The United States stands at a crucial juncture in terms of educational governance as Congress debates the reauthorization of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) of 2001. The law's mandated test-based accountability transformed both the substance of federal education policy and the historical relationship between the states and the national government. While supporters believe that federal accountability is necessary to promote educational improvement, close racial and socioeconomic achievement gaps, and improve international economic competitiveness, opponents argue that the law is an unfunded and unworkable mandate that stymies the creativity and flexibility of local teachers and school administrators. These three valuable books will help citizens, scholars, and policymakers contemplate the future of NCLB and the appropriate national role in school reform by illuminating the historical path and political dynamics of federal education policy. They are part of an explosion of research on federal education policy in recent years that includes Elizabeth DeBray, Politics, Ideology, and Education: Federal Policy During the Clinton and Bush Administrations (2006); Kevin Kosar, Failing Grades: The Federal Politics of Education Standards (2005); Paul Manna, School's In: Federalism and the National Education Agenda (2006); Lawrence McAndrews, The Era of Education: The Presidents and the Schools, 1965–2001 (2006); and Patrick McGuinn, No Child Left Behind and the Transformation of Federal Education Policy, 1965–2005 (2006).
One of the things that makes these recent studies so interesting is that they must account for why so much of the earlier literature on federal education policy was so wrong in its general prognostication that an intrusive federal education law like NCLB would never come into existence. Lee Anderson, in fact, acknowledges that his book derives from a 1997 dissertation—published only four years before NCLB was enacted—whose main argument was that “a law like No Child Left Behind could never be enacted in the United States” (p. ix). While the three new books vary in their substantive coverage of federal education policy and bring different disciplinary perspectives to bear in their analyses, all of them highlight the significant role that ideational, ideological, and institutional changes have had in the evolution of national school reform debates. The books by Anderson and Gareth Davies share a similar substantive focus—the early history of federal education policy—and are organized around pivotal legislative episodes in federal education policy: the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) of 1965, the Education for All Handicapped Children Act (EAHCA) of 1975, and the creation of the U.S. Department of Education (DOE) in 1979. Anderson begins his story a bit earlier with the National Defense Education Act (NDEA) of 1958 and carries it up to the present with chapters on Goals 2000 (1994) and NCLB, while Davies covers a shorter period of time (the 1960s–1980s) in greater detail.
Anderson focuses on the rhetorical debates in Congress around each of these legislative battles. His use of Americans for Democratic Action (ADA) scores and roll-call data to closely track the voting patterns of liberals and conservatives and the shifting nature of the educational coalitions in Congress is informative. The analysis demonstrates how the liberal–conservative divide in education was not as wide or as consistent during the period as is often supposed. Anderson finds that some measures, such as NDEA, ESEA, and Goals 2000, were passed with liberal support in the face of conservative opposition. Others, however, such as EACHA, the creation of the U.S. DOE, and NCLB witnessed a more complicated ideological dynamic, with many liberals in opposition and conservatives in support. One of his most interesting insights is the comparison of the EAHCA with NCLB. Support for EAHCA was bipartisan and almost unanimous despite the expansion of federal authority and the creation of a large unfunded mandate for states. Anderson shows how the power of the rights revolution of the 1970s combined with old-fashioned interest group politics to trump ideological reservations about the new policy. In the end however, while his documents how congressional rhetoric and liberal and conservative ideology on education have evolved over time, he does not sufficiently explain why the shifts have occurred.
Much of the answer might be found in the Reagan administration's concerted but failed effort to role back the expansion of the federal role in education. But unfortunately, Anderson's book largely skips over this period as it jumps from the Carter era to the first George Bush presidency after devoting less than a page to the 1980s. This omission is significant in a study of education and ideology for three reasons: First, Reagan offered a more explicitly (and consistently) ideological view of the federal government's role in education than any president before or since; second, this vision played a crucial role in Newt Gingrich's assault on federal education policy in Congress during the 1990s; and third, should conservatives remobilize in opposition to NCLB, it will likely be around the Reagan vision of block grants, decentralization, and school choice. Reagan's preference for local control and market forces in education—much like the Republican Congress's in the mid-1990s—does not change but rather is ultimately overwhelmed by broader educational and political developments.
