The computer is widely celebrated as a global universal machine, but the gender gap in information technology is going from bad to worse. The paradoxical tale of how this once highly feminized field came to acquire a distinctly masculine professional culture is the subject of a growing sub-field in the history of computing. In her important addition to this scholarship, Marie Hicks uses feminist theory to reframe the question of female participation around heteronormativity and thus empowers analytical alternatives to the triumphalist narratives of progress and innovation. With its emphasis on gender and labour, Programmed Inequality dives right into the core agenda of the history of technology and builds an articulate and well-supported case against equating ‘revolutionary’ technology with progressive values by documenting how computerization became a site for the systematic discrimination of female workers. Hicks's work sets an example of a creative and engaged scholarship that brings hidden figures and processes to light by integrating a wide range of archival and published sources as well as oral history and visual materials.
The book's argument stems from an astute combination of chronological and geographical choices. Focusing on the computerization of the British civil service from the mechanization of pre-war years to the spread of microcomputing in the late 1970s, Programmed Inequality spans the conventional analog-to-digital divide and supplements the US-dominated history of computerization. The book also addresses the operation of the modern welfare state in a significant development of Jon Agar's The Government Machine: The Revolutionary History of the Computer (2003), which reflected on the longue duréee interplay of mechanization and British state power. Not only did the modern state rise as a ‘data-processing machine’; quite literally speaking, its very functioning was predicated on the exercise of technocratic control over the lives and bodies of female operators.
The first chapter of the book describes how ‘girls’ were first ‘put into machines’. Before the war and before the digital computer, the data-driven state and business incorporated many office technologies such as punch-card accounting machinery and created a new sphere of allegedly unskilled or ‘sub-clerical’ work designated to young unmarried women. During the war, Bletchley Park, the cradle of Colossus computers, like most home-front industries, was an overwhelmingly feminized workplace, but the women's role was largely forgotten. While secrecy played its share, the cultural construction of female work as possessing little value was another, perduring factor. The analysis of institutional reforms from 1946 to 1955 in Chapter 2 shows that evacuation of the agency of female operators continued while technology was changing. A decade after the 1946 rise of the marriage bar, most women still left the civil service upon marrying. The British government created a new machine operator class and later institutionalized the so-called ‘excluded grades’, segregating female operators from the civil service's meritocracy. Hicks calls the discourses justifying this gendered hierarchy a ‘fiction of deskilling’: bureaucrats camouflaged the difficulty of female operators’ work in the language of emotion, for example describing the selection of employees to be ‘temperamentally suited to get the best results from the machines’ (p. 69).
Chapters 3 and 4 form the core of the book, painting a complex portrait of the long decade from the mid-1950s to the late 1960s. At this time the computer not only became a standard tool – over two hundred mainframes ran the central government – but also the very symbol of the government's public commitment to forge a new social order through technological revolution. Institutional rearrangements and massive capital injection into the national computing industry did not just produce more hardware. Automation came with ever-growing demands on programmers, operators, data input workers and systems analysts. Although this rate of computerization created more opportunities for women, female operators often had to step aside to make room for the male officers they had trained. But the government could not retain its male executive officers with technical experience, and the labour shortage was maintained by an artificial divide between operative and administrative tasks. The cover image of the book is emblematic of this topsy-turvy dynamic. The operator Cathy Gillspie was first trained to operate the Post Office's Leo III/26, but she eventually left for an IBM installation of the national electricity supplier – the very IBM 360/85 depicted on the 1970 publicity photograph. Hicks restores the voices of such individual women and subverts the meaning of this stereotypical image, which otherwise celebrates Gillspie's body shape and misrepresents her professional practice. In the process, Hicks reveals how ordinary operators negotiated femininity and work during the swinging sixties.
The final chapter argues that in the 1970s, the state technocracy made an integrated commitment to a male-identified ideal for computer work and to a centralized mainframe computing architecture which it imposed on International Computers Limited, the leading national company created in 1968. But this commitment eventually led to a failure: the country had to give up on competing with IBM and the shortage of skilled labour continued. If Britain's 1973 acceptance into the European Economic Community brought equal-pay legislation, it was the so-called ‘computer strikes’ that made the state realize how proximity to machinery gave a low-level, feminized workforce great power to sabotage governance. The civil service did end up preoccupied with its female computer labour – but as a security concern.
The strong causal argument of Programmed Inequality connecting the ‘loss of edge’ with centralized technocratic control and hierarchies of gender, race and class provokes some questions within and many more beyond the immediate scope of the book. Would better civil service job opportunities for women have saved the British computer industry or, to avoid the contrafactual, could we accommodate the heteronormativity and Cold War frameworks to explain the American conquest of international markets? As the British fertility rate declined after 1964, what was the interplay between the state's reproductive, migration and labour policies? And is there any relation between gendered computer labour and leisure? After all, decentralized home computing gave rise to even more exclusively masculine subcultures. These questions in no way compromise the book's success in bringing home a point of great importance in this age of Big Data: ultimately ‘computers need people’ (p. 17).
