In The Egyptian Economy, 1952–2000 Performance, Policies, and Issues, Khalid Ikram describes and analyzes policies and issues related to the Egyptian economy between 1952 and 2000. He focuses mainly on macroeconomic issues related to institutions, political economy, and specific features of the Egyptian economy; in doing so he tries to explain the ills that the Egyptian economy has faced and the decisions undertaken in attempts to solve them. To the best of my knowledge, it is the first such study of the Egyptian economy over this extended period, and with such detailed analysis.
The author's style and organization of the material are effective in presenting his argument. However, his sources and methodology change significantly when he discusses the state of the economy after 1987. In the first chapters, which deal with the economy during the Nasser and Sadat eras, he combines interviews with documents, which add a very interesting flavor to the book—a sort of political–economy and historical approach. For the Mubarak era, in a chapter that begins with 1987, he analyzes the data in a purely economic manner, not depending on any interviews or historical reflections, as he does in the first part. This change of style can only be understood as an attempt to avoid sensitive political friction; still, Ikram might have utilized some interviews to complement his arguments. Without them, the book suddenly begins to read more like an applied macroeconomics textbook.
Another major drawback of the book is the use of long chapters without subtitles; a clearer introductory map for each chapter could have been undertaken. The author's inconsistent use of the title “Doctor” for some policymakers in the first few chapters seems inappropriate because other doctors are mentioned without the title. One of the author's comments in Part I, on the constraint of ministries in policymaking during the Sadat era relative to that under Mubarak, seems to be more of a suggestive point of view that is not supported by any evidence. The book also suffers from a great imbalance in its use of graphs and tables, which are scarce for the period prior to the Mubarak era (the first table appears on p. 66). For the Mubarak era, on the other hand, tables and graphs are often more detailed than necessary. In some cases, Ikram explains certain economic terminology but in others assumes that the reader is familiar with them. Footnoted definitions would help.
The book is also unbalanced when discussing trade policy, the informal sector, and small and medium enterprises, all of which deserve more attention, even if the macroeconomic sections have to be shortened. In terms of the status of trade policy, the book might have addressed the services dimension especially, because it plays an important role in the Egyptian economy. Ikram could also have provided a thorough analysis of how trade policy has been used to serve lobbying interests and achieve social aims. A special chapter might have been devoted to the status of small and medium enterprises and coverage of the informal economy. Background material and literature for this is readily available; coverage of such issues would ensure that the book is comprehensive. Issues related to public finance and certain specific macroeconomic issues might be summarized more briefly without affecting the author's main thesis.
Ikram's scholarship is, nonetheless, sound, accurate, and thorough. He depends on national and international sources (such as national accounts and estimates of unemployment and poverty levels), which allow for a thorough analysis. His application of economic theories to the Egyptian economy adds an interesting flavor to the book. The author provides a balanced approach in terms of representing the differing views of foreigners and nationals and their different ideological takes on specific issues. In some cases it may lack the courage to comment on policies adopted by the government. The aim may have been to avoid political friction; such criticism could have been stated in a diplomatic manner, however.
Overall, this book is an excellent contribution to our knowledge of changes in the economic policies adopted in Egypt over the period under review. I can think of no similar work that has tackled the status of the Egyptian macroeconomy with such deep analysis while reflecting on the internal political dimension, social aspects, and external influences of donors. I would recommend the book to academics, undergraduate and graduate economics students, and certainly to the library of my institute. Because it is written in English—and because of its price—its audience may be confined to libraries of think tanks, major universities, and international organizations. A paperback edition and an Arabic translation would expand its audience.