Anderson's somewhat narrow focus on Congress and on legislative enactments produces a limited view of federal education politics, with insufficient attention devoted to the role that presidents, bureaucrats, and judges play in influencing the size and direction of federal school reform efforts. It is in providing this broader political context that Davies's book shines as he highlights how major changes in American electoral politics and governing institutions precipitated policy transformation in education. Davies also uses education as a case study of the growth of federal government power more generally in a way that makes his findings of greater import to political scientists and scholars outside of education. In the process, he also challenges a long-entrenched piece of conventional wisdom about the nature of American politics since the 1960s—that it was a sustained and largely unbroken reaction against Great Society liberalism. Davies uses federal education policy to demonstrate the “persistence and even growth of big government during a supposedly conservative era” (p. 1).
One of the most fascinating insights from the Anderson and Davies books is that conservatives often readily acquiesced to, and sometimes even promoted, the growth of federal authority in education. (For more on the role of conservatives in American political development, and in the areas of education, social security, and environmental policy, see Brian Glenn and Steven Teles, eds. Conservatism and American Political Development [forthcoming].) Anderson notes that this is because conservatives have always been torn between the principles of local control and efficiency. They have struggled to reconcile the desire to minimize federal regulation with a need to ensure that federal funds are targeted appropriately and effectively; he calls this the “federal control paradox.” Davies, meanwhile, emphasizes how the categorical design of ESEA and its broad distribution of federal funds created powerful constituencies behind federal education programs, which conservatives, like liberals, were eager to satiate for electoral reasons. He shows that while the vote in Congress for the original ESEA legislation in 1965 was overwhelmingly partisan—with four-fifths of Republicans in the House voting against it on state rights grounds—when the law came up for renewal in 1974, conservative opposition had all but disappeared. In the late 1960s and throughout the 1970s and 1980s, education emerged as a “motherhood issue,” and congressional Republicans voted overwhelmingly in favor of new categorical education programs and ever-larger increases in federal spending even as evidence cast doubt about the effectiveness of ESEA in improving educational opportunity.
Davies concludes that “initially bold departures in policy become embedded in the fabric of American politics, acquire a constituency back home and supporting lobbies in Washington, and become if not impregnable, then at least firmly resistant to assault. Conservative opponents can turn with surprising speed into conservative champions” (p. 2). While traditional electoral and interest group politics clearly play an important role here, one of the most important contributions of Davies's meticulously researched book is to show how much of the growth and path dependence of federal education policy after the 1960s is owing to forces outside of electoral politics. He demonstrates how the Civil Rights Act of 1964 led federal education policy to become inextricably intertwined with desegregation and rights-based litigation during the 1970s and 1980s. An avalanche of state and federal court cases based on the Act and the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment precipitated the expansion of federal authority into new areas of education, such as bilingual education, education for the disabled, and compensatory education. The key actors in these areas were lawyers and think tanks and unelected officials in the courts and executive agencies, and together they combined to produce a new, more coercive regulatory federalism.
One of the distinctive features of both the Davies book and the Kaestle and Lodewick volume is the way in which they frame their analyses with concepts (such as “path dependence”) derived from the American political development tradition and the work of scholars, such as Jacob Hacker, Paul Pierson, Theda Skocpol, Stephen Skowronek, and Karen Orren. Carl Kaestle does so to draw a conceptual distinction between policy changes (“changes in the federal government's actions”) and polity changes (shifts in “the institutions and procedures that define who will participate in education policy decisions and how”) (p. 17). He and the other authors go on to demonstrate how the two concepts interact in practice, with the increasing complexity of the education polity since the 1950s producing an increasingly dense policy stream in national education reform debates. The Kaestle-Lodewick volume is uniquely valuable because it brings together young scholars with a shared interest in school reform from diverse disciplinary backgrounds (education, history, political science, economics, and psychology) that employ a mix of methodological approaches. The chapters emerged from a three-year advanced studies fellowship program at Brown University, which enabled the authors to develop a common set of educational concepts to provide linkages across authors and disciplines—something that is all too rare in edited volumes.
