Lawrie Balfour's excellent monograph aims to mine the political thought of W. E. B. DuBois for insights about democracy that speak to key contemporary problematics of democratic theory and praxis in the United States and beyond. Democracy's Reconstruction parallels DuBois's method in his masterful Black Reconstruction ([1935], 1992); it reads his work, particularly his highly sophisticated understanding of the uses of the past and “the political importance of the way historical stories are told” (p. 6), in order to speak to the paradox of a moment in US history when racial progress has undoubtedly been achieved (as signaled most visibly by the election of an African-American president), yet tremendous racial inequalities persist and US citizens continue to evade grappling with the constitutive injustices of their collective past. As such, this book, as Balfour explicitly notes, is not meant as a comprehensive introduction to DuBois's political thought, but rather aims to mine his ideas (sometimes reading them against the grain) and methods in order to show how his work “makes a particular kind of political critique possible in the present” (p. 22).
Balfour acknowledges that DuBois may seem like an odd choice to turn to for insights about the present moment in US history, given the very different racial order in which he lived and wrote for most of his life. Yet one of the most interesting and thought-provoking claims in the book is that of the similarities between what she calls “the two reconstructions”: the post–Civil War era and the current post–Civil Rights era, both of which are marked by inadequate commitment to the material elements of racial justice; a failure to acknowledge the pivotal role of African Americans in securing their own freedom and enhancing the democratic rights of their fellow citizens; a willingness to privilege the interests and feelings of whites over the implementation of legally guaranteed rights for blacks; and a backlash against race-conscious public policies (p. 26–27). This will no doubt be a controversial claim for some, yet, as Balfour suggests, even if one is not persuaded by the argument, having to consider the implications of the comparison between the two eras already provides important insights into the nature of contemporary politics in an increasingly multiracial and multiethnic democracy.
The book consists of six loosely connected essays that analyze different themes in DuBois's massive corpus, by focusing on selected texts and placing them in conversation with work on similar questions by contemporary political theorists. Chapter 2 analyzes his retelling of the history of Reconstruction and uses it as a basis for thinking about how the idea of reparations might allow us to conceive of racial justice more fully in the present without evading the shadows of the past, namely, the legacy of slavery and its continuing effects. Similarly, Chapter 3 focuses on his nuanced account of John Brown's politics in order to examine the creative (and unreconcilable, in Balfour's view) tension between a renunciation of violence in pursuit of racial justice and the recognition that maintaining racial injustice is violent; thus historically, radical revolutionary acts have often been necessary to spur the cause of black freedom.
Chapter 4 utilizes DuBois's approach to autobiography and his conceptualization of racial identity in order to speak to contemporary worries about the delimiting effects of collective identities. Specifically, Balfour juxtaposes Dubois and William Connolly in order to show how the latter's inattentiveness to power asymmetries rooted in race risks eliding the very real costs associated with generosity and democratic openness for blacks. Chapter 5 focuses on gender in DuBois and the question of his feminism. Balfour argues that despite certain undeniable masculinist tendencies, DuBois anticipates many of the key ideas formulated by black feminist theorists, and she contrasts his attention to the way slavery has shaped black women's lived experience to the inattention to these differences in contemporary debates among white feminists about the proper role of motherhood in women's political identities. Finally, Chapter 6, which is concerned primarily with the international or global dimension of DuBois's thought, utilizes his “raced universal[ism]” (p. 133) to expose the dangers of contemporary cosmopolitan perspectives that do not pay sufficient attention to the racialized forms of power that have shaped the modern world.
One of the important contributions of this book is the way it grapples with texts that have not received the bulk of scholarly attention in the secondary literature on DuBois, such as his biography of John Brown and his first book on the suppression of the African slave trade in the United States. Another virtue of the book is the way Balfour explicitly grapples with the issue of canons and how they are constructed and reified. Scholars of African American political thought engage with DuBois's work, but this is much less true of political theorists more generally. Balfour critiques this kind of textual segregation within political theory that cordons off a figure like DuBois from democratic theory and renders his work parochial rather than universal. In contrast, Democracy's Reconstruction calls for, and enacts, a challenge to received canonical boundaries by putting him in conversation with contemporary theorists as diverse as Connolly, Martha Nussbaum, Benjamin Barber, and so on.
Yet while Balfour's text begins to suggest how and why political theorists might profit from an engagement with disparate philosophical traditions, it does not always live up to its full potential in this regard. There is a tension in the text between the singular focus on DuBois's political thought and the goal of putting him fruitfully in conversations with other political theorists writing on democracy. Some chapters succeed better than others in this regard. In some, the other side of the debate is not as fully developed as is the analysis of DuBois. This is true of some of the invocations of democratic theory; for example, how taking DuBois's reading of John Brown seriously would challenge the emphasis on the legitimating effects of deliberation in much democratic theory is an interesting question that could have been further developed. Another opportunity to more fully enact the kind of conversation Balfour advocates is the discussion of reparations. She shows why DuBois's work on Reconstruction points to reasons to consider the idea of reparations, but does not really address how whites might be persuaded to embrace reparations. It may be that DuBois does not offer many insights in this regard, but this is one of the key questions raised by reparations, and Balfour could have drawn on other sources to explore how white attitudes could be changed to become more supportive of public policy aimed at repairing racial injustice. Similarly, the weakest and least persuasive chapter is the one on DuBois and feminism, where a more revealing comparison might have been a juxtaposition of his arguments with those of black feminist theorists who were his contemporaries or with more recent debates in the scholarship on the experiences of black women during slavery.
These are minor flaws, however, in what is otherwise an elegantly written and well-conceived book. Echoing both Balfour's call to avoid thoughtless textual segregation and DuBois's internationalism, I believe this book will be of interest not only to scholars of African American political thought and race but also to theorists of democracy and those interested in politics in America (in its hemispheric sense).
