When a leading theorist of agonistic democracy writes a book on Antigone, it seems fitting to acknowledge the accomplishment by contesting its core claims. Bonnie Honig's Antigone, Interrupted offers much to praise and is certainly a book worth reading, contesting, and interrupting for all interested in contemporary political theory. It demonstrates the ongoing significance and contestability of Antigone for democratic theory, feminist theory, and political thought more generally.
The book provides a model for textual analysis attentive to the debates of contemporary political theory. Addressing the reception of Antigone and its uses from Hegel through Judith Butler, its first part situates claims about Sophocles's play in ongoing debates and develops the idea of an agonistic humanism. The second part of the book develops a novel reading of Sophocles's Antigone, and demonstrates the contribution of those insights to current political theory.
Titling the first major section “Interruption,” Honig shows the significance of Antigone to the development of political theory and contests the dominant view that treats Antigone as a heroic dissident. Honig situates these debates in the context of feminist theory and the politics of lamentation. While showing the limitations of reading Antigone in terms of antipolitical resistance to political orders, she engages such interpretations as those of Lacan, Elshtain, Loraux, Butler, and Irigiray in striking ways. Her interruptions to canonical readings are meant to reflect the interruption to sovereignty involved in Antigone's own political actions. By distancing the figure of Antigone from the heroic prepolitical figure dominant since at least Hegel's famous use of the play, Honig interrupts the depoliticization of Antigone and opens possibilities for considering the politics of loss, family, burial, individuality, leadership, and judgment.
With this series of interruptions, Honig sets up the book's second part, which focuses on her fresh interpretation of Sophocles's play through careful analysis of key passages. By reading the play in its context and classical conventions regarding burial, lamentation, private life, and political demands, Honig succeeds in showing the contemporary relevance even more fully than those readings that would abstract from its context. By placing emphasis on conspiracy as a type of political action, Honig opens lines of interpretation for the play and questions of political action more generally. Her reading moves us beyond the rigid sense of opposition and reconciliation inherited from Hegel's reading, and offers valuable substance to a politics involving perpetually contested play of reconfigurations.
Revealing Creon's conspiracy with democracy, Honig shows the tension between Antgone's honor-based aristocratic view of individual distinction and Creon's law-based, democratic view of replaceability. Beyond the mere opposition, she shows the ways that Antigone outmaneuvers Creon's conspiracy with democracy, bringing to light the contest between individuality and democratic equality and informing contests within modern democracies on similar terms. The insights offered in the chapter are valuable, but they leave questions about the democratic character of “agonistic humanism.” Might it not be valuable to consider the “aristocratic” elements of agonistic politics and the possibility that these may offer a useful challenge to democratic consensus?
Powerful insights emerge in chapter 5 through an intertextual treatment of Antigone's final dirge as parodying Pericles, mimicking Creon, and citing Herodotus. Her use of the infrequently treated parallels between Antigone's dirge and the story of Intaphrenes's wife in Herodotus sheds new light on the significance of Antigone's words. When Darius offers Intaphrenes's wife the choice of one relative to save and she chooses her brother, he demands reasons. As Honig shows, the move from lamentation to logos requires Intaphrenes's wife to “calculate the incalculable,” yet Antigone does not give reasons for her choice because Creon is less politically gifted. The result of the comparison calls attention to “sovereign efforts” to transform “infinite loss” into desires that are “finite” and “governable” (137). By contesting the meaning of her actions, Antigone acts politically and resists the view of her actions Creon wants to impose, revealing its effort to force infinite loss into finite political frames and offering an alternative view of public lamentation. She thereby interrupts his efforts to offer a finite definition of political actions in terms of a friend/enemy distinction. Honig's Antigone neither succumbs to Creon's view of politics nor embraces apolitical lamentation, but acts politically between infinite lamentation and the finite demands of a city. In so doing, Antigone's actions and the play as a whole show the contestable character of any political resolution.
This reading, Honig argues, reveals the possibility of an agonistic humanism that is beyond the binary of “polis-dominated politics” and the “tragic” politics of “mortalist humanism” (147). Rather than countering an absolute politics with absolute dissidence, Honig's Antigone reveals the variety and contestability of political possibilities involved in what she, using Rancière's term, describes as “working the interval,” a political interruption to one set of sovereign claims. Agonistic humanism would find political possibilities between tragedy's infinite suffering and politics' finite constraints. The insights of chapter 5 offer the most potentially fruitful material for current political theory as they bring to light exciting possibilities for agonistic humanism by identifying the activity of politics with the continual play and reconfiguration of contesting elements and claims.
The theme of conspiracy further shapes Honig's interpretation as she reads the Ismene-Antigone relationship as one of sorority and conspiratorial protection as well as rivalry and difference. Reading Antigone as conspiring to protect Ismene's life and the secret of her initial private effort to give a burial to Polynices, Honig presents Antigone as a proponent of multiple values, Ismene's life and her own sacrifice, in a manner that resists Creon's forced choice and offers feminist theory a model for agonistic sorority. This possibility, more political and less heroic than the Antigone of principled dissidence, contestable though it may be, offers an opening beyond the dichotomies into which a Creon-centric interpretation would force the play and a valuable resource for agonistic politics. Beyond communicative rationality and strategic action, the performative conspiracy that Honig attributes to Antigone shows variety in the possibilities for genuine political action.
By finding in Antigone political action and claims to sovereignty Honig uncovers a resource for the politics of agonistic humanism and offers a significant contribution to the possibilities for democratic theory opened by aesthetic considerations. It might be possible to explore more fully the way in which such an agonistic humanism could be seen as consistent with a spirit of tragedy. Honig's challenges regarding genre and the occasional identification of antipolitical lament with tragedy forecloses the possibility of considering tragedy as entailing the very play between infinite loss and political closure of possibilities Honig describes. With fresh questions about genre, a fresh reading of Antigone, and an important contribution to democratic theory, Antigone, Interrupted marks a considerable achievement of value to students of ancient tragedy and all interested in political theory and deserves a wide readership.