As their title indicates, one of the central themes of the book is to distinguish between national and federal initiatives in education reform and to show how they interact. Standards-based school reform originated at the state level in the wake of the 1983 A Nation at Risk report but ultimately coalesced into a national movement that led to federal policy changes in 1994 (Goals 2000) and 2001 (NCLB). By contrasting the nature of American education at the middle of the twentieth century with the contemporary period, Kaestle demonstrates that “the growth of the federal role in public education represents a fundamental reorganization of U.S schooling” (p. 15). Nonetheless, centralized mandates in education have typically been difficult to enact legislatively and even more difficult to implement effectively due to the limited capacity of the national and state departments of education. In the end, he concludes, for federal school policies to be enacted and implemented effectively, they must be sustained by a national reform movement.
Substantively, the Kaestle-Lodewick book is organized around four topics: federal school reform policies, intergovernmental relations in education, the pursuit of equal education opportunity, and the public and private sectors in education. Douglas Reed focuses his chapter on the local level, examining how the “federal schoolhouse” was built in Alexandria, Virginia. He describes how federal desegregation pressure—even while vigorously resisted—created “bottom-up pressure” that ultimately enabled reformers to build an “educational policy scaffold” to advocate for improved special education programs in the district. Moving to the state level, Kathryn McDermott offers a fascinating comparative case study of the different approaches to school accountability reform in Massachusetts and Connecticut. She emphasizes how variation in local political context—and in particular the timing of accountability reforms relative to state school finance litigation—decisively influences the implementation of federal policy.
Elizabeth DeBray-Pelot's chapter demonstrates how the proliferation in both the number and type of interest groups operating at the national level in the 1980s and 1990s served to dismantle the “iron triangle” in education, challenge the status quo, and pave the way for major policy change in NCLB. Nora Gordon finds that local context also limits federal efforts to redistribute education funding through the Title I program, while Maguerite Clarke analyzes the initial congruence of state education policies with the mandates of NCLB and the subsequent effect on student achievement. Additional chapters examine Progressive era reforms (David Gamson), the contradictory rulings of the Supreme Court on equal educational opportunity (Adam Nelson), the nature of reform in black high schools (Kimberly Freeman), school choice and the blurring distinction between public and private schooling (Christopher Lubienski), and the evolution of preschool policy (Elizabeth Rose). Collectively, the chapters in the Kaestle and Lodewick volume emphasize that the education polity has become increasingly fluid over the past 50 years as established partisan ideological positions, interest group alliances, and institutional relationships have been remade—and have remade policy—in response to new understandings of the educational challenges facing the nation.
Going forward, Kaestle expects that the rise of education to the top of the national agenda will lead presidents and Congresses to continue to reinvent the federal role in education even as they struggle “in a federalist system in which states and districts can resist, renegotiate, and to some extent ignore federal efforts at educational governance” (p. 37). Much will depend, he argues, on the outcome of the ongoing competition between three very different models of school reform—standards-based, market-based, and school-based—that currently coexist uneasily in federal and state policies. “The polity,” Kaestle notes, “breeds entrepreneurship and initiative, which brings with it the risks of balkanization. The opposite risk is coherence through stifling standardization. Finding the desirable compromise is an excruciating, delicious puzzle in U.S. policymaking” (p. 37). Anderson, meanwhile, having once thought that an expansive federal role such as that contained in NCLB was impossible, now believes it is unlikely to go away: “Because it builds on such a deliberately negotiated and gradually developed array of earlier laws, No Child Left Behind appears to represent a permanent transformation of dominant views about limited federal involvement in schools” (p. 188). While acknowledging the growing opposition to the law in some quarters, he concludes that “a federal retreat from the law's high-stakes accountability requirements appears unlikely” (p. 195).
Taken together, these three books are a reminder of how much has changed both in the substance of federal education policy and in the ways in which this area is studied by scholars. They demonstrate how the field of education policy studies has been enriched by the incorporation of a wider variety of disciplinary and methodological perspectives that have produced more systematic—and generalizable—studies of policy change across time and space. All three books emphasize that federalism, ideology, and limited administrative capacity complicate the federal government's efforts to generate educational improvement in a historically decentralized school system. And yet school reformers must contend with the well-documented reality that the dynamics of local politics in the United States tend to produce egregiously inequitable opportunities in education. How American educational policymakers resolve this conundrum in the next few years will be of enormous import for the country's economic, social, and political future in the twenty-first century. As the country grapples with the efficacy of the new educational accountability regime embodied in NCLB, these books make a timely and important contribution to our understanding of how the country's half-century-old debate over equal educational opportunity has evolved and of the many complex and contentious issues that remain before us.
