The current trend of research on terrorism-related topics and suicide bombing in particular has yielded varied results in terms of accuracy and quality. Although there are many books from which to choose, only a handful are worth their cover price. Ami Pedahzur has written one of the best researched and cogently argued analyses of suicide terrorism in his book with the same title.
Pedahzur argues that leaders believe suicide terrorism is effective. Not only will it destroy a specific target but also, more broadly, they believe that suicide bombing will translate into political gains for the terrorist organizations that employ them. Pedahzur makes clear that this is not an Islamic phenomenon—it has been utilized with great efficacy by secular groups. “Islam is not the factor that explains suicide terrorism and treating it as so is misleading.” Nevertheless, unlike other studies on the subject, Pedahzur's does not go so far as to outright dismiss religion as fostering and creating a politically receptive environment for violence. However, he glosses over some of the Islamic debates regarding whether Wahhabism or Salafism permits the tactic. His discussion of the debate is found in the footnotes and not in the main text.
Regarding the upsurge of the globalization of suicide terror, Pedahzur posits that there might be a connection between the cessation of state sponsorship for many Islamic terrorist organizations by rogue states like Libya and their shift toward al-Qaءida. Yet funding is not the reason why groups shift tactics. Suicide terrorism requires individuals willing to kill as well as willing to die. Pedahzur points to a cult of martyrdom in places as diverse as Palestine, Chechnya, and Sri Lanka that has created a permissive environment for this kind of terrorism. To accomplish this task, terrorist organizations capitalize on the community's hopelessness and powerlessness.
Pedahzur also focuses on individual bombers, their commitment, and their motivations, including financial motives, personal revenge, and the desire to erase social stigma. He analyzes what makes bombers volunteer and provides well-documented details about the bombers themselves. He describes two ideal types of bomber: those who are recruited and those who volunteer. He goes on to argue that bombers are rarely high-value individuals to the organizations—rather, they are canon fodder for calculating leaders who see suicide terror as an expedient and effective tactic. More than providing merely statistics or raw numbers, Suicide Terrorism details the very personal stories of the bombers in amazing detail, drawing similarities across cases and across regions with numerical bases for the changing nature of suicide terrorism.
Pedahzur correlates suicide terror campaigns with various political events such that he is not merely providing a statistical breakdown but testing some prevalent political theories regarding spoiling the peace or the result of state coercion. In some of the cases, the correlation between policy and suicide terror is clear. However, Pedahzur avoids making causal arguments about the proliferation of suicide terrorism and exogenous political events or endogenous policies. Although life is difficult for many of the groups, Pedahzur avoids a single causal variable or overly simplistic conclusion. Suicide terrorism is a complex phenomenon, and he demonstrates its complexity.
It is difficult to ascertain whether the switch in tactics—targeting civilians, future potential use of weapons of mass destruction, or nuclear facilities—is because of political expediency or a change in the ideology used to justify suicide terror. Pedahzur includes an impressive comprehensive list of all suicide attacks for every country and region of the world, organized chronologically. The appendix includes all the attacks, locations, target(s), total casualties, and claims of responsibility to date. Pedahzur's study is a corrective of previous datasets that were often incomplete or poorly defined.
The richest detail is provided regarding the Palestinian case. In particular, Pedahzur draws on his previous research regarding the significance of network hubs for suicide terror and the key role played by middlemen. He details the story of the Hebron Soccer Club, in which eight of the eleven members became bombers—all of whom had been connected to terrorist organizations through the coach! He also adds that family and kinship networks play an important role in bonding individual operatives together, ensuring the mission's success, and reinforcing commitment to each other and to the mission. “In all eight members of the Al Qawasme humula (extended family), who in fact interacted on a regular basis, committed suicide attacks during the first few months of 2003” (p. 132).
There are only a handful of issues that merit limited criticism. Pedahzur makes clear from the outset that he writes about this subject as an Israeli, having known and taught victims of suicide terrorism and lived in a society under siege. He goes to great lengths to provide a voice to all the sides of the Palestinian–Israeli conflict; in his attempt to take a middle-ground position, however, he has avoided some of the more controversial events. For example, the author neglects to explain how Ariel Sharon's visit to the Temple Mount or Muhammad Durra's death may have exacerbated tensions between Israelis and Palestinians. These events might have also led to an increase in Palestinian popular support for use of violence against Israeli civilians. He likewise underplays some of the domestic variables that propelled Islamic parties like Hamas to win support among Palestinians, particularly the cronyism and intense corruption of the Palestinian Authority. These small critiques aside, Suicide Terrorism is an extraordinary piece of research and provides incisive analysis of the subject.
