Emily Wilcox's remarkable book, Revolutionary Bodies: Chinese Dance and the Socialist Legacy, fills an enormous vacancy in English-language historiographies of Chinese dance. Not only does it cover a key period in Chinese dance history, in fact, it offers English readers a crucial definition of Chinese dance itself as a distinct genre. Spanning the Second Sino–Japanese War (1937–45) to the early twenty-first century, Revolutionary Bodies follows the development of this dance genre as it paralleled the building of the modern Chinese socialist nation-state. Drawing on exhaustive primary-language research both ethnographic and archival, as well as thoughtful participant observation and detailed movement analysis, this monograph is a gargantuan contribution to dance scholarship and to Chinese studies. The book offers a diverse and nuanced portrayal of Chinese dance in the People's Republic of China by expanding our limited Western understandings of Chinese dance as comprised only of either the “divine and ancient” shenyun variety or the revolutionary ballets of the Cultural Revolution. As Wilcox describes it, Revolutionary Bodies “narrates the development of Chinese dance as a complex cultural phenomenon that transcends simplistic dichotomies between personal and collective, hegemonic and resistive, traditional and contemporary, or embodied and conceptual” (4).
Wilcox's main argument about Chinese dance is that across its development from the 1930s, through the Civil War, the early Mao era, and the Cultural Revolution, to the postsocialist period and the twenty-first century, Chinese dance has consistently maintained three core commitments: “kinesthetic nationalism,” “ethnic and spatial inclusiveness,” and “dynamic inheritance” (6). Moving chronologically across her chapters, via detailed analyses of numerous works (and conveniently inclusive of QR-code access to video recordings of many of the pieces discussed), Wilcox demonstrates how these commitments manifest. By “kinesthetic nationalism” she means that Chinese dance is determined by aesthetic form more than merely thematic content or where or by whom it is performed. Early pioneers emphasized the importance of developing a genre that was formally specific to Chinese culture rather than derivative of Western forms like ballet or modern dance. “Ethnic and spatial inclusivity” refers to the fact that, from its beginnings, Chinese dance has drawn from the wide ethnic and regional expanse that makes up the modern Chinese nation-state, from Uighurs in the Xinjiang region to Dai peoples in Yunnan. Finally, and this is Wilcox's most important argument, by “dynamic inheritance” she means that Chinese dance is a construct; it is a multifaceted, continually evolving complex made up of inherited traditions (actively researched by Chinese dance scholars and choreographers) mixed with creative innovation.
Chapter 1 covers the Chinese Republican Era from the Second Sino–Japanese War up to the founding of the PRC. Wilcox centers her investigation on the key figure of Dai Ailian. As a Trinidad-born overseas Chinese educated in Great Britain, Dai exemplifies the ways that ethnic and spatial inclusivity are at the roots of Chinese dance. This chapter chronicles the crucial moment when Dai's research in Chinese folk forms prevailed over other artists’ use of ballet and modern in their work, which thus cemented kinesthetic nationalism as a cornerstone of Chinese dance. Chapter 2 studies the educational institutions established during the formation of the PRC, particularly the Beijing Dance School (now the Beijing Dance Academy) in 1954. These schools were essential in developing and sustaining Chinese dance as a national form. The chapter especially explores the contributions of Choe Seung-hui, a Korean dancer who pioneered what is now called Chinese classical dance by helping to assemble and teach a new Chinese dance curriculum drawn from the movements of Chinese opera. Chapter 3 debunks the notion that the Communist China of the 1950s and 1960s was isolated from the world. Wilcox chronicles the circulation of Chinese dance at international socialist arts festivals and the emergence of Chinese socialist dance dramas during what she terms a golden age of Chinese dance. In Chapter 4, Wilcox challenges prevailing misconceptions that the revolutionary ballets of the Cultural Revolution were a natural outgrowth of the forms of dance that predominated in the early PRC. In fact, when the authoritarian architects of the Cultural Revolution effectively banned all but eight so-called model operas and two ballets, this was a distinct departure from the decades of robust cultivation of native Chinese movement forms that came before 1966. Finally, Chapter 5 covers the post-Mao era of the 1970s and 1980s, and Chapter 6 moves into the early twenty-first century. Both chapters recount the return to a preference for Chinese dance, even as choreography expanded to include more commercially focused output as well as experimental work. In these last two chapters Wilcox affirms the continuing presence of the three core commitments in the contemporary moment by emphasizing Chinese dance as always both a self-consciously nationalist project and a practice of constant renewal and invention. In the final pages of the book, Wilcox attends to the question embedded in her subtitle, Chinese Dance and the Socialist Legacy, by arguing for a more complex picture of Chinese socialist culture beyond equivalences with the Cultural Revolution: “Recognizing the redness of Chinese dance is not only about setting right the historical record; it also means dismantling monolithic conceptions of Chinese socialist culture and admitting the aesthetic and political multiplicities that coexist within this legacy” (214).
Revolutionary Bodies is an accessible, clearly written, extensively researched book. Wilcox definitively accomplishes her aim to assert the relevance of Chinese dance as a genre on par with other global concert dance forms, as well as a discipline equally worthy of study in comparison to Chinese literature, visual art, or film. Furthermore, the book nuances an understanding of Chinese dance by emphasizing its panethnic inclusiveness, internationalist roots, and inventive qualities. My only small, lingering question about the book is its relative silence on the politics of Chinese dance as a tool of Chinese nationalism. It is not that Wilcox is not explicit about the nature of the form as a nationalist project. It is that she is so matter of fact about this while also avoiding exploring the potential marginalizations, resistances, compromises, or suppressions that might have occurred in service to the nationalist imperative. And she is careful to not use the term “propaganda” even once throughout the entire book. In her last chapter, Wilcox explores an experimental dance work that draws its plot from the 1988 Hong Kong film Rouge and 1984 novella of the same name, both of which are widely viewed as expressions of anxiety about the impending 1997 handover of Hong Kong to China. Wilcox is judicious, however, to discuss the 2002 dance iteration of Rouge mostly in terms of its aesthetic innovations to the classical Chinese dance form and as a piece about generalized nostalgia. Likewise, in her discussion of the piece Fat Tang Thin Song (2013) Wilcox tells us that the contemporary figure in the piece, who stands apart from the action of the other dancers in period costume, offers a way to bridge the historical characters to the present, that is, presumably, to see them as an analogy for contemporary concerns. Wilcox skillfully sidesteps an elucidation of what those concerns might be. I am wary of replicating the tendency of Western scholars always to be looking for political critique in every work of contemporary Chinese art; this tendency is filled with its own prejudices. And, of course, I recognize that Revolutionary Bodies is a major contribution to Chinese dance scholarship, so its acceptability to mainland Chinese scholars is paramount. Wilcox demonstrates impressive tact in respecting Chinese dance on its own terms. Ultimately, Revolutionary Bodies makes an incredible mark on the disciplines of dance studies and Chinese cultural studies. Wilcox's scholarship is a model of thorough research, accessible writing, and sharp argumentation. More important, it introduces us to the field of Chinese dance by following its birth and growth in concert with the dynamics of contemporary Chinese history and offering us a complex picture of an important world genre.
