This volume represents the published version of the author's Gifford lectures for 2004. They are a culmination of several decades of work on the rationality of Christian theology, and the interdisciplinary character of ‘postfoundationalist’ reason. The work itself is a fine example of the kind of interdisciplinary conversation between theology and science that he has been advocating. In this work he takes on a major topic of interest for both theology and science, i.e. human nature. Van Huyssteen tackles the scientific issues surrounding palaeoanthropology, including a number of beautiful prints of palaeolithic art. He then brings this into conversation with the theological concept of human beings as creatures in the image of God.
In terms of methodology, Van Huyssteen advocates what he calls ‘interdisciplinarity’ as a form of post-Enlightenment reasoning, which draws upon the various disciplines (including humanities like religious studies) yet is grounded in our common human reasoning. Using terms like the ‘multidimensional transversal nature of human rationality’ (p. 41), he insists that our reasoning about any important topic must break through the various boundaries around academic disciplines. In terms of the substance of his argument, he presses for the importance of religion and the co-evolution of religious experience/imagination with other early elements like speech and art. Thus religion is an important and natural part of human being. At the same time he reviews the various conceptions of the notion of the ‘image of God’ in humans, noting that a relational and embodied understanding of imago dei fits well with his evolutionary conception of religious experience. My brief review will circle around two themes. First is the question of eschatology and abstraction. I then turn to the issue of a robust theological voice within an interdisciplinary conversation.
After reviewing a number of authors (e.g. Moltmann, Jenson) who follow a New Testament trend to locate ‘image of God’ language in Jesus, Van Huyssteen is concerned that locating the image of God wholly in Christ, thus placing it in a strong eschatological context, does not do justice to the fact that all of us are even now creatures in the image of God. This is a good point. There is a tension in the biblical witness between the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. In the New Testament the phrase ‘image of God’ is mostly, but not exclusively, used in reference to Christ. This usage, with Christ being the Second Adam by virtue of his incarnation and resurrection, does have an eschatological direction. But the Old Testament places the image of God more fully in the present. Yet in bringing together both testaments, we are already making a confession that Jesus is Messiah. This automatically involves us in a Christocentric interpretation of scripture. So when we come to consider these various biblical texts regarding image of God, it is only natural that Christian scholars will move from the present to the future, from the old Adam to the new Adam. Van Huyssteen's main complaint is that such a move can pull us away from the embodied human existence in the present and become too abstract. But he is too hard on abstraction. There is nothing wrong with abstractions – in fact science is impossible without them. The problem comes when we confuse our abstractions with reality. So as long as theologians don't confuse the promise with fulfilment, there really should be no problem. We don't want to over-focus on the Hebrew Bible texts and the present being of humanity, any more than we want to confuse our abstractions with reality itself. We must not miss the future promise of being conformed to the image of Christ and the ongoing redemptive-eschatological action of the Holy Spirit in creation.
My second point has to do with the importance of a robust Christian voice in interdisciplinary dialogue. Early on in the book there is a problematic call for theology to adopt an ‘interdisciplinary rationality’ in order to strengthen the public voice of theology today. Two problems come to mind. First of all, is there really such a thing as interdisciplinary rationality? Van Huyssteen does better when he writes of common-sense reasoning which interdisciplinary dialogue draws upon, as well as the more focused methods and epistemologies of specific academic disciplines. But this reader has not been convinced that there is any such thing as an interdisciplinary rationality. Yes, we do want interdisciplinary research, reflection and conversation – but this is not itself a specific rationality or epistemology. This conclusion becomes quite important when we talk about theology.
The problem I see in Christian academic theology today is a loss of focus, a loss of any sense of a robust theological reasoning that is grounded in the Word of God and the specifics of classic Christianity. By calling a theological method to embrace an interdisciplinary rationality, Van Huyssteen may only make things worse. One wonders if his emphasis on religious experience might signal something like Schleiermacher's methodology. Christian theology must be especially careful in our age to ground its rationality in divine revelation, and not in the more ‘acceptable’ areas of religious consciousness, comparative religion or philosophy.
The problem with too great a focus on interdisciplinary work for theologians can be a loss of a robust academic, Christian, theological voice. The temptation in religion and science dialogues is to speak of generic religious or spiritual issues without getting down to the nitty-gritty of specific theologies. This robust Christian theological voice does sound rather softly in the pages of this book, in his discussion of the image of God, but the work cries out for greater theological development. For example, at the very end of the book he writes: ‘This kind of disciplinary integrity means that Christian theology has an obligation to explore other issues that are crucial for understanding human uniqueness, issues that may not be empirically accessible’ (p. 325). What is missing here, theologically, is any developed notion of revelation and the Word of God. There is much more he could have said within the discipline of theology in this volume, and cut back on other parts of book. This alteration would have made this book more of a work in theology and science.
