Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T02:59:43.164Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Drag model from interface-resolved simulations of particle sedimentation in a periodic domain and vertical turbulent channel flows

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 June 2022

Yan Xia
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems, Department of Mechanics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, PR China
Zhaosheng Yu*
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems, Department of Mechanics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, PR China
Dingyi Pan
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems, Department of Mechanics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, PR China
Zhaowu Lin
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems, Department of Mechanics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, PR China
Yu Guo
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems, Department of Mechanics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: yuzhaosheng@zju.edu.cn

Abstract

A drag correlation is established for laminar particle-laden flows, based on data from the interfaced-resolved direct numerical simulations (IR-DNS) of particle sedimentation in a periodic domain at density ratio ranging from 2 to 1000, particle concentration ranging from 0.59 % to 14.16 %, and particle Reynolds number below 132. Our drag decreases slightly with increasing density ratio when the other parameters are fixed. The drag correlation is then corrected to account for the turbulence effect by introducing the relative turbulent kinetic energy, from the IR-DNS data of the upward turbulent channel flows laden with the particles larger than the Kolmogorov length scale at relatively low particle volume fractions. A drift velocity model is developed to obtain the effective slip velocity from the interphase mean velocity difference for the vertical turbulent channel flow by considering the effects of particle inertia, particle concentration distribution and large-scale streamwise vortices.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Computed drag coefficients $C_d$ for a sphere settling in a periodic domain at different grid resolutions, as compared to the standard drag coefficient.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Comparison of the present simulation and the previous experimental and numerical results (Lomholt, Stenum & Maxey 2002) for a sphere rising in an inclined channel at $Re_p^{Stokes} = 13.6$: (a) sphere trajectory, (b) velocity in the upward direction, and (c) velocity in the lateral direction. The position is normalized with the channel half-width, and the velocity is normalized with the Stokes settling velocity. The vertical dashed line denotes the position where the particle touches the wall.

Figure 2

Table 1.Summary of the simulation settings used for IR-DNS of fixed beds of spheres. Here, $\phi =N_p {\rm \pi}d_p^3/(6L^3)$ is the solid volume fraction.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Comparison of the present drags with the previous drag correlations (Beetstra et al.2007; Tenneti et al.2011; Zaidi et al.2014; Bogner et al.2015; Tang et al.2015) and the previous IR-DNS results (Akiki et al.2016; Seyed-Ahmadi & Wachs 2020). Each data point of our work is obtained with five different realizations.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Sketches of the particle sedimentation in a fully periodic domain for three different particle volume fractions: (a) $\phi = 0.59\,\%$, (b) $\phi = 2.36\,\%$, and (c) $\phi = 14.16\,\%$.

Figure 5

Table 2.Simulation settings for particles settling in a fully periodic domain, where $N_p$ is the particle number, and $\phi$ is the particle volume fraction.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Average drag $F_D$ normalized with ${\rho _f}{\nu ^2}/d_p^3$ as a function of the particle Reynolds number $Re_p$ for (a) $\phi =0.59\,\%$, (b) $\phi =2.36\,\%$, and (c) $\phi =14.16\,\%$. The existing drag correlations (Wen & Yu 1966; Beetstra et al.2007; Mazzei & Lettieri 2007; Tavanashad et al.2021) are also shown for comparison.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Normalized granular temperature $T/u_s^2$ as a function of density ratio $\rho _r$ for (a) $\phi =0.59\,\%$, (b) $\phi =2.36\,\%$, and (c) $\phi =14.16\,\%$.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Two-point autocorrelations of the fluid velocity fluctuations (a) $R_{uu}$ and (b) $R_{ww}$ computed for two different computational domain sizes at $Ga=7.3$ and $24.3$, and $(\rho _r,\phi )=(2.0,2.36\,\%)$.

Figure 9

Table 3.Comparison of the particle Reynolds number $Re_p$ relative to particle-induced turbulent kinetic energy $(k/u_s^2)$ and particle granular temperature $T/u_s^2$ for different domain sizes.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Momentum transfer coefficient $\beta$ normalized with ${\rho _f}{\nu }/d_p^2$ versus normalized granular temperature $T/u_s^2$ for (a) $\phi =2.36\,\%$, (b) $\phi =14.16\,\%$, and versus density ratio for (c) $\phi =2.36\,\%$, (d) $\phi =14.16\,\%$. Note that for each $Ga$, the points (marked by symbols) from left to right correspond to the density ratios changing from 1000 to 2 in (a,b).

