In her 2000 SHGAPE presidential address, Elisabeth Israels Perry lamented that despite a generation of women's history scholarship, “Progressive Era historians have not changed their treatment of women as much as they might have.”Footnote 1 Attention to gender has improved since that address, but conspicuous gaps persist. Kathleen Sprows Cummings's study of Irish Catholic women's activism goes a long way toward filling some obvious holes.
New Women of the Old Faith examines the lives of four Irish Catholic women: Chicago journalist Margaret Sullivan; Sister Julia McGroarty, an advocate for women's higher education and a founder of Trinity College; Sister Assisium McEvoy, a Philadelphia teacher who lobbied to improve standards in the city's Catholic schools; and Katherine Conway, a Boston editor and prominent antisuffragist. Together, their biographies complicate understandings of Progressive Era women's activism in myriad ways.
Most significantly, Cummings rejects the common assumption that Catholic women possessed little influence over the era's social or political affairs. Conway, McEvoy, McGroarty, and Sullivan—like Jane Addams, Alice Paul, or Frances Willard—took active roles in reforming education, social work, and political life. Cummings attributes their omission from narratives of Progressive Era women's activism to a belief among women's historians that faithful Catholic women were limited by the patriarchy of the Catholic Church hierarchy and therefore held little power to sway the era's major social issues. Still, Cummings argues that her subjects felt subjugated neither by their faith nor by their status as women in the church. Conversely, their place in the church empowered them, but it did so in ways that most historians have failed to recognize.
The problem, Cummings suggests, is that historians have not been willing to grant legitimacy to alternate definitions of Progressive Era women's power. Looking for precursors to modern feminism, they have limited their sights to Protestant social reformers and feminist “New Women” who demanded suffrage and social, educational, and professional equality. Cummings calls attention to a different ideal: the Catholic “True Woman,” defined by her self-sacrifice, spirituality, and maternalism. The New Woman and the True Woman stood in stark contrast, yet Cummings maintains that both provided viable paths to female empowerment. Catholic True Women claimed that their innate virtues and purity gave them far more moral authority than the degenerate, self-aggrandizing New Women. By embracing True Womanhood—and by defining themselves as the antithesis to New Women—Catholic women garnered significant authority in church decision making and won the right to participate in church activities in the public sphere.
In positioning True Women against New Women, however, Cummings presents something of a false dichotomy. She does not substantively engage with a number of other ideals of womanhood circulated during the Progressive Era, from the “municipal housekeeper” to the “scientific mother,” ignoring their potentially significant relationship to True Women.
This criticism, however, is far outweighed by Cummings's many astute contributions to Progressive Era historiography. In addition to complicating ideas of Progressive Era womanhood, her study clearly demonstrates the centrality of Catholic women in the period's social transformations. Moreover, although her subjects may have consciously defined themselves in opposition to the period's New Women and Protestant social reformers, they were just as influenced by Progressive era trends. A quest for standardization and efficiency motivated McEvoy in her parochial school reforms, for example, and the journalist Sullivan understood the power of mass media to shape public opinion. In lobbying for a Catholic women's college, McGroarty established relationships with many secular proponents of women's higher education. Conway, even in her active opposition to women's suffrage, played a key role in the era's political struggles. Such evidence shows that these women are not on the periphery of Progressive Era history, but rather at its center.
Although Cummings's primary analytical focus is on gender, she also makes the case for paying more attention to religious identity in histories of women and the Progressive Era. Religious identity was far more significant than gender identity in informing the worldviews of the four women she chronicles. Stigmatized by Protestants and secular women in a period rife with nativism, they felt more marginalized as Irish Catholics than as females. They believed they could best achieve their goals by forging alliances with Catholic men rather than with their self-proclaimed feminist sisters. Even if it meant sacrificing some power, they saw working through the church, rather than the women's movement, as a more effective means to achieve respect for themselves and their fellow Catholics. Their activism was motivated not only by the desire to improve women's roles in society, but by an effort to improve the status of Catholics in the early twentieth century. By participating in Catholic education reform or lobbying against women's suffrage, Catholic women grappled with what it meant to be Catholic and American. They put forward their own definitions of good citizenship during an era in which that concept was hotly contested.
Cummings refutes the notion that Progressive Era Catholic women were anti-modern, oppressed, or opposed to social change. Instead, she shows them in a far more nuanced light, stressing the importance of taking such women seriously rather than treating them as anti-feminist, anti-reform stock characters. In making this appeal, New Women of the Old Faith joins Maureen Fitzgerald's Habits of Compassion (2006), a study of nineteenth-century Irish Catholic nuns working in New York's welfare system, and Anne M. Boylan's Origins of Women's Activism (2002), which examines Catholic laywomen's public activities in the antebellum United States. Like the subjects of these books, Cummings's True Women may not fit comfortably into prevailing narratives of Progressive Era women's activism, secularization, and feminism, but that does not mean that they do not belong.
