Global historiography has long focused firmly on colonialism, but often fails to look to the modes and methods of imperialism that bolster the enterprise beyond the obvious workings of both hard and economic power. Miriam Kingsberg's groundbreaking work, Moral Nation, successfully enhances the discussion of how both thought patterns and the narcotics trade reified nexuses of imperialism from and including Japan.
The economic, ideological, and political roles of the drug trade in Japan's growing empire in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries are worthy of study, yet the field has proven woefully underdeveloped. Kingsberg's monograph, the welcome entry of which doubles the number of scholarly texts from the Japanese perspective, begins with the framing of Japan's imperial enterprise and the debate over drug use in the modern era, both of which overlapped with the acquisition of Taiwan following Japan's victory over the Qing in 1895. What Kingsberg effectively proves throughout her work is the complicity of multiple individuals in multiple spheres and arenas, across oceans and borders, who bolstered imperial objectives with contentions about the role of narcotics in defining Japan's role in shaping civilization.
In conflating narcotics abstention with civilization, imperialist apologists in politics, medicine, mercantilism, public health, social welfare, and research concentrated much of their work in Darien, Manchuria, and on the role of opium addiction. For all of these individuals, whom Kingsberg introduces as “moral entrepreneurs” (p. 2), narcotics, as both object and definer, became the cornerstone of issues of identity in Darien's cosmopolitan metropolis, regardless of whether these entrepreneurs decried the drug trade or utilized it.
Over the course of seven chapters, Kingsberg, highlighting the moral entrepreneurs' usage of opiate addiction as a metonym for empire, places the work firmly within the larger context of Japan's growing colonial landholdings on the Asian mainland. The strongest and most compelling aspect of this well-researched work is Kingsberg's analysis of how drugs reify methods and modes of imperialist philosophy, whether considered variously as a counter to Euro-American examples, as benevolent, as pan-Asianist, or as exceptionalist. For Japan in the Meiji, Taishō, and early Shōwa eras, building an empire was concomitant with building a nation, as Kingsberg notes early on, and thus, with a drug trade as intertwined in empire building as Japan's, one cannot simply write “a domestic or even regional story, but (rather) a global account” (p. 8).
Kingsberg's final chapter moves the work out of the context of empire, at least in terms of Japan's empire, and also away from opiate use. Returning to the home islands following defeat and occupation, Kingsberg's work considers the role of trade in and addiction to hiropon (Philopon), the homegrown methamphetamine, in reshaping narratives of civilization vis-à-vis narcotics usage and of moral entrepreneurial endeavors. The chapter, while it broadens the scope of the work, could easily stand alone as a separate article, or the first chapter in a future monograph.
Kingsberg's work, while innovative, is not without its limitations. In adopting sociologist Howard S. Becker's definition of “moral entrepreneurs,” Kingsberg construes the moral entrepreneur as one who defined behavior and sought to codify moral rectitude, although she does not state outright that she is doing so. In this view, “entrepreneurship” is limited solely to conducting moral stratagems. Both Becker and, by extension, Kingsberg consider entrepreneurship to consist of moralistic appeals and campaigns, the activities of moral crusaders, rather than a matter of enterprise, an activity that mediates two sides. This is not, however, the only current definition of the term. In fact, the concept was altered by Jack E. Nelson, whose work on the Salvation Army's efforts against the prostitution trade and alcohol consumption in Japan established a wider definition. Nelson's moral entrepreneurs sought to alter a nation's moral consideration of an issue, while crucially selling the work to donors abroad.Footnote 14 This view considers not merely moral exhortation but the sale of a stratagem to two equal parties, in this case Japan's government and foreign donors. By often overlooking the mediatory potential of her term, Kingsberg foregoes an opportunity to explore the other party to whom her moral entrepreneurs were selling their work. While she provides the reader with a fascinating exploration of the entrepreneurs themselves, it remains unclear with whom they also engaged, or how presumably serving two or more masters with at least partially divergent interests affected their strategy.
This aspect notwithstanding, Moral Nation is a far-reaching and scholarly study of a too often overlooked facet of global and colonial history. By highlighting the profitable and unsavory aspects of national interests, which often undergirded empire, Kingsberg's work provides explanations of Japan's imperial enterprise beyond the march of militarism.
