{i})$ plane. Grey bullet and error bars denote mean and root-mean-square of the fluctuations, respectively. (b) Time series of normalised kinetic energy $\kappa$. The grey line indicates mean kinetic energy. The colour circles/squares and lines indicate DRW, TVF and DTVF solutions labelled in figure 3.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Transient stages of the development of SPT in the long parallelogram domain of figure 2(b) $(n_1,k_1,n_2,k_2)=(10,2,0,4.5)$ at ${{R}_{i}}=600$, starting from a 10-fold azimuthal replication of DRW$_{F}$ (red bullet in figure 12a). (a) Time series of normalised kinetic energy $\kappa$. (b) Selected snapshots of radial vorticity $\omega _r\in [-4000,4000]$ fields at the mid gap $r_{m}$. Subpanels T1–T5 correspond to the points indicated in (a), while T6 is taken beyond all transients for $t\gg 1$. See Supplementary Movie 4.

Figure 13

Figure 14.An instantaneous snapshot of the statistically steady SPT state in the long domain at ${{R}_{i}}=600$. (a) A close up of snapshot T6 of figure 13(b) at mid gap $r_{m}$. (b) Azimuthal vorticity $\omega _{\theta }$ distribution in the $r$–$z$ plane at azimuthal cross-sections $\theta _1 = 0.5$ (bi), $\theta _2 = 2.3$ (bii), $\theta _3 = 3.1$ (biii) and $\theta _4 = 4.3$ (biv) (black vertical lines in panel a). Colour ranges between $\omega _{\theta }\in [-1500,1500]$. From left to right, the black curves in (b) correspond to selected isocontours with (bii) $V/r = \{-20, -80\}$, (biii) $V/r = \{0,-30,-100\}$, (biv) $V/r = 0$. See Supplementary Movie 5, showing a cross-sectional sweep of the instantaneous flow field along the full perimeter.

Figure 14

Figure 15.The morphology of SPT within the centrifugally unstable region of the annulus gap. Same as figure 2, but at $r=r_{cu}=(r_{i}+r_{n})/2=7.705< r_{n}$. Colour ranges between $\omega _{r}\in [-4000,4000]$. See Supplementary Movies: (a) Movie 1; (b) Movie 2; and (c) Movie 3.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Examples of centrifugally driven exact solutions in the three domains for $({{R}_{o}},{{R}_{i}})=(-1200,600)$, visualised through $\omega _{r}\in [-4000,4000]$ colourmaps at $r=r_{cu}=(r_{i}+r_{n})/2=7.705< r_{n}$. Here (a) $(n,k)=(5,7.4)$ SPI ; (b) $(n,k)=(6,5.7)$ SPI; (c) $k=9$ TVF (ci) and $k=4.5$ DTVF (cii).

Figure 16

Table 1.Statistics of several time signals (mean $\langle \bullet \rangle$ and root-mean-square of the fluctuation component $\sigma _{\bullet }=\sqrt {\langle (\bullet -\langle \bullet \rangle )^2\rangle }$, this latter corrected for domain size) of the statistically steady turbulent state as computed in the full orthogonal domain and in the azimuthally long but axially narrow parallelogram domain. The uncertainty margins correspond to 95 % confidence intervals obtained through stationary bootstrapping.

Wang et al. supplementary movie 1

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Wang et al. supplementary movie 1(Video)
Video 49 MB

Wang et al. supplementary movie 2

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Wang et al. supplementary movie 2(Video)
Video 6.1 MB

Wang et al. supplementary movie 3

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Wang et al. supplementary movie 3(Video)
Video 5.1 MB

Wang et al. supplementary movie 4

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Wang et al. supplementary movie 4(Video)
Video 4.9 MB

Wang et al. supplementary movie 5

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Wang et al. supplementary movie 5(Video)
Video 707.8 KB

Wang et al. supplementary movie 6

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Wang et al. supplementary movie 6(Video)
Video 6.5 MB

Wang et al. supplementary movie 7

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Wang et al. supplementary movie 7(Video)
Video 9.8 MB
Supplementary material: PDF

Wang et al. supplementary material

Captions for movies 1-7

Download Wang et al. supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 19.2 KB