Figure 11

Figure 9.Relative differences between the drag forces obtained from the new drag correlation (3.11) and the DNS for (a) $\phi =0.59\,\%$, (b) $\phi =2.36\,\%$, and (c) $\phi =14.16\,\%$. Here, $\Delta F/{F_{DNS}} = ({F_{D,MOD}} - {F_{D,DNS}})/{F_{D,DNS}}$.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Pair distribution functions $P(r,\theta )$ for (a–d) $\phi =2.36\,\%$ and (e–h) $\phi =14.16\,\%$, at $\rho _r=2.0$. The Galileo numbers are $Ga=7.3$, 24.3, 48.5, 72.7 from left to right.

Figure 13

Figure 11.Pair distribution functions $P(r,\theta )$ for (a) $(\rho _r, \phi )=(10, 2.36\,\%)$, (b) $(\rho _r, \phi )=(100, 2.36\,\%)$, (d) $(\rho _r, \phi )=(100, 14.16\,\%)$, and (e) $(\rho _r, \phi )=(1000, 14.16\,\%)$, at $Ga=24.3$, and radial distribution functions $g(r)$ for (c) $\phi =2.36\,\%$, and (f) $\phi =14.16\,\%$, at $Ga=24.3$.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Schematic diagram of the upward particle-laden channel flow studied by Yu et al. (2021), where $x$, $y$ and $z$ represent the streamwise, transverse and spanwise coordinates, respectively.

Figure 15

Table 4.Physical and computational parameters of the DNS database for the particle-laden flows (Yu et al.2021). Here, $a$ is the particle radius, $N_p$ is the total number of particles, and $\phi _{{0}}$ is the mean particle volume fraction in the whole channel.

Figure 16

Figure 13.(a) Two-dimensional schematic diagram of the computational model for the relative mean velocity; $\delta r$ is the distance between the shell and the particle surface, and $\varDelta$ is the thickness of the spherical shell. (b) Relative mean velocities of the fluid in a cut shell of thickness $a/4$ with respect to the particle as a function of the distance between the shell and the particle surface for different $y$-bands at $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0, u_i/u_b)=(0.05,2,5746,2.36\,\%,0.092)$. The averaging is performed for the particles located in each $y$-band, and in the legend, ‘0.05–0.1’ means the $y$-band $0.05H < y < 0.1H$. (c) Comparison between the relative mean velocities at $\delta r/a=1.0$, 2.0 and 3.0, and the interphase mean velocity difference $\langle {u_f}\rangle -\langle u_p\rangle$. (d) Drag predictions from (3.5)–(3.11) with different relative mean velocities. The inset shows the close-up near the wall.

Figure 17

Figure 14.Relative mean velocity $u_{rel}$ as a function of the distance to the particle surface at $(\phi,\rho _r)=(2.36\,\%,2.0)$ for the particle sedimentation in a periodic box. The dashed lines represent the corresponding interphase mean velocity differences.

Figure 18

Figure 15.Comparison between the interphase drags $F_D$ obtained from the DNS data (4.5) represented by solid lines and the drag correlation (3.11) without turbulence correction represented by symbols for (a) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.05,2,5746,2.36\,\%)$, (b) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.05,2,12\,000,2.36\,\%)$, (c) $(a/H,\rho _r, Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.1,2,5746,2.36\,\%)$, (d) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.1,2,5746,0.84\,\%)$, (e) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)= (0.1,10,5746,2.36\,\%)$, and (f) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.1,100,5746,2.36\,\%)$. Here, $F_D$ is normalized by $\rho _f u^2_b/H$, and $Re_p$ is the particle Reynolds number based on mean slip velocity at the channel centre. The horizontal dashed lines represent zero force for reference, and the vertical dashed lines represent the position where the particles touch the wall.

Figure 19

Figure 16.(a) Profiles of TKE normalized by the square of the mean slip velocity $u_s$ for the turbulent channel flow. (b) Relative difference between the DNS drag and the drag correlation (3.11) for $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.05,2,5746,2.36\,\%)$.

