Over recent years, scholars have questioned the coherence of ‘popular science’ as a category of historical analysis. One concern, as Roger Cooter and Stephen Pumfrey have observed, is that the phrase conflates science for the people (sometimes called ‘science popularization’ or ‘popularized science’) with science of, or even by, the people (sometimes called ‘folk science’ or ‘ethnoscience’). At the same time, however, attempting to separate these two obscures the extent to which they are interconnected through domination, resistance and appropriation. More fundamentally, as James Secord has argued, the treatment of ‘popular science’ as a separate subfield within the history of science undermines the important insight that science is a ‘form of communicative action’ and that the making of scientific knowledge involves the successful enrolment of audiences. For Secord, ‘popular science’ needs to be reinterpreted as part of a wider economy of ‘knowledge in transit’.
In the brief introduction to Understanding Popular Science, Peter Broks devotes just one page to considering these fundamental questions. Dismissing Secord's analysis with the complacent claim that it ‘need not trouble us unduly’, he seeks to ‘reclaim’ the term ‘popular science’ as encompassing ‘a set of problematics’, but then makes no attempt to define it. Furthermore, while he concedes that it is an actors' category, rather than a ‘natural category’, and promises to show how it has been ‘invented, redefined and fought over’ (p. 2), he persists in using ‘popular science’ as a general descriptive term, which undermines the valuable design of uncovering its historicity. This lack of terminological and conceptual precision obscures the nature of Broks's project: what is it, exactly, that he intends to help the reader understand? Pitched at undergraduates in cultural and media studies, the book combines a somewhat schematic history of science in public culture over the last two centuries with a prescriptive model of science in public. The historical part helpfully links together summaries of existing scholarship relating to Britain and the USA, but without providing radically new insights or an analytically rewarding framework. In the concluding chapters it becomes clear that the history is intended to underpin Broks's prescriptive model of science in public culture, which, however, is offered in a very tentative and partial manner.
Broks's historical exposition provides an accessible conspectus of recent historical scholarship which should be useful to those in the disciplines at which it is aimed. Chapter 1 covers the early nineteenth century, drawing on a view I have recently propounded that the ‘invention’ of the notion of ‘popular science’ was a concomitant of the formation of the disciplinary sciences at this time. Broks discusses the ideologically charged contest for and use of scientific authority in the period and the developing role of science in the new print media, culminating in an account of the Vestiges controversy. The second chapter focuses on the rise of the scientific expert and the commercialization of popular culture in the later nineteenth century. This revisits Broks's own historical work (vide Media Science before the Great War (Basingstoke, 1996)), while registering the insight of more recent scholarship that consumers of mass market productions should not be dismissed ‘simply as passive consumers’ (p. 35, original emphasis). The next chapter deals with ‘Science and modernity’ in the early twentieth century, emphasizing the growth of expert systems and the increasing demand for public trust in science. At the same time, Broks observes, there was an increasing separation between scientists and the wider public, and the emergence too of new specialists in science communication. Chapter 4 describes the later twentieth century as a period of ‘Consuming doubts’, when the ever-increasing distance between the system of scientific expertise and the wider public led to declining levels of trust, but when popular science writing was more widespread than ever. Although not presented as such, the next chapter is also broadly historical, describing the debate over C. P. Snow's Two Cultures, the rise of the Public Understanding of Science (PUS) movement, and the ‘science wars’. Altogether, however, Broks's history is rather too schematic and unproblematized to be of use with undergraduates in the history of science. In particular, transformations are often described in terms of large sociocultural movements, such as modernity and postmodernism, and it is striking that certain important historical developments, notably in communication and education, are largely ignored.
The breadth of Broks's historical coverage does not lend itself to detailed analysis, and it is only in the final, prescriptive chapters that we see what have been his driving principles of selection. The lesson of history, he claims, is that ‘popular science’ – at this point, apparently, to be read as ‘science popularization’ – is a contested form of mediation between experts and the public, which generates multiple meanings. The practical upshot is that in studying ‘popular science our concern should be with meanings not information’ (p. 143). Thus, in Chapter 6 (‘Going critical’), Broks seeks to supplant the dominant (information-deficit) model of scientific communication associated with the PUS movement with a model based on the contested construction of meaning. Describing the emphasis on dialogue which characterizes the approach commonly termed the ‘Public Engagement with Science and Technology’, he suggests his own variant, which he designates the ‘Critical Understanding of Science in Public’. A final, shorter chapter offers a ‘speculative suggestion’ as to how this model would work, proposing (with an eye to the notion of the ‘agora’ in Nowotny, Scott and Gibbons's Re-thinking Science (London, 2001)) that popular science should be thought of as a ‘conceptual space’ in which meaning is constructed and negotiated.
Neither this prescriptive model of science and the public nor Broks's historical overview is analytically incisive enough to mark a significant advance in the state of the literature. Nevertheless, the book is both well informed and well written, and it provides a thought-provoking read for the historian, as well as a broadly based introduction to the history-of-science literature for those in other disciplines.