Figure 20

Figure 17.Comparison between the interphase drags $F_D$ obtained from the DNS data (4.5) and the drag correlation with turbulence correction (4.7)–(4.8), for (a) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.05,2,5746,2.36\,\%)$, (b) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.05,2,12\,000,2.36\,\%)$, (c) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.1,2,5746,2.36\,\%)$, (d) $(a/H,\rho _r, Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.1,2,5746,0.84\,\%)$, (e) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0)=(0.1,10,5746,2.36\,\%)$, and (f) $(a/H,\rho _r, Re_b, \phi _0)=(0.1,100,5746,2.36\,\%)$. The solid lines and the symbols represent the drags from DNS and the correlation, respectively, and $F_D$ is normalized by $\rho _f u^2_b/H$. The vertical dashed lines represent the position where the particles touch the wall.

Figure 21

Figure 18.Relative difference between the DNS drag and (a) the drag correlation without turbulence correction, and (b) the drag correlation with turbulence correction (4.8) at the channel centre.

Figure 22

Figure 19.(a) The turbulence correction $\psi$, and (b) the relative contributions of the turbulence to the total drag from the present correlation (4.8), as compared to the DNS data of Fornari et al. (2016a,b) on the particle sedimentation in isotropic turbulence and the DNS results of Homann et al. (2013) on the flow over a fixed particle. The present DNS data at the channel centre and off-centre positions are also shown.

Figure 23

Figure 20.Correction function $s(I)$ versus $I$ from a model for a turbulent flow over a fixed particle in cases of (a) one dimension (4.15), and (b) three dimensions (4.18). The approximate solutions at low and high $I$, and $s(I)=I^2$, are also shown.

Figure 24

Figure 21.The normalized turbulence correction $\psi /C(Re_m)$(4.19), as compared to (a) our DNS data and (b) the DNS data of Fornari et al. (2016a,b) and Homann et al. (2013). The correction function $s(I)_{3D}$(4.18) is also shown for comparison.

Figure 25

Figure 22.Relative mean velocities of the fluid in a cut shell with respect to the particle as a function of the distance between the shell and the particle for different $y$-bands of width $0.1H$ for $(a/H,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.1,5746,2.36\,\%,0.1)$ at (a) $\rho _r=2$, (b) $\rho _r=10$, and (c) $\rho _r=100$. (d) Comparison of the particle volume fraction. (e) The fluid Reynolds shear stress for different density ratios. In the legend of (a), ‘0.1–0.2’ means the $y$-band $0.1H < y < 0.2H$.

Figure 26

Figure 23.Comparison of three slip velocities: the effective slip velocity $u_s$ (i.e. ${{{u_rel}} |_{\delta r/a = 2}}$), the interphase mean velocity difference $\langle {{u_f}} \rangle -\langle {{u_p}} \rangle$, and the interphase mean velocity difference with drift velocity correction (4.25), for (a) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.05,2,5746,2.36\,\%,0.092)$, (b) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.05,2,12\,000,2.36\,\%,0.1)$, (c) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.1,2,5746,2.36\,\%,0.1)$, and (d) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.1,2,5746,0.84\,\%,0.1)$.

Figure 27

Figure 24.Comparison of drag predictions based on the effective slip velocity $u_s$, the interphase mean velocity difference and the interphase mean velocity difference with drift velocity correction (4.25), for (a) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.05,2,5746,2.36\,\%,0.092)$, (b) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.05,2,12\,000,2.36\,\%,0.1)$, (c) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.1,2,5746,2.36\,\%,0.1)$, and (d) $(a/H,\rho _r,Re_b,\phi _0,u_i/u_b)=(0.1,2,5746,0.84\,\%,0.1)$.

Figure 28

Table 5.Physical and computational parameters for the sedimentation of particles in upward laminar channel flows. The particle Reynolds number is based on the mean interphase slip velocity at the channel centre.

Figure 29

Figure 25.Profiles of (a) fluid- and solid-phase mean velocities, (b) particle volume fraction normalized by the mean particle volume fraction $\phi _0$, and (c) comparison between the DNS drags and the drag correlation (3.11).

Figure 30

Figure 26.Normalized fluid pseudo-TKE $k_0/u_s^2$ as a function of $Ga$ for different particle volume fractions and density ratios